High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRFA/1854/2015disposed of

State Of Haryana & ORS v. Ram Kaur

2017-05-24Mr. Justice Arun Palli7 pages

!"# #$%&%'(

) *"!"# !+,!'!"-+./-0!'1$2.%&%"%'33#$"+4+5!'&"!"#4

!'$-6.3!

77#33!'"

8#+&.& *9"!9:!.+!'1!'"-#+ #&7'1#'"& !'1"-#+$''#$"#19!""#+&(

!! !

! !

# $ %&

'( "

! !!

! !

! ! ! !!!! !

! !!!! ! !

'( " !!

!!!! ! !! ! !

!!!

'( "!

'( "

(;

0 * 00 ) * +"-#*"!"# !+,!'!

+ " ,+-.("("/" &- + "( --0((/ "

+"-#$3!%9!'"&<3!'1='#+& + "(1-- "(23&- + "+.4-#- -(23 + "- 4-(235 + """ (235 + """ (23 + ",4

(235 + "( 4

0(235 + "& 6-(235 + """ (235 + "7-# (23 + "0""# (235 + "( 4

6(235 + "' 4

(235 + "8,1-

(235 + "

-4

( (235 004 +!3 9- .

6 7-3 3- ,,&-3- ,,-2 ,

-- !

,, -3 :& ";23& - 6- 5

! ""

!"!"

"!"

6-,,"&2 - - 3< -< - <

-,,- 6, 3

6 "3 -3 63

*"!"# !+,!'!"-+./-0!'1$2.%&%"%'33#$"+4 +5!'&"!"#4 !'$-6.3!8&*9"!9:!.+!'1!'"-#+"

> 93!

3 -%(3< (3

= - >-(3>?

6 " 3 26 3-

"!!3 =""

?6 "3 ="" "

?). " 3 =""

!?( ,

" 3 ="" "

?'-,

"!3 ="" "

? @,

3 ="" "

?+1,

82%

"3 ="" "

?+1,

1#-" 3 =""

?+1,

-1 8"

3 ="" "

?- 418 3)3-1 & 6- 3< 2,

@ 3 !

). "

-3 3-(3)

9& ""

-%(3< #3 - 12 -3<

$:, 3 " 6 66 2 - -3 ,& - #3 - 3 .3 3

- (3"

' -, &

-#2#

"A3 - -23 -

3, 3 , 2 & "

=;B")C? 2-26-& 3< - , 36& 3

--3< " 9& =;B")C?-3 & & 3 ,D

, < " -3 3 6- & =;B")C?&

"" -- 3 3 -, 3-

,, 2 3 D

E-2 - 3< -

36"

- -3< -- , 36& 6-& "

- 3D

E&3 "' -3 -, 3 & & 3 ,$:, < ""

E-

F =

F?"- 33

- *:

?-#3#!+'#1$.'&#3 +"-#7#"%"%'#+!3& +#3%#1.7'!=!+11!"#1@ @A B7#+"!%'%'/" '"% %$!"%'.<& 1!"#1 )7#+"!%'%'/"C%33!/# !'!67.+#C%3!34!'!67.+!'!6-!'14!'!67.+ -!6.+1!&&4 %+D7.+4 51.3!7.+4 !"-7.+4 %'D+# -#3!'1=!&!$2.%+#1"1#C#37&&#$"+& )4 !'1> !" %'D+#.'1#+"-#$" -#3!'1%& &!9# C%33!/##A$#7" C%33!/#51.33!7.+!'1!"-7.+-# 3!'1=!&!$2.%+#1!5."'#,#!+!

