Sarabjit Singh v. Union Of India And ORS




   
  

 !"#$"%&'&#() (* +,-!./ 0 + 12&!0&(3.  



4

(&#(#$
(5&  (5#!."+'  0    ) 67

 0
08






  
 

 
    
 








 

 
 

!

" #  
 $


%


 

 
 &

'

(



 
 

 
 )

0 (2 ,8*9 +/  


*+
,-


" 
.   
* 
/

0
".*01

 

,
%   

2   

  


)
 


 
   
  






 

3


  


 
 
 
 
4& &4$5
-

".*
6

 





*

"
 
4) &4$5
 
-



)
 

3 
-
 






 


  &7 &4&4


".*
6

 
 
 
45 &4&4

& 3
0
  

- 


 
 

)  
 
 -

-


 


 -6 - 



 




 
 


 


-
 

3
 -6
-
 


&4 $$ &4$8


 
 
  


 
 

 - 




 
&4 $& &4$8
"

 
 


 

 

- 
 

 
 
 

  -




".*
! 
$&



   -


#


 


3
)  
  
  


 


&'

4$ &4$5

  


9
 


$&
#





 


 3




 - 
 
  $:

4& &4$5
/

&& 4& &4$51
 
 

)
 
 



 


- 

  
 





3
 
 




0
 
 
 
$4 4'

&4$5
/

$:

4'

&4$51 
6
-

".*




 
4& &4$5

*
 "
 
4) &4$5
 

 


)
 
  



- 
 -6

  

 





  -
&4$5







 


".*

45 &4&4
/ 
$& &4&41
 




 

)
 


 -





 -6
- 





3
 
 


6
-

".*


  
&7 &4&4

3 

*



 
 
 
- 
".*

  


)
 

&5 &4&4


*+ ,-
 
 
-

)
 


 
 



 



;
(  
" 

<
= 






  -

 







 
 


 
- -



 
 
+ 
+ 

" 

 
0+ 



(


*+
,- 

- 

* 
;(# 


&4$8
 0

3




 -






>  

   
>

 
 

   
   
*+
-

3




#-  









 


-
 
 -

 




 






 - 
>








 
  


5




 

0? -

 "




0 -#


/1




5 $
 

 >  


*+





3

=  

 

# 
 

 

                            
     



     

 !"

'

  # $   %

%


     

                    &'((

   )"""*

&'( + 

      



     

 !" 

   , &'(  

  # $      %

%


        

 

  )"""* -       

      

     )"""* &'(  &'(   

                     
     .     


   /

-#


/1




5
 


>  
 
*+



 
 # 
 ,      0!1

  

      





  0!1 

                        
     


  

   
 -

  

    

       -                        0!1   

)

       



   0!1                        
                
 

    

           
.       
    2
3

 4, 4 


       

  #     % 5 6/ 

   %                       
          - 

 %

   

.     0
    

 9  -  :

 

  %     5   6/       

    %                        %   5 6/  9   

 9 .

    

%



 

  9      

  :     ,: ;4   8 0 <
   

/ 3
0< 

+ 



(


*+ ,- 0
-


 
-

".*




&4$8
 
 
>  




7 $
/1

7 $
/1
 

3
0
 

 

)
 








 

 


 
 
 

 

-











 

 

-

)
 

 



*+

 
 
-


* 
,
  
$:

$& &4$8
- 

 
= 
-

!  



 $;$''

 


6#
 
  
9

 
'


2
 
 
 

 

-


)
 




*+

 
 

* 
,
 &4'8
  $9 $& &4$8
- 

 
= 
-




'4;)8:7
 

 6#
 
  
&75

 
7
 3

  
 




  
 

 


)
 



  



#
@ 

)
 
   


 

* 
,
 '4$8
 

4'

4& &4$5 





*+

3


 
  
 

$4 4$ &4$:

45 4$ &488

 


-



  




 

 

 
 


$)
 




 
 

 - 




  
&4 $& &4$8 3


 
 

)
 


 

-

".*

 

*+





   
 

-
 




A




3
 

2

 




 
-
 
-

".*


-

 

$)
% 

 
 

2
  
 
- 
 
/2 -#<   1

 
 
$7
% 

-
 
/3 #(  1

 
$9
% 



 
 
 



 -6
-


 
 

 
=  
 
3
 
 



 


)
 
 




 

 









"

-

 



$9 7




$9 9





-



".*

 
 

 
 
-








3




=   
 #=> ?

