Pinki And ORS v. Ombir And ORS




    
   



 

!
 "
#$


%%&&

 '($
 "
#$


) % "

    
  $ $*+&"%
,#$ -
".
$
#
%%&& $
,+ #&
,#$ -
". $
$ % " 
/

$
 !+$
0+%-
". $
$ % " 
/
    

  2#
%%&&
#$+3#


 
%%&
$
!

 3
 "

4$"
""

%

"
(5
$ " 
6&'

2$(+ &-
7#4 
$
#$
82$(+ &8
4#$(5 2$(+ &
#
$9"
&'
%

2#
($

'$3 3
$'
$$"
 "


$5 $
#
"9+"

%$ 
%%&
$
#
 &
*+'$

 ,#$
)9 "$
*+'$
'
4#

.#+&$
" 



(+


:
%'

 &
*+'$
4
3
"'"

0 $& ; %&-
7#4 
$'
4#$
#
4
$$$"

< "&
; %&- ; $

+

$&
 " -
#
4
+$#$
!
45


=& 
; %&-
; $
4#$
#
""




(+


'

 2#
&3&
$%$ .

 &
*+'$

&"

%

+ "$
,

#
$
>#&
-

! '%



+ 

"#

 &
*+'$

?

#
&'

% -

4
.$$"
#

$"
3
6$
($ 3
$3 $

/;) *
4
' 3
$'
%% 
"
 "
#"
$+!

4#
'$5&

 &
*+'$

 &
*+'$
&&
"4

#
$"

"
$."
'+&%&
 9+$ -
4##
%$."
&


?)
/  ""


4
$3 $"

&
,
,"$
7#4 + "$
,


 "
 
? 6
3


'($


,+( , 3#-
4#
4
"$.$

#
$ "
$

?)
4
$3 $"


#
' 

, "%
3


+ !

4
%$
 "
#$$
#
(

' 
""



, "%

4# (# 
?)
4
$3 $"-
#
+'($

$ "
$
4

"""

#
?)

2#
2$(+ &
$'"
&&4 3
@+ 

$
 & 

"$
 "
"9+"  





   

 

   

         !  "  !    #  #   $       

  %  &'()*(++    !  ,  %-

 

".* "

'

/0 1233  4"  %  !5 

         

-"- 5

    "5 1233



 



    

 

  "123'

 



   "/   ,  123'

 



  



 ,  

  ,

""



   ""   

 

  23'

)'"6 2#
2$(+ &
$


"$ 3
"

 " -
"
 $3 $

?)-
"% 

5
4

-
"% 
 , "%
 "
%&"

4 $

$ "
$

4&&


+$$
'


 &+ 
#
&&3"
$
4 
 .&."


#
&&3"
" 

2#
2$(+ &
#&"
#
#$
 
."  
+33 
#
&&3"
.#&
4
 .&."
4#$
." 

+33 
#
.#&
#
(
& &5
'%&"
2#
$&. A$

 "
$$""
(5
&$ "
2$(+ &
$
$%$"+"

(&4 7 $ "

 

   "  

   "  ""  !         "

!"

"

 

 "

"" !   ! , 

,! 

""  "



 &5!-     

 

  5   !    

!   

 "

,





2

  

      .     ,  "

     

  ,  3  '

  8

 5 



 -     "

   "3 ./2

  ,  3   ./  "

  "  3   3 0 5  

"

      "

 

 / 



  7 "-        

   5 

*5 "3  





 5 5 , '

8

93 :5 "3  ./    3   ./  "  3  7   5



         5   "" 

  5   ,     ;  ,  3    

./           

 '

  8

  7  <    

!      ,  3    5

    ,    5  7    ,  

 5 ,"

     

 "'

8

       , 

     

   ,  4     ,   

 "   ,  "      #4'          3   0 

    " 

       !! """ !  7 "-    "

 " "



 , 5   ; ,

    !!"" !  %&'()*(++ ! !,3 0 -3

'

8

 3 ./   

8, " !5" ", 5     5    =

 >!    

