High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/596/2012allowed

Ranbir Choudhary v. T.D. Vivek Kumar And Another

2016-07-27Mr. Justice Amit Rawal10 pages

!"

#$ %"&'('#) * +, +,

* -. , /.

! "

# $

% &' !"

(& ! "

)))) * + " ! , (

'- $ " - . + (

'

'- /.

,

. " " '

!

"# $ % &'()

/""'' " " '

"" ,

0 " "

!"! "

! '

'

*123$224 !

! "'!"!"

! "

' ! ""

!

' " " /"" 0 ,' "

" "" 0 ' "

5!

' " ,

*126$224 *1 & ' & *6 & '

& ' *726$224 , "

!'

" 89 5!

$226$224 # !' "

! " '"

0

,'

,(! '

' !

! "'

!"!"

! " '

' "

: " !

(

' ";

< &

* +

, % -

./

0 # $

. ' , "

#% -/ . '

"

"

" "

,' 0 ","

/ + '

!

! "

'!"!"

! " '

'

"

!

! " &! $2 " &!"!"! -

% &' ! "

( & !

' " " # * $ "

!!

(& '

'!

"

"$2*$ "

! ' (

!!

' : ! !

# $ ,

'

/"",0 '

""! "

=>: ? ' ! #, "

' #@ '# *$..&! % '$$.

0 AB B , "

;'"

'

!! ! $226$2248C5/$9 ' ,

! /"",

,' "

" ' " '0 ,'

,

"

/ "", ' ""! ' !

',!

; 89/ " 89,

""! " =>: ? ' ! #, *626$224, & ! "

' (! "

! ' !

, '

"

" "

,' " ! / (! : !

"

" , ! " "

'

'

' #@= " ""! " =>

: ? ' ! #, ! ' "

! "

""89 " 89,0

! !

"

' #@: ' /"" ' *726$2248C5 /DE / 79 ! " ' $226$224 ,

' ! /"" ,

,' " '

F//F ' ' !

! " ' !"! "

! "

'

' !

", "!

, " ! !

;

< &

* +2

3 8 9 , ;

<&

!! 5 "&! $.E$* " &!"!"! *67.F//F0 ' "

!

! " ! "'!"!"

! (

' 2

3 8 9 " " ' ;

< &

": * +2

3 8 9 /

! " # $ $# % #

# # $

"% $

&%%

%

"

$

%

%&% $ $% $ !'% $

( )* +& % , - & $ . / "% "

001 !

23 " $

' 4 # " 5 "#$ " $ $

%

&$ 4- "% # $" $ $

$4( 6

#% 5 " & 07 % &$ $%5 8

#$ $ $ % % % $ &% & 9 " # " # % 6 "

& #

!' $ $:

#$ " $ % $ # ! ' # 3

% # 8 !' $ " $# # #$" $ #

' $ " :

0" %# /

" $ " $

3

% $# $ #$ / % # 6%- " #$ $ $ % 0 & 2 0

001 :!

2

& &&

# #$ $# 6% #$ & % #$ "

$ & 2

$ $ $& & & 2

& $# & # # & #

%" # ; % & ( & & 2

$%

# + : 5

& # % " $ 3 $ &6 # $ 3

#

+ 02 $ % 0

& #$ & $%

& & & $ # &#$& $ $

3 $

#"3

% $

$#

" %

3 # $

$ $ %

() < ) % &&= >

0 ")*+& % # . &?. > !

@ (+ "); % # % )*+& %"

2 0 & 2

"

1 9 & + "

00@A !

26 +& 6 % #1 % B +& =>CD!:; " = ? % A$ B+% ? +& & +CD!" #$%&"%

$ +% )/ &$DAB

% #%% #$ % $

%&

$ E+D

#

#$ $ #$1@A(

$$

$ 1

#%& 6 " # 5 2

$ # % # &

2 % # %%

% !(% "

00@F :A!

2 #" # % #$

% #" ' 6 % @@"

$ " "

% " %

#1@A " #5 ;" % & " #$( & % &

$

1

"

#%&# 626 +& 6

"#5 2 % &$ % & %% #5 $# % & $

%

"

#3 $#% % "5

(& #%5

1

"

$

$ #2 1

3

% " & $ #

A( % " & %%% & 6 0 # % %

& " 5 " $#3

$1

2"

#% ; " G

% + # % &% $& # % =& '; & 2 .$ 00 !G : "!

"" "

" !

' !

" ", " ,

': , 89/ " 89,

,' "

" ' "

"

& / ' @ !

"" ! ' 0 !"

@""! " & /' " ' "

, ,

0

,' "" ! / (! " !

" " 89 (! !!

' " ' ,

0 '' " " "

'

(

'

" 89/""89 !"!"

! '

" !!

,

", "

"! "!" !

" (

'@ " ! !

" 89 ! 5!

' ! "" /"" 5!

'

' "

(

' ! " ' ,

! / (! "

'

' ! / (!

, "

!

/.

+, +, '

+ '=

"(4 # + "(4 #