Mann Cold Storage v. State Of Haryana Through Collector Karnal And ORS.

    
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
     



 *(&  *(&  *(&  *(& 

=0A 0A 0A 0A 1 &544'# &544'# &544'# &544'#"

"

"

" 

< 

 

 

 

 

       























     ++&,,*'( ++&,,*'( ++&,,*'( ++&,,*'(







    














!!!!









  




&+'.&'( 
&+'.&'( 
&+'.&'( 
&+'.&'(01






=0A

=0A

=0A

=0A 1

 

 

 

 

       























     ++&,,*'( ++&,,*'( ++&,,*'( ++&,,*'(

 


 


 


 


!



!



!



!
 








&+'.&'( 
&+'.&'( 
&+'.&'( 
&+'.&'(01

"





=0A

=0A

=0A

=0A 1

 

 

 

 

       























     ++&,,*'( ++&,,*'( ++&,,*'( ++&,,*'(

 


 


 


 


!



!



!



!
  




&+'.&'( 
&+'.&'( 
&+'.&'( 
&+'.&'(01



1 
 # 
 # 
 # 
 #    %&&'(#

%



% $ 
 
  $ 
 
  $ 
 
  $ 
 
           >'4*! %.95*(&/4() *%9&&'*>%!.95*(& ()&*++&,,*'(-,*'./'&% 7)4)&:*.*9!!*%;

;*'* ???? !0%*,1 !0%*,1 !0%*,1 !0%*,1 
   
   
   
   2 3  4.

.&()4566'%.&%!
 

!

A

*%& 7&4'8 .&54.&. * * *,, ()& *++&*, )*9& *%4&'  >(   566' *5@>44(4'-/ /*%. 4'9,94'8 4.&'(4 45*, *5( *'. @>&(4'   ,*/ % ()& *:&   7%&94(;! *5( *%& 6


7&4'8(*:&' %6 3  ; /*;   +%&&'( *++&*,01! 5)*, ,,&'8& )* 7&&' ,*4. ( ()& / /*%. .*(&.

 

<+*&.7;()&,&*%'&..., 4(%45(>.8&!*%'*,0)&%&4'* (& %(

7&%& &%%&.*( )&B
& &%&'5&>%(C1!/)&%&7;

;
& &%&'5&&(4(4'01 4,&.>'

'.&%

&5(4'    () )& *'. 5@>44(4' 5(! D

 0 % )%( B()& D  5(C1 *( 4'(*'5&   ()& & ,*'./'&%01 /* +*%(,; *,, /&. ()&%&7; */*%.4'8 7&'& 4( &')*'5&. 6*%:

&( 9*,>& H
 <-G +&% @ ;*%. 7&4.& */*%.4'8 (*(>( (%; 7&'& 4(-4'(&%&( *+%94.&.>'.&%()& D 5( 2"3  % 4& ,; (*(4'8! 4' ()& +%&&'( 5* *&01! 5&%(*4' ,*'. /'&. 7; *++&,,*'(-,*'./ /'&% 4(>*(&. /4()4' ()& %&9&'> >& &(*(&   94,,*8& *7* *%'

'*,! &)4, *'. 4 (%45( *%'*,! 5*6& ( 7& *5 5@>4%&. 94.& (4 45*(4' .* *(&.



 DD *'.

. E

 DD  4>&. >'.&% & &5(4'  A =   ()& D   5( %&+&5(49&,; ()&+>7,45+>%+&'*6&,; ()&.&9&,+6&'(*'.>(4,4K*(4'

' ,*'.*%&4.&'(4 4*,*'.566&%54*, &5(%

*'.<!%7*'(*(&!*%'*, 3 88 8%4&9&. *8*4'( ()& * %&*4 4. *5@>44(4' +%5&&.4'8! *++&,,*'(-,*'./ /'&%+%& &%%&.I <

 DD !/)45)/*.&54.&.7;( ()4 >%(94.&%.& %.*(&. E

/)4,&.4%&5(4 4'8()&%&+'.&'((5'4.&% 7F&5(4' >'.& &% &5(4' <G   ()& D  5( ( 7&&' +%& &%%&. *( ()& 4'(*'5& &  *++&,,*'(-,*'./ /'&% .64((&.,;! ()& 7F&5(4'

