High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRFA/1931/2014disposed of

Power Grid Corporation India Limited v. Ajmer Singh And ANR

2016-02-16Mr Justice Rakesh Kumar Jain12 pages

!"#

$!

!%

% & ''()** )

+, -( !.#/

-*

- 0 ! -/1

! " " # ( $$ "% &'

$ &( % &'

$)!

% &'

*

$ + %#%"

- 0 ! -/12

"*

345

' ,-

%"

' .

/ ). .0- -0 & ' 1

%

/ )2.23 2.34%4-5 4-2%42.%444 4.- -,.- -0% & % ' & ' %

"

'6" '

6"

7&% ' '"

' 1 '%

'" "

!* & 8

& 9 / ' 1

'

%

"

" '6" " 04:

, % "

&"

) 5$ $ &"

),0

) $ % # '

$ %

';

'

% ' "'

4--<0--< --=+"

1

'' 1% '

" '

0 '6" '

%4.08> '

* 9 " 54 --.% ''

1 '

, --" '

2 '

'6" ''

%& &

53 -- 43 -- '

%

5, ' ' '

"

'>*' % 3 ' ' 1

'

>?*' - ' ' '

* *' #

% '

" '

4 '

'6"' % ''" % & "

0 -5% '

1

"

"

0,%,-%---<@ ' ?

&

&@ "

''"

&@

0 -5

"

2, -5% 4, -5 3 -5

& '

&@ "

'

1 ' '"

: "'

" '

''" % : ' '

& '"

'

%

'

" " ' '

& "

" '

& ' % '

: &

1

''"

' %

'' % & "

%

&

1

%"

1 ' " '

'6" 1% %' '

" "

''" "

"""

'

"'

''" "

'

&

:%1 ''" ' ' 1

'

' "

% ''" ' '

2 --4

!*6 & 3%7 '89 :* ,;7

4 '

'< # 95 "

1 "% &

"

0,%,-%---<@ '%

"

'

& '

6"

1

'"

& 1 "

'

' &

' "1

&

"

'

''" %

'" &

" ' '" ' 1

'"

&@ '

" '"

& " ''

'

'

1 '6" '' % &

1

&

' %

&1' $

1 '" '

"

1 & +1 1

% '" ''

; ' &' 1

&"

' !@ #

%A"

"%

' $ $ % !@5 ?

%

!@ =" %

&

&'

"

' & ' "

' 7 &

%

''"

"

"

;

'' % ''"

0 " ;

' "' &

' "'

'"

' @

&"

1

1 & 1"

& "

'"

% @ B;4

2 --3 B;.

5. --,% "

'"

@ B;

= ,, --4 @ B;5

5-2 --.% "

'" ' 1

% &

: '

"

'' % &

&@ @

: " "''%

&

% , %..%. ,

' " , %..%. 5<@ '

&%'

"% "

1

"

' C,D " "

:

@ "

'

" '

0 '

%

" '"'%1

: '

&@ " @

'6" % ' &

" "

11 "

' & 7* "

9 4 -82 '4

!,4 >' /* :* 979'

"':79'

4

92 ?3 =2

" ,D "

'

&@ & " " ' 3%.0%.440,

'" 3%.0%.4.<@ "%

"' 2-%.0%. <@ '

&@

" & '"

'' 1% '& '

"

2-%.0%. <@ '

'

" '

0

) '

6"

'

E ''" " 1 '

'6" ''

"

' ''"

4 " "

''" '

% 7* "

' & ' :* ' 4 92 = 35 =) %

&1"'

'

'

' ''" & "

1%

' 1

&1'

" &

%

''"

1

'

1 '

''" &

:

"

" 7* "

E@

!

!

" #

$

$%

" &'

( )*+ ( '' , --%

..

/ / )0 1,

2 3 ''

..

$-4

" 1'"

&@ "%

& "

'%

' &

'

" '6"

%'"

'"

%'"

'

% 1

'" '

'"

"

")

1

1 ': " %'

'

&1&

6"

1 "

''

'

'"

''"

'

'"

'

'' % ' 1

1

'

" "

1

) 1 '

& "

1

:

"

%

"" &

%'"

&@ " &

: "% "

1 #&?'" % 7 '89 9 :* & ,;7 9,89 9 / @,''' 44 2 )35 3':'45 ) ' % "%

7* "

& &

5 #&?' 7 '89. 8"

''

"1 '

% " E@

,

5 '

!

6 ('

'' 7

! !

! " #

$ $ " #

# "

"

" %

$&$

!

!

'

?

(

"

" )

$ %

'(

* )! +

# "!

#

!

(0' ,

& '

8 '

2 3 9!! :&, ; &' # --

...

$% !

, -

$ "

" ! !

$ #

!

!

*

" ! " +"

$ " "# $

"

$ "

"

!

#

! " " # !

"

"#"

!

.

$ "

# #

"

#

" !

/ #

!

+ " !# $ #

" # ! . "

"# $

$

"

$"

! *# " "

!( 01) ( 230 +

/

" !

" - 45

$"

!

% !

"+ 6 #

7 "8 $

& '

8 '

6'!

+'

.(, --

2

-/ "

, -+ # #

!% !

!

#

# $

$

+

#

#

!

$

!!

"

"# %

&$

/

$09"

!! *#. "

" " %

&$"

$! *#( 431)

09

) /

"

"%

&$

!

-

7* "

-9A4 19A;'

, 38'52 'B 9 :* & ,;7 92 3 5 =

'& '

/" %7* "

9 % :* & <2 35 =

' "1 '6" % 1 ' "

7* "

3 4 " 9 %.'

8"

9%'

1

1

'

% " E@ $

!

" :

"

#

/ "

" "

$

;

! !

"

!

!

"

! " %

<(" "

$

% !

.!

$ $

$ " % '

# !

$ !

# "

$"

"

$ .* !

"

8 ==0

8 ==0

$ ! " ( 000001) ("

& 00

!

( 3

"

"

> >" ( 30 "

$ ! ( 2030001) ( ?20001) #"

"

"

$

#

))#

$

/$! "@%! 00? !

"

$

( 43 20 #!*

$ ( 234@001) ( ??@@001)+

!

$ #

! "

8 ==4

# ! "

"

! "/$! " $

$

A

"?

! ":

%

@ @ "

!

" "

" ! # * "

!

# "

!

"

!

!

"

!!

*

$# !

*

!

! "+ !

:

+

" !

"

" ! " !

9

!

# " "

!

! /

# /

* ""

0

39

" 009 "

"

$

; !! ;

7 !!

! !

"

$

" "

!

!#

#

"

!

$

!

"

!

! !

# !

+

# " ! "

" !

$

#

"!

0

" "

! !!

/$*

$

# # !

#

"0

"#

!

!

"

. "

"

!

"

" $

; $

("

.!

!

;

" *

$

$

" # !

"

:

" !

"

! $ !

" !

#

# #

! $

!

!

" #.

#

$

!

#

!

"

"

!

BC )

& '" ' ' &' 1 "

'"

''"

' '

&%'"

% ' &

% ' 1

1''& %

"

1 "

'% "% "

&

1

''

;

'

& '& '

"

2-%.0%. <@ '

'

" '

0 '

? %

"

1% &

&%

@

%

@ %&% ' )** ) 3- 0 ! -/15 B %