 !  ?

5   0    

  9 : $  "

 

 ! 

           

   4

    

 5 

,  !  -, 

 "#4' ! 



   , 

   -       

    "

!"

   &5!-

  

  "        

  "

 



 

 



"

   $   

! 







 "! 5 

 ;-

"

   4" 

-

   

 

 8,

"   !5      *  >!

  

  !  >

      

- )9:3@'A93B&: $ 

 " " 

 ,'

!!?

%  -  ,

"

     

 "

"

 





-

 $ 

  

  



     ,  "  

 "



  

 ,"

@5-

 ,=



!?

5 0  

 9 :   

 "

"

  

  4 

   

 

     5  

  ,  "

,   

!  5   5 

!  5   "

 "" !  " ,    



,           

  -  5     =

 >!  

 !  ?

5   0    

  9 :



5 

""

, "      <     

  5   5     #4'6

  =$ "
+

&
$
%%&&


"++ &5
  ""

#
#
2$(+ &
#
&"

%%$
$&
." 

4

;
%$'$&5
  ""
#
B
)'
#$
4


"% " 
4

 "
#


0.$ ' 
,#&
2#$ )'
#$
# 
"$
$
 "$
$&
4#
" "
 "

#
'&5
''($ -
#+ -
#$
4 
$

" (&. "% 

)'
#$
2#
& 3

)
%$$
 $3 $

?)-
@+&

"$.

&&3"
.#&

$' & $&-

" & +$

.#&
+'($

#
'

$3 $
 ?)-
.&(&5

5
4


#
'

$3 $
 ?)
 "
" & +$

.#&
+'($
$
4
"5


 "%$.
#
%%&&
$'
#$
$3#

3
'%

 
2# 2$(+ &
 
(+ "

&&4
$
%$"+$
%$ $("
+ "$ C." 

 "
6"

6.&
$"+$
2#
2$(+ &
#

$+ D"
"% 
 "
"+'

$$"



$' & +$
4#$

%$ +
 +%% "

%$.

 
(5 "

$ (&
"+(
$
 $-
&$ "
+

&
$


+$$
 "
4 $
 .#&

#
'
 
  ""
#
#
2$(+ &
#
$3#&5 #&"
#
.#&

@+ 
4
& &5
'%&"

2#
&&3"

" 
!
%&



 "

)
4
$3 $"

.
#+3#
" "
%

"
45



?

#
?)-

+'($

.#&
4 
" & "
 "
.
'$!
$
&+$
 #
.#&
4 
" & "

2#
&&3"
 "% " 
4

- , "%
*+'$'%& -
9'$
 "
)'#$
E
)'
$

$'
#
'
.&&3

4&&

$ "

:$&.

#
#$ 2#+ -
)'
#$
 B
4 

 "% " 
4


2# ?

. 3 3
$
#
"% "
#
#
&"3"
?)

#

' 

, "%
*+'$
4#$
, "%
*+'$
3 "

3 $ 
($
6$' &
6+$-
#+ -
 $"
 $!
 "

&'
#
(
$3#&5
$9"

 ?
#.
%$+ "
#
$$"
 "
#$"
$3+'
 +

&
$
%%&&

2#
 ""
% 
'$3 3
$'
$$"

#  &
*+'$
'
4#

" 



 "
#
$' "

# %&
$'






2#$
 
' 
" "

$$"
$'
4##

+&"
(
+&&"
+
# &&3"
$
4
 .&."

#
" 


?)
4
$3 $"

3


"$.$

#
.#&

;4.$-
"$.$
#
(
@+"

."
9+"3' 
""


%

"
(5
&$ "
<?67#4 
2#
?)
4
$3 $"


-
#4.$-
'! &+$
$
.#&
+'($
4 
'  "

#
?)

, "% 
4# 
(# 
?)
4
$3 $"
" & "
+'($

&&3"

.#&


?
 &"
%$% 

&4
#
.&:@+ 
9+"& +#$
$

(+ "
(5
 "
$$""
(5
6$' &
6+$ (+ 


$' &
$&-
#
%$ +
#

%$.

