← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/5532/2017disposed of

United India Insurance Co Ltd v. Krishna Rani @ Krishna Devi And Others

2019-07-03Mr. Justice Fateh Deep Singh12 pages

      ! "!  # #$% &'

'

(

)!!% $ *+",*!

++-- . %% / %01/ %#.!  % 0%+ !% 234

/ %0! 

++--% . %% 56!  % 0%+ !% 44 

/ %01/ %#.! 

++--% . %% 56!  % 0%+ !% *&  7 - %'5%$08-  

 

             





   

               

 !

    "#$% #&%%$ '''

08-95'

  

   



    ! " #  ! $$   

  $%& ' (#!)"*' (#! # +#       

,  ,- . / /#$ 0!

-1!     

, 

,-(2 1 ' (#!)"* ' (#!     3

!"$ !

$ 

,  ,-(2 *  (  %        1     $    %  &   4"

$ !  $!

 

  0#  

 "#  "  '$$ 0 !,# 567 ,# 89 #     # ! "   $   # 

 $  !- & :"0;

"    /

# "# %%2<=0> " ,-?+-5  =!    $ !     "  %&

,- ,#     

#,+ $!       

 ,# $$  

 ?+- 5 %%2    ,-  $ , 4"#  #$  $!   %%2$  -

 $ !     4  $!

    $$#     $$    "

$$# #  "

"  " $, "&5> (>

  ,-  @""  :"               ,-  @"  :"     >   0#     "     #$  $!

-     $-#

  "  ,# #  

# #,!  #$ $!

-  

$

"     "  %& 

 ! +#"!   "  ' (#!)"

*' (#! $#  +#$ /  $#     #   ,4  !- & :"0;

 =! $" # #     " #,!! ,-$#     

   $ #  ,

-  $  $ !

$  "$$    # - 

' (#!)"* ' (#! " , %& )" $!"

!  A #'#4$&5>1>

  ;  -  $ 5#)#++ )# 4 ,#B>  !$&5> (>  $!  !

   $   ,-@"":" "

" ! #$4  $ %& ' (#!)"*' (#!

3  #  ' (#!)"*' (#!%&

 $  !#

+#   $  $ :'#4 :,$ $      4"#  ?+- 5 ?4@& :"  # "/2

,  "  "    ,#  $  "    -%%2$ $        ,# ! # $ #"#    #C> 7;  ' (#!*' (#!  ! $# $$ 

"  -4

$  

#  "

"  " $    &5> (>   ,-         &&8 / #, - $ ! =! & :"0;

"  -    $$# $  & :"     $ # - 

 <=0;

B,- -  =! $ E       #   $ !

$ $$ 4

$ #  "

"  "

"

$ ,-       =$ !  

  

C> 7 

% )" " ,  ' (#!)"*' (#!$!" !

 A #'#40&5>>1>

   

  - $ 5#)#++2 )# 4  !  ,#B ! 0 &5> >(>  $!" !

   $ , "

 ,-     "

" !  , $! # $ #$4  , $ %    '   (#!      !  %

 " $ = ! 

     # $,$$#   $' (#!   %  &   $    !#

  +#      

#  #  #   ! $  ,    8 E           $   $  :  : '#4:,4"#  ?+-5 ?4@       , 4        #$    /2    ,  "  "    ,# - "   -%%2 $ $           $ =!  ",-$#       ,    ,#    0#     

     !- & :" =  $#  -  $ $  $ =!0#  #$ $!

-  

#-!   $$   " #,&

:"       , #$     !  = # & :"$ -   

2     $   $ !& :"$# , ,  $- $ $ !

$

   

" $ 

   ,=$#    $ ! !- & :"  $ ",   ,#  #!!-# !$ $



  $ , 

  $ ,  $  , , $  ,,  <  %%2 #   - "  ,      ?+-  5          $      !     

" $  $$ #$ , -

"

$ , "   $$# $   , # -# #  ,# 

$   -"#  !- &

:"! 

,-4"$ $  %%2

#   - "  ,   ?+-5  =!     $ !     "  %& 4" $  !   $

$# 

! "  ,# $ !   #,  

 $$   #  "

"  " 

"$,-     $$"

- "  ,# # 

   # $

-#      #  $ !"        # $ !     ' (#!)"*' (#!    -  

" $!



