← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRR/2155/2022dismissed

Ravi Kumar v. Rita Goyal And ORS

2023-09-19Mrs. Justice Manjari Nehru Kaul16 pages



      

 

 

 

  



   !"# 



   "# $$    %#  $%  &' (" $%)"

  )  * 

% $%)%%%' "

)  (  $%) + " $%  "

)   * 

, % -. /  #/% $%+ 0  1)   * 

, % % $%"$  %'!%)    "2!  * 

3%    %#& %  4 "

&

&    %/%  !"  )

"

5 & 1(! "

(    "



* "  

6%%6% * 

&

 * "



&78 , %.9   %9%.   

 - 9 - -:) 86 &   "



4 6 !'

  1"

(   ( (" !*

& "% % ;    " *   

     

%9%. 

*  

3 "

 '   & 

!<

**  =  >?( ( !

,!6")&&

"



" 1(  !

"

&& 

, %2:.

:- <

* *  =

&>?

  *

" "*    

"!       * 

&   "     

% 8    *   78

@

("

& (   ! "!

  !  (   "

** "

 

  (   

*" *

 ! 

"!    0 

&     

"    

  78

@

%)&&  ! * 

 &

   !

 &

& & !   "

         ,

"6  

*  

*6 "  &( 

   1     "

   

 *  "

 1% ;    " ( " (

&  

*   6     @ !   (     

B   )

B :   "! &    *

 

  

     

   "  

 * 

&      "

 "     !A @ !C**     *"(&

%; " "!   &  * "

( 

* *   &

 A @ ! <)

B:?!

 1

 *"" %

% ;    "   "" *      "

( "

(  B 

& "D:  *  A @ !    "  ""! !

*

(  

@

%)   *A @ !C** <)

B:?  .%/%.  5

 D

& 6" 4 

 , %:)"   ( 

" *  @

&  ""         (  

"(1   **

  % ( 

 , %              ! *   "   

"

(  !(

( " (1 %7 

, %-E 0    &   1 *664( (

"" ( 



" %2 (

%9%.(  "

  

"   664*

& (*  .



*664*

& 

&

@

 

    

%,

"! 664 

"" 



&(" * 

:( 1

&% 4 "    "      0  : 

, %- "  & "! %; " ""*     ""! 

E

 , %  (""  )

"  E

, %.(

( &    

  1 "    

"( " 

 *!  %7 (

 "

   (   "   (         * 

&( ""!* % ""*

 

 ! "

 * 

*    

  !"

"E

, % " 

&

&  %; " "!   " "

! *  

 , % E   !" 

" (   *   *   (

  

  "

*    "     * " * % -% F 

 , %9 E % % )&&(" $ & *  

"$ & 6  " "  

(  !  ** *

"( 

& ""  *!

   "  ""! (       * !"%

% ; " "!&  "6  ( "

& &      

 "

&(





(  *

   (      & ( "!"  

 "



@

( "   %; "    "6  "  

1

& &

G *A @ !  <)

B:?(

"   *   

  ""! ( "* 

&   % .% ;    "   "" *  "!    

(

1

& 





* 

& 

"!"

"*   * 

'   * 

"!"

" 

-:)86 ( ""!

 *  * ! "  "  "

 "

*%8 (  

-:)86 ( 78  &   

 *   :  1

(" &

 "1

"!     % D    "        

"  "

&    ( 

  *  ("" *  

"    

 ! *

"$ &   

"$ &  ** ( ! * * & & (  " %8* !

&   " ( 

 

"    *

"$ &   **     ""& 

  

   ! 

     &  :*%; "* & 

*    " 



 



&& *   "   ( " &  

  !

 " (  **

@



 *$ & (""

"**( ""

&! 

     

"&*  "  *    *   :

!

&% 9% ;    " 

& *   

 ( "

"

&  

   &

@

 (  *"  (   " 6  ( 

"!

  (

"!

 *  



&       % ; "  *



   

      " 

    &&  *   " ! ""         (     "!  

@

   



" % /% 

"   ""

&( "  

 " 

 "* *    

 ( "

 

&   

   !   "        ""&

&



  &    &

! "

%D " (

 

*   6    )

B :

   :.      

 "

"    6 *  

 &

*  

   ! (! * 6$:$ , %9 9(

    ""%2 (

 

    *   

 (  

&"!   

  (  ( %8 *     **

*&

 !&

   "( 

&  *  6 



%, (! &

(  "( *& * 

   

"    

 ( 

&   &

   ""&

&



% % ;   

  "   "! &    " *78

@

(     "

  "* ( "

&   "!  (

 ""&

"!(! *( &

 ! *

% ,    "

 ( " 

  (   B   "

 

A @ !   .%/%. ("   A @ !   (  (   ! '  

1 "  



&       

    ""! !

(  

@

%A @ !C** '  

"!   B  

  664 *

&    *     

"   "     1

&     "  *   "

   "

&  

   % ;   

  "  ""* 



"  !  *   

& (  (   !:(     

 @

 ( " 

(  BD:      

 

&  

"    "*    (  % 2   A @ ! "

 

! "

(

   *""  

A @ ! 

"!   

&(* 



& 

@

%4(

 "" 

     "!&&

 

 ! 

 

" 

   

 @

 



""! * "

 %;  

 " "!&  " "* 

(1

&    ( 

" * 

" 0    (

        ! 

"

 

 ( "  &       

 "

 "

! * 

"

!% 2      &    !   "

       

   

* 

&  ** "  !" " 

"*   *  (   ""& "!   !

