High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/3654/2018dismissed

Iffco Tokio General Insurance Company Limited v. Kuldeep Kaur And Others

2018-07-05Mr. Justice Tejinder Singh Dhindsa6 pages

!"#$"%&'&#()*+*

#,&#"("- .('/- (%"#01 (2 3!4* 11".. (!

5"-'/'

6/.4""16 /-#!7"-'

"'1#(4"(!'

-"'"(!)

-*'78 (& .8 -94:#% !"$#-!7" 11".. (!* ;;;

11".. (!('/- (%" #01 (2 7 ' $&."4 !7" &('! (! 11" . '' &.&(<!7" 8 -44 !"4=**+1 ''"4>2!7" #!#-%%&4"(!. &0'

-&>/( .9 !& . (487"-">2%. &0 (!' -"'1#(4"(!'(#*!#7"-"&(7 :"

>""( 8 -4"4 %#01"(' !&#(#$ '*9+9 ? -&"$$ %!'0 2>"(#!&%"4 !!7"#/!'"!* . &0 (!'6/.4""1 6 /-96 '70&-@&(<7 (40-&,6 /-$&."4 %. &01"!&!&#(/(4"-@"%!&#( #$ #!#-5"7&%."%!$#-<- (!#$%#01"(' !&#(&(!7"&-$ :#/-#( %%#/(! #$ 4" !7 #$ ', - ( @&(<7 &( -# 4 %%&4"(! #( *** . &0 (!'8"-"!7"8&4#8 (41 -"(!'#$!7"4"%" '"4* '"'"!/18 ' !7 !#( ** ', - (@&(<7 '&(%"4"%" '"4 .#(<8&!77&'>-#!7"- '1 .@&(<7 (4>-#!7"-&(. 8 .>&-@&(<78"-"<#&(<!#8 -4'5&.. <" A&0< -7* ', - (@&(<78 '-&4&(< 0#!#-%2%.">" -&(<-"<&'!- !&#((#*

B 87&." '1 .@&(<7 (4 .>&-@&(<78"-"$#..#8&(<7&0* ! >#/!*

87"(!7"2-" %7"4(" -@!*3 8-"(%"@%7##.9A&0< -79 @ 0 ( 9 !-/%,!- . >" -&(<-"<&'!- !&#((#* +==>"&(<4-&:"(&( - '7 (4("<.&<"(!0 (("-9% 0"$-#0@ 0 ( '&4" (4'!-/%, < &('!!7" 0#!#-%2%."#$ ', - (@&(<7*' -"'/.! ', - (@&(<7$"..4#8( (4!7" !-/%,!- . - (#:"-!7"7" 4#$ ', - (@&(<7 (487#4&"4#(!7"'1#!*

&(!7&'% '"8 '-"<&'!"-"4#( **&!'".$*

"'1#(4"(!(#*&*"*#8("-%/04-&:"-#$!7"#$$"(4&(<:"7&%." ' .'#!7"('/- (%"#01 (2&*"*-"'1#(4"(!(#*&(!7"%. &01"!&!&#( $&."4'"1 - !"8-&!!"('! !"0"(!'4"(2&(<" %7 (4":"-2 :"-0"(!#$!7" %. &01"!&!&#(*

-#0!7"1." 4&(<'#$!7"1 -!&"'9$#..#8&(<&''/"'8"-"$- 0"4 >2!7"." -("4-&>/( .)

" #$

& '()$*)+,,* &

. ! / /

* 0

( 1 %

( $ (

2 -&>/( .7 '-"!/-("4$&(4&(<'&($ :#/-#$!7"%. &0 (!' (4 7 ' 8 -4"4%#01"(' !&#( 0#/(!&(<!# '*9+9 ? (487&%78 '

4&-"%!"4!#>" 11#-!&#("4&("C/ .'7 -"'>"!8""(!7"%. &0 (!'"D%"1!$#- ( 0#/(!#$ '*9?87&%78 '1 2 >."!#!7"8&4#8?%. &0 (!(#*#( %%#/(!#$.#''#$%#('#-!&/0*. &0 (!'8"-" .'#7".4"(!&!."4!#-"%#:"- 0#/(!#$%#01"(' !&#( .#(<8&!7&(!"-"'!E+F1"- ((/0$-#0!7"4 !" #$$&.&(<#$!7"%. &01"!&!&#(!&..-" .&G !&#(* #/('". -"1-"'"(!&(< !7" 11".. (!('/- (%" #01 (2 7 ' '' &."4!7"$&(4&(<#$!7"-&>/( .#(''/"(#* '-"< -4' %%&4"(!7 :&(<

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

7&'#/-!&' #$!7"%#('&4"-"4:&"8!7 !&('! (! 11" .&'8&!7#/!0"-&! (44"'"-:"'!# >"4&'0&''"4* 7" %%&4"(!&''! "4!#7 :"#%%/--"4#( *** &( !7"% '"8 '-"<&'!"-"4#(!7"' 0":"-24 2*-#!7"-#$!7"4"%" '"4&*"* '1 .@&(<7% 0"#(-"%#-4!7-#/<7 ( $$&4 :&!!7 !7"7 4 %!/ ..

