High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRFA/1515/2014disposed of

Harijan Co-Operative Society Ltd Singhpura v. State Of Haryana And ANR

2015-12-22Mr. Justice Ramendra Jain7 pages

!"# $#%&'&()#%#*+#,

) ./00/ ,#'#(") ,1'2!32!(-0#(&,$4%!"#5&"2 ,0!("'202!,*!-,(16,!7&1 , , !7&1-,*&"86*!,!&( , ,0&77!(&!-,*&"86*!,!&(- ,06,'286*!,8!6'2&1-,06,#'227!5!"- ,9&1,!*0&(:2-,!;#'23!7- ,,&"!*0&(:20!&(&-,1'2!3&($!7- ,6(&'286*!,!,:!($,9#$!,1!'2- $4%!"#' ,"2#7!($5(#,' ,+2&(!'2!&(-''&'"!("$4%!"##(#,!7-!,3!(! !;#'2&($!7 2&',$#,5&77$&'<'# ' - =-

>" - ??

" ??@- > " > @- @

" @ =-A > -A > -A-A

-A -A @"A=

-A=>?- A?

"A??

-A??

"A> =-A@>=-A@>?-A@>@-A@@ -A@@?"

A-

=A-

- ?-

- >- ?

" ??

- > >" >

>A=" > @-

=- @ - A

- A ?" A @- AA>" A

@ >" @A- @> -= =>"= ?-= >A-=A ="=A @-?

@@- ?A A-?= -?= ?->>A->? =">? @->@ ">@

-@ =A-@?

'A !($> @

2#7!($5(#,'!,#&(!<<#!7'##1&(: 6,"2#,#(2!(%#*#("

%*<#('!"&( ,"2#!%C6&,#$7!($

A ,&# 73-"2# !%"' "2#%!'#!,#"2!"4&$#("& &%!"&($!"#$

?-&''6#$6($#,0#%"&( "2#/!($%C6&'&"&(%"->@

, '2,"-."2#%". -"2#0"!"# !,3!(!-'6:2""!%C6&,#7!($&(4&77!:#' 0&(:2<6,!-0!

&$(-!*<6,!-!""!(82#,!!($82#,!82#*!5!"&-&'",&%" &($ ,$#4#7<*#("!($6"&7&"&'!"&("2#,# !'%**#,%&!7!($,#'&$#("&!7 0#%",'?->!($@-0!

&$(2#'!*#5!' 775#$+3("& &%!"&($!"#$

>- &''6#$ 6($#, 0#%"&( = "2# %" 2# /!($ %C6&'&"&( 77#%",

,'2,"-."2#77#%",. -4&$#!5!,$'A- !($ $!"#$ @>

-!''#''#$"2#*!,1#"4!76# "2#!%C6&,#$7!($DAA-

<#,!%,#6<""2#$#<"2 "5!%,#'(0!

&$(F&($,!$-0!

&$(3#F <!'',!$!($!&,6*1&(1&($ 7!($!($D>-

EF<#,!%,# , #2,&!($2!2&7!($&''!"&'

&#$5&"2"2#!5!,$' "2#77#%",-"2# 7!($5(#,' &7#$+;#%"&('-52&%25#,#,# #,,#$""2#7#!,(#$,# #,#(%# %6,"2#7#!,(#$ %6,"+#75 $&'*&''#$"2#,# #,#(%#<#"&"&('4&$# !5!,$ $!"#$ ?

A " &' "2&' !5!,$ 52&%2 &' &*<6:(#$ +3 "2# 7!($5(#,'+# ,#"2&'%6,"

/#!,(#$%6('#7 ,"2#7!($5(#,''6+*&""#$"2!""2#!%C6&,#$ 7!($&("2#%!'#&(2!($5!'7%!"#$&("2#2#!," 0!

&$(%&"3-52&%25!'

$#4#7<&(: !'"&(&0#%,#"!,&!"-6'0"!($!($,!&(!,1#"5#,#7%!"#$ %7'# " "2# !%C6&,#$ 7!($ 2#,# 5#,# '%27'- %77#:#' !($ "2#, ,#'&$#("&!7!($%**#,%&!7#'"!+7&'2*#("'7%!"#$%7'#""2#!%C6&,#$ 7!($2#'!7#$##$' G=!($G -52&%2!,#"2#*'",#7#4!("

<&#%# #4&$#(%#-2!4#+##(""!773&:(,#$2#7!($<#,"!&(&(:"'!7# $##$ G= 5!'7%!"#$%7'#""2#!%C6&,#$7!($-52#,#!'"2#7!($ <#,"!&(&(:"'!7#$##$ 5!' ,*&(:<!," "2#!%C6&,#$7!($'

