High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRFA/1253/2014allowed

Ranbir Singh And ORS v. State Of Haryana And ANR

2020-01-31Mr. Justice Gurmeet Singh Sandhawalia32 pages

!""!

' (#")

"*"!#")

#%%$&'+&#,-

&$"#." '

'/00/00/1 /2/ 3// /1/1/02/10 102/3/3/3/ 32/3 33/11 33/0//3/2/2/ 32/31///22/20/2/30 33/301/0/ /////22 2/2/23 23/ 220 223/203/20/0/0/12/122/121/102/3/ 3/31 31/330/2/0/1/1 / 11/0 34

'1///1 2/2/22/230/0 02/0/004

'23/1//01/31 313/0 0/0/ 33/11/1124

'/03 1/0/304

'//11/02/1314

'2$"#223 5) 675 88897

" #

# #

% #

& (

(

% *

(

+$ ,-./ 0/1-

% ( % 2' % 88$"# $.$&+$ / 033 4- " 5

13.-6

713.-

' !

/3/30/1, & # #& '

' 5 #

09/.0//:

- 13.- 2 #&

1,-,;< 5 694 // 10/;< 8 # 0 # ' # =# ' !

# #4/

' &

< '

' 1:34;<

0-3/;< 5 2

# '1 331;< #4/

#& ' >00,:90;< -/?'

1,-,;<5

, !

' #

# '

' # ://;< 5 ' ' =#

2 '## # & =#'

' ' >1:34;< 5 '-# #

& 2 -/?' '#

#& '

' #

> 04//;< 5

61 // ///;<8 - @ #

'##

'&1.3,# & !

A # '

5 ##' B ' =

& ' @ #

94 // 10/;< @ '' #&

4 !

' ' 4/?

# @ #

& '

,// 5 2 =#

' 1

#& '

9 @ #

B=0/ 0:'

# # 2 & % # 2

# #

@ 4 ' <

# # ' & ' '

A ' @#$ =# A

A& '

'/ &$#+";'$"#(+#"!

!$'

: '5

09/.0//:

- 13.-

3/.:4 4

@# $

' A& ' '

# C

, - 4

D* #

6D*8@ ' 4< 9

04/.0//3'

9:,0. B ' ' " 5 !

0-/.0/1/ ,:3,33 2

' 5

# "! !

B=1

< 8 <+&&$;'

! '

'% $.$ # 7% $!

&&!

$'% = 1

09-- 0/& 10& 0 $

03/:

,3& ,4& , @#$ 01/-.

,3& ,4& - ' ..31 44& 4/& 4 A& ' :49 19& 3& $&7$"#,:0,33 3 !

0,: '

' ' # "! $' 0

:2:

$>+"# ?*@$ 8 $ @$<'8 $ $ -$"$$"#$"

/3/30/1, 2 ' ' '

1-1/0/1, /-100/1,

/-/10/1- 13/10/1- 1//:0/1- /11/0/1- 1,/,0/14

,//,0/14 0,/-0/14 0./:0/14 13/10/19 1./10/19

0//10/19 /1/00/19 /./00/19/1/,0/19 1,100/19 0./.0/1:

04/.0/13 14/00/1. . @ 13 13.-

# # #

- ' ## ! @ '

2 #& '

1/ ///;< 5 & *"+ @ B E C 6@BE8

5 '

5 1 // ///;< '# '

$ ' $ 00& '#< # ' C

1.3/2 @#$ $

' 5 A

# & !

1.3/ *

!+A

#' B ' 5 2

:0:

# '

##&

# 5

0 #&

#' B

, *"+

- @BE !

# # ' 1/

F<1

!& * !

0//:<0//3B=1 #

#' ##

= ###

11 F<0 # %

* 2 ' &

* # < & D!

#= 13/,0//4 B=,

<1' ##

# #' B ' = #

<02

*"+

' B=-2

<- - '

' ' @BE

C' C'

' #

#5 10

& '

C' 5

:1:

' # $ '$ 00 &< # $ ' @ ' #

# & !

' B=- 4/ @#$ $ ' ##

5 B=-' ' & /:1/0//3

4 #

$ @#$ ''

1, @ <=# F<0 #%

# *

2 ' !

& ' C #

C' 5 ' 5 #

*"+ @BE

2 ' 14/# #

$ '$ 00 #

<1 & D!

1- F<, #

B=F,; ' '

:3:

13@ <=# 5 '

# & !

14 F<- #

* B

- /1/.1.306B=38

9 1-/01.3, 6B=.8 '

/:/:1.3,6B=1/82 &

B=11

< A !

# & '

B=10 19 F<4 '

# ( @ !

1./30//3 6B=F4;:8'

' '

B=F4;3

;

- ' # -

2 ' !

