High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/606/2012allowed

Yadukul Bhushan Bahl v. Delhi Financial Corporation And Others

2016-08-30Mr. Justice Arun Monga8 pages

!!"#$#%&'('$ )* +,'-'+.'$.%!.+ //!++% 0!1$'$ !+.# #%%"#+1/1 #%*.%,#(1. .!1$ !$/%,!% $

!"#$%& '( $(')#*%&+,$

1!$!% &

1%234'$.+*!%#1,5" !6# .

14%6+3+*,5" !* 1 .!//!++%

1%23',(!*,5" !* 11!$/%,!% $ 77777 (')#*% 89: %%!;'1! :<"++3 #$ -!%%1!"1,$'=2!" ++2'$ !;"!/ #%$ ;!>/ #%#$+$(1% !, #+!"!1 ##!,"/#!$ $ %,$,#$/$!,

//!++% :/+#% ##$((1#!5!, .!,#$>#$$+ .!$'# $!!-#%(,!"+1 #%%,"%$!?'!% #+1!+#!#%2'%" #%=3".++!%(#%( .! % #"!, !, @; #$$'!,'%,!1!" #%A .! !

#%%"#+1/1 #%$" *AB1$.1 CAB" D =3,!!%,% * =!#%(#++!(+*%'++ 5#,%,6# .' 2'1#$,#" #%*6.!1!=3 .!//!++% * .!++!(!,('1% 1*.$=!!%"++!,'/% ,!/$# $'>*@9*AAB:

B@ =!1! .!#"!++!" 1

1%23 4'$.+* +!1%!, !%#1 '%$!+ $$#$ !, =3

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

#%,'$ 1#+ "%"!1%* #% !$$!%"! .! /1#%"#/+ =116!1* 6.!1!$ % .! "% 113* !" #% ) !% # +!$ .! #%%"#+ 1/1 #% !%1"! .!

+#=#+# 3$'1! 3*/1 #"'+1+3!" #%) *6.#".6$#%$!1 !,=3 " 8)A@B*#!*6!@A@B.!+%#% .!1!>!% #%!,"$! 6$ -!%#%A@@%,* .!1!1!* .!/15#$#%$ .!$#,!" #%6'+, //+3!'1 .!1$'=># $ . .!/1"!,'1!'%,!1!" #%$A%,) AB" #$ ++3,#!1!% 5#$::5#$ .!/15#$#%$!" #%)$/!1 .!/15#$#%$*/1"!!,#%($=!1! .!">/! !% "'1 *#!* .!"%"!1%!, #$ 1#" ',(!*1!1!?'#1!, =!#%# # !,6!5!1*%/1"!,'1!#% .#$ 1!(1,'%,!1 .!1!>!% #%!,/15#$#%$+6.,=!!%++6!,%

$'//1 .#$"% !% #%*.!1!+#!$'/% .!2',(>!% 1!%,!1!,=3 .! %F=+! '/1!>! #% . /0 // 12

344 425626

/64*78 5

/ 449: -9 !'1 .!1$'=># $ . .!5!.#"+!#%?'!$ #%.,=!!% -!% #% /$$!$$#%=3 .! #%%"#+1/1 #%63="-#%AA.!$#, 1'"-6$% $+,6#%( .!" . .!$>!6$ -!%%$'/!1,1#

!1./$"!1 #%"1#>#%+/1"!!,#%($6!1!#%# # !,.!'1 $=!+6.5! %%:$'# !, .!/+#% #% .!/1!>#$! . .!/1"!!,#%($'%,!1!" #% ):AB" .5!% =!!%".++!%(!,=3 .!//!++% :/+#% #! $'=># $ . .!" #%#%# # !,=3 .! #%%"#+1/1 #%#$/!1$!

6# .' 2'1#$,#" #%%,* .'$* .!1!#$++"#'$%!$$%,/!15!1$# 3* .#$ $/!" .$ ++3=!!%#(%1!,=3 .!'1 $=!+6%,* .!1!1!*'1(!$ .#$'1 11>'+ #% .!++6#%($'=$ % #+?'!$ #%$+61 ,! !1>#% #% .#$'1 &:

E.! .!1 .!% #"!, !,@; #$$'!,=3 ++!" 1

* !+.# #%%"#+ 1/1 #% #$ #++!(+ %, 6# .' 2'1#$,#" #%*>'".+!$$+!(++3$'$ #%=+!G

E.! .!1 .!2',(>!% $%,,!"1!!$ .!'1 $=!+6 $'!11>+$# 3%,/!15!1$# 3G )

E.! .!1 .!1!.$=!!%>#$//+#" #% >#%,*>#$: //1!"# #% " $ %, >#$"%$ 1'+ .! $ ' 13 /15#$#%$+6G

!1"% 1* 1%23',(!*+!1%!,"'%$!+11!$/%,!% $%,$'=># $ . .!1+! .!$'1! 3#$ .%'1 .!">># >!% $/!1 .!$'1! 3=%,H,!!,!;!"' !, %"! .!+#=#+# 3 .!/1#%"#/+%, .!('1% 1#$":!; !%$#5!*#!*2#% %,$!5!1+* .!$'1! 3"%% 1'%

