High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRFA/1496/2014dismissed

Mukesh @ Hanuvinder Singh v. State Of Haryana & ORS

2022-03-30Mr. Justice Anil Kshetarpal15 pages

!"#$%&'!!%'#%"' (%( #%%')()!*++

,-%($. !,/)!"%&0)!1$ 233%44 !# 5%&(,( 0# #% &6 ! !"#$%&( 2 %(3!"%!#( * 78

0890

&%(%!#*

&0 $ $ &:"/' #%:

&9 ; 4 &:"/' #%

&9)!& :"/' #%

&9 &# &0 4)-:"/' #%

&9,4/)& &< 4:"/' #%

&0 !"%%390$ &; :"/' #%

& !- =9 ,($)-:"/' #%

&0,"$)&" :"/' #%

&0 ,1 #9$,& ! :"/' #%

&5)($ 45%&; :"/' #%&

& & #%%-,3# :"/' #%

&)#%!"%& & :"/' #%

&0,&)!"%& !"$):"/' #% &#$%4 !"<!%&( Mr. Shivendra Swaroop, AAG, Haryana and Ms. Vibha Tewari, AAG, Haryana.

#! "

$!! ! !

!%#&!' "!#'#!(!') !* '#+ ',-

!!'

! !

!!#

.! - /, ! "

0 &# ' ! 1 #

!# 0 ! !

!!'! 2

!!'

!!#

324' ,) ,56 5, 55 '#5) ,

!#$"!

'!& 7!1 "!

+!#"

'#" !#'!!1!'!!

! 7! ''#!

(!' , '#! #

!# 0!* '#+ '2""! !!'

!!#

.*2/ !!

&!80 !

! # ,!2

# &

!# "" ! !

!!'! " '

! "!

'!# '

! !

!''! !

! !

' !'1!'!'"0 # !# 0 &&'%#&!'

9'#!'

!#1#' # !$!!'(!6

'#(!56, 7 '# ! ! " #

""''!!' #!

(! 6, 7, ! ( ! :

' ) ,

''#!(!' !- 2.2 The relevant particulars of the acquisition are compiled in a tabulated form as under:- Sr. No. Title Details 1.

Date of Notification under Section 4 of the 1894 Act .

15.12.2006 2.

Date of Notification under Section 6 of the 1894 Act 18.10.2007 3.

Number and date of the Award of the Land Acquisition Collector.

Award No.22, dated 14.03.2008 Revenue Estate Rohtak.

Land measuring 270.14 acres 4.

Amount assessed by the LAC.

Rs.16,00,000/- per acre.

Amount assessed by the RC.

Vide award dated 01.11.2012, 05.11.2012, 31.07.2013, 13.03.2014 and 31.05.2014, the reference applications were dismissed.

5 ! "

& ! *2 '# ! 2 !!# '

'!& 7!1 "! +!#"

'# !"

'#'+!

" !#$'! '

"2 "!' '# #"0 # '! ;& &! '

"2 ",!$<!"!! !& '0 "

'# '"#'= > # !9'

! !# "(!'!

, 7'!

! +!#"

'#(7 " !#'!

! +!#"

'#$

720 ! +!#"

"! !

#!' "

$!""

&&! " !

!& 7!1 "! !"

'# '"!

,? !(+@#

=!' ,!( !

&!# !

&!' & 7!1 "! 0!* '#+ '2""! ! '#'!!# ' '! !!'!

) 9& 0 !'!#!! !( :

' "!# '0

"'!!'!

!1 %#&!'

!# 0!

!!'!2

!" #$#%$&%$%!'((('( 5 9'#! 1!!

!,!"

'#$'! 1!!A &'!# =B( #!1,!#;!! ! !

! ( ! , 7,$

1!#!! !# !

CA=CA=),=B ( D;D ',$

1!#! ! "

'CA= '#=B5(; ','!

'#$'! 5 '!! '#,!( :

!A &'!#B

;

'',$

1!#' ''#!(!' * '#+ ',- B = $ $

!A &'!# 1!7 %

!1!'!"

0 "

' '#-

!" #$#%$&%$%!')(('( 55 9'#! 1!!

!,!"

'#$'! 1!!A &'!# =B8 '#!(',$

#!#! ! "

'CA=?,"

2""! ! 7,!' ''#!(!' !- , # !#) , 78, " ' 72, 0 %#&!'# !# 5 ,

!# 0!:2,CA=5, 0 ## !# 5 -,CA= ?= ,=B ( % ",'! !"

