← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/5013/2012dismissed

Balwinder Singh And ANR v. Gurdarshan Singh And ANR

2018-02-19Mr. Justice Arun Monga13 pages

- 1-     



!" "#$%$& '

(







  





)* + ,+  

   

 



  



 

 ! "" ,+     $

%  

 

&'$

 (  *+*,-*!.

 $/  



 ( ( $ %  

      



  



$ 

  ( 0 ( 

"

      (

/      

(   .2.

.*-

33*4!-*2

!!!

5.2

  ,344!3464+"*

!245"*

-34!4+"*

-34-4+"*

,+44-!45"*

--4!43"!2

,344!"5  ($ / !,,3",2

7

       

 

 !

(  %   !!*443

!!!4!

 

 -

(  %   !!!4- 



 

8 6*!!!,,,

  / $/

 

  /  0 % .

(  (  

- 2-   /  (

 (   

   / (  

8 +!!!,,,

( 

    



 

 ( ( 

      

     % .

(  

  

 : 



 (   (   "

  %

( /

 : ($/  $ (     

  

  0  

; !

  % /    ( 

% .

( 

1  

  

 )  "77

  (  

-6!!!,,,  $: (   +!!!,,,

 

  $





 

  

  

 

   (   )

!

 

    1  



 (  .!-!,,,    

(

   

 

   (



"  

   

 





       

 



   

  

 

 ! "

"  

 

- 3-  

    

    # $   

 

    

 %&

 7   

(

 0( 

"

' '  

 ' ' (

) " ' * +

  ) "'

   0( ;9"!



 1

;



;9"- 

;9"6 %

 

 !

;9+

7     

  

(  

   !,*.-**+

 

 

  

!!!!-**2 ( ( $ %    



 $

  



$   



  

   

     

(

7 $ %  (

     

(

 

 $/  

 / 

  

!6*2-**.

   / 1(

< 1 $ 

 

  $    

( 

   (

$ 

  

)   $ 

6* -**5

- 4-

 

   !2*5-*!-

 

    ) 

 

(

( $ 

  !!*5-*!3

     

  (

 

((  

!,

( 



7 $ % 

( 

 &'$

 (

  $

( 



$

   (    

 

  

$

 $( $ )  $  



(  

     

< 1   !6*2-**.



 ( 

!, ( 

 " 

  ( 



 $  ("

  



  )  $

 $ 

/ 

/ 1(  

(( 

   8  -2  , ))      $" 

=->  !* 8  -2  )((

$ 0(

 

((  %

(

 $      (    

$

  (

 

/   

0( )((  / 

  

/  

( (     ( 

(  

   %

 (    ((

)((

"

0(

  ($

  

   

- 5- / 1( $ 0( ' 

?

 

 +!!!,,, =?0"!>  (  %

  1

  / 

% .

(  7  



 

 

     

$( 

((

$ 

    $

 (/   

&   

  ;  



    ! "  !# $  %!&''()*+

  

     8  -2  , )) 

$ 

)((  $    



  

( /      &     

!6*2-**.

  "  

 $

 

            

1   

,  

 

 (

$ : 

     !2

(( ( 



 

  



 

  

$  !" $(  

$ 

    !6*2-**.

 $  

   (

7   

(  

  



 %       

$  

((  

 ( 

   &

  

: 

- 6-    (  %

( (  (  

  (      

( ( %        %







/ $  



 

(   

( 



 

   

  

  

$%  

    

(



 

 

 $    $"  =-> 

!* 8  -2 ))" -././ &        ! 0  

 1    2 ! 3   '4      1     0    !2   .!

   0     /

!0 



  

     5 !

  1   ,   

  1 , 2



 23  1    

2  1 

2

            ,       ,          

      

0 "

6 (  

 (   

       

$  

(( '  

 

    

;  



  ! " !#  $ ,-= >     "

- 7- @%4       !   "    2  ! 2 

0     0 " !7 

  &

      -   1,   1  

  &

  -1!

  " &

    

 !7  2 ! 

 "

      

 1  

  "   ,   2 

" 

  1  2  

!

  !7 ,      

    

  

  0 

 8

  "   

" 

!

! 2   9

   ,  & :

0  ;

,  < (  & & -,  

 9   )   0    ) ", <1 =>- . 7?( /, ) " 0 =

  #  )8  %   - 

  $ @!

2, --. 7?( /8 0&1#2,89& %  ( ! ) "0))



#0 ,89& -#  %  ,      

 >   =

 0 A "

 & , . <</    =&   

 

!7  

  &

   -19& :

B

.

/ 0  ! !2 1  !7  "

    

   0!   !

  , 

!    

 

"

 !7   

   



0!"

0  

  2 0 

 !  



"  "4  

,      !7  "

    

 !

   ,    

    )

2,   

9   )  B

 .

/

,  

 "

 

9 

2! 0   C  

    

!7  "

   =

1  9

 

    

  2 

  2   0  

    !7 4

"  

1 ,

 "     =

 1  ,

 !  

C 8 "

 ) "B

.)8% -/.

/

, "

> "! 0 C   2  -&

, 1

    1, 



   



1  ,

2 2 0    !7 !2

    ,!

 

2 





  0       

 !7 C 4 , 

 1 ,   

 !

98 B

.

/  ( "1

%7 "! 0,C9    2 

  

 

!7 

     B   ,  !7  "

2

"      "      D ) !'

./&

, !   2 1       2   ! "      "    

   E

2

!  9

" E  ,  1                  

- 81  B       

 

   1 8   7 "!7    "         1  !



