High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/5054/2012dismissed

Sukhwinder Singh v. Jaswant Singh Etc

2019-11-29Mr. Justice Sudip Ahluwalia7 pages

!""#$%$&'(")*"+,-, ./01$&2"+$&3044"55 &! 6% %1 &!$&30 +% "%4&2"&!%

!"#"$%&

+ &3$-2(# !"+!0"44"55 &!

+74 + $-2(# !"+ "%4&2"&!%

% )$& 0$+-"4.!82(# !""&"+ 5-.&9 *

' 0$%44" 50 %*""&4+""++"2 3 $&%!!0".23)"&! &2"#+"" 4 %%"2*8!0":2225$%!+$#!.23"-:.20$ & $& $($544" 5 ;2 !"2<=-($2"10$#0-!0"+$3$& 5.23)"&!

"#+""2$%)$%%$&3!0" $($5.$!$5"2*8!0"4 4"55 &!1"+" .40"52 0".$!1 %$5"2*8!0"44"55 &!-100 2#5 $)"2!0 !!0" "&!+ 5("+&)"&!$%!0"1&"+5 &2)" %.+$&3<>7

#)4+$%"2$&70"1 !><-70 ! .&$<>-7$55 <??)$&- >)$&-;-=-<- %)"&!$&"2$&!0" ) * &2$+!0"8" + ,,,@%$!. !"2$&($55 3" 2$1 5-"0%$5 $%!+$#!:.20$ & &20"$%$& #!. 5408%$# 5 #.5!$( !$&34%%"%%$&!0"2$%4.!"2 5 &2!0 %*""& ("++"2!0 !+$! )$&30%&70.%0$ )1 % +$3$& 558#.5!$( !$&3!0"% $25 &2 &20"0 &2"2("+$!%4%%"%%$& !!0"44"55 &!"0 22"4%$!"2!0"5 &2+"("&." &2% $2+$! )

$&300 2 5%3$("& & $2 ($! &2 &3+"")"&!$&0$% (.+! 0 %*""&.+!0"+ ("++"2!0 !!0" "%4&2"&!%0 ("&5"3 5 $30!- $!5" + &!"+"%! $& !0" %.$! 4+4"+!8 &2 1$!0.! &8 +$30! 9.%!$$# !$&-!0"81"+"!0+" !"&$&3!2$%4%%"%% &2!$&!"+"+"$& !0" 4" #".5 4%%"%%$& !0" 44"55 &! ("+ !0" 2$%4.!"2 5 &2 $55"3 558-+#$*58 &21$!0.!2."#.+%"5 1"&#"-!0"4+"%"&! .$! < 0" "%4&2"&!%#&!"%!"2!0".$! *8$5$&3 !0"$+A+$!!"& ! !")"&!

%-$&10$#0$!1 %#5 $)"2!0 !!0"4%%"%%$&2$%4.!"2 5 &2-10$#0+$3$& 558*"5&3"2! "%4&2"&!%$&#"4+$+! ,>;@>= 0" "%4&2"&!% 0 2 *""& #.5!$( !$&3 !0" % $2 5 &2 #&!$&..%58!0"+" !"+ &20 2 5%*""&4 8$&3 0 /! !!0" "&!+ 5 (!B &2 !0 ! &"$!0"+ !0" 44"55 &! &+ 0$% 55"3"2 +"2"#"%%++$! )$&300 2"("+ &8 $30!-$!5"+&!"+"%!$&!0"

% $24+4"+!8- &2!0 !!0"80 201"("+-) &$4.5 !"2!0" "("&."

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

< 8" + @ C@=- $& 10$#0 !0" 44"55 &!D% 1& & )" 1 % +"#+2"2$&!0"#5.)&4%%"%%$&& 22$!$&-70 %+ $+2 1 +$ +!0"8" +!$55 **$ C@1 % 5%5"2$&!"($2"&#"

+)0$%%$2"0"& )"#.5!$( !++"#+2"2!0"+"$&1 %+$! ) $&30!$5570 +$<- !"+10$#0!0"44"55 &!D%1&& )"1 % $&#+4+ !"2$&!0"#5.)&4%%"%%$&&!0"* %$% 4 ! 2 !"2, 0":2+$ 5 .+!&"("+!0"5"%%45 #"23+" !"++"5$ &#".4& !0" 2#.)"&! +8 "($2"&#" 5"2 +) !0" %$2"

"%4&2"&!%?""&2 &!% % &!"2 $&!0"551$&3 "C!+ #!% $!% $)4.3&"2.23)"&!@

# "

$ !

%! !

& !"

'( !

)

* ! !!

! +,-

.* !

.+/0

* ! !!

! ! # ! )11- ,/

!!2 !!

3 !

! !

* !4)1$) $5

.* !

.+/, ! $$5 !! !

!! !! # ! !!

++/ .6 .

! !! 2 !!

! !!

# !

!! 7 )1# !

