High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/3541/2018dismissed

M/S Mubasa Electricals P Ltd v. Punjab State Power Corp Ltd & ANR

2019-07-15Ms. Justice Jaishree Thakur8 pages

! "

#$%&

&() * ++

, '# (#-$.

(/ ''+' *0

2

31#1%4+'

53 & ++

, '# (#-$.

(/ ''+' *0

2

.1'

6'17' '53 1 ++

, '# (#-$.

(/ ''+' *0

2

(/ '7

17' '5$1 ++

, '# (#-$.

(/ ''+' *0

2

.#

'() * 53 1 ++

, '# (#-$.

(/ ''+' *0

2

8 8

.1)31& # 531# 1 ++

, '# (#-$.

(/ ''+' *0

2

! 8

.1).19 %&

&56:' ++

, '# (#-$.

(/ ''+' *0

2

8 ;<

' &5*#1 ++

, '# (#-$.

(/ ''+' *0

2

('

'606#0';5 &5

!" 71 ++& 1 $

9: '

&< 8<'

= &: & '

++& 5/1 1#++'

$<

) 5 &<'

= &: &

"

!" ++& &&/ 5 0+ +'< ':'

+ # $#%&%

71' '1&&+ $) 0 '

++ & : ' '5 <' # 0&'

)&):0&'

>#

&/ 71 ++ & 1) $

9: 1&& :

0+#: -#:0 + $< &

;#:

5( &5/1 $<

$-

+

# ' .

'$ &

'1'

'(&$'

): /' '1)

/

$

&5/1

9 $'

) <'

: 9 '0

71

:'

''

+' 0:

'

' :)'<: '0 6,

+#

'

/

5 0

'/'

''

'$ '5/1:)

1/'

::' ) : /'5'

+

# '.

5/1 1/0 $< &

;#:

5( &5) ' '

::' ) : ' '5'

! !5/1 1/+

$< 1#'

! 0

'/'

0 $ 9 '

'

1&/

''

05 &

;#:

0 &# /'$ :):# / # $&

1#5&&/ $-

+

/'::' ) :

-#:0 5 &1$

* ' & ++ ': $ 1& ++ 1

#'

&/1 & 9

&/+ :

: '$ '&/'&/# '.

:'# #0

/#&$ ++& $& +'

/''

: /'

1) 1 '& ' &

'0 < ' '+ ) '<+#'+ '/1 '$ 1$

+') 0

+#

/

$#'

#'

1#&$ #

1#&$ &)

0

'$<0 $&

') # '&+'

< : ' 1#&$ )#'

+#

4+ #&<+$& & ) < + =:

0

' 5+#

'

/

: # 5/1

1$

$& '

+'

' '

'

1 0

' '/

#' / 1# >#

+'$ : #++& &

' 9 /<$#

#'

''

+' 10 '5+#

'

/

+'

'

:': =#++&< ' ' / 1

#& &) '<+ ' 0

'/'

''

& '

%',6?#+ 5/1:) 1/'1&: 10

' ' +'+ '&< 71 /' 0 $ 1&& :

&

;#:

5&'

<

5

/'1&:

0 # $ :):# '

: /'

&

1$

&&/ '&<'

+'+ '-#

+#

''

'

5 /'/1 1$#

#':

#'

'& : 71 ) +'

/''

# ' =

!

" "

#

$%

"

"

" &'# #$(&$# "

# #

!

#)

*

+

"

"

&

#

"

&

&'# #$(&$ # # "

"

!

# "

"

""

" " #

" ,

"

"

"

"

#

" #-

.

"

- "

/&$0 '(0

"

"

"

# # &'# #$((*

.

"

#-

"

! #

"

2 $(& "

2 $4*$4*5&#

!

"

# "

" (

"

"

" (

#) " "&(

#.

8 '&<+#

+'+ /' + $< '

+ 9:5$# 0# ' '0

/' /1 &0'

:&&/ 1/

&01)

& 1 + '#& /''

'1

-#

#+ # 1/0# 1

1 $ +5'

# /1 ' '/ &

1&

#+

'

# # $<&9: 1&&71 '1' @

&

:

' '$<+

' )&$&

' #'1 5'

'

'0

&

:

#' + ' &<

+ '0$& <+ '/'' <A #'

'0'

5 '1/01'

-#

0# # 0 ) '0 1'

B@2 /&&+#

& #& 0# # '0+

' / 1 < /'

' +

' /&& '

1 / 1 < '

+

& #& '0'

(<0 /&&$ 0 $<+

'/ 1 <

9: +# #+$<'

A ! 71 /' & ) +#

#

71#5 '0 &

'# < /'5 ' 0 ):# 5#

:

+#$& +& <>#

'

'

5 /1 C71 -# 0# # '+'

<1

) -# 9 +&

0+ ++')& '

0 $

#

#'

&/

-#:0 ):# 5

#

):# -#:0 /#&&<& 1 # +&#:

#'

'& : 5/1

&< +'0 $-

) 1/1 &

1

$< ('&0 &

;#:

1':1 &<&&/ $-

/'71 0 & 0

') $ 0 ' '

=

5 &'

0 5 ): + )9 1'

'$ 5

' "*+ ,

) D1

'+ 9:'