"2#7!($5!'7%!"#$5&"2&("2#*6(&%&<!77&*&"'-'!7#&('"!(%#' '*!77 <7"'(735#,#!4!&7!+7#-!'+&:%26(1 7!($5!'("+#&(:$#!7"5&"2 #'&$#("' "2#%&"35#,#<6,%2!'&(:"2#<7"' ,%('",6%"&( 26'#'

&("2#!,#!"5!' 6,"2#,'6+*&""#$"2!"!''#''*#(" %*<#('!"&(+3"2# 77#%",!($+3"2## #,#(%#6,"!"$&

#,#(",!"#' ,"2#7!($7%!"#$ (*!&(,!$!($+#2&($"2!"5!'""!7736(F%!77#$ ,2##("&,#!,#!5!'

"+#$#4#7<#$!''#%",'+3%!,4&(:6"<7"'-52&%25#,#'7$!"6(& ,* ,!"#'5&"26"!(3$&'"&(%"&( ,!"#'(*!&(,!$,"2#,5&'#-,!"2#,- ,

A ,#'&$#("&!7<6,<'#-"2#<#<7#$("<,# #,"+63<7"'(,!$(!%%6("

$&'"6,+!(%#"5!' 6,"2#,'6+*&""#$"2!""2#%!7%67!"&(*!$#+3"2# 7#!,(#$%6,"+#75!

"#,!<<7&%!"&( %6"&(<!,!:,!<2A@ "2#!5!,$&'

("%,,#%"6,"2#,-"2#'!7#$##$' GH!($G 2!4#+##(5,(:73 &:(,#$2#,#5!'(*!"#,&!7(,#%,$"<&(#"2!""2##("&,#7!($5!' !:,&%67"6,!7!""2#"&*# !%C6&'&"&(2#*#,# !%""2!"'*!77<7"'5#,# +#&(:'7$&("2#!,#!'25'&"'<"#("&!7&"32##4&$#(%#7#$+3"2#0"!"# 5!',&:2"73&:(,#$!($&( !%"-$#'#,4#'"+#&:(,#$ ,"2#,#!'("2!"

"2#%('&$#,!"&(<!&$&("2#'!7#$##$'<,$6%#$+3"2#0"!"#5!'7#''"2!( "2#!5!,$ "2#77#%",6,"2#,,#7&!(%#5!'<7!%#$6<("2#*&(&*6* 77#%",.',!"#' GIE &G#$ ,,#:&'",!"&( "2#'!7#$##$'&("2# !,#!-52&%25!'D>-

EF<#,'C6!,#3!,$ ("2#"2#,2!($-7#!,(#$%6('#7 ,"2#0"!"#'6+*&""#$"2!"

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

#,#(" /#!,(#$%6('#7 6,"2#,,# #,,#$"'!7#$##$ <,$6%#$(,#%,$ +3"2#7!($5(#,'-52#,#$&

#,#(",!"#'2!4#+##(*#("&(#$ ,"2#7!($ !+6""&(:"2#*!&(,!$!($+#2&($"2!"I2&7#,# #,,&(:"'!7#$##$' G H!($G -&"5!''6+*&""#$"2!"&("2#!

,#'!&$'!7#$##$'-"2# 77#%",.',!"#'2!4#+##('25(!'

EF<#,'C6!,#3!,$-+6"'"&77"2# ",!('!%"&('5#,#*!$#!""2#,!"# *,#"2!(-

EF<#,'C6!,#3!,$ 2#'!7#$##$'<,$6%#$(,#%,$+3"2#0"!"# ,*<!," "2#!%C6&,#$ 7!($-2#(%#-"2#'#!,#"2#+#'"<&#%# #4&$#(%#6,"2#,-,#<73&(:""2# !,:6*#(",!&'#$+37#!,(#$%6('#7 ,"2#7!($5(#,'"2!""2#77#%",