1: F<9 % *

; #

'@ #

B=F9;

# #' B

<0 $ ,,;1..96B=F9;08 1/013 "$ 139;0//3 19149'

' 1..9 ' #

4//#'

#' B *"+'

A 1.3, 4/'

' B & '# & !

#& #'

$ '$ 3 A !

% ! ! + 2 '9 # # & ' % &'

# !

' #' B '5 ' #

# # ' @#

# 13 #&

&D!

#= * # <0/04* 2

B=F9;4 /-/.0//9'

' > :301;< 5 #

####&

= >0/ ///;<5

0/10<0/1, 2 < #' B '= B=F9;9

< '=

B=F9;: #

#' B '

@#$ $

A& ' 5 1. @ <=# #

*#'1&# '#

, # B=F9;4 '

# 5 !

'1/ ///;< 5 # & !

' ,<- # # '# 3

# # <'

A< '

*"+ > 1,

'10 # # #' B B=F9;4 '

# # 0/ F<:

$ # !& # ( < &

0//9< 0//:#' B 2 #3 ///;<5 % >1 4//;<5 BF

! 01 F<3 &)

' 00 F<.

#$ ' '! 5

## *"+ A '# 1:0 %

# #

2 #

# #

## 0//3<0//.

1:0. '

# A '&

'',39 @#$ '991 $

01. A& '3,42

- '

# # & ' '

B=F.;@

B=F.;(

' #

## 0, F<1/

C @BE +

"$ 03;0/1/ *2'

00/,0/1-6B=9,8 # ' 1.3 @#$ '

' # ' #

# >01 // ///;<

' 09/.0//:2

'= B=9- '

' 2 '

# & '

# "E@

' '

# ' #

' " ' #& # & '

B=94 0-

F<1 A #

5 E &

B=1

B=,, B=1'

B=0

B=,,' #

' #

# 5 @ 9:,0.

9 # ,//./ '

C # C ##

2 ' ' # ,:0,3

:0 ## # 5 #

#' B '

A ' @#$

# & '

' ##

A ' 1.30

@#$ A

' #

# B=-

11 11< 00 0, 0- 03 0. ,1 '

# # & C # #'

##2 C

' # 5 #

*"+'

5 -

9 !

# +'!*''+"

%* %'$''''@"

5$ A <$&*

!# #

' ##

= ## '

5 A ' @#$

#' B

2 B=,G-'

# '

$ ' $ 00

# &

#@ #

# '#

5#3/.:4 # 5 B & '

# # '

9 04/.0//3

9:,0.B ,// 5 09 '

5 - 9 5 < 8 <+&&$;'

"# 8!

+" B+"! 'C

"# 8!

+"2 B+"! 'C ("

*$&&- $!D*+ # B+"! 'C 1

,91- 09-- 09-- 0 $

1/9903/:

03/:

, @#$ --/0- ,.4,- 01/-.

- ' 0://:

0143:

..31 4 A& ' .99 :4:

:49 $&7$"#,:0,: 0:

' 7 &

:2:

-:3 #@#$ 60,/8 A '61:/ 8 $

6:38

' @ #

!"D '

5 A ' @#$ 2 :0' 03 '

# ' $ ,- '

# #1:34

0-3/;<5 #/-/90//: ' 2

B=09 1//.0//:

19 '

09/.0//: ' '

; A A # > 0,44;< 5

=# 61 1- // ///;< 8 # 4 61/-08 0. B=F4;:

# ( @ !

1./30//3'

5 '

06 , 4

# < &D!

#=2 !

:0:

5 ;# ' @ #

!"D

' 5 2 !

# '

## "

5 E ##

' ' 2 !"D

5 = = -

' # ( @ !

< H68 2 !"D '

5 = =

<- ' 682 '

9 682 ' !+@#$ 5

# ,//# ' 2< !+ 6 82

' &6 $ -.I,148

A 6 $ .:I 109 8 ! 6 $ 031I 1:. 8 * $ 93I/4/8 B6 $ 1-I0198A &

!GB @#$ '

A &* $

= - ' #

5 '

:1:

## "E 4< 8 2

9 82

- = #

9 8 2

@ * # *#

"E< & #

# '

= #

<9 6=82 # '

*2 & ' "E

& ; 6=< G A8 ## = # <9 (@!

# 6=<!G*8

9 @ '

# ##

<9 " 5

13.-J ,/ @ # # & !

A '

@#$ $

;

2 '

' '

5 ,1 $

' #

5 A !

- /1/.1.306B=38"

@#$ A '09, 1-'

:3:

# =# 9/ '

5 - 091 3'# =# 4--4'5 9 1-/01.3,6B=.82 ' " 5 !