 (5 "
$ (&
"+(
4#$

.&
$
@+ 
9+"& %$" -
'$

"""

%$% "$ 


$"

$ %$

?

#
 

# "-
#
 "
$$""
(5
6$' &
6+$

 +&"
(
3 $"
#"
#$
(
 "
(5
#
2$(+ &

.+$ 
#
%%&&
4#$

#
%$ 
 -
6$' &
6+$
#

@+"
"$.$

#
&&3"
.#&
 "
'&$
 "
#. (
$$""
(5
#
2$(+ &
2#+ -
#
 "
$$""
(5 6$' &
6+$



(
&&5
3 $"

2#
?)
4
$3 $"



4#$

" 
!
%&



/
'%
4
'"
 $$"
' 

#
" "

/
)
4
&"3"



 "
?)
4
&"3"



2#
%%&&

""

" & 
+'($-
&+$
$
'!

#
&&3"
$

?


(&.(&
#
%%&&
4$

4$
(+
$3 $

+'($

$
4#$
" & +$

&+$-
'!

$
$ @+
& 3
'
4
&

&'

#
%%&& 

2#
& $3+' 

%%&&

#
5
4

4

 "% " 4

4#$
$ % "
$
  " 3
#
#


$ "
 , "%
 "
#5
$

#
'
.&&3-
#+ -
#



$ "
4



B##$
5
4

4
$ "

, "% $
" "


$$&. 
$3+' 
(+ 
' 

.

'&5
''($

(
$&"
+%
(+ 
%$"
($ 2$(+ &
$

$' &
%$" 

;4.$-
#
%%$  
&&3"
5
4




4#$
" 
!
%&


$ %
$
"+(
, "%-
'%& 
 ?)
3
'

3
$'
9'$
 B
4#

+$
#"
3
'

3 $'
)'
#$-
B

#&"
(5
&$ "
2$(+ &-
, "% +&"
 &5
 
)'
#$
 "
 $'
%&
(+

 $3 $ +'($

#
$

2#
%%&&
%"

$'

& 
$'




-
4##
$
"+(

?


& 
 ""

#
, "%

# ' 
($
$& 6+$
3 "
3 $ 
(+
' 
$$""
(5
%& 4#$
%&
$

# ' 
($
&$ "
2$(+ & 3$&&5
+('"
#
#
#
$3 $"
?)

#
(
 '%& 

, "%
 "
+'($

$
4
$$""

# (

' 

, "%
2#
%&
$
#
& 
"

#
$3 $ +'($

$
4
" & "
(5
, "%

#

' 
""



7$
#
$&
6+$-
, "%


#
$

A' 
# "
#
#
# 
'"


' 
($
%&

;
#
+$#$
$+ "

"'
#
# $'"
%&
#
)'
#$

4


" 
 "
# )'
#$
#
 $'"
$3 $ +'($

$
2#  $"
 $!

?

+$#$
%


#
5
4

# "
#
" "
4
'. 3

#
'$5&
4## 4
#"

#
$
 "
&&3"
$
' 3
$'
%% 
"- #
'$5&
 "
"$.$
%"
45
$'
#
%
?
'

$3+
#
5
4

4
'. 3
(# "
'$5&
 " "
 "

$
' 3
$'
%% 
"-
$+!
# '$5&
(+
$

#
4

$' "
+ +#"
2#$


+$#$

." 
@+
"'3

&&3"
$
?

& 
#3#&5 '%$((&
#

$
'
4#

" 
4#

'$5&
(+ #$
 
"'3

$ ?

.4

(.

 "
$+'

  -
?
"

 "

5
 $'5

#
$"$
%

"
(5
&$ "
2$(+ &

2#
%%& " $.

(
" '

"
 "
$" 3&5
" '

"

 

 

9+ B##$
%! 3:$ "

F :/



'

 C %