2!$ &G#$,!"#'D >-

EF<#,'C6!,#3!,$ ,,#:&'",!"&( "2#'!7# $##$'&("2#!,#!-&"5!''6+*&""#$"2!""2#'#,!"#'$&

#, ,$&

#,#("!,#!' >-

EF<#,'C6!,#3!,$-!'&''6:2""+#,# #,,#$"-&'(""2#,!"# , "2##("&,#!,#!!%C6&,#$ = #!,$7#!,(#$%6('#7 ,"2#<!,"&#'!($<#,6'#$"2#<!<#, +1!($"2#,#7#4!(",# #,,#$,#%,$ ? '<#,'&"#<7!( G <,$6%#$(,#%,$-"2#!%C6&,#$7!($ &''25("+#7%!"#$%7'#""2#6'0"!($-&(&0#%,#"!,&!"!($,!&( !,1#""5!'("$&'<6"#$"2!""2#7!($ ,,!&(!,1#"5!'!%C6&,#$ *6%2<,&,&("&*#""2#!%C6&'&"&( 7!($&("2#<,#'#("%!'#0%27'- 77#:#'!($,#'&$#("&!7%7(&#'2!4#!7'+##('25("+#7%!"#$%7'# " "2# !%C6&,#$ 7!($ 2# !%" "2!" "2# !%C6&,#$ 7!($ ,*#$ <!,"

*6(&%&<!77&*&"' 0!

&$(5!'("$#(&#$,*"2#!

,#'!&$ !%"'-&"%!( '!

#73+#%(%76$#$"2!""2#!%C6&,#$7!($5!' &" ,6,+!(&'!"&(+#&(:

7%!"#$%7'#""2#$#4#7<#$!,#!'&("2#%&"3 > ""2#"&*# !,:6*#("'-7#!,(#$%6('#7 ,"2#7!($5(#,'

'6:2""<7!%#,#7&!(%#6<("5'!7#$##$' G=!($G 2#7!($ <#,"!&(&(:"'!7#$##$ G= $!"#$

=-52#,#+3(#1!(!77!($ 5!''7$!"!(!4#,!:#<,&%# -A

EF<#,'C6!,#3!,$-&'7%!"#$+#3($ "2#!%C6&,#$7!($-52#,#!'"2#7!($<#,"!&(&(:"'!7#$##$ $!"#$

-52#,#+37!($*#!'6,&(:?

'C6!,#3!,$'5!''7$!"!(!4#,!:# <,&%# -

EF<#,'C6!,#3!,$- ,*'<!," "2#!%C6&,#$7!($#'&$#'

"2&'-"2#7!($5(#,'2!4#<,$6%#$(,#%,$*!(3"2#,'!7#$##$'-$#"!&7' 52&%2!,##G",!%"#$+#75) G !"#

,#!

#4#(6# "!70!7# 4#,!:# #:&'",!"&( 07$ '"!"# ('&$#,!"&( <#,

'C3!,$'

&( 'C6!,# 3!,$ &(

&$( -

!*<6,!

-A

&$(

-=>-

F$F -

&$(

-=>-

> =

??FE

F$F -?>-

@ =

F$F

@ =

F$F -

? A

&$(

@ >

F$F -@>-

A= 0&(:2<6,!

F$F -

F$F

E A

F$F ->

E =

&$(

? A

F$F

A E

F$F

-=>-

@= F$F A-

A-??EF ?E

@= F$F A-

A-??EF ?

F$F =-

= ?

F$F -A=-

? E =

F$F

?=E ?

A F$F A -

> >

@ F$F @?-

A8F F$F - -

@ =

F$F -

@ =

F$F

@ =

F$F

E A

F$F -

E @

F$F - =-

A@E AE

F$F

A@E

F$F >

A@E

F$F ->

A@E

F$F

A@E @

F$F

A@E

F$F >

A@E =

F$F -=

A@E ?

F$F =

A@E

F$F -=

A@E8

F$F = -

A@E8E

F$F >

A@E/ A

F$F >

A@E A

A8F@ F$F

= A@E

F$F >

A@E

F$F -A

> A@E A

8F@F F$F A-?

A@EJ

F$F ->

F$F >

F$F ->

? A

F$F

I A E

? A

F$F

I A@E

F$F - -

I A@E

? A

F$F

E A A

F$F @

? A

F$F

? A

F$F

? A

F$F

@ 2#'!7#%('&$#,!"&(<!&$&(*'" "2#'!7#$##$'-52#,# "2#!,#!$#!7"5&"2&'!7'7!,:#!'%*<!,#$""2#'!7#$##$' G=!($ -'6:2""+#,#7&#$6<(+37#!,(#$%6('#7 ,"2#7!($5(#,'-&'

EF<#,'C6!,#3!,$-"2#,5&'#"2#<,&%#,!(:#'+#"5##(

EF!($

EF<#,'C6!,#3!,$ &($&(:2!'+##(,#%,$#$+3"2#%6,"+#75"2!" "2#7!($<#,"!&(&(:"!77"2#!