&(

"!   * " 



 

! *"( 

   8

 "6 

  

 "

 "

! *       ,& "  )//% % D " "

& "

 

 '$()* $+,-./ 01 $2)2.  )/3),)" 454   $! 45& '6/) #)7 )/6 #)7 ()89)26 01  .9 .7(6"    $! 

 ),- '$(60 %+*)/ )26) 01 $2)2.  .7(6" 4  $!

"  

 " *

   &

     

 6 ";(* (  ! ""  

 ( "     1 & (    " !      ( *   

   *   ! * &&



H



*

* "(

 "   "!

 %7 !

 &



 "   

   



 @ !  "   (!(     *  % % ;  

 """!  

 ( 1

&   

    

 



 -:) 86

  "      & *  (   "   "

 " 



( 

*

   *  '  % % 8 " "*     "  "

  % % +*   

& *  ( "   "     

*

6%%6%  

 



  





 

       

  

 

  

   

         

 



       

   

  

      

          

  

           



                       ! "

  



                

      

 

  

  

  

 #       

       

     



              

  $ %                               &

'  

     

   

   ( -% 4 ( *"

( *    "

 

*  

*

6%%6%  * 

@ !  "

  *     "  *    " 6    

      (  " !   ""   ! 

 &

&& !"      ( 

6%%6% 

"!

1 !6  



<? 

"  0

 

  

( & "! "

"

& "%  % 

   (   

  6%%6%   B

! 

!  (  

  6       B  ( & " * 

  



"!

(*    ( %8  &  ( "   * 

*"(" ( !* :5 & +  *2

>"6 

')/-..:$6,8(0$2)2. +,;)<"

!$4&(

 "    )*+ ,      -

  !* ,     

       .

 

     /    .   

    

             

 /     .   0

    -  1    

          

    2     

   

      

            

      .   



   

  **3       

         

        4.





  

        

 

3        

     .   

  

   



  .



     

   

 /  





   

  .  

       -

  !* ,  / -

 !* ,    

5

                

   

    6         ) 

      

   

  (3     5      63        

  

    -

  !* ,      

       ( .% 4 

   & 

*    

 * " 

-:)86"

&(     %%   

&%8( " "   "     ! 

   

"   

 -:) 86 (  " (  " "

! 

 * "

&   *

% )!7#"             

    

  

 





   



 

     .

 

   



 

 (       

" "(   

  < ?

B  * ! <

?

 * !

&  <

?

 *  !    G   & 

% 9%    " 

"

" 

-:)86    & ( "   *  " =&  ! & & >

   

 * "%,&"

(  " 

      &   *  !  & & !   &     &

 

 6 ""(*  &

 ( " 

  ! 

 1   "

" *  

   6

" "(% 4 (   =& >  & 

 *

 

 



-:)86

((""" B

= > @"

*  !(  =& "!>% /% 7 * 

&    * *    

 -) 86      " *  ""& 

 *    B( ( ( " 

**  

  %7 

  **  * (   

 * ! 

<?% %

& 

 @

(  *  



* 6   < ?

D  *  ( ! ! 

   *    

 %%   I

 

"&""    *! 

  "  "&""! 

"* 

0! 

@ * % <

?

D    =& "!

 *! & &>   *  

-:)86I % 478

@

("

& 

 *

  < %%  * *   ?% )   ""&

"""  !  

   

 (       

"

 

&%)  %%( ( "!& 

"

&   !  

&







1    

" *(    

0    ":

     % )* 

&       

&*" (! *  %)*    ! ""&

( """ 

  78 &

  ! *    



  !



  @

" * !  

" 

% ""!( "

(  B D:

""& !

 

% % 4

( "

& "



 

6%%6% & 





"!

&  !(

     ( !

  

"  ""* 

&

" !

&&   ( !

1 *    *!% 4* 

 *   (   !

 ( "

" "

& (   :    

&   

"  

-:)86% % ;    " *   

 

     ( 

& 

78  ( ! 

&

&   !  

&%4*    

 "*  * 

*  (""&   

*  

& ""&  * 

"% % 4 6  

*

 !

 

  !" "* 

":

, % E )"           * "     !      *!%8( "  "  *  

*D:'  "

&(        )

B : (  

    @ !

<)

B:?%'

&  

& ""!   " *  0

 ""( 

"

& 

"   "

!3** *  

"% +  

@ !  "   ""  664 *

& *  ! *  %% %9%.( (

""  

"

(""

   *

"%2   

664*

& ( ""!  "    

" ( 1

&    *   "

 * "* 

 *(     (  (  * :! "   "     (   "!& % 4* 

    *      

, %E)"  

  & "!

 !

 

""(% -% + ":

, %E)"   

"  & 

 

 ( 

"2  ("" $ & 3**

*

"* ""& "!

  (  

  "

   "

*% 4 

   ""! !

&  1 ""  

 

"!"

"* ""&  *    * 

&  (  

        

" "(% 4  6  

 (    

   !  "  

 "

"* *

 

 * 

"

 "

! "



"0   % 4

 %%

"2  $ &

      

" ** (      &   

  

 

  "   

"! "

" *   ""&   * "

! *

"%7 * 

 !" "* 



 



& * 0 &   ""&   *



   " **   *  *   

    &

    & &    "  "

" 

-:)86%  % 8        *

*@   *   6

""(  &    

*@   6 ""(%4* 

"

& * 



 @

* 

, % ( 

 & % .% 4 6  

*

 ! ""&"

!  !

 &      %/% !"  )

" 

5 & 1%4





& 

* !      % 2 (    "   !

  

  ""

  

       B



  *%

   %#!  $.:2.*<./ 4&  D1

&3

   J3, D " J3,