Shefali Grover v. Pawan Grover
CR No.5128 of 2023 1
CR No.5128 of 2023
!"#$%&% '
((% )%*+*
#,#%&%
*-(
! " # $% $ #&'
() * ! + ,&+ -).
, /0 * 1 2
!!
0 / 2.
The parties to the lis are husband and wife. The respondent-plaintiff i.e., the husband filed a Civil Suit (Annexure P-2) for declaration that he was the sole and exclusive owner in possession of plot bearing No.2086, Sector 46, Gurugram, measuring 98.67 Sq. yards (hereinafter referred to as the disputed plot) and that the name of the petitioner-defendant mentioned in sale deed dated 07.09.2009 reflecting her as the owner of the disputed plot was not binding upon the respondent-plaintiff. Consequential relief of permanent injunction restraining the petitioner-defendant from alienating the plot in dispute or from taking forcible possession thereof or from interfering in the possession of the respondent-plaintiff was sought.
* (
0 * / 0 * *
/ ** / 0 "0 (
*
CR No.5128 of 2023 2 / 0
*00
3.
An application under Order 7 Rule 11 CPC was filed by the petitioner-defendant (Annexure P-3) for rejection of the plaint. Various grounds were taken vis locus standi to file the suit, non-affixation of ! *,
*, (*
/
*( *,* *
0 /
*, / (
0 *,* * 2 0 &'
(3) 0
// 0 5 0 / ,
! /
, , " (
7 ,(
, *
! , / * / ! ,*
' *,* * *,* *
0 *
*5 / 8%%& 8%%) 9, ! * */
,
/ :,
/
! 0 ;
* ' 9,
*
0 $$8 * $ #/ ,* /0 * *
" *, * *
0 * 0
** *8%% 2
CR No.5128 of 2023 3 * / &8) * 0
* 0
* / 7
,/ <=* ' !
! " #$ !%
&'
!(
!)"
(# % % * #+), & , & # -# " !* $ " !% +* #" ././0122 ,)3% %* #+), & , &# -# " !* $ ""
+ %% %* #+), & , &# -# " !* $ " !% !+* #./45. 0.0 % " *// * " ) # % !, 6 #%++& !, " !%
# !,
!% +* #" ./4/1 47. <=* ' ! 0
('
/ '! "0 (' :
*
!
&)&) "0 0 ' 0 / *
0
:
0 (' .0
*
"0 ' :,
! 0
*
0
('
/ '! " (' :
*
! &)&) "0 0' 0 /*
0
CR No.5128 of 2023 4 :
0 (' . 0
*
" 0 ' :,
! 0
*
$ " (
0 '
, 0
0*<=*
/! "
,/ ! 0
* !/,;
/ /';
0
0(
/
/, $ # "0
* /
0
* * , > * <=* '!
0 0 0 * * / *
*0 ,
0
* * <0
* * /, $ # ? / 0
* * , !/,
, / *,* *
0 /
* / / 0
9 *
*0 , 0
* &8)8%%
0 ( @&8)@ A/ B &)
,/B
CR No.5128 of 2023 5 ) 0 * * * C &*) // * 0 '0 *B &)
//* < / / * * * //* / * :0 < / C &) , * 0 0/
' /
, -886& 886)
/ **!
./ C &) *,
/ /
* :0
C &) /*
0 /*
0 /
* :0
C &5) ,/ / /C &!)
,/ 0 0 :0 , 0C &-)
,/ 0 , C D /
* *
,
0, * : / 4# %% &3%% )
0/*,B
CR No.5128 of 2023 6 &) ** 0/ *
0* 0 , 0 C ) / ,/ * C &) *, A # " # !( ! )#"
!8 % 8 " %"3 #( * )# !% +* #" +7.9.+:./42% 8 % %+!.0/4./.1 !( 5 ! 0
,0 /
0 0
*
0
* * , "0 / ;
!" #
$ %
&'( ))*+* ,
-
%
,
,
!"
- &'( ))*+*. 3 " , ,
,/ * "
!"#$ !%
&'
!(
!)"
(# % % * #+), & , & # -# " !* $ " !% +* #" & ) <=*
/ !
0 0
0
* * "
0 ' $ $ $$8
3$ $$$E "0
,
/ 3$ $$$E(
/3$$$$E( *
/ ,#;
/
0*,
0
/'
" 0
//
CR No.5128 of 2023 7 $30
* '
0*<=* '! 0
$$8 0*
:
* ? / 0
0
, 0 // :
0 0 *, 0
,/0
/
*
,(
0 / ( /, $ # * 0 * * 0
** , "
,)3 % * #+), & , & # -# " !* $ " 8 " "
+ % % #+), & , & # -# " !* $ " !% !+* # & ) * * <=* '! ,
/ *0
'
*
,/0
/
*0
*,
, 4 "0 *!
! // /, * ( 1 2
!!
"0 /" / / , /
0)1 2 345 -* 3 #4.* ./.1 (/ /
1 2 3 14 2 3 14