High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/3539/2018allowed

Sarwan Singh And ANR v. Deeso And ANR

2022-12-06Mr. Justice Harminder Singh Madaan11 pages

!"##

$$%% & ' #

($ )

$"#*+ #$$%%

$' *+ $, -.' /$0

2 %0*## #' #3(// +#'% *!##4$%

%0' #"%" +"%4 5 " " , )2 &6 # # " +#% 50 $ ,

! "#* %"% $ +*/%0*#!!*'"# . '/(.7'%$7'/ #5 '"#%/$ '

## &#%*

" ! "# + * 2#"! "# . ! 8 9 9' :/$03 ' #"+#% 9!%5 :%/; 5'%*" ' # #

; 5'%

,#%/$!"+ $*!# $' $$ # %/ $ 50 %" ! / ($,

#%<! /* !# $, /'$!#$ ! $%0 %%# # $#+ + /%#%/$

# $%" # $ * %%!" ' ! /

=##

*3(//!#!#% 4 5 " " , )2 &6 +50 $ ,

*!## '%##>)

=## #%/ % +/$** !#/' /!#/>)

=## $ ,

! #%" +% + +"%# '/#/>)(

- (%

;##$ %+'$$ # $+ %/

# " "'/*#; 5'%',

+' #%/"# $*!# !# " ', *#+ !"++' #' /$0" $,

?!+ /$ (

%4#!" +' #%/"# $%"!# @6A$ '/ /#%"

#%/$%%'% %B ;#' /$0! #%%5%$0#/'/$*#!+ !" + 0 "#" $, '

;#! %# $,

+ ! #"+#%"" +#0#+$$ ##:' 50%"#$ $$%

,#$$%!"+# $, -.

' /$0*!##$'$$ # '"#'%

9#+# % '% #$ 5"" # '"##

3 '% #$$%%#'5/## $$%%#/+$$%' - ('%6 !# :): $ /$% C' 50!0 %+*!##$0 " ;# % # $$%% ,

! "# + # "+#%!#%"+% +"%!/$ +#"+#%#/%%" %#'"## '/!#+ '% #$$%% $ ,

#%/$5 #; 5'%5''/ + /4#/'%55 '"# *# * 5%%!5$% 50!0%+ <' #

=# #$$%5"$$+#/%0 5#%# $, -.' /$0*!## '#%+5%%!5'#"

- $$%D#"'#'/'$'5'%D+ # !*#$$%%'%#+$ '#'/5 # ; 5'%' "# %5'#0!#0#+ $ ' # / / !# ! $ + # ' /$0 + 0 "#50$ <"#$$%%,

!"#!/$ +#"+#%# %+ /

2 $ " %0B # '5/ / 50 % '% #$ *!'%5 %+ #" 50#; 5'%!# " ', $ #/$'"! 0 *# 5"

$ ''

" #!

' ' ( " !

)

& !

**% **+!

" *%*,*%&

! -

. & /

/ " 012.2,+,

**% **+&

' '

' ' 30 ,,***#$%#

30/ %*,,,

**,

*,*/

)

' # -

. 4 !,55 62 7#894

4 !2 89

)

= &

)

' '

" ! "

. 4

" &

' +# -

. 4 ?

3 '% #$$%%#$% %'$ <'"/50"%E'"#:'

- #/

* ,

- * 5"

*!# %"!#/% '%"# #%%"%$*!5 +##' /$0

6 # $%5%0$0/$ $ "# + 0/ %0 ! / F' ' ('% # ('%#%#%50 + #"+#% ;## <'"/ %'$50% '% #$$%%!

*$50#$C :' $%3+) :, 6 !## 3)* 5"

-*!# !5 +#' % %%+%5%' - #* #!+ / 5*4 +%%# %+/ # +%5% ' " # ' # $ 5'+%5%0! #' %*#' # $ + # ' 5 "'%0 "%" %' C 5% /$%$%0 ;#5' #' 5%#5 #$%050%""+ / $ '% +50#' 5 # "5' '

" #* % '% $ , - .

' /$0# <'"/# $ "

%&'()*(+,#-) !# ! 5 +# $ +#% 0""!## " ' #B '' *# +"% %0' '#%4 !!##!'%%%!# " 0 $ +#%/ 0" ' #B ' '5D !# # ! # "" # + * ! # $5%0##%## 0 /

# ! % # " # '%0G $5%0 $% '$ $ G! " "*#; 5'%# "#%0C #' /$0# !5 ### ' $%0 9!' # 5 +## "'/+# $ '% <' 0#%4 !/$0!'%5/"% 5'#%4 ' $ "%% #!0 /

"#'5//50% '% #$ !%%""# '"##<'"/ 50#/* 9##$C:' <'"/

'$ #% #/ 5 +"

##'"#%/$' &#%*

*# ' /$0% %%+%5%'

- #*#!+ */ 5*4 +%%# + # %+/ '#+%5%#' "#' # $ 5'+%5%0! # ' * '# ' # $ + # ' 5 "'%0 "%" %' C 5% /$% #$%0 9#' # 5% ##5' #' 5%#5 #$%050%""+ / $ '% +50#' 5 # "5' '

9#*#; 5'%##'"#5 +# $$%% ,

! "# ! #+" +" % '

* !## ! +% $ '$

$ '$

' # 5# /## !/$ ++#% 0"" '#B '"* !##+% 0 5C500 ' "" # ' *5 / $,

!/$ +%4 0"#B '"# !45+% /#' $%0D '%%0#; 5'%"+ + 0 "##' /$0 + #/'$50#%/ / $, ' 9 /0 +!* # 5 + # ; 5'% '5%+!<'"/

'$ *!# #$C:' #5 +# + 0$ +5 #$%0!%%%#' +# %5%0'%#5 #$ +5'/%#+$%0 / %#'#C+% '%%%/$%0#+5 /50#; 5'% ### '%5%!# " 9 ! ' # 5 + # + % " +" % $50 + +% +"%' # '%# ' 4+%5%0

9##54##*!## 4$%##"!##C$ C$ $5%0#4 + +%4 0"#B ' " / *##4$%!##% 4 !$ 4/ $ ##%/*#

%4 !"#/%# !#'0 "%"/ ' %#%"#/"+#%* 3(/'%#4 '4#54# 4 * # $ +" /'%$% <' !## # # ''/5 9#5 '%# *!##'$$54! 50+ 0+#%! ""# #+#%5$ 4 #/%# *# *$ 4"%4 #/%# /#"*!###0#"!#$%B " +%4 #%4 /545# /' #$$"#/#$ ;#" 50# ; 5'%#''5%%5%5 ;# ' /$0!! "%0" + 0 "# ;#+% /#' $%0*0*'%5 5'/%#+$%0/ %'"#

;# *#$$%#/ ;#+ "+50# ; 5'%', #H?

@ + ', "#' /$0 ('%%0* # % + 0 "# " # ' /$0!# !

95"*#$$% %+%50 #$$%%#5/ '''$'#

=#'#/!# " "', F'%0# %%'*#$$%%%!$ %0

# / $$% %%! $ %0* # /%%'$$% *0*$ "%0

2 <

!"#$ %&"'

!()$* "&#

'# !+,

"&#