High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/4906/2012dismissed

Seema Sharma v. General Public And ORS

2019-07-24Mrs. Justice Rekha Mittal9 pages

!"#$ %&'($$) (''#

$ %

' #$ %

& (%

***** $) (''#+%,- )#*""&

% " +, "

* % " -,%

. %"

/%$ %

)#& "

&& /" 2#2/# - # # " % 2 * 0 ,1# 3 - #

- # #,1# ,%#

# ,1# 3 - # "20&" & /0 ", %"

%# ""1 "

&% && / 2 1!# $5, ( 6780 ,1 7+, /

2 &, $ 0 "

+, && / 2 1 !# 60 97 0

!2 0 :2 $2 ;

-$0 #&0

0 ,"

,$0&

* #, %

"%"

, && %"

01(7# #2

, ",%% #3 - )# & ( % # %# ""1 +,

" , # ,&<""

7&,& 2=%, 2/"

#3 *#

"/ & / # /

> 3 # # 8, # % "/ -% %# ""1 " %%& &" &% #<""&&,2/#0 )#,&, % #%

#3 -* ,#& , #*"%!$ * ,1# 0"/0

,%#

* -# ',0 * 2 ,#& # / 3 - &0 0 1 * # :0"

3 -& /

> -#$% -$

-#* ,0 # , :0"

#%*3 - #/

8," *," 1,

/',0 9 & " &&"%

, /

1 ,%%

% %

&% 2 %, " 2# 2/ 3 -$ !#',0 :0"

*##%"

0#0" 2 #"/"1 " # %% # % ,00 ,%#

21 ,1# !#',0 )# ", %"

%# ""1 # " *#" %"

01 &

2/&

&## #= (7 #, &&

4# "" &&"%

20&"

& / #&%11 ,%%% %

2/ & 9 " *

0 2, "

# " &&"%

00 # *

0 ,& <""

7 &,& 2 =%, 2/ # - # *#2/ :0"

* 1 "0

&& #3

#:0"

# 0 2 # 2/ !# ',0 # =%", 0 ,%#

$ ,1# ""1

8," *," 1,

% &%11 ,%%% %

$ /',0 # ,& /

0 %

3 - # =%, <"" # , @ , # 1,

3 - # #

% ""/=%, <"" , /',0 !#',0 $

# * 1 =%, "

&,& 2=%, 2/ # ,%#

# ,20 0 2/ %,"

1 " <"" # 2 &,% % & * &0

& #<""2/* /% / %2, ,2-%

& 1 " @ 1,

# ,% / % & "1 "%,0 #$ % ,% 2/ #0 & # <"" *"" #" 1 %%& &" & ( 5# , # 1,

<"",,2/ ,&%,%%,0

% #%

" #<""

0 & 2/#0

"1 & 2,

,% / % * # 1 / %0 &

"/ #%,0 % & & 0 2/ #0

"1 & 5# "%# ""11 #8, &% # " , & * # ,20

# " * #, %

#,"

( , 8," & 1 & $ # % /$ # ,&& % 1%2/ #8, 1

1%# ""1

" %%& 1 # <"" &&, 2/ / ',0 @ 1,

% /',0 % % %&/

# <"" 0 # % #

# # 211

4$ # &2"/ %," %"

0 # 1# # ,%%&%1 <""&" 2/* / 00 #*

0 @ , # 1,

#&" 1 ,2

0 %

0 1 ""/" #,

2/ 0 ?,"/

4$ /',0 # /&" * # 1 % 3 1" 2# <"" , #@ , #2 1,

% /',0 * & #1 "<"" #"/% % %&/

#<""0 #%#

#$## 0 & "

#1 "%,0 ), %

#<"" ,,2/,&%,%%,0

% * #%

" #1#"1# 2/ %," 1,

# 2 ,% "/

2"# %

0 # 2 1 # # 0

" 1 & ) ) # ! # ,%

0) ) @ 1,

0 1,"

/ %% "1 # 0

" %,0 0 # 8, # 0 " %1# 2 ) ) & #%= 0

21 2" # &,% # %,0 %%1 %,"$ 0 # 0

# % = 0

#%,0

/ %

2"* ## &

# # 0 # ,#& $ #

/ * # #

#A 0"/

0 # % ,%

0 @ , # ,20

# <""$ # 2 &%% ""/ 0

0 *

! & 2/#0

"1 & / %0 & * &0 *# 0 *

/2/#0

"1 & %%,

##0 #

# / *# 0 * "

" %#" 3 - #

"/&0%0 1* #:0"

@# # %," #& $&, #& &62!

