← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/5588/2017allowed

Shriram General Insurance Company Limited v. Anita And ORS.

2023-07-11Mr. Justice Harminder Singh Madaan6 pages

  

    

 

 !"#    $%& #' ()! "*#+ ,-  ++((

.! &

 % +        

 !& / &0"



&%& ($&1%0"

+ 2    4&(,

0  %"

 

 

&%

&"" 5 &&1# ","(6 &11&

&2788 :#+8 ;"#&1#<!!=% 1&1 &(( 1

=

>&0<  (?$ %&(5 +&((&&&1

# ","(?

6!

@"("=& % (,#&1  05% %,% "% ( (&"$

&04!

 %': 0  ,"

( #& ","(! 5%&"%0 

=+( "?

6 %&((5 %  !#!( &+(&>!&?

&%  5   %&   ' (  7+&

(0  2&(=%&  &  %  7&1%5 #6!( "05% %"

%&# ' (7+&

(0< 

%

&%5 %& : !# * 0<*'

*70<  (05%%

 !""!#6 %&>!&!6,%&#&   # # A #&

&%& 6,5 "

&!

  :%#

+ %+(&"6,$ %&(0 %6 &5%&"%

2

  5 "

 (&"$

&4!

0 & &"

<  (  :%(1 (+

&" 0 #(,0%&+  & # %B$# &

0 1, 

%B$% &

#$&1%0 1 , 06 %& &(( 1

=

> 0 & &"

<  (05

7!2

0$"

0C#&*%5=0<!!=% 0% &( "( + &!$"

& ; .%&"("

0 8 %&

 %"

 & %+ &7 (B5 $%& #' ()! "*#+ ,- $&

+! 0/ &+!B&! # ","(&E! &  ""&1 0 5  ,  5 =&((5=?%5 &+&

#+(,# 5 &10F+ !#?%! +%& &&"#%&

#&(, + &5!((,+ !+%& &1  6&11& &"0 %+  &( 5&



# "  &1 %"( &#+ &)!#& 5 #:%+ &5  E!

++ !& & ( &" &!++ %&+"

&"( &#     % &1  1!# 0    ""&   *( &# :&6! (0<  %&

 %:&6! (5%&( ((5&1

%  "( &#  + &  + (,  &    

    0  1

&0 0F +

&(6(5 $2 7  * ("!(

&



& :

(# %(,&"# & 0F+#

&& F    &&  !"

  + A+   ;F:%

# &    B ;  G   ;F  + #

& :% # + !#"#

 ;  A    G  8F+ !#

 *#+

++(,&1 #!( &+(& "#  8  A    G 0;0F

& -    (    "

&    + & 00F

&& ! +

&"% 1 0F :

0 0 :%"( 51 &  H8I+ !# %&

"#+

&# %

&(&1 %"( &#+ & &((& (&D

&0+ 6(6,6 %+ >& (,  ((,:%

&  6+ & 6 %"( & E!

(%  ; :%& ( %+ 2&! ,

11& & % ++ "% %&*! 6,5 ,&(&1 %+

(+ ,&1

#6 ""+ 0 %&#+!1 6

& B&! ,6 6(& (& 6&(& , + ,"#+

& %"( 

2 &"    (  5   1&    %  +   + 2  % +!

" %!1%"!(  )% % ( "!( %+ &6&1&1

%!1% %" 8 $"

& ; %"

& +"& (+&&5& %1  + ,# "#+

& !"

!#!( 6 &) +&

  5& %

&1 , %&1"

&& & , %( 5

&#6&1 "0 %5 %&"( !

%&&! % ((6(& 6( + ,& %"



%+#  & 6(# !

&&1  !

   %  !    #   %&"(0  "#+

&0  &&"

& %$"$"%!(0 %(1 (%& %&"

&#0 # ,6 )

,0  E!&  +

&5%&"% %&"

&#% ( %&(&% 

=+( "

""! , % 1(&1 &&1 %%&"(:%(, %&1 6&

%&"

&#% & ""! !&1&>!&&

&&1!

! # %&"(    +  %  "  "%!(  !  $"

&  ;

&+ 6(&"



%% ((6( =% 7  %  :&6! (  "( (,  ((  &    &  &1

&# ( =%J&05

= %&"# "  0F+ !# & &I&#   !

!++"

0 #"#!

;0F+ !#

!"

&1I + (&&1A+0 %+",

"#!

60F+ !# *&&1 1"  6, &#!( &+(& &!0

%"#+

&5!("#!

600F

 &1  0F! %" (% 0 5!(5=!

60 0F 750 %# A&#!#(&#& !$"

& ;& =%:%!1% ## .%&"("

0 8+&&1

 #&&#!#"#+

&( =%% "#& 6&1

+ &1  6!

!&1+", (05%&"% " &!

& %+"&1 6& %"

"

&(,61&

  )5

=& "&

& %""%!(0 % 1

% &16! 6,  %&# %(,&"# 0FC %"%!( F  & 6!"



  + (    (&&1  A+    %  " 0  %  # %(, +",    %  "(   "#  !

  0F0  !

+", 6;0F A )!&1#!( &+(& +&  &  %  "%!(0 

(  "#+

&  "#  !

00F ;A :%"(  ( 1 ! A+    0F    (    

    0F  :% 

& %!"#!

00F 00KK  + ## %+&& #&&#!#+ 6(& 

%& % & % 61& 6( =%  - "!( %&! ,% !6#&



(& 6&(& , %&! ,&(&#&  ( =%(,&"

%  ++& %% %5% &165 # ","(#1& 57 (0 %!%  ++& %& %7%   &!>!1# &!++ %&"  & &    

 

      

       



  



 

  

 !"6, %+A*! 2   "&   (#

$ 

$

 %



6,

; *&

4"% %&*!  750) & ,#& %&"  &&"& &  

6(&%"

" % 65 ","(# (0&

,%  ++& %&%:%:&6! (% 

5& %&#

&

&( &1% (,>"

!"%+(  &6, &! , ; )  &5    %  

&(  &"!&  60  (  &

((5+ (,:%&#+!1 &#&& "#+

& 0 0F  1   6,  %  :&6! (    %  +   & !" ( =% % # "& &5& %1  %

&  0#+ ,# ++ &# % ((# & # & %&1& :%A" &"&6,"( 6 !6, %# %5& B&! ,% ((6  (    "  &  6,  &(&1    A"!

&  ++(&"

&  6  :&6! (

L& %!"%#&&"

&0 (& ((5+ (,5& "  $&" (

 ((5+ (,0 %#&"(( !

++(&"

0& ,0

&+ ""&1(,   4&>  

!"#$ %&"'

!()$*  "&#

'# !+,

"&#