' /:/:1.3, 6B=1/8 ,0 '

' B=- '

& '

= B=10

, # 2 '

#' B '= F9;9

'= F9;:

;# '@ #

'&1..96B=F9;08 1/013 "$ 139;0//3 1914 ,, /-/.0//96B=F9;48'

' >:301;<5

' #' B ' ' =

# # *' ,435 ,- # /-/90//: 1./.0//:

<1, :13;

-9/:

' $ ; A

0:31 11-///// 0,4493

<1- :0/;

-9/:

' % # ;( A 3,411-///// 0,4493 , <14 :9-;

99/:

' ;% A ,,94 11-///// 0,4493 - <19 :94;

99/:

;( A 1/.- 11,9,31/ 0,-30/ <1:

11,-;

1,:/:

;% A 1,-- 11-////1 0,4493 <13 11..;

0/:/:

' % # ;( A ,-:.

1193:-04 0-14/:

<1.

1041;

044/:

;% A 0093 114:9.4.

0,.004 <0/ 1,,1;

/,3/:

' * & 0.1:

11-:0/// 0,:/49 .

<01 1---;

1:3/:

; A 4,34 11-/.3// 0,4::/ 1/ <00 143,;

4./:

' "* ; A 1-43 11-///// 0,4493 <0, 143-;4 4./:

# ; A 1-43 11-///// 0,441:

<014.3;

4./:

' ;

A 4,411,.:4,9 0,441:

1, <04 191-;

4./:

;% A ,104 1/3///// 00,1:/ 1- <09 19:.;1 1/./:

' A # ; A 1/-0 11-///// 0,4493 <0:

1:-.;

1:./:

' # % #

1/-0 10////// 0-:.99 <03 1:4/;

1../:

' # ;( A 40:1 11,.9..9 0,4444 1:

<0.< & 1:40;

1../:

' # ;

A 10914 11,..,:0 0,4444 <,/ 1:41;

1../:

' # ;( A 404 11-///// 0,4493 1.

<,1 -0-;

.4/:

@#$ ; ' 0949 1//3//// 0/30.0 0/ <,0 -41;

114/:

@#$

;B 13.9 1//3//// 0/30.0 <,, -40;

114/:

@#$ ;B

1114 1//3//// 0/30.0 <,- 40,;

134/:

@#$

;

14// 1//3//// 0/30.0 0, <,4 40-;

134/:

@#$ * ;

19,4 1//3//// 0/30.0 0- <,9 43:;

0,4/:

@#$ %

;

001//3//// 0/30.0 .,9//// 1.,-1- <,:

43.;

0,4/:

@#$ A # ; ' % <,3 4./;

0,4/:

@#$ ;B

14 1//3//// 0/30.0 0:

<,.

903;

034/:

@#$

# ;

1904 39-//// 1:34,9

<-/< & + 9,/;

034/:

@#$

" ;

1/1/ 1//3//// 0/30.0 0.

<-1 9-0;

034/:

@#$

; ' % 1341//3//// 0/30.0 ,/ <-0 :99;

99/:

@#$ %# ; ' % ,00.

1/0.9::- 010::1 ,1 <-, :93;

99/:

@#$ A

0/3, 1//3//// 0/30.0 ,0 <-- :9.;

99/:

@#$ * ;@

0.,3 1//3//// 0/30.0 ,, <-4 3/-;

119/:

@#$

/3,, 1//3//// 0/30.0 ,- <-9 3/4;11 9/:

@#$ %* ;@

-41 1//3//// 0/30.0 ,4 <-:

3/9;

119/:

@#$ #C ;@

1.43 1//3//// 0/30.0 ,9 <-3 3./;

0/9/:

@#$ 2 ;

,/.- 1//3//// 0/30.0 ,:

<-.

3.1;

0/9/:

@#$ # ;

04.- 1//3//// 0/30.0 ,3 <4/ 3.0;0/ 0/9/:

@#$ # ;

,,-- 1//3//// 0/30.0 ,.

<41 3.,;

0/9/:

@#$

;

1:0.

1//3//// 0/30.0 -/ <40 .3-;

0.9/:

@#$ !

;

03,, 1//3//// 0/30.0 -1 <4, 111.;

11:/:

@#$ $C ;

-149 1/,,.109 01,9-9 -0 <4100/;

0/:/:

@#$

;

0,.9 1//3//// 0/30.0 -, <44 143,;

4./:

' "* ; A 1-43 11-///// 0,4493 -- <49 1909;4 4./:

@#$ A

; # !

,-.

1/4///// 019.:/ -4 <4.

1,,1;

,3/:

' * & 0.1:

11-:0/// 0,:/49 -9 <9/ 1-::;

0/3/:

@#$ '

; !