;

1>.#$+#=#+# 3#% .!>%%!1%,>,!$#%,#" !,#% .!$'# %,1#(. 3 $* .!'1 $=!+6.5!,!"+#%!, #% !1!1!#%1!$/!" .!1!+#!$'(. %,* .'$*'1(!$ .#$'1 1#1>#%( .!#%,#%($'%,!1".++!%(! .5!.!1, .!+!1%!,"'%$!+1 .!/1 #!$%,//1#$!, .!//!1=-

1 .! /'1/$! //1!"# #%( .! "% !% #%$ %, 1#5+ "% !% #%$ .! +!1%!, "'%$!+ 1 .! /1 #!$* # 6'+, =! / 1!/1,'"! .!/15#$#%$!" #%$A%,)AB" %, 1)9 .!2',(>!% "# !,$'/1.!$>!1!, .'$&:

E.!1!%3#%,'$ 1#+"%"!1%*6.#".#$'%,!1+#=#+# 3 .! #%%"#+ 1/1 #% '%,!1 % (1!!>!% * >-!$ %3 ,!'+ #%1!/3>!% %3+%1,5%"!1%3#%$ +>!% .!1! I1 #% >!! #%( # $ =+#( #%$ #% 1!+ #% %3 ('1% !! (#5!% =3 .! 1/1 #%J 1 .!16#$! #+$ ">/+36# . .! !1>$# $(1!!>!% 6# . .! #%%"#+ 1/1 #%* .! #%%"#+1/1 #%$.++.5! .!I1#(. -! 5!1 .! >%(!>!% 1 /$$!$$#% 1 = . .! #%,'$ 1#+"%"!1%$J*$6!++$ .!I1#(. 1%$!1=363 +!$! 1 $+!J%,1!+#$! .! /1/!1 3 /+!,(!,* >1 ((!,* .3/ .!" !,1$$#(%!, .! #%%"#+1/1 #% %3 1%$!1/1/!1 3>,!=3 .! #%%"#+1/1 #%* #%!;!1"#$!# $/6!1$'%,!1$'=:$!" #% *$.++5!$ #% .!

1%$!1!!++1#(. $#%1 .!/1/!1 3 1%$!11!,I$# .! 1%$!1J.,=!!%>,!=3 .!6%!1 .!/1/!1 3

) .! #%%"#+1/1 #%$.++.5! .!$>!1#(. $%, /6!1$6# .1!$/!" (,$>%'" '1!,1/1,'"!,6.++3 1/1 +31>(,$1>#%(/1 .!$!"'1# 3.!+,=3# $# .,6# .1!$/!" .!1#(#%+(,$ I8 IE.!1!%3" #%.$=!!% -!%(#%$ %#%,'$ 1#+ "%"!1%J '%,!1 .! /15#$#%$ $'=:$!" #% * ++ "$ $*I".1(!$ %, !;/!%$!$ 6.#". #% .! /#%#% .!

#%%"#+1/1 #%.5!=!!%/1/!1+3#%"'11!,J=3# I$ #%"#,!% + .!1! J $.++ =! 1!"5!1=+! 1> .! #%,'$ 1#+ "%"!1%%, .!>%!36.#".#$1!"!#5!,=3# $.++*#% .! =$!%"!%3"% 1" .!"% 113*=!.!+,=3# #% 1'$ =! //+#!, #1$ +3* #% /3>!% $'". "$ $* ".1(!$ %, !;/!%$!$%,*$!"%,+3*#%,#$".1(! .!,!= ,'! .!

#%%"#+ 1/1 #%* %, .! 1!$#,'! .! >%!3 $ 1!"!#5!,$.++=!/#, .!/!1$%!% # +!, .!1! J B IE.!1! .! #%%"#+ 1/1 #%.$ -!%%3 " #% (#%$ %#%,'$ 1#+"%"!1%J'%,!1 .!/15#$#%$$'=: $!" #% * .! #%%"#+1/1 #%$.++=!,!!>!, =! .! 6%!1$'"."%"!1%*1 .!/'1/$!$$'# $=31(#%$ .!"%"!1%*%,$.++$'!%,=!$'!,#% .!%>!I .! "%"!1%J - 2 <242

4 5 / 254 =>

E.!1!%#%,'$ 1#+"%"!1%*#%=1!".%3(1!!>!% * >-!$%3,!'+ #%1!/3>!% %3+%1,5%"!1 %3 #%$ +>!% .!1!I1 #% >!! #%( # $ =+#( #%$ #%

1!+ #% %3 ('1% !! (#5!% =3 .! 1/1 #%J 1 .!16#$!#+$ ">/+36# . .! !1>$# $(1!!>!% 6# . .! #%%"#+ 1/1 #% 1 6.!1! .! #%%"#+ 1/1 #% 1!?'#1!$ % #%,'$ 1#+ "%"!1% >-! #>>!,# !1!/3>!% %3+%1,5%"!'%,!1$!" #% ) %, .! #%,'$ 1#+ "%"!1% #+$ >-! $'". 1!/3>!% *I .!%* 6# .' /1!2',#"! .! /15#$#%$ $!" #%A .#$" %,$!" #%A .!1%$!1

