Sat Narain v. Phulu

  
  
  

 !"#$%&'((#"

)*+,

#- '%./.&0 



       
+0 1 2+

  2 $/&-0 +$3.4#5.& 67#4"#8'9%#- $ +$7!":#&-.& 68'9%#- $-6#((""#&- 
#4/6 .&'#" 6("#.&-.

6#9.&  #."'.&;-6-6%!$-/;":6#/ ."'-6 ($/&-#((#"8:6$;5-6/!.- ."';56.< $/(%.

.%($ $<#&%

# $<&--/""'#-' 

8:#/'./<.//' -  ./  %"#.<'  -6#-  # $<&-  -  /""  '#-'  

=  :#/ &-$'.&-;-:&-6(#$-./ $/#" >#&#"/ "#&' $#--#"

%&/.'$#-.& 


?@


?@:$(#.'#/#$&/-<&52#/- '#- $A%!-.& -6/#"'':#/ .A'#/  

&B 

8 #&-6$/!< 


?@:$(#.'#&'-6-#$ -'#-:#/A-&''-





$-6#-'#-8-6$/(&'&-# $'-/""#&-6$(.%

"#&'<#/!$.&  >#&#"/#&'-6--#"%&/.'$#-.& $>#&#"/:#/ 
8

?@  :  # $<&-  -  /""  '#-'  

  :#/  A%!-' 

?@:$(#.'&-6#-'#- -$#''.& 
=

?@(#.'#$".$8-6 --#"#<!&-(#.':#/
B 8

?@


?@:$-;#'4!/-'8:6.%6 :$(#5#;"--6#((""#&-&#%%!&- <$- # <&58:6.%6-6 #((""#&-:#/&-.-"'-$%.9&#%%!&- <$- #  (#$- "#&';5

  -6$/(&'&-:.-6-6#((""#&-6"#/-'#- $A%!-.& -6/#"

'':#/ .A'#/=

-:#/#"" '-6#--6/#"''6#9.& &- ;& -$ ./-$'8-6/!.-:#/ ."'8:6.%6:#/'./<.//';5;-6-6 %!$-/;": 6($.<#$5.//!!&'$%&/.'$#-.&;

$-6%!$-/;":

:#/-6#-:6-6$-6$:#/#9#".'# $<&--/""#9#."#;"&-6;#/./   :6.%6  -6  $".

 %!"'  ;  %"#.<'  ;5  -6  #((""#&-@("#.&-.

  6 # $<&--/""'#-' 

./;#/'&-6#$".$# $<&--/""

'#-' 

= -6-6%!$-/;": !&'-6#--6#"" '# $<&-- /""'#-' 

=%!"'&-;($9';5-6#((""#&-6$./& <&-.& -6# $<&--/""'#-' 

=.&-6# $<&--/""

'#-' 

8:.-6$ $&%--6 #%--6#-#$&/-<&5#$".$(#.'

./-;#%%!&-' $6$./&/(#$#-$%.(- $(#5<&- #$&/- <&5 


?@8:6$#/ $(#5<&- 


?@&B 

8 :6&-6'#- $A%!-.& -6/#"'':#/#"" '"5A-&''8-6$./ #$%.(-6./(!-/#'&-&-6%$'.;.".-5 -6'%!<&--%!"'&-;

A("#.&'#/-:65-6/#"'':#/&- -$ ./-$'&-6'#-:6&

$/6# $<&--/""'#-' 

:#/ -A%!-'8:6&#"" '"5 -6&-.$/#"%&/.'$#-.&6#'#"$#'5;&(#.'$#'4!/-'&-6" #" &-.%8-6#((""#&-%"#.<'-6#--6&-.$#<!&- /#"%&/.'$#-.&

8

?@:#/ (#.'  &  

 & -6 # $<&- - /""  '#-'



=8&#</ -6:.-&///#&'-6 'C$.-$6#';&#'4!/-'

&-;":-6-A- -6# $<&-8$#-6$8&&/.'6./%$#-'/$.!/ '!;-/6# $<&--/""'#-' 

8&-6;#/./ :6.%6-6 /!.- 6#' ;&  ."'8 :#/6#9.& -6$:.-&///8&#<"58<#$>#/68 7!"'(#&'
#</66! 6-6&#</ <#$>#/6#&'7!"'(6#'

;&:$.--&:.-6-5(@:$.-$.&-6/#<<#&&$#/-6# $<&--/"" :#/86:9$8-6&#< 
#</6:#/#''':.-6(&&"5
#</6:#/ ($'!%'#/#:.-&//.&%!$-8:6/($/&%#--6-.< A%!-.&

-6# $<&--/"":#/ !&'-;6. 6"5'!;- !"#'6;&($/&- -6$89&6./&#<:!"'#"/6#9;&-5('.&/-#' 6#&':$.--& 9&6.//-#-<&- $!&/%&-$#$5- -6 #%-/ ("#'' ;5-6("#.&-.

:6$.&6/-#-'-6#-
B 8

?@:$(#.';5-6#((""#&-@("#.&-.

--6

= $/(&'&-@'

&'#&-&-6'#- A%!-.& -6# $<&--/""8 :6$#/-6%#//-!(;5-6#((""#&-@("#.&-.

:#/-6#-


?@:$ (#.'&-6#-'#-6!/8.-6#/;&$. 6-"5%&%!$$&-"5 !&';5;-6-6 %!$-/;":-6#--6'%!<&-8&-6;#/./ :6.%6-6%"#.<:#//! 6- -  ;  <#'8  :#/  /!$$!&''  ;5  /!/(.%.!/  %.$%!</-#&%/  &-  :$-6 & $%#;" &-6$%&-&-.&/! 6--;$#./':#/-6#--6#((".%#-.&

."';5-6#((""#&- $/>.& ($<.//.&-"#'#''.-.&#"9.'&%:#/ &-'%.'';5-6":$#((""#-%!$-./#"/<$"5-;&-.%'#&' $4%-'8#/($<.//.&:#/;.& /! 6--($'!%-6$:.-&///--6 # $<&--/""8 $:6.%6-6#((""#&-6#'#<("(($-!&.-5:6.%66

#."'-#9#." %#/./<#'!-9& $($<.--.& -6#((""#&-- "#'#''.-.&#"9.'&% $-6$#/&/<&-.&'#;98'&- .&'-6#--6$./#&5 $$$.&-64!' <&-/#&''%$/ ;-6-6%!$-/;":/!;/-#&-.#"

D!/-.&  "#:#$.//.&-6($/&-#((#"%%$'.& "58-6/#<./ './<.//'&/D!&-"58-6#%%<(#&5.& #((".%#-.&/#$#"/'./<.//' )
#4/6 .&'#", !' 



<>