' /&%&.&*,( /4() *'. %&F&5(&. 7; *'.5@>4 4(4',,&5(% ,,/&.7; %& &)(4 45*(4'>'.&% &5(4'= ()& D  5(  '

>7&@>&'(,;! *'

' /*%. /* +*&. 7; ()& * *'. 5@>44(4', ,,&5(%4'&J&%54& +/&%>'

'.&% &5(4'  ()& D 5( (' D "

 ()& %&7; .&(&%64'4'8 ()& 6*%:&( 9*,>&   ()& *5@>4%&. ,*'. *
 !< !

-G+& &%*5%&7&4.&*/*%. ()&%(* *(>(%;7&'& 4(-4'(&%&( 2<3 &4 4'8 .4G*(4 4&. ()&%& ! ()& *++&,,*'(01G,*'./'&%01 4'9:

:&.
& &%&'5&>'.&% % &5(4'  ()& D 5(!/ /)45)5*6&(7&+*%(,;*,,/&.

.7; ()& ,&*%'&.
&

&%&'5& >%( 94.& 4( */*%. .

.*(&.

 

<! ()&%&7; 8%*'( (4'8 &')*'5&. 56+ +&'*(4' H
 <-G +&% @ ;*%. 7&4.& */*%.4'8 *,, ( ()&%

(*(>(%;7&'& 4( (-4'(&%&(4'()&4% *9>%>'.&%() )& D 5(88%4&9&.*8*4'( '(*'5& ,*'./'&% *6&!()&+%&&'

'(*++&*,/&%&+%& &%%&.*(()&4 2=3 6+ +>8'4'8 ()&* %&*4. /*%.! , ,&*%'&. &'4%5>'&, %&+&&'( (4'8 ()&*++&,,*'(-,*'

'./'&%>764(()*(>'.&%464 4,*%54%5>6(*'5&*'./4()%&+ +&5( (()&,*'. %6 64'8+*%( ()&*6&*5@>44(4'

'*'.()&%&9&'>&&(*(&!()&6*% %:&( 9*,>& (*'. 4'5 5%&*&. (
 E= +&% @ ;

;*%. 7; ()4 >%( 94.& F>.86 6&'( .*(&. E

%&'.&%&.4' E

DDD0%4F )*'*'.*'()&% %4F )*'*'.*'()&% %4F )*'*'.*'()&% %4F )*'*'.*'()&% 9 9 9 9

(*(& *%;*'*

(*(& *%;*'*

(*(& *%;*'*

(*(& *%;*'* **'.*'()&% **'.*'()&% **'.*'()&% **'.*'()&%1*'.()>!()&*++ +&,,*'(-,*'./'&%4&'(4(,&. 464,*%7&'& 4( 2= 3  I) )4,& %& &%%4'8( ()& .&544' %&'

'.&%&. 4' 5*&  &%'*%. %*'

&%'*%. %*'

&%'*%. %*'

&%'*%. %*'

'54 '54 '54 '54 &+) *K * &+) *K * &+) *K * &+) *K *'.

'.

'.

'.

. % 9 9&%'6&'(   *%'

. % 9 9&%'6&'(   *%'

. % 9 9&%'6&'(   *%'

. % 9 9&%'6&'(   *%'

'*(*:* *'. %!

'*(*:* *'. %!

'*(*:* *'. %!

'*(*:* *'. %! %&+%(&. * M

<

<

<

<   "

  "

  "

  "L ! ,&*%'

'&. &'4% 5>'&, *, >764 4( ()*( '5& ()& %&) '(4 45*( (4' >'.&% &5(4'= ()& D 5(/*4>&.'