'#$'!, #!#

#!!#CA= '# #'

,# !# - -

CA= ?= ,=B5 & ; ','! !"

'#$'! 5 '!! '#,!( :

!A &'!#B &$

;

'' $

!" #$#%$&%$%*&%$ + ,%%

$%('-'( 5) 9'#! 1!!

!,!"

'#$'! 1!!A &'!# =B( <!1 $ 1!# #!!# - ), # !#

CA=, ! !# !

#!!# ) - '#) - ,# !#

CA= '# CA=5,! !# !

!#!!# ' 6# !# -) 6 '# 6

# !#) 6

CA= '#CA=),=B E&"

$!'#!!#! 0 !""! !

CA= 5

'!! '#,!( :

!A &'!#B &$

'' 5 $

!" #$#%$&%$%!(''(.

) 56 9'#! 1!!

!,!"

'#$'! 1!!A &'!# =B (' '#=B &8 % 5- '!! '#!( :

##' #! '0 !1#!'!

!" #$#%$&%$% / $ !(')'(.

!A &'!#=BF"!(',=B (' $'"0'& !!#,=B &= ",=B :

(' 5 =!' ,( :

!A &'!#(!

;& = $

0 9

!" #$#%$&%$%!'((('( 5 ! "

1! #!# ! ""$' #&!' !1#!'!

!#& "

' $

#!#' 55 ( CA <&!' CA=

(!="

5 =!' ,!( :

#!#! ""$' #&!'

"!#!!#

!#& "

' $

1!'' 55 ( CA <&!'

CA< ' '#! (!' ! * '# + ',-

CA< ' '#! (!' ! * '# + ',- 5 CA<5 * 2""! ! CA< $ #< !# 5 -

) CA<) !

!"!&!' '#!

" '="0

!" #$#%$&%$%!')(('( 5 5 ! "

1! #!# ! ""$' #&!' !1#!'!

!#& "

' $

#!#' 55 ( CA <&!' CA=? (!="

7 2""! !

5 78 * '# + ''!'#!(!' ,# !# ) 72 " '

) CA=5 2 0 %#&!'# !#5 ,

!# !:2

CA= 2 0 ## !# 5 - 5 =!' ,!( :

#!#! ""$' #&!'

"!#!!#

!#& "

' $

1!'' 55 ( CA <&!'

CA<) 2 0 ! "0 !( !!

" '

!"!&!'="0 $

!" #$#%$&%$%*&%$ + ,%%

$%('-'( 5 ) ! "

1! #!# ! ""$' #&!' !1#!'!

!#& "

' $

#!#' 55 ( CA <&!' CA=

2 0 ""! !

6 5 =!' ,!( :

#!#! ""$' #&!'

"!#!!#

!#& "

' $

1!'' 55 ( CA <&!'

CA 2! !# 0 ## !#

CA 2 0 ' ''#!(!' * '#+ ',-

5 CA5 2 0 ' ''#!(!' * '#+ ',-

CA 2 0 !2""!G !

) CA) 2 0 *2 #

,# !# 5 - 7H

2 0 ## !#) 5 $

!" #$#%$&%$%!(''(.

5 6 ! "

1! #!# ! ""$' #&!' !1#!'!

!#& "

' $

#!#' 55 ( CA <&!' CA=5 '#CA= !

& '

CA=)

0 !2""!G ! !0!

5 CA=

0 !2""!G ! !0!

5 5 - '!! '#,:E< #!#! ""$'#&!' !1#!'!

!#& "

' $

#!#' 55 ( CA <&!' CA 0 %#&!'# !#56 5

0 %#&!'# !#)

- 5 $

!" #$#%$&%$%!(')'(. 5

#!#! ""$'#&!' 0!1#!'!

!#& "

' $ #!#'

55 ( CA <&!' 7 0 !>!'! "=$! '!0

(&( "

78 0 !>!'! "=$! '!0

!!'

5 72

0 !2""!G !

5 '!! '#,!( :

#!#! ""$' #&!' 0!1#!'!

!#& "

$ #!#' 55 ( CA <&!' CA 0 #

,# !# 5 -

0 1 !

7! !10, '

"# !#& "

#!!# "'$!!"!1 ''

& ' #!# 0!!

!1! !

' &! +!#"

'#" !#'!!1!'!!

!, 7,

'#!I

# #

% %

& &

(

!"!

'!#'

!"! !

!''!"

'!'#!# !2$"!

'! #

$'"0'!#!

CA=$

&!!1!'!!

"!'

#! '$

# !+! '#!!

!,!2$'"0'!#!

&!!2

!!#'''!