,#'!&$'!7#$##$'&'7%!"#$!$;!%#("",&( "2#4&%&(&"3 "2#!%C6&,#$7!($"5!'#4#('!,:6#$+37#!,(#$%6('#7

,"2#7!($5(#,' ("2#7&:2" (6*+#, '!7#$##$'<,$6%#$(,#%,$+3"2# 7!($5(#,''25&(:"2#4!76# "2#7!($D-

EF<#,'C6!,#3!,$-"2# '!7#",!('!%"&(' G=!($G -52&%2!,#&'7!"#$-'25&(:2&:2#, 4!76# "2#7!($%!(("+#,#7&#$6<(!($2!4#,&:2"73+##(&:(,#$#4#( +3"2#%6,"+#752#,#&'(#,,,&("2# &($&(: "2#%6,"+#75&( &:(,&(:"2#'!7#$##$' GH!($G !7'-!'"2#,#&'!,#%&"!7&( "2'#'!7#$##$',#:!,$&(:!%C6&'&"&( 7!($-52&%2'25'"2!""2'#5#,# :",#:&'"#,#$!"2&:2#,<,&%#'5&"2!4&#5"%,#!"##4&$#(%#2#77#%", 2!$!7,#!$3!''#''#$"2#%*<#('!"&( "2#!%C6&,#$7!($DAA-

<#,!%,# ,"2#7!($6<""2#$#<"2 "5!%,#'(0!

&$(F&($!$- 0!

&$(3#F<!''!$!($!&,6*1&(7!($!($D >-

EF<#,

? !%,# ,"2#7!($7%!"#$+#2&($"2!" %!7%67!"#$D-

EF<#,'C6!,# 3!,$-"2#<,&%#<#,!%,#567$%*#6"" >-

EF'"2#!

,#'!&$ '!7#",!('!%"&('<#,"!&("'*!77<7"'!($!%6" *#,#73AAK&'!<<7&#$ "2#,#(%('&$#,&(:"2# !%""2!""2#'#<#,"!&("'*!77<7"'-"2#4!76#'2!77 %*#6""A

EF<#,!%,#'"2#77#%",2!'!7,#!$3!5!,$#$ "2#%*<#('!"&(DAA-

EF<#,!%,# ,"2#7!($6<""2#$#<"2

"5!%,#'(0!

&$(F&($,!$-0!

&$(3#F<!'',!$!($!&,6*1&( 1&($ 7!($-2#(%#-"2#,!"#!7,#!$3:&4#($#'("%!77 ,!(3&("#, #,#(%# ' !,!'"2#7!($7%!"#$+#3($"5!%,#' ,*"2#,!$- , 52&%2 %*<#('!"&( 2!' +##( !5!,$#$ D >-

EF <#, !%,# &'

%(%#,(#$- &( *3 <&(&(- "2!" %#,"!&(73 $#'#,4#' " +# &(%,#!'#$ %('&$#,&(:"2# !%""2!"$&

#,#(%#&("2#4!76# 7!($!+6""&(:"2#,!$ !($+#3($"2!"-#'<#%&!77352#("2##("&,#7!($ !77'5&"2&("2#*6(&%&<!7 7&*&"'&'(""2!"*6%22#,#!,#"2#,'*!777&(1,!$'&(+#"5##((*3 <&(&(-!%6" K("2#4!76# "2#7!($!+6""&(:"2#*!&(,!$567$ +#,#!'(!+7# "#,!<<7&%!"&("2#,# -"2#4!76# "2#7!($+#3($"5 !%,#' ,*"2#*!&(,!$567$%*#6""

-? -

EF<#,!%,#-52&%2 "2#7!($5(#,'!,#2#7$#("&"7#$" (4&#5 *3!

,#'!&$$&'%6''&('-"2#!5!,$ "2#77#%", !''#''&(: %*<#('!"&(D AA-

EF<#,!%,# ,"2#7!($6<""2# $#<"2 "5!%,#'(0!

&$(F&($,!$-0!

&$(3#F<!'',!$!($!&, 6*1&(1&($ 7!($&'6<2#7$!($"2#7!($5(#,'!,#2#7$#("&"7#$" %*<#('!"&(D

-? -

EF<#,!%,# ,"2#7!($+#3($"2!"2#3'2!77 !7'+##("&"7#$"!77'"!"6",3+#(# &"'!4!&7!+7#""2#*6($#,"2#%" A 2#!<<#!7'!,#$&'<'#$ &("2#!+4#"#,*'

!;#'2&($!7 6$:# #%#*+#,