7 )138

$ !

! ! !!

# !

)11

9# ! !!

7 )177 )1

2 !2

# ! !!

!! '2 !!

3 3 !

! !

!! ' 2 !:

* ! !!

! # !

! 2 ! ! .

3 !

;

!<" =< 63 % $00)8$93335/8(;

> * ! !!

> !

! !

! # !

# ! !!

$ !

( !

!! !

! ! !

> !"+3$&3!0+.30!0" ( $5 *5") !"+$ 5$&#5.2$&3!0"+ 5 &2 2#.)"&! +8 "($2"&#" +"#+2"2 $& !0" +$ 5 .+!- &2 #&%$2"+$&3!0"%.*)$%%$&% &2 $! !$&%*!0%$2"%-!0$% .+! $&2%&! &3$*5"+" %&!! /" 2$"+"&!($"1+)!0 !*!0!0" :2 .+!%*"51$&2"#$2$&3$& (.+!0" "%4&2"&!%0 !!0"

: &2$&E."%!$&+$3$& 558*"5&3"2! "0 *$5$! !$&"4 +!)"&!

> "&!+ 5(!$%&!$&2$%4.!"1"("+-*8($+!."!0".&9 * #/ 3"" 5+4"+!$"% $%4% 5#!-,;> 0"+"$& !"++""++"2! %D!0"#!D-!0"% )"1 %4 %%"2&!!0"! !".&9 * &2

"("&.""&!+$"%4"+! $&$&3!!0"% )"1"+" ##+2$&3582+ 1&.4

&2$%4.!"258-!0"+$3$& 5"&!+$"%$&#5.2$&3!0"70 %+ $+2 1 +$ +),;&1 +2%!$55,=1"+"$&!0"& )" "%4&2"&!.+9$!

$&30%+$30!58*%"+("2*8*!0!0":2 .+!% *"51-10"& 2)$!!"258!0" "("&.""&!+$"%%!2$&!0"& )"%!0"""&2 &!%- $!1 %$&#.)*"&!.4&!0"5 $&!$D%%$2"!%0101!0"% )"1"+" 3!#0 &3"2$& (.++$! )$&30-!0"4.+4+!"2+"2"#"%%+@$&@ $&!"+"%!!0"5 $&!$?44"55 &! ! %.*%"E."&!%! 3"2)$!!"258- !0"+"1 %&+2"+"$!0"+!0"#&#"+&"2 5E "0%$52 ++!0" $($5 .+!&!0"* %$%10$#0-!0" "("&.""&!+$"%1"+"#0 &3"2 &+!0"+"$% &8$&2$# !$&!0 !""&2 &!.+9$!$&301 %"("+ &!$$"2*"+"""#!$&3%.#0#0 &3"% &!0"!0"+0 &2-C@ 10$#00 44"&%!*" #"+!$$"2#48!0" $& 5 +2"+4 %%"2*8!0"

:2.*.23"%! 5 %%-:.20$ & $& >=,,=& >,=<-3"%!%01!0 !"("&!0"! !"(! &2!0""0%$52 +

5"% :.20$ & 0 2 *""& +"%!+ $&"2 +) $&!"+"+$&3 1$!0 !0" 4" #".54%%"%%$&!0"% $25 $&!$ ""&2 &!.+9$!$&30("+ !0"%.$!5 &2"C#"4!!0 &$&2."#.+%"5 1 ; &%.#0%$!. !$&-#0 &3"!0" "("&.""&!+$"%$&!0"& )" +$! )$&30 &2!0"+" !"+!0"4+"%"&!44"55 &!1$!0.!&!$8$&3 0" +$&3 !0" "%4&2"&! .+9$! $&30 +" 2"")"2 ! *" $&#&%"E."&!$ 5$&($"1!0"2"#$%$&!0$% .+!$&D(!)* ($%+"!,#-(.+(/(,*)(0(-+"1(($2(1 (## 3

; 4 5'10$#00 %*""&#++"#!58E.!"2*8!0":2 .+!% *"51("& !0"+1$%"-!0"+" $%& ) !"+$ 5 ! $&2$# !"01!0" 4+"%"&!44"55 &!?5 $&!$2"+$("20$%$&2$($2. 5 $30!-$!5" &2 &!"+"%!$&!0"2$%4.!"25 &2"("& %%.)$&3!0 ! ! &8!$)"-!0"

"("&.""&!+$"%0 2%!2$&!0"& )"+$! )$&30!0+.30 10)-0"#5 $)%0$%+$30! &%"E."&!58-&3+.&2% +") 2".!! $&!"+"+"1$!0!0"$)4.3&"22"#$%$&%*!0!0":2 .+!%*"51 0"44" 5$%!0"+"+"-2$%)$%%"2 +!$"%!*" +!0"$+1&#%!%

6 (")*"+,-, A0"!0"+%4" /$&3?+" %&"2F "%? A0"!0"++"4+! *5"F "%?