M/S Luxmi Saraswati Agro Pvt Ltd v. State Of Punjab And Others
!"!# $!!
! !#!
#%&'#((&) **
+,-.
/+-!
!-!!
0.#
-! !"!# -
+,-! - /
-!#!
-! !"!# -
!+
1".+ * - !+
!"!-!.
! "!
# $$$$ !+
!"!-!.
2 * 34 %& '() *+,+ ,- '( ) *++ ,-
! . #
& !/ . 0 #
'() *+,+ ,-.
1 !/
!
.+ '
! 2 / ..
.& .. &#& & / .
. 1 !
/
/ 3 /.. - 1 // #!
.. / & 1 ! .. &#&/ 1 / / #
/ 1 "
&& .& .. & ..
. !
#
'!
.. / .&4 &
.& & ,-561 / &!
/,5 1 !. .& /
& !. 0'2 ! !# 0'2 7!.& 1 !
! !
#& ' !
. %& 48 9% 4:
.% 4 .. . ;,+,- 8
3!
5*.. & <,5- !# .#.& = !
5.#.& & !. #
!. /.& !. !
.. / & 1 < ,-56 . 3 /!
.
3 / !
1
.. & <,-56 / &
,*,- #& / . # 6 4
!
.
.. & < /
,5- !#
# . !
. .. & & !. # .. !
.#.& &1 .. & < ,-56 .& . . . #!
.
53 /!
!
# /.. &!
/ ,5- !..&
1 !. &! !
#. #& .
; 4
!
. !# '.!
- .&
..&.
/ !
2 !
./#. / 3 /!
.. # .. &!
/<,5- > !
.. / & !
/<,5-1 !/ .. !
/< ,5-& !.&1 !
.. / & !
/ < ,5- !
#
3 /!
1 &.& !
!.
!
+ 2 /! # #.
.
!
. ? . /! # ! !.
1 ..
.& /! '.!
-8880 '!
.. / .&,-561 . .!
.& @-88
/ !
.& ..# 7!
5.& >> . /
! "
# $ A . # 7! .!
! .. & .. !
/<,5- ! /.& #
B
93 /!
:!
/,-56 '
.& .. &!
/<,5- ! .& .!
.!
9 ..
!
.. /!
/,5-:
#
* .. /! # ! .. &!
/<,5- !. !
.. /#!
5.#.& &1 !. !
.. / !
!.& & #& 1 !. C & !
.. / , ) # .& #& .
# .&
! .&
#.1 & ..&
.. !.&
!
5.#.& D!/% C :#.! ' !
.. / 7!
5 . &
! .&
#. .& .
5 .
!. # # . 1' !
. % &'
& ( ) ! " "
!!
(# "
' ( % *
' + ! ,- ./01 ! & !
' # !
# !'
" ' & ! 2 + ! ( ""
!
! " # '
"
# ! & ! '
"
# ' "
# !
! ""
# !
" " & ! & ' *3* *3* 4 ""
'
+ ! ( " (# " " ! ' "
# !
!
"
#
( + ! ) ( "
) ! "
(
"
'
"
( # "
(#
'
( !
)
" (# * 3
' 2 ' /67801 **
!
: /** "" 07 - ' "
60 6-1 ;60 2! "
! (!
" ! "
( ! " "&
""
(!
" ! ( "
(!
" ! "
(# (#
# ) # !
"
(!
" ! < (# * "( & ! # "
# (# "
" &
(
3 ! 2 6- ) "
( # ! "
! !
& # !! ! 3 (!
" !
!! ! #
"" ! 8 ! 67- ,/61 ! # )
"
#
"
( 2"
# &( ( # "!
# "
!
"
)
"
"
# "!
=>
# '
"
# "!
' # !
'
# & '
? )!
' "" "!
! !
"( (#
( "
(# & "
'
! @ '
( &
> ! @ "& "
' #
5
" & ! # ( ! "& "
( # (# ! @ / .
A 5
' 6 "" 6, ,
* 5 ' , " ,B1$ 2 "
" & + 3
' 2 ' /67801 **
#' ( !
! @ ' !
) & ( ""
(# * !! C * D & & 3 /67771 B ** ,, / "
68
61E"
F! G 6 !