"!#!!#CA='!'# !

# '#$

!# 1'!!

#!' " " (

!1 '

$ '0!1#!'! "

"!'!!#!0 1! !'!'#!# ! +!#"

'#$

!#$'!' "*& 720!2

&&!# '!'

"' 7!' '

#! '!""!G !

!0!

6 -CA= !2

!!#' 7'''

#! '! !'!

"!'#! !

" ' '#!

!"!&!'="0CA=)

=! ' , ! "!

'!# ( ! '

!", $"! # $' !

!'' !2!

#!# 0!( !,'!'#

"! #!!# '5 )6 # !# -5 '#

"! #!!# '6

# !#

6 ) !$!

!! !"

'#$ 1! !!' +!# :!'!, !1#!' ! ! ! !$

' ,,?(!

!'!'#!# !

"!#!!#') ,# !# $ !

'#&!

' '#6

$ !+1 "!'

'#)& "

!!' "# ! ),, ? ! ! (&!

!!' +!#

"!#!!#

'"05&' !# ' ''#!(!' (! ! '!'# !

#!# 0!"

!$!

! !"

'#" !# # '!9

!!' '!# !

' - )# !#

'#&!

'#6J

"# ! , , -? " !#' $ 0 '#!

!!'

!# 0 "'K! 1' " (! &!# $"#' ! !!"0 '!

)

2 3 ) 9' ## !# ,!2,

! !

""0!A &'' !

CA= ,CA=),

!1!# !

"!'

!$ !

!! " 1!0 & "" K! '#!!

!,'&

"!B !

"!'

"!#!!# - )# !#

CA=,!

!1!# !#!1!" !

!#!"

'# 1' !

#!' " " '# " !#

0 "

! &! +!#"

'# !2

!1!#

!"7 !

#!# 0!

( :

1! !!"!1 ' !#,!!

+!#"

'#&!$

'#),,? ! !$!!

!*2

#0 #!# ,,? ! ! !

'!#!

!'!

"! ! "

'#! ! !

" ' '# !

!"!&!'="0!*2$ #

!!''!#'

!'# $

! !# !!0!

&!#

' ''#!(!' ) 9'! ## !#56 5, &"

!#!#'

! ## !# $!!!#!#9'! ## !#5) , !2'!#!

#!# 0!"

!0$!! ""

!# ' ''#!(!' !- !)

'#'!'# CA= '#CA= ! 1!0 & "" !

:!!"!

'! # !2# !#) )5 9' ## !#55 ,!

! '#' !

!A!& "

#!# !"

!1!0 & "" !!

'#!

) +0# !

!#!"0 '!

&!!2

'!# !1 "0$!

&! + ',$%#&!' # !# ) '# 56 5 ' *2

!!' #!"1!!# !!

!,!2

!!"0' '!

&!# &

!#! !' ) 9' ## !#5) ,!2,

! '#' ''!

!! !# '# 5 -!!# # !*2 '# ""!

!$!

! & "" !"

'# $ !'&

"!,# &

!#!!

!!'! !'

$"!!"0' '! #

!#'*2

!5 ,#!#!#') !2

&&!# '!$"!

!1' ''!

!! !# '# 5 -!!#

2""!G # !(!' 5 !- ,!& 7!1 "!

! +!#"

'# !+!# !

!#'!# ' ''#! (!' !- !) 6 9' '0

!,!

#!# 0!"

!$!

!''"0 & "" !"

'# !# ' ''#!(!' !- :!'!,!0 '' !!"!# '

B!'

!' !"!

'!#'

!"! !

!''! !

, !( :

!+!

!# #! 0 !& !!'

0 "

' +!# !

$"!#!' 0'!" ' !1

'# "#!1

#!# 0 !

' !' #!#,

!!' 7!''!#

CA:2'

" !

"!! , !1#!' ! +!#"

'# '

!# "

'#9 !1#!' !

"!'

, #!# !"

,#' & +!#"

'#",CA=,

! +!#"

'#,$!1!, '!! #! !$ 09

" !#' &&! " !

,! !" "

'# "#CA=

!" !#'!!A ' 0!

# '##!

' &

+!#"

'# !, !1#!' !

"!#!!#'5 )6,# !# -5 ,$!

'#&!

!+1 "!' '# & "

!!' "# ! 6,,? ! !!

!'! !

"!'

!!' +!#

% &' !# ' ''#!(!' !-

(&"

"0,

"!#!!#'6

# !# 6 ),$!

'#$ !+1 "!' 7 '# & "

"# !

1! ! ),--, 5)?

