← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/2956/2018disposed of

New India Assurance Co Ltd v. Sahil Parwal And ORS

2019-07-17Mrs. Justice Lisa Gill10 pages





 ! " !  

  !#$%!%&''() 



      

      

 

     !

 

"        )*+ , - -,-,,

# $  % !  ' ( ) *+,-.'+/012 '  3( ) *4004'+/012 $

"& !  '  0( ) *+,-.'+/012 ' ( ) *4004'+/012 $

"&

%&7 

'   8  3( ) *+,-.'+/012 '   +  8( ) *4004'+/012 99999 ,-,,.  

5 " 

 ') *+,-.'+/01 ) *4004'+/01

6  

'    /30++/04&  

  6       $    

  &

: (' ; ;2 ) *    +,-.  '  +/01&  

 6  '

  6    <  & "

" 

& 





= '

   6  ) *    4004  '  +/01&  

 6  '

  6    < 

& > " '

   6   & ' 5  ! 6 &  ! 



   '  

6

  

 & "& 

'

  $ ?

" &+/01 ' 

  ) *+,-.'+/01'

 6 ) *4004'

+/01

 > "   '

 6   

 "

    '  '  '-,  <'

"  8  '

"') *4004'

+/01&

   



 6$  % &

! &'  3<   $

"&

%&7  '   +  8 !

  0& 

  ! '7   

     =   )    

        

"

 &   <'

"  '

"'



    '43  '

"') * +,-.'+/01&     80/-+/01 )

>'! &'

 6 "@  ' ) *+,-.'+/01

 ! 

  

 0..'$  (' ;$ ;2& < 

&/+/++/08&

" "'  >>&: 7

/ >&: & 6 ""

 7 <0+<A<-3-,   & 6 &6 ""

 7 <-4<8/4.'7 

  &   !  6      0< !

  

"&     

  " "   &  >  "

      '    

  ' 6  

 '&

' 6   "" <  

 '&

 ! " !

5  

    %$  >'/+/++/08 /4/++/08 6  

  

 ""  



' $  7  &%"

&

   ' /4/++/08/0/8+/08  

  4<1  

&



6 

6 ) 33  /+/++/08&   +4,&884&881 &    !

  & : &

"

  "

  0< !

 

"& 







          = 

       

    " "   !

"  '    '' "  !   6  0< !

 

"     "'

 



''   '' 66>    '

 " 6   >   & '' 1-B  

&     '+.&88&1.+?<& 

 



 #< 0 $ 6  0+&8-&8.+?< +

 '' +-&///?< 1///?<@+-?0//C +///@0+@01C 3&8+&///?< 8 1-B

 '6 >  ' 6  

'   '

       "

 6  

" 

 >   7

'



 

+-B'6 



:     6   >   " 3    0&40&-//?< - 

'   "  +/&///?< .

  " -/&///?< 4

 ' ' -/&///?< 1 

'   0&-/&///?< , D@  ''   -&//&///?< $#1  .// 2*

"" ! '&   !6' &6  < & 6 <

& 6 "

"= '

& > "     ' ' '



 <     " 

  

       '    <    & ! " 

&) 





 "  "

     !

!

 

 ' ! '

'' &  '

  5      ' 

     

      

    ' " 6   !  6 

6   !

   !  >   

  " "  !

"''' "! 6 !<  0

' "   

"

      "  @

!  

      

      &'

 

'0&40&-//?<   '    " 

' 6   '



6"

 

+-B



6 " :  &

 

!  

' 6 "  

   

 6     < 6

!  '   

         

       & 

   

6    &   '

"  

!

 !   = 

  

  " "  !

"''' "6 6   !<  0

'!   

'' 1-B 

      &   

6   

    " 

&   6  

       6    <

  6         '       6

   !     '    !" "  

       '    <    & 

 6  ) 33  /+/++/08&D@ <0-0&

 "   = > /+/++/08  )

"

 

  0-/ 

') ! 



"

  '

>  '

   &

"

! "      '   

> "

 6'7    6

    

) '&   '  !