1/!1 3" *@@8@@ J%3#"!1 .! #%%"#+ 1/1 #%*(!%!1++31$/!"#++3' .1#$!,=3 .!1, #% .#$=!.+*>3//+3 .!,#$ 1#" 2',(!6# .#% .! +#># $6.$!2'1#$,#" #% .!#%,'$ 1#+"%"!1%"11#!$% .!6.+!1$'=$ % #+/1 # $='$#%!$$1%!1>1! .!++6#%(1!+#!$*%>!+3&K 1%1,!11 .!$+! .!/1/!1 3/+!,(!,*>1 ((!,* .3/ .!" !, 1 $$#(%!, .!I #%%"#+ 1/1 #%J $ $!"'1# 31 .!+%1,5%"!L1 I 1!%1"#%( .!+#=#+# 3%3$'1! 3L1J = 1 1%$!11#%( .!>%(!>!% .!#%,'$ 1#+"%"!1% .! #%%"#+1/1 #%L1 "

1 % , #% !1#> #%2'%" #% 1!$ 1#%#%( .! #%,'$ 1#+ "%"!1%1> 1%$!11#%(11!>5#%(# $>".#%!131/+% 1 !?'#/>!% 1> .!/1!>#$!$ .!#%,'$ 1#+"%"!1%6# .' .! /!1>#$$#% .! 1,* 6.!1! $'". 1!>5+ #$ //1!.!%,!,

%//+#" #%'%,!1$'=:$!" #% $.++$ ! .!% '1!

%, !; !% .! +#=#+# 3 .! #%,'$ 1#+ "%"!1% .!

#%%"#+1/1 #%* .!(1'%,%6.#".# #$>,!%,$'". .!1/1 #"'+1$$>3=!/1!$"1#=!,

1)9 .!2',(>!% .! +!(#$+ #5! #% !% * #% '1 /#%#%* #$ >%#!$ .! #% !% #% .! 1+#>!% #%!%" #%( !" #%$A%,) .!" 6$% $#>#+1E.!1!$!" #%A .!" "%$#$ $ .! /1/!1 3 .! #%,'$ 1#+ "%"!1%*!" #% ) -!$ 6# .#%# $$6!!/= . .!/1/!1 3 .!#%,'$ 1#+"%"!1%%, $ . .!$'1! 3%! .!/15#$#%$"% 1+!". .!1 .! 1+#>!% #% !%,!, /15#,!%,,# #%+1!>!,31 1!"5!13 .! >'% #% 5'1 .! 1/1 #% =3 /1"!!,#%((#%$ $'1! 3%+3#% !1>$!" #%) .! " %,% '%,!1!" #%A .!1!D .! "%"!,!, /$# #% % 1!"1, #$ . .! % #"! , !, @; 6$#$$'!,=3 .!++!" 1:,!!%,% !+.#

#%%"#+ 1/1 #% /'1/1 !,+3 $ "%$!?'!%"! .! /1"!!,#%($ #%# # !, '%,!1!" #%): AB " ;B%,; 1! .! /1"!!,#%($'%,!1 .!/15#$#%$!" #%AAB" (#%$ .! /1#%"#/+=116!1* .'(."/#!$ .!$>!6!1!!%,1$!, //!++% * #%!$$!%"! .!1/1 #%., -!% .!/$$!$$#% .!5!.#"+!$ "%$!?'!%"! .!1!>!% #%!,/1"!!,#%($=' (#%$ .!$'1! 3*$ 1.$% -!%%3" #%'%,!1!" #%)AB" !" #%)

AB" *#%$!1 !,#%A@B*6$#%5('! .! #>!6.!% .!+% 6$,5%"!, .#%(/1!5!% !, .!1/1 #% #%# # !/1"!!,#%($#%

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

1 .!1!(#%(1!$%$* .!2',(>!% $%,,!"1!!$ '%,!1 ".++!%(!1!% $'$ #%=+!%,.!1!=3$! :$#,!.!$'# .!//!++% : /+#% ##$,!"1!!,*#%!$$!%"!# #$,!"+1!, . .!% #"!, !,@ #$6# .' 2'1#$,#" #%%,.!1!=3$! :$#,!6!5!1* .#$$.++% /1!5!% .!1/1 #% -!" #%#%""1,%"!6# .+6*#/!1>#$$#=+!$

14'$.+ .#$$ (!$'=># $ . %3" #%#% !%, =! -!%$.++=!* =11!,=3+6+#># #%,% #% !%, ,!+5!% .#$/#% .#$$ (!M#=!1 3#$(1% !, .!/1 #!$ 1#$! .!/+!$%,6.!% $'"./1"!!,#%($1!#%# # !, //!+$ %,$++6!, 4/-* (')# 546 %&+,$ )6/6402 @4

A4@

)6/6 /= A4@