Sumati Kalia And Others v. State Of Punjab And Another
!
"# $
%
$
!"
$
% & (!"
##)"
*
$ ! $
%
$ &
,- ./
!(
563
. 9!."
,#; /
.( ! 0
( !
+$
. '$
6 !
.
- '"
!(!
! .
+*
+8
(
.' = ("
62..
(
'
..
(
(
. = !8
. !"
'
: ( 2 .
"
.( '
$ 8!!"
'
(
. '
=
.
>
!.
.
. +!
! 8 8 !
.
'!
+!
!.
.
8!.
8
!.
.
> 4
(
'
(
8!
..(
! !+
. +!
+.
! !+
?
.
'
.'
+8
"
$
2
. '
(
8!
= .
$'()$'(*$+',-$', . $//01 2-* 2-& 4 3 ++'54 678"
%@+. ;
5
8! $( .
.
(
!
= .
%@+. ;
--'. 9+(*% -('
'2 :34 3 ++'54 66"
8!. !(
!
(
5 +$
$ '.= '
+. 8"
8!
$
(
''(
'
!
!
1! %@+. ' $- + +'9 - $//01 2-* 2-'20/-
3:4 ++'56: !.
+(
8!
$ 5 2"
'
''
"
8!
+
'' '
=
$ .
( (
(
. ''
' 8!
=
$
;'
'
8.
'
5
.
8"
.
5 2"
. '
''
2
. 0
$
'' (
'
!
!
"
'
"
!(
.
+.
!8
!=
$.=
;'
'
! ..
''
1!"
.
!
' +.
7!
5 ; ;
<: ;
- 9+= $+',- . $// 01 '( '2
( .
.
(
'+ 5
.(!
+$"
5
8.
'
+
#
..
7!
* (' %5>+'2 $+',-'20/- .
$//01'( '2'0/- & 83 43 ++'54:
!.
%(!
8
..8 (
+.
!
8! %(!
0
$
+
!8 *
%@+. ;
+'$+',-9 $//01 '( '2'0/- :
34 ++'5
. +$
*
$
+
"
!
8
!
!
" #
$%&'
* ('"
..8
((
)
563
. * *" + , ,#; /
..
+0
!
!+=
3%
$
.$0 0/ Whether reasoned / speaking?
Yes / No Whether reportable?
Yes / No