 5@; .               

%



                         
   %   5 6      

           
    .  A


.     


     5@; #== -                                   
           
%        

                       

%



.    

     

:

   

       A


.           


     5@;/ "


-

 



$'





-

 

 




"

 



 
 




   -

 
2 ;(  
2 ;B 
2 


".*
   C



- 


 
 

- 









 -; -
  

  <


 

&:+ 92&!  0&(3.  ;' &(5*'! (

"!+#<"*9#+=#+ !&#(7!5 (5 (#!."+>?    &;&< @

 

 


 

 

 -


   
 


*+



 

-



 
 
 



3






 
 




 



 


 

-




 


 

-

"


 
 
 @
A 

 
/@A1









$9
 

 "




 





 
 -



-

".* 3

 
&7 &4&4


-

".*
  

  




0
-6

  
3



0





 



-

)
 


 

".*

 

*  ,
- 
 8958
 
$:

$& &4$8
 


 
 

 
 


C

 -


 
= 




 
 

 - 



C 
&4 $& &4$8
3 ".*
 

 

 
 
 
-

)
 



,
 8:5$
 
45 4$ &4$:



 

$)  
 
 
-




 
 


* 
,  '4$8
 
4'

4& &4$5

@ 


 
 
6

 - 


.-6
 



# 

  


  
 
3
 





- 


 
&4$)#$7

 

-
  




0

- 

 


-

)
 




".*
 
 * 
,
 &4'8
 
$9 $& &4$8
 


 

A

  

-

)
 




 

  


 
= 



 
 

 - 




C 
&4 $& &4$8
3
".*

 

)
   
 

 


 

A


 

&9 4$ &4$)
 -

 
4:

4& &4$5

 
 



)
 




 
 

 


*+

,  
@A

)
 



 




%  '95
% 
 7&)
% 
 $8);;$9
/9#51

A


 3
 
,
% 



".*

 
 




 

$'
% 


 

 
3
".*

$4



 
$:

4& &4$5


3 
3
 
, %  





 


 




 
)
 
 






 

 -
&4 $& &4$8


 



"
 
 
3 

 
 
&4 4& &4$5
 
 


 #  

 




 
 
 

)
  



&$

 
5
 

% 
 '95

A





 

 
 





&4$&#$8


2
   
 


- 


 
&4$9#$:



 





   3



)
 
 





 
 








 
  




 
 




 
 
 -6
- 

 



-  
  -
&4$8
 

 -


 
&4$5
 
-
 

3 
-




 
-
- 



-




-




"



 

 

 

 
 -
 

 


 
- 


 -


 
 


 


 

 
-




   


 -






 
  

 

 
- 



 

  "



 



 

 
  
-

)
 


 

 
>  

-
-



3 
-

 - 


 


$$ 


 
 

-

)
 



 
 


 -

 





&4 $& &4$8

 
 
 - 







 - "
*+3 A !&";&;' (&#(#$
(5&  (5#!."+'>0="%& < 7" ;" "!&!&#( #BC#$/5"%&5"5#(C@


 
 
 
 

 


-




*+
- 
 

-
 =
-

2 
 
 =




&&7


 
2
  








 


".*
  
 



 


  
 


 






 =

 
3






 




"
0.+&   1,    ;'  D'  &(5*'! (  "!+#<"*9 #+=#+ !&#(7&9&!"5>0 (7&("8"+ < CB@

%

2 
 
 
 
 
 - 


 
= 
 - 




 

-
 



 




 

 


 

 
 








 




3



  

 






 


 




 -6
-
  

6 
=
 
-

".*




$9 7

$9 9





@ 

















 

 


".*
 
 
 
)
 



 
 






6 

$&

 

3



".*

 






)  






 -6
-

-
-  

  .

-
 

 

 




)  
 
 

 - 

 

-







 - 

 


 



  
 
 
 

-



 



  


  

 
-




3 



".*




$9 7

$9 9





 



 
 
 
 

 



 







 - 
 

 
 


-  


 &4$8






 






 -

  


)
 

 
 
-  

3










 
 










$)
&4&$

















































/
6 
%


1 % 

 
D
 

 ;  E; D
  - E;