8&!("''"4!7" %%&4"(! (4!7" 7 4>""(-"<&'!"-"4$#-% /'&(< %%&4"(!

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

7"-&>/( .*#8":"-9!7" ":&4"(%" '-"< -4'!7"4"%" '"44#&(<8#-, '@"%/-&!2/ -48 '4/.

11-"%& !"4&( '0/%7 'H@/(&.6/0 -9%%#/(! (!#$ ?' *6* &%"

&..4"1#'"4!7 ! ', - (@&(<78 '4- 8&(< '*9?1"-0#(!787&."

4#&(<!7"A#>#$@"%/-&!2/ -4 (47 4 .'#1. %"4#(-"%#-4%#01/!"-&G"4 %#12#$'! !"0"(!#$ %%#/(!#$ ', - (@&(<7 'I*!#'7#8!7 !7" 8 '4- 8&(<' . -2#$ '*9?1"-0#(!7 !!7"!&0"#$7&'4" !7*!&' '/%7&(%#0"!7 !7 '-&<7!$/..2>""(! ,"(&(!#-"%,#(&(<>2!7"-&>/( . 87&." 8 -4&(<%#01"(' !&#(* /-!7"-0#-"9!7" <"#$ ', - (@&(<7 !

!7"!&0"#$7&'4" !78 '4&'%.#'"4 '2" -'>2%. &0 (!6/.4""16 /- &*"*7&'8&4#8* @&0&. - <"8 '":"(0"(!&#("4&(!7"%#12#$!7" #'!

#-!"0 "1#-!>-#/<7!#(-"%#-4*%%#-4&(<.29-&>/( .7 '(#!"--"4&( ! ,&(< <"#$ ', - (@&(<7 4"%" '"4 '2" -' !!7"!&0"#$7&'4" !7* 7"-&>/( .7 '&01#'"4 %/!#$?-4 $-#0!7"0#(!7.2&(%#0"&(!7" .&<7!#$!7"!7-""."< .-"1-"'"(! !&:"'#$4"%" '"4 ', - (@&(<7 (4>2 %#('&4"-&(< <"#$4"%" '"4 '2" -'!7"0/.!&1.&"-#$ 7 '>""( 11.&"4* @/%7:&"8&'&(%#('#( (%"8&!7!7"</&4".&("'$/-(&'7"4>2 @/1-"0"#/-!&(

/-!7"-0#-"9 '1"-4&%!/0. &44#8(&(

! "

% #

& ' & 44&!&#(#$F#$!7"$&D"4&(%#0"!#8 -4'$/!/-"1-#'1"%!'97 ' >""( ..#8"4*. &0 (!'7 :">""( 8 -4"4 0#/(!#$ '*9?!#8 -4'

.#''#$"'! !"9 '*9?!#8 -4'$/("- ."D1"('"' (4!7"8&4#8&*"* %. &0 (!(#*7 '>""(<- (!"4 0#/(!#$ '*9?!#8 -4'.#''#$ %#('#-!&/0* 7" 0#/(!''# 8 -4"4 /(4"-: -&#/'7" 4' -" ' 1"- </&4".&("'$/-(&'7"4&(% # (% '" '/1- *

7&'#/-!&'#$!7"%#('&4"-"4:&"8!7 !!7"%#01"(' !&#( 0#/(! 8 -4"4>2!7"-&>/( .% ((#!>"%#('!-/"4 '"D%"''&:"* !7"- !7"' 0"&'8"..$#/(4"4 (4 '1"-4&%!/0. &44#8(>2@/1-"0"#/-!* 7"-" &' (# 0"-&! &( !7" 1-"'"(! 11" . (4 !7" ' 0" &'9 %%#-4&(<.294&'0&''"4*

./%,2 H7"!7"-'1" ,&(<?-" '#("4) "'?# H7"!7"- "1#-! >.") "'?#