'

*'.()>/*7&; '. '& ;&*%   ()& & %484'*, '(4 45*(4' >'.&% &5 5(4'    ()& D  5( 4>&. '



 DD!()& &'(4%&*5@>44(4'+%5&&.4'85 5'&@>&'(,;,*+&.*'.()&,*'.

.4' @>&(4'/*()> >!,4*7,&(7&%&(>%'&.(()&,*'

'./'&% 2E3 ' ()& ()&% )*'.! ,&*%'&. (*( (& 5>'&, )* '( 7&&' *7,&  ( 5'(%9&%( ()&

*5(>*, *+&5( /4() %&+&5( ( ()& 4'*, .&(&%64'*(4' 56+&'*(4'*7 7>(()&*5@>44(4'4')*'.7&* *(
 E=-G+&%@;*%.8%*'

'(&. 7; ()4 >%(  /&9&%! )&&%4>,; ++& ()& +%*;&% 6*.& ' 7&)*,   ,*+&. *++&,,*'(()*(() )&*5@>44(4'+%5&&.4'8)*9&, 23   ) )*9& )&*%. ,&*%'&. 5>'&, ()& +*%(4& *'. 8'& ()%>8) +*+&% 7: 

4'. >7(*'5& 4' ()& >76 644' 6*.& ' 7&)*,   *++&,,*'(-,*'./ /'&%

2D3  %&8*%.()&+,&* *5@>44(4'+ +%5&&.4'8)*94'87&&',*+&.

.' *55>'( .&,*;

;&..&5,*%*(4' (4 45*(4'- ->7,45*(4'>'.&% &5(4'= D 5(4>&.

.'

!4(4+&%(4'&'( (6&'(4')&%&()*(()&*4.4 >& 5*''(7&.&*,(/ /4()4'()&+%&&'(*++&*,*'.( )&*++&,,*'(!4 *(*,,*88%4&9&./ /* ( +%& &% 494, I%4( &(4(4' 5)*,,&'84'8 ()& *4. (4 45*(4' )*94'8 4'9:

:&. %(45,&

() )&'(4(>(4' '.4*  3  I4 4()%&+&5((()&.&(&%64'*(4' 6*%:&(9*,>&!()&+%&&'(*++& &*, *%&.4+&. 

4'94&/  ()&(*'.(*:&'7; ()&5>'&, %&+%&&'(4'8 7() +*%(4&()*(()&6 6*((&%459&%&./4()()&F>.86 6&'(.*(&. E

%&'.&%&.

.7; ()4 >%(4' 







 E

 DDD

 E

 DDD

 E

 DDD

 E

 DDD (4(,&. B% %4 % %4 %4F )*' *'. *'()&%9 (*(& %4F )*' *'. *'()&%9 (*(& %4F )*' *'. *'()&%9 (*(& %4F )*' *'. *'()&%9 (*(& &  &  &  &  *%;*'**'.*' *%;*'**'.*' *%;*'**'.*' *%;*'**'.*' '()&% '()&% '()&% '()&%C*'.()&*6&4()>*& &.H
 E=-G+&%@>*%&;

;*%. 4' *9>%   () )& *++&,,*'(-,*'./'&% ' *..4 4(4'! ()& ,*'./'&% )*,, *, 7& &'(4(,&. % */* *%.   *,, (*(>(%; 7&'& 4( *'

'. 4'(&%&( * +%94.&. >'.&% +%944' () )& D 5(0*6&'.&.>+((.

.*(&1)&,*'./'&%)*,,*, 7& &'(4(,&. %,*( (4>6H"

N7&4.&*/*%. 4'

'(&%&(()&%&>+'*/&,, 2 3  ,, +&'.4'8*++,45*(4'01!4 *';! )*,,*,(*'..4+&. 
  1 
  1 
  1 
  1     5(7&% 5(7&% 5(7&% 5(7&%"

"

"

" !!!!

(4: 0 0 0 0

<

<

<

<  I) I) )&()&%+&*:4'8-%&*'&. & )&()&%%&+%(*7,& & - -