High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/616/2012dismissed

Avtar Singh v. Kuldip Singh

2015-05-28Mr. Justice J.C. Verma8 pages

!"#$%&'()* +'$, -( ...// 00$ ' ,232

/ -( ...

' 55555

'!" #,3,

,#($ ($,6$)+

,'( 00$ ' #, $ 7 '$

,'( '

-30$,

// $0) ($00 ($28

6$ ' 73-6 '$

2',

'3- )2( $,/3,+

(2 ''

-$2

73-6 '$

:;'( 09

3,') 3 '

6'( $ '29$2$

// 00$ '"/0$ ($ $23 ',/ ,6$ 2',$

- '( , '2 $2 $02 $,$ -() $09$ ' -( $

-(,6 , /0$ + 0$ 6/, 4($2,$<==<>"&?$2/ ,$6$8$ % "< < ( '2 ' '

6'( /0$ $ 6$

$, '' , /0$ + '0$ )9( 3/ '( /0$ 6$ $2'$'

3,'''(

''($''( '($8

6 ,3 '332 2 '0%)'(

'9$2 $223 ( '( ')'( '2($ $

3 '

6''(

''($''( /0$ ) 9$// 00$ ' 2$// $0) 2(30 8 , 2',$

,6 , - '(

, /22 + , 4($2,$ <==>"*?$2/ ,$6$8$ % $,"< : 8$2 2/0 -'( /$,'

2)009 29

,$6 09 3,'!

A( /0$ 27 '9

'0$ ) '$ ( $ '

/0$ '$

' $2/,$% ,B

A( , '( /0$ ($2 $32 $ ' '(

/, '23 'B

< A( , '( $ '= 3 '

, 6$ ' 2 '

$2/,$% ,B

* '

-,$0$29 00$2

/$,'

2$ /,+

-$( -''(

,, 2/

3 2 0)0 09

3,'($( 0'($'2

''( /0$ ($28

6 ,3 '332$ ($28

$223 ()'( 2

-2

2$ 9 <9$2

$-$ 3 '

6$ '= $ '$ $+3,'( /0$ $ $223 () 3 '

69$2$02 09 3,'+

73-6 '$

:; (3-('( 09 3,'($ ' 2

22$,%'-,$ '

$ %,

''( $ '2) $0/, ,, 6)$

-'(

3 '

6),

9$2-,$ '

''( 68%'( ,2'$// 00$'

3,'+

73-6 '$

C 9) 00$ '2'($''( +

''(

,2'$// 00$'

3,'

,+$0 ,0 -$0$23,

-()D /$,'

/$ ',6'( $ '2($ ' 228E'

/2 $83'/22 ' '($' ( 9$2 ' )(

',$ 2

$ ' 6/,/,

'$,%,/22 22,%'

8 ''

,'($ 9($''(

',$ 2 ,,($' 2),$'( '($'3,

-(9$2 '

' '( + 00$- ) 9($' ' '$0D ( 2 /22 2 '0%) $73

6$ ,2'$// 00$'

3,' 2'<

'8 +$0 $ 9, -

,2$0'( ,2'$// 00$'

3,'F2+

'($2

23-(' & 3 2 0,'( ') '( '( ,($ )($23,- '($'

' 0%'(

,83' ,$0$29 00$2 '$,%

232'$ 2$ 23//,'2'( '"

$ '$ ( $22

2$ '(32)'(

,$ %2382'$ '

$0@3 0$9

,6 ,'( 2$ %6 2$// $0 ; '

,( -'( 3 2 0,'( /$,'

2)009 -2382'$ '

$0 20$9

,6 8%'( 23,'!

> ?

A( 0 ,2'$// 00$'

3,'($26 2, ,$0$

$+$ 0$80 '(

$ ($2 6 2, $ $ 6 ,/, '(

'$,% $ ,$0

$+$ 0$80 '(

,B >

'2E $ E 308

'$D ' 2

,$'

, 9$ ' 2'$6/ $ 2',$'

$ $02 '( -,3 '($''( %$, '

30%/,+ ,

,B >

A( ,3,

-(9$2 6/ ''

E $ E /$,'

30$,0% 9( ( 9$2 ' $ /,/,

','( + 00$- > +?

A( ,$ "/,/,

',($2$ %, -('9 ,2( / ,/22 + 0$ )9(

( 2($60$' ) 9(

(8 0 -2''( /,/,

'$,%8%'( + 00$- >+?