   

 

 2        0    0 2  0 0 !

"E  9   1

     "      

   "



"

  

 2!

"

2!  "    !2



) !'

./  E



       

0  !2 

!0 



  

     5 !

  1 ,     

  1 , 2



 23       

2    1  

2                  ,   9 !0      1  7   

 !7   

  B   ,  

   3 " 

  

  "  B       2



5 1

       "           

"  

 0  2!"

0!2



C9

- 1   ! 0 C   2

 !        0   0   9 

          

 

"   

, 2     0        

  

   7     





!

  3 

7    

9   , " 2 

!2     

"2!



0    $  -9 

,!

  0 

  

!7      B     

   "             2    !       "       E

2    2 C9( ! ) "B

.)

/,    C 1   !3 !2 2, !0  2 

  2

      

 0 "

 !

  4

  0 !  !2     2 !2 

!7    

    ! ",  !

"

 28 2

 !7 4    

 ! 

" 

 0!

 

  " 2  !7  !0

C9 ,  ,0   !0

 ", E   

 0    ,     !7   

   



 ,  1

   

  0  8! 0

 ,  ) "B

.

/  "

> "  ! 0    -,&

1



 



1  

2 2 0    !7 !2

1  B   ,!

 

2

 

 



  0       



- 9- !7  D     -   1, =

 1  

   

   

!  

   2 0 9

1  

    -,&

1

  0  2,&

$  0  

2 !7 



 2     )

2,   =

 1  

  3    7 

   &

 ,   ) !'

 ./  &

 , 

 "    1  

!0 

,!

 1    !    ,   2  

    E

2  

     8 "

1  !

  &

   -1,&

  0     ) !'

 ./  &

     0   C      1     0    !2   .!

   0     /

!0 



 

   5!

1  ,      1 , 2  

   

  2 3   1    

2    1  

2              ,    ,          

      

0 "

C) !'

./&

 

 " F C   1    2        

 "   1  ,   2   

   

E

2!  

  C ) !'

 ./  

2   ) !'

 ./  &

     -9    !'

1   3  1     !2 

   !2  1 ,  ,    3 1  ,1  2,        

 

   E

2 !  

  4 ,!7     1   

  

  &

9

2

,0 !7  

    1 2   1  

!

, 0   E     2   !



8   =

1     !7   

,  , " 2

   

2 

4  

2 

2   9 

, ! 0!2   ( " 1 7 "   !0,





  0   0  

 

     !7   0 "

!2=

1  8

  " &

,   1  

!0 



 

   9 ,  ,0   

     

 0 

!

 2 

   4

 

 !

! 2   2 0   

  

  0   

    9  

 

     >   =

B

 .

/      

  !2 1  ! 0

%  C GGH9, &

 < 1  1

    , 

    1  

0 "

) !'

./&

  0     1   

- 10- 0  !2 .!

0     / 

!0 



 

   ,!

1  ,    1 , 2

   

  2 3   1    

2    1 

2           ,           

   0 "

 4 ,     0     

!7 

    !2

1  I0   , !7 

!





    !2

1  , 

!  2   3

  ,  

4   !2

1       

 4  ,  

      !  

2

 !2  1

 " 

 1    2   

!    C4 ,  0     -,&

, E

0     0   

0 2 !7        

 1  

  &

 J9

, 2

!7 

!2  

   1      ,1  2    

   2          "   1  , 2 

   E

2!  

    !

   

   

 2

      4 2 0    ) !'

 ./  &

      -   1   3   1    

2  1   !21     !2 2  

         1  4 !7 ,  

 !2 

, 

 !      

'3 ,  2,

1  !21

 &

  -1  

"   0  



"6 < (  

0   $

(

((  $    (

 

  9  (

/  

0(

((  / 

   

  

  

(( (

   

  

 $   /

 

A )((  /

  

 $    

- 11-

    !*  

.

!/   )   +& ( && 

 " @4 

    0   !     

!2) )  1 , 3  

!2  1  =

 1  ,  3

 0 9 

,   ! !2 &1 

  

4

  "

00 

  

, 

  



!

"A 2!,

    

 "

"3

!







 !  

       !

       (  

    !

 

 4

=

1   !

  

 3 !2 9  E

  

=

1   



'3   !2 #  +  1 +

 #  0  0 1  , 01 &''  7 ! ( ,%   ,   "

0!2) ) :

0 "

4

    ! 

!2  

8 2I0 &1 

  "

0 2  

   4 8

 2      

 0  

     "

 !

 

 !  

    9  "



 !       !2     8

 2    " !

" !  

- 12-

    9

,

  " !    !

   

      =

1  

!21 

0  !2

9 E  





 

" !       4 0       

     "    !2 

   8

 8 2    !



    6 4  $   

.

!/,- = > $ 

 



 ,- = >

8







((

 

((   % ( ( %

 (       

 (

( 7  /"



( 

(   ) 

   

$  %     (



 $    



(/





   

  

0   $



 ,- 

     / $

  / $  



   

(( 1  

 ( 

  $ $ 

  /       



   <  

$ $ 

 

#  

 +!!!,,, !6*2-**.

   

  

   (

  -6!!!,,, .!-!,,,

- 13-  

 

  (   

$ %  (

  (

( $ %  % 0  (   

  $



  

 

 

 (/  



(



 0   (    ( 



  (    

   :   $   $



( $/   

% .

(  !,

(  

     (/

   /  /

  / (    $ )  $

( $ 

     

(





$ :     ( ) 

    ( 

    (

,+    "-./ .0 '1

( %B  4%

C   $

C