% #, & 0

,%,% 0,%#"%1 %

2"##&"

# ,"

, %$ +, 2 & ! %0 " %# 1@ # * #0

$1 #8, &% " %# ""1 2/ 0 "

2" 2 0 %%1"/ )#21 #8, 1 % &% # <"" &&, 2/ "

&&"%

00 #*

0 &" #1 <""

7&,& 2=%, 2/#3 5 &%%&"

% %&/ #<""* , %#

, /

48,"

& , / 0

" %

# &" & 2 "@ #1 %%,0

%$ #* %% /',0 ,& #<""+, &%11 ,%% % %

, /

,2 # <"" +, 0"/ 2% , # =%, * " ?

, /

, /',0 @ # * # 0

$ % 2/ %," * # 1 "

&,% <"" +, 0%%

%%1"/-% 8," $& +,/$*," "/ 0

1 <""&&,2/ 2& 2/= 01 %2

1* /',0 " &&"%

& 1 # <""2/ % / % 0 * ""* 2/ " 8, ,2-% -, & " &, "

7 4 *#2/ " 8, ""*

&&"%

& <""2/* /% / %$

,%# &" # 2

1 " <"" # 2 " % /$&"

#" 2, # <""

4 *#% %&/ # 0* , #"%#3 " &"

#1 "<"" #& # 0# 20&"

%$ *,"2

/ -, % # & % "" ,& & # " 1 "<""@ # * #0

$ % 2# /

% & "1 "%,0 % %&/ #& 2/ #* 0 #% 1 1 # /% 2",& )#21 #8, #+, <""21,, 2/,&%,%%,0

%, " #%,0 *," "

1# ,#*:0"

# *,"2

" -/ #&& /,1#" 02, #*," 2

" "

# 02/* /0 1$ "$1 %

#:0"

#&& /* #" 2*#& -#',0

* # &%% % # && *#%# *," 2%0 # * *#%# *," 2 * ,& -# ',0 )# " % # ,1# 0"/ ,%#

0 2, #/ # 2 =%", 0 #

% 2/ /1

,0 $

(6 # 2 !& 1,%#

#% ,1# 0 2 ##,#0

"1 & ,1# # 211 ,& , " 21

! %

# 0

1 & A#, !1# #1# 2% #<""

0 2 & 2/#0

"1 & 0,%# " # * %0 &

0 1 0 # ##, # 0

" 1 & # 21# "/

1,2/%,"

#,% % %

0 2 ,/1

) ) ## &,% / %,0 &

# # 2 1 0

##,#3 ## 21

1 ,%

0 )#

21$% 2/%,"

" #<"" " & 1 & 0 # ,"

0 &

# %

" ,&& % ,

*## " # "1 " 2

"2 #8, 2"* @ # * # 0

$ @ %,"

* # # 1 8, *#" %%& 1&" # &

% 3 - # " 2#<""

7 #2 *#0 ,%#

*=%",0#

%+, 00 2"&& /* 2/ #%

" #<"")# #1%

2 # &&

" # <""$ # % " 2# / #&& /*#%#* ## 2/:0"

# 2/ &

# :0"

!# ',0 $

#$ %"

0 * # 1 #

"0 (7 # , && #21

" %"

2/&

& #&& # 1# "/2-% 2/ #8, #& 2

@ **#

2%,#2$ && " " %%1"/0* #% B;C,"

A <# #& !1(

/( <# #&