A( , '( 0 ,2' $// 00$'

3,' 30

,'$ $09 '(3' 6/0 -$00'( /$,'

(9 $,,$% 8 , 0 ', $0 3,'B 6 ''

0%)4($2,$<==>"*?$ 4($2,$<==<> 4&#?$7 ('( ,+ '( ,9 )/ ,32$0$6$8$

$,"<$ D2$7,$>E ?2(92'($''( ,2 $7 ('( , +

92'$'

'6$ $ ' <:''(

' '($' ( 9 00 ' , = 2/22 22 '( /0$ ,6 4($,2$ <==<)'( '9$2 $2($+ -8

6 ,3 '332 9) ) 6 $ '430

/ -( 2'($'

-( $ '($

$ $-,

''2 *:>E ?$ '($'( ($,

2)&)="$''( '

''2 00 /,

$,$%$0 -(

($ $'

, -(+ 009$0$ ( 9$2/3' $ '3$0 /22 '0$ 430

/ -(>A?$// 8E'/,+ ( -$,

$-,

''2 00)/$%6 ' 2$0 2

,$'

'3,

-(, '$ $83''$D - /(%2

$0/22 4($2,$<== 22'$'

,,8,$'

8% $($3, -(>A?9( 00$'

,$03,

-() $ '

< < ,%8$2 2'( 6 $ '430

/ -(,

2'(

''2 009(

(($28

/,+ 8%( 6$ ( 29 22) $($3, -((3-(

$-,

''2 00 2 ' ,$ % -(')'

, 2' '/,/ ,'%)% ')9(

'($2

6$ ) '($2$8

' '( 2, -$,)

*<'( ,$ 2 ,/ ,'% ')&&, $2$23 ,!"

G !"!#$%&!"'$($)"#()') )"#$'

!" "($'*+!"#)*$#$%*,,-!#./!&"&!")%.%0"*)*$1 '*1$!+.% *,"$ *'.! #/ ",0 *( ) !)!",'$!(!''#"% )($')*)2)!) !)"#$'

!"(#$.!#'(!")#*$!+0*) "!#'$#./!

(!")#*$)%3 $$+ ) ! )"#$'

!"!! #'3 *$ &#") &!"

",#$(! ) !

($)"#()3)#4!$&''!''*$ ) !&"!&")%"#$%&#")) !"! ") !)"#$'

!"!!3.!*$1#/"!#+%*$&''!''*$3($)*$2!'*$ &''!''*$*$&#")&!"

",#$(! ) !($)"#()#$+ #'+$!

',!#()*$ 2") !"#$(! ) !($)"#()3

) !)"#$'

!"!! #'&!"

",!+"*'0*//*$1)&!"

", *'

&#") ) !($)"#()3 ) !$3$)0*) ')#$+*$1) #)0 !"!) !"!*'#$*$')"2,!$) )"#$'

!"3) #)) !)"#$'

!" #'$).!!$(,&/!)!+*$) !

,#$$!"&"!'("*.!+) !"!

".%) !/#0 ") !)*,!.!*$1*$

"(!3) !)"#$'

!""""#$%&!"'$(/#*,*$12$+!" *,' #// .!+!.#""!+ ",!$ "(*$1#1#*$')) !)"#$'

!"!!#$+&!"'$'

(/#*,*$12$+!" *,#$%"*1 )*$"!'&!() ) !&"&!")%

0 *( ) !)"#$'

!"!! #')#4!$"($)*$2!+*$&''!''*$3 ) !" ) #$ # "*1 ) !6&"!''/% &"-*+!+ .% ) ! )!",' ) !

($)"#()

"-*+!+ ) #) $) *$1 *$ ) *' '!()*$ ' #// #

!() ) !

"*1 )' #)"#$'

!"!! "($'*+!"#)*$0 #'$$)*(! ) !

($)"#()" ) !&#")&!"

",#$(!) !"! H : #, + $

, -'238"2

C'(

2',$'

') ;&) 2$0 66+$80 /,/ ,'% 2 ' ,

2',$'

23 (

'$0/$%6 '$ % 2'6 % E/0$ $'

'238"2

C'(

2',$'

');& $2$23 ,!

G6&/#$#)*$7+(2,!$)&2"&")*$1"&!"#)*$1) !