  ,#        2  

B>       # C> ' -$!    $   >2

B> % #$    =   > B '#

  >3 1   $- >2

B> 1 $#! 

>2

B> 1  

$ : $#-$ ! >2

B> #   =   >2

B> 0#     $ !    "#     '  (#!)"*' (#!  4"'" '4  ,    !   

    !    4"

 ! , 'B2:"0!

-)'4  5 - 2

B>E    -$$    $ ! =!      'B2:"

0!

-      !

-!     $!       $    !-  :$)"$ !  "   , "    !

-    'B  2:  "  0!

-        $,  !       #$  !#$    $#! -  $  ! !   " $#""     $' (#!)"*' (#! #

"

!- !   "!, # " 

$$#  4"$ #  !!!#! "   ,   !  $!    $    ,- ,# 

! 

4  $         -  " , ", 

 3  $     $!  =  #69 $ ! 

,     $  $!   ##   $*

F% #$  

=      !#

   

   ,-    ,#    $ $  

!  /!     $-$ $#  2  

B>G

= =3H

I

F9H 

J  

6 B9K . $   $!

  ,- ,# !   

$$ !

,   2

B>    # C> 1 $#! 

2

B> #   =   2 

B> 1   2 

B>  $!

2

B> /  , $#   ,   

  -

    ,- ,#   

$ ,- $ ! " $!

  -

  $ !    2

B> -,    * F #! !   

  A    !# =$ 2

B>

,      $  ,    =      -   !# 2

B>

,  -, $ !

( 

     /     " $  

       

 ,        #$##     $$"

-   $ !      

  4"  $ !    $!

$$#   %&    ,#        2  

B>       # C> ' -$!    $   >2

B> % #$    =   > B '#

  >

1   $- >2

B> 1 $#! 

>2

B> 1  

$ : $#-$ ! L >2

B> 62 4 $9 #   =   >2

B> 1   >2

B> 0#  $ ! "#  $    ",# #  ! -  'B"" < $$   $ ! #$  $$! = #  -  

>



> 

> ,# !  , $ ,-  ,# / # "# $! = # ,-  $      !4     =,  #  -  ,+ $  ,-      ,   ,#     $ !

  $ -  =!"

$  $! = ! 

  $#! 

0#    " #$ $!

- "# $!



# $   !-,  $  2

B>  " +#"!  EM,  :#  ! 0# : -  % $   *+"  ,*!  .%' 

"  6  !   %

   6 %,8 !  %.%': -% $  *+",*!!  0

46 3  ,#  

  4   $! = #    - ,# #  -#  ! ,-,  " $   # ,   ,-   $ !  -$#!    ,   #$       $   #"  ! ! - 'B""

< $$  & # $   $! = #   

   #   ,-  $  !

  $!

= #   ! - 

>

   

 "# $!  #  2   3B>   $  #   ! - 

>   " $!  2  B>   

    #  -  

>       

 $"" $!    =  2  B> 0#  #$ $!

- #    $! = #  !4  =, #-,+ $ ,-    / " $$#!$   "  

,- ,# $$! = #   " /

  $ ",   ,#  #!!- # !$ $

   $ ,

     ,# $ $   $! = # #$  $$#   $

#  $ ! =! 

$   $! = ! # !   #!!    

$         !     #$   $ $ # $-  $! = #0#  #$ $!

- #  $ $   $! =  # $ -  =!"    ! $! =  !    "  $#!  4"$ $!   $! =  ## $!    $    2 

B> % #$    =  !#

 

 ,- ,#

  $ $    

!    /    !         $-   $ $#  2 

B>G 

= H  

> 

6 B9K . $   $!



,- ,# !   

$$ !

,   2

B>    # C> 1 $#! 

2

B> #   =   2 

B> 1   2 

B>  $!

2

B> 

 !#2 

B>6

> 

9 -,   *

F #! !   

  A    $  ,    =     -   

  -

    ! 08- 5! '

'

(   ()

* 

 +  

, *

 - 

,+