' 2 /@< ( # 1 /
1 B ** 8 / "
6
6-61 F < & & /
-1 ** , 6 / "
6
601 ) 5 &
( ""
&
(# * 2 * I 5 * " 5& !
/67,-1
*F 6B8 :
2F 67,- * 6,BB'
+ " ! " (# # .
,/01 ! # ' 676 ) " & +
6B (!
"# ! & " ( & (# # .
@ & # " & "
! "
' # .
! & '
!
: /67,-1 *F 6B8'
" 67 :
2F "" 6,76 7' "
;B ( /61 ! , " # & # .
" " "# ! & "
"! . @ &
( /1 , & " G '
( /1 ! ,' @ & ( & "
# = # .
( '
! ' " ? 2 # .
# . @ &
# .
" ""
' @ & "
" & ! ( /01 ! ,'
.
@ & # " + (# ( ' .
( & " ' !! ! ( /01 (
/1 ! , !
! .
& "( (# (
/01' " & .
( /61 ! , ( & ( /01 ! , "
"
.
# ! & ! ! , ! "
6B (!
"# ! & " , - 67-7'
& " "
6 67, 2 ' & ! + ! 6B " ! " " "# ! 6 67, ' "
! &#
, ) "!
! "
# ( '
"
( /
" ! "
( 1'
( /01 ! , ( ( ""
"
"
> ' !
'
# .
+ & ( /01 ! , " !
" ! " "# ! - # 2 !
.
( & " ( /01 ! , .# & "
""
' .
# " "# ! - # * + #' @ & & ( &
" ! " (
/1 ! , ) @ & ' !
' ( ! ! ' @'
67-7$ ! 2 F < J# &) "
J#' /67B81 0 ** 7B' "
(
""
! ""
( #
# " & ! F ' 67 B'
: /** "" 0
' "
, ;, > & ( +#
' #'
& (C !
"< 2 .
A 5
' 6 ' 67 " 8 "
!
"
<
E !!
!
!
!
) & ' &' ( ""
)
"
( /.
A 5
' " 6,1 C )
"
"
# "!
)
! ' > '
!
! ! &
' # &# (' #E
' "
& "" # < '
'
" '
! "
"
( '
"
"
"
8 2 " # " ! , 678B J( 67B ( < "& ( ! # " '
(!
# ! ' #' B 678B
( 0 67B '
( "
& " !
) & (!
B (!
"#
! !
! B 6788' ! " 2 (# ( "
# !
< ' (
( ( "
(# !
! "
(
(! < ' (
! # ! # ! " !
( !
+ )
C
"
"
# "!
!
"< '
""
# !
& !
! ! "
& (!
" (!
( F '
( -
67B &# # ! "
! ! ) ( F " ! % * 0
, 67B- !
" " <
" " #'
! B 678B 0 67B ( & ! ""
6- ! 5 ' 67, ) % * K) "
J# &J F '
%
#' 67B, ** 45 *
6:
2F 67B8 *
89' !
' " '
# " ( ! , 678B
6 67B >
" "
,
678B ! ! ! ! +
6 67B < & ' (
# ! "
& "" !
! & (!
(
( # !
& $ "#$
% & ) &
( ""
#
C .3 /31 5 & .
. /67B81 ** 0 8 / "
61'
&
( ""
& ! !
"
"
& ( !
(
'
& ! *
C %
)
& /L) ! * 1 /
01 , ** 8,- / "
01 1 .
#&C :#.! ' !
# 5 !/ 7! .&.#. 1 #& .!
#
5 . 2
. !
.. & . 1 /&!
/,5-
/ #!
!
/ &&!
/,-56 #!
#!
3 !
/,5- . & ! & !. !. !
. !
. / #!
/! #& . *88/# . .6 '
! 1 ' !
#
/ . /! 7! . / /! #& 222 '
! 2 !
!
./!
. / 1 # .& /!.#!
.. / .
2
#
.
.
#!
/
/!
.
& ..
& . 1 !/ .. .
.&/ / !. . .. #!.
!
.!#. !
& / ' !
. .. & !
/<,-56 3 /!
1
!# .
'!
.. / .&,-56 !+
!"!-!. # ,*,-
( />
E >) > F"
H G