     "&

 ! '   '' "! 

    E 6    !

 

)

 "  6 '

;





&<@ ' ')

' !

   5 



        

>   <  !&

 '

"

)  

!    

6@

    

  !

"'' "!   !

 7;6   #(31# #456'%($#1 (76#(&%48#(9,$:#(:$;%6.  -

#(:-7('$#5

-  

  

   

 =     !     

         '      '

6  6 

6 6

 





'   

    "

  



  

&

 ++    '

 &@   F<8<   >% "&   &  '

 "&$  7  &%"

&   "

" '

! 5  ! 6

 F<8   



     /4/++/08 '6 "' ' %$  >



"

   %$  >  ''"6 >

   /1/++/086:

  

 ' "'



'  @  6 

"" 6   > " ' "

 6

 " /,/++/08 $  "    00/++/08&0+/++/08&0-/++/08& 01/++/08&  +//++/08    +8/++/08  

  

 "  

 +1/++/08



!

 

 

 F<8&! 

 "  &D@ <,



*   6  "

 

F<3< > &$ & %$  >&  !

     '

%$  >' /+/++/08/4/++/08 '

&D@ F3?

&' %$  >&

 ! 6  7 $&$ *''

&%7  >&! 

 &D@ F-?

 F<-&    6  

       

   '    5 

 &     !

  "&

 >&



'

 

6' 6   F<-   

'' ;1-B 

  '6>  ' 6 

'

 '

      " 6  

"   >   ;7'  

  6

'' !'6 

F<.<$>



   G*

&*6>& 7  

!

  & 

 "

& &!  



  6 

' 8&3/&///?<7'     

"  6 "  '3<-  @ 6   '  

 6 

 '  

F<1&  " 

 ':&8   

  "0/&///?<'> 

  '

61///?<    "  !6

 6    

 

'& '

 6   &1///?<





   

 '

' 

6+-B  " !

!

 &'

         

     

 "

    

  '   

  &  D@ F-?

&      "   '    

 

 

  



 !

  !  '

'

&

++    '

 

66

 6-/B







 ':<&

'



+-B&6     

> 6 "  

 '

   @ '

 &'

'

 

-/B

 '+-B 

 <



=   6>  !

'5 "'7;6      

           

!""  !#$% 

' 

1///@-/?0//

&3///?< F   '' "    

  '  3/B        '  

 '' &  H(3///?< & (3///<3/B2I-.//? .4&+//  "'

5 ?

<

 &

++

 ' & '&  '01

6   

' 

& &

 

0+&/,&.//?<H.4&+//@01I     '  

          & 

   6          & 0+&8-&8.+?<& 

 



    

!&   '0&//&///?<  '+-&///?<&  '

 '' "  " !

  '

'

&

6!&



' 

'+/&///?< 6 "   '

'   "  

!&      " 

 6   ' < & 

       " 0&40&-//?<&

@

! 

'

' F<,< !

" F<0/<   &!  6   

 !6@  5  !  6  6

!

 

'

 

 >  $  7  %"

7!& F<, F<0/& !       !   !   $!&

 "

" 

 6 

 &  6 "  

 

 ! !

    >  '&

  

'0&//&///?<  '0&40&-//?<    "  

       " &  

 '     &@  '' &





  

   '0&//&///?< 

'  ' '  '

-/&///?< 

 

<

  '

 5

 '' 6 

<> 

 #< -6  %#:1#'4 47($ 0 

'  0+&/,&.//?<

 + $   0+&8-&8.+?< 8

 '' +-&///?< 3    " 0&//&///?< -

  " -/&///?< . 

'   0&-/&///?< 4 D@  ''   -&//&///?< 1 

'  0&//&///?< 6#(:$#1 //.

.

2*

        6        

<

             '      '  

> 

6!

6     '4-B     ' ''

"'   J      6!

          '



&6  

  ' =,-,,>  

  7:3%

> F  > "?

 # K ? F 6 # K ?