!!' +!# '!0!

! !

'! ' ' '#! (!' ! - !&!,'

"!'

'!) # !# ,$!

'#6

!+1 "!' 7 '#)& "

"# !

),, ?, &!

!!' +!# ! !"

'# "#

"!#!!#-- ,

,) '#

'! +!# '#

9'1!$

#!1#!'! #!# 0!(

,!2

!"0'!#CA=,!

"!'

'!$

!!' #!# 0!"

! !" "

'# +!# '!!A ' 0!

# & !

CA=, !1#!' < !

" =1*#

!#"

'#&!

'#6)

!+1 "!'6-)56)(+@# ," !#'!

!A ' 0!

# 9'! '#!!#1!$ !2, '

!!"0 '!

"!#!!#' - ),

!# 0!"!

'!# '

!"! !

!''!"

!& 7!1 "!

+!#"

'#'!

!'! '0!1#!'! 1! !

#!!# $!

! &

"! !" "

'# > 6 2'

!+!'"0, ""! !

"" '## &

!# 6 ""! !'#'& !""

'! " '

, '0, ! # !#

&'$+:

890

8 !# ?$%#$%&(3% -)!1@&% (!%" *%(@ ?$%#$%&&%3&# A4% *%(@

Sr.

No.

Case No.

Party name 1.

RFA-6268-2015 RANBIR SINGH & ORS V/S STATE OF HARYANA & ANR 2.

RFA-322-2018 YUDHVIR V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND ORS 3.

RFA-9554-2014 PREM SINGH & OTHER V/S STATE OF HARYANA & ANR 4.

RFA-1953-2013 SURAJ MAL AND ORS V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND ANR 5.

RFA-1954-2013 RAM KISHAN AND ORS V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND ANR 6.

RFA-8820-2014 KRISHANA DEVI THR. SGPA V/S STATE OF HARYANA & ORS 7.

RFA-5847-2015 RULIA V/S STATE OF HARYANA & ANR 8.

RFA-62-2015 M/S ONE POINT REALITY PVT. LTD. V/S STATE OF HARYANA & ANR.

RFA-1074-2014 MUKESH @ HANUVINDER SINGH V/S STATE OF HARYANA & ANR 10.

RFA-683-2014 PRABODH CHAND MITTAL V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND ANR.

11.

RFA-7921-2013 SMT. NAINI JAIN V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND ANR 12.

RFA-8724-2014 MUKESH @ HANUVINDER SINGH V/S STATE OF HARYANA & ORS 13.

RFA-575-2014 SARITA JAIN MITTAL V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND ANR 14.

RFA-1955-2013 PHOOLPATI AND ORS V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND ORS 15.

RFA-7919-2013 PARUL JAIN V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND ANR 16.

RFA-1598-2014 RAM PHAL & ORS V/S STATE OF HARYANA & ANR 17.

RFA-4448-2013 SHRI KRISHAN & ANR V/S STATE OF HARYANA & ORS 18.

RFA-9749-2014 ZILE SINGH V/S STATE OF HARYANA & ANR 19.

RFA-7920-2013 URMIL JAIN V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND ANR 20.

RFA-8725-2014 MUKESH @ HANUVINDER SINGH V/S STATE OF HARYANA & ORS 21.

RFA-4373-2013 BHUPINDER SINGH V/S STATE OF HARYANA & ANR

) 22.

RFA-8004-2013 RAM KISHAN AND ORS V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND ANR 23.

RFA-8726-2014 MUKESH @ HANUVINDER SINGH V/S STATE OF HARYANA & ORS 24.

RFA-9814-2014 DILBAGH AND ORS. V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHER 25.

RFA-1496-2015 JAGDISH AND ORS V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND ORS 26.

RFA-5845-2015 NARESH & ORS V/S STATE OF HARYANA & ANR 27.

RFA-5846-2015 HOSHIAR SINGH V/S STATE OF HARYANA & ANR 28.

RFA-1952-2013 SURAJ MAL AND ORS V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND ANR 29.

RFA-1496-2014 MUKESH @ HANUVINDER SINGH V/S STATE OF HARYANA & ORS 30.

RFA-1073-2014 MUKESH @ HANUVINDER SINGH V/S STATE OF HARYANA & ANR 31.

RFA-7918-2013 VIKAS JAIN V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND ANR 32.

RFA-1497-2014 MUKESH @ HANUVINDER SINGH V/S STATE OF HARYANA & ORS 33.

RFA-7917-2013 VIKAS JAIN V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND ANR

890