High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/27082/2019dismissed

Narinder Singh v. Union Of India And ANR

2023-01-18Mr. Justice Jasgurpreet Singh Puri10 pages

!$%&%"'( ) )* +

( , - ) + + + ! " "

#$%& ' ( #) **** + +

)

/0 + , " "))-.))/ ' 0)01)0$2 3 %/

,4 #) '5" 6 +'5" 6

! ""! " " "" ,4, )7$$)0$1 3 %$ +

" , 3 %$+ " 8 %'""!

"090/)0$2 ,4

""4!

+ ,

","4 "

4 " , , ; !

4 % ,! 3'''3'''<

"",4 !3 %/+

" % ,4 " ,"," 6 " ,! ,! = ""! , ""4 !",">

,! "090/)0$2 =

! 4 " ! " ! 4" 020/)0$2 "

= ! 4" ! $)$))0$1" ""

! )9$))0$1 ! " " ! 4" ! $)$))0$1 " 4

"4 = ! " "

! 4 " ! 3 ''' < >

% !"," >"

, " " 7

, ","4 "

* " 8 $ 8 ) "", ,45"!4 ! 4" ! 3'''< " 4

" ! % "" " 7

> " 7

",4

!"4!!,

"""

, ,""

8 $ ,? " !

3''' ! !"4!!,

,! " "

! 3''' " %,#/)

$$$))0$1> ,! 4, 3'''3'''< "" " ! % "4 ","> ,! "

" #" 7

4 !4"" $04 ! "4 "

$04 "

, , " #@$ %, 5 ( ,"

#)% ,!"

. "4 ",4 % ' 5" ! ""! " !

! 8 %$8 %) 8 %@+ " 8 %$

," " " . ,44

." !" $24 $$!

,45> " ! ",4 3 %) ,4 "! #2 ,

""4 ,4 "48 %$>

,! "4 "

4 = ,! ","" ! " , ! "," "4

" "4 ! 3'''3'''< "," ,

""!, " ! 4

, "

> " 7

" "" " " ! 4

" ""

, ! 4" !

3 ''' < "

" 4 " ""

8 $ 8 ) & "'

2 !

"# 330%$ %"' "

, 8 " A " ""

", ! , " "

! 4 " ! ! > #" 7

""4

4 "" . = !","4.

","4

" 50%2 & "'

2 !

"# 330%$ %"') > ,!

! 4" $)$))0$1 ,!,4 " " #/$ %, ! """ " % " ! > ,! , ! ! 4 " ! 3'''< 020/)0$2

! 4"

"" "," ! " " 020/)0$2 % "," ! "" " ! , = , !

4 "4> ,! " "

"48 %$ = ,

,43'''< ! 4" ! , ,,4 >

,! = ! 3'''

, ,4" " #/) %, !

"$$$))0$1, , :,4 ,4

3 ! !,

," !

6 ! , 4 ,%

, " > ,!090/)0$2 !

" 3 %- 010/)0$2 "4

"3'''3'''<"

$04 ! ,! ! 4 " ! 020/)0$2 " ,

" "

" ! = ! , + ,! % " 3 " "," "

!3 %/0)01)0$2 ,! , "," " > ,! ""4 "4 4 ! 4"

! 3'''3'''< "

" " , " = !4 ,,4 3 "))- '> ,! !, . "" " 4,"" 4 !"4 (! )2$0)0)0 ! )4 65' ,

! 4 !,

65' ,

, !" 4 " = "

4 65' ,

",", !

4 ' " " ' "

,4 3 %/ ,4 , "," B "4

4 3'''3'''<6 " " 4 "," ! "

" ,

! , ""4,4 "4

",4 " , , " " = 3'''3'''< " ,

! ! " " !# "

+ ! %

> 3''' <

,! ! 4"

5 $)$))0$1 020/)0$2+ ! 4" $)$))0$1 "," , ""4 ,4 " ! 4" $)$))0$1" ,

,4 , !, ! ! ,4"

" % ! 4"

$)$))0$1

!"4 ","

, "

020/)0$2 ""4 " 020/)0$2

" ,

,4 , 4 = ,

! " " ""! ""+ ,4" " ,? ," ! 3''' " " "

#/) $$$))0$1 " , :, ! !

! , ,44 4,"4 ! ! " ,4"

" % ,% ! , " ,4 " "

$0C$0D)04 " , " !!"4 3 %-010/)0$2 ,! $0 4 ,! ." ,

0)01)0$2

! )04 , )04 , " "

! , B "4

, ""4,4 % "

! , =

, "3 3 4 "))- ' "4 4 )2$0)0)0 ! )4 %

" 4,

! . "" 4!"4 (! 65' " 4,

! " "

% !"

4 + 4

65' "4

4 4 ,!" 4 + "

",", !

% ?

4 ' "4 !

! 3 3 4

"))- ' ="4 , 4!

,4 !

) )*

+ +

F .# ," F .#