"#+"-#3!'1!$2.%+#1 %'"-#$!&#%'-!'1&7#+"#&"%9', E4"-%&3!'1 %&&%".!"#1!5."> ##"!=!, +9"-#!$2.%+#13!'1 +#C#+4"-#+#%&!*-%C*-!6"%$3','#!+5,.+"-#+ 9+#4"-#&9!33%'&"!'$#&+#3%#1.7'5,+#&7'1#'"& A"A> !+#'"5#%'/"!6#'%'"$'&%1#+!"%'

!&9&" &!3#%'&"!'$#&!+# &.5&#2.#'"7#+%1

'"% %$!"%' .+"-#+4"-#,!+#&-=%'/"-#9.$-3#&& 9!+6#" C!3.# "-!' "-# !&&#&&#1 5, "-# 0 -# $33#$"+&+!"#&!+#7+#C!3#'"!'17+C#15, E !+# !3&'""!6#'%'"$'&%1#+!"%'!&%"1#&'"+# 3#$""-# "+.# 9!+6#" C!3.# 7+#C!3#'" %' ! 7!+"%$.3!+ ,#!+ .+"-#+9+#"#&"%9', EC%F!C%F"#&"%9',

7#"%"%'#+& E4 EG4 E@!'1 E!'1"-#!=!+1 A B!+#5#%'/$'&%1#+#15#%'/+#3#C!'""!&$#+"!%' "-#9!+6#"C!3.# "-#3!'1!""-#"%9# %&&.!'$#

'"% %$!"%'.<& "-#$"-.&$'&%1#+%'/"-#+!"%

3!=%'$!&# +#9-!'1!'1+&8&'%' '1%!

&.7+!4H$."%&5#%'/9!1#!&"-#!=!+1A B%&

'#,#!+3!"#+!$2.%&%"%'.+"-#+"-#!$2.%+#13!'1

"-#$!&#%'-!'1%&!=!, +9"-#!"%'!3%/-=!,C%F !C%F"-#!$2.%+#13!'1 A B4"-#+# +#4$'&%1#+%'/ "-#7"#'"%!3%",4'!".+#!'12.!3%",4!'"-#+H$."%& 5#%'/ 9!1# " !&&#&& "-# !$".!3 9!+6#" C!3.# %' C#95#+ G%#!""-#"%9# '"% %$!"%'.<& "-# $"-.&4"-#9!+6#"C!3.# "-#3!'1$9#&"&@) < %# H I I !'1 H

I I@) J -&

, 3 , -2-26-& 3< - , 36& 3

-3< -3 & "

=;B")C?"-3< & - 26B3,26( ,

'-,

"(- - 2 -3< -& =;B")C?&- ,"&2 -, 3 &--33

" - 2 -2-26-& 3< -, 36 & 3

--3<

"#3- -&3< 23

, - 2 26 ). "

2& "

=;B")C?-

2 -2 - -- B26+1,

82 +1,

1 #- +1,

-1

( ,

'-,

"- 2--, 36 6

G -& =;B")C??"-#3!'1=!&!$2.%+#1"1#C#37&&#$"+& )4

!'1>!" %'D+#.'1#+"-#$"J3 3

3" --, 36&3< , 3, 2 3- 3 , 26). "(&- &- --3< & 2, @ 3 !

" .

,33 2-2-26 & 3

- - 3< B3, 26 ( ,

'-,

&- - , 6 ,--#

-2 -&26& , -3< & ;B")C" --2 , 3, 6-.

& &-3-2- 6 & "3&--, 3 3 - , -2 3- 3 - - &

3- "

- 6- 6& =?"- -8 30 6)3-1 3 -3 -& -33 3&-&" &&--

6 -, -- 3

- 23 3 " - 3 #

- & & ,, 3--, --- ,3-

6 "&2 -2 - 6-

- 23 - "(-

6-3

- 6

- 3 -, -,

-& =?

-3 -22&- &-

) -33 ,36" - --

-3 - 32 -

"&2 -

-, ,, , 3 - 6 &-, 36 - .

6 " -, - 6- - ,323 - ,, -8 30 6!""

"7-33

3 -, 37 ,, , 3 < -

3- &-, - - -, & 3 ,, 3 -#

"-,, ,- 2

"&2 &

3 3 -- -3 B, ,-

-3- , "(-

-3- 3 - -23 33 3&-&" -'6 3

-%#' -&-"

%C%3%&$#33!'#.&!773%$!"%'& 7-&1- .

6 2-

3-,,3 3 "

G-- ,16$ H$ G-- , * H$