.,41//3//// 0/30.0 -:

& <% 9-0;

034/:

@#$

; ' %

1341//3//// 0/30.0 -3 & < -0-;

.4/:

@#$ ; ' 0949 1//3//// 0/30.0 -.

& <@ :,4;

-9/:

@#$ A

1.11 1//3//// 0/30.0 4/ & <( 10-.;

04:/:

/114 1140//// 0,3/-3

F 9;4 1--9;1;

/-/./

$ 1,- # B

*' //:- ,:34-:- .

:3010, K10?L 3:9/ @6K14?

L3..-8 ,4

#& #/./40//: ( 0//:

0/30;<5 2 #

0//: ' 0,44;<5 6B=1,

14 1:

0- 09 03

,/G4482

1:/.0//:6B=0:8'

' >0-:.;<5 ,9 #& ' ' 0//:

# 0//: ' ' #

# 2 #'> 0/30;< # >0,44;<

# =#

#1/-0

# 106B=0.8 @

# =#

# & ,: #

B=F9;4 >:301;<5

,435 #' B

& =# 10?

:4?

# $"# $'

A$ BC,-7 '

'<'7$"#!D*+'+ +" +! $"

BC83/

2 = B=F9;9

= B=F9;:

F<9

' '

' ! #

' 1..96B=F9;08

& 2

& #2 #

,3 ' #

= #& '

=# ://;<5

-# 2 # & &

# =!

65$>"?$%+&5 $$"#

'<' "+""#+$$"# $"

6BC82/'

# #

' # < H0/ F 5

# #

#+ =

# '

@ # #

#& D #

+ <:

<1/ # M #

# #1..4

*# 1..9

-618

@ '

& =#

B= :

J ,.

'< & =!

6&&$ @%$"-/5$# $'<'&&!

5$# $'630BC80/'

' #& '

' '

= 5

& # -/ ' = 6 +@$"&$&

$ ;(+"##$'<'8%!+$&7$"#!D*+'+ +" +! / "$6311BC 80/'

& # !

& #

5 ## -1 @6 $@ ##-

'<'7$"#!D*+'+ +" +! / -# $,$# ,$"(&%@"

+ -/-# $,$#6/33BC8 /

5 '

& #

- '

# ##

2 5 =#

## = '

# '

& # 2

< 5 #

& #

:2:

H102 # 5 # #&

5 '

#& 5 '

# #&

-618 " #& 5

## @

' # ' &

#& '

# '

-618 "

5 '

-618 '

5 5

5 #

< #

# =

5 '

:0:

J -0 & '

# #&

>0,44;<5 #

B=1,

14 00

0- 09 03

,/ 44

# 0,44;<5

= #& 5 (&%@"

!* ) -, !

5 #

# !

-/?

## 4/?

# # 2 # #

$ ,-

& 2

2 # '

& '&

# #

:1:

-4 #

>0,44;<5

' B=0:'

>0-:.;<5

2 # % #

# 1:/10//4 6B=108 > 3.04 5

6- ,1 .4/;<80N # '

& 1:/.0//: B=0: ##% #

#>0-3/;<5 2

' # = % #

& % # @ #

& =#

= 1/ -

# =

-9 #

' =!

# 6$ -$"$ 8 $ ; +!*& * $& 5$ A +"; $ # $"# $"

<' ? +'

$"?*@$ $"#

'6/BC830 '

## && @

:3:

68$, +$5 $@@#*'*,#*&$@+#5*&&$BC,- 7 '$"#

'<' 8%!+$&7$"#!D*+'+ +" +! $"#

'6/ B0C 8 3 1;, ' # ' 6'

$+$"#

'<'8 $ $ -$"$$"#

'6BC8 0

4/ 9/? = !

$"# $'

A$ B'*% $C

= :4?

#=### -: @

=# C

106B=0.8

## -3 @ # !

# 0/?

0,44;< &

133-;<

1334;<5 6.1 0, -//;<8 -.

& #$ '$ 00

# $

0:/30//:# @

16 $@?$* <'8 $ $ -$"$$"#$"

6 1//10/0/ !

# #0/&

113/5 64:

0//;<8

06--/ 8 #$ '$ 00

# A .--;<5 6-4 .9/;< 8 #& 2 ' @#$ ' &

4/? @ '

' '

#' B

' #& '

# #

' 4/

2 #

# #

' # !

2 =!

6 $;$ $>$8

-<'8%!+$&7$"#!D*+'+ +" +! $"#'

+! 6/3BC81

' !

' 41

' !

# # '

' B

' !

# A

A& ' #

' # # & !

!+!

# ' *

' #

# # '

' # # &'

'5 #

&+ 40 & '

# >1334;< 5 6.1 0, -//;<8 '

09/.0//: # 4, @'

4- #'

68<' $"8*A 6BC80

# B8897C /

& ; );$

);$