!()#($)"#() ") !'#/! *,,-#./!&"&!")%' #//$).!

+!!,!+)"!82*"!"!-!") #-!"!82*"!+"!1*')"#)*$.% "!#'$$/% ) ! #()) #)'2( +(2,!$)($)#*$'#"!(*)#/

) !&#%,!$) #$%!#"$!'),$!%" ) !0 /!"#$%&#") ) !&2"( #'!,$!%H *

, -'E $ E

) /

2$6$8$

$,;;";<$ ,'( % $,C"&, 2/

0%)4($2,$<==>"*?

29 8% ($60$' $''$ $ '(

-(2 $07

' -($22($, (0 ,9(

0$ 22(9 '8 $ ,#36D ,3$,2/ $'(

E )

,/$0 -() , ' <

&C /

2 $6$8$

2,'( % $,2;CC"C&);&"&<);&C"&&);;";<);;C";&) "< )E&)EC)E)E*)E:$ E<, 2/

0%) $02 2(9 '($' ,

'$ -0 < 2 9 8% ($60$'

,32$0 $6$8$

E&$ EC2(92'($'$07

' -($ 430

-(2 26$,$'(($+ 8

2(9 7 '/22 $2 $ #,32 @3$02($, 2$ D 0$ 22(9 $2$ ,#36D $3, '( $6$8$ >E?)/22 $07

' -($ $0 + -( ($28

2(9 $07

' -( 2$'( ,3,

-( $ '

: '( /%$6$8$ E*/22 3,

-(2 $07

' -($22($, (0 ,($28

2(9 3,'( $6$8$

E<$ E:$02)3,

-(($28

2(9 0$ $ 0$ $2 $ , #36D 8$ /% 4($2,$ ,$9$, E;,64($, <' $8 &2(92'($'0$

2/3'

9 ,2( /($60$' $''$ $ 3,

-(2 $07

' -($2$2($, (0 , 3,'(

4($, <)'( 0$ 22(9 '8

30'3,$0$ ,/29 '(

($2

2(9 $2 ($, ($,$ 3, -'( 6$

-/ ) '($28

2(9 '8 +$ $ '

,6,$0$29 00$2

$2/,3

$,0

8% $ '", '430

/ -() 2$6/0%/,+ ,

, '($'$-,

''2 00>E ?9$230%

8%3,

-()

$ '<)8%+ ,'3 9(

(/22 4($2,$<==>"*?

9$2',$ 2 ,, $+3,430

/ -( $ '", ' $,'

''2 00($28

/ ,,6 8%3,

-($ $223 () $-,

' ' 2 00 ($2 $ 8

') $2 $0, $% 6

E/0$ $'

238"2

C'(

2',$'

');&)

2$ 3 , ' C ( $,-36 '$+$

8% 3 2 0,'( 00$ ''($'2

-(9(($$00 0%

''2 00$ ($

$, 2$ ,'430

/ -(

$ '", ')($2 ' 228E)$+ ,2

2(308 ,$9 $-$ $ '2) 2 '232'$ $80 8

$32

2$ 3,

&C$ ( 00$'

,$0$($3, -(

>A?$// 228E$ 30% ,,8,'

$ '2", '2 '( '( ,($ )/0 $'( '2'($'

$($3, -($ $28 , -( 9 /,/,

',2($60$'

$ '( %($

''2 00 /%9(

( 2E A<=

$+3,+'$, -($// 00$ ')9( '0$ ) 2 '

/,+ 8%$ %

$'(

,)'( ($+ '$'$008

2(9 63 (0 22$2/,/,

',2($60$'

#3 ( 2', 22 ($2 8

0$ 8% '( /0$ "$// 00$ ' '($' 2

-( $ '9$2 ',

+ 00$- 9$0,'( 0$2'

% $,2$ ( ($ ,$'

$,,+'

$, + 00$- )( 30 '8 '8 /,/,

',=2($, (0 ($60$' $ 9$2$02 '

2/3'

,' 2 '

'($'

$00%)

$ '<3,

-(9$2,

'+ 00$- 9$0+

/0$ ' $'

;:: 3,

,/$0 -( $ ' ($ 2(9 (

$'+ 00$- 9$0

$00%$ 9)$'+ 00$- $22 30$6 322$ )($ $-$,)$0 I$68,$ A$0 ) (2 0$ 2',

'2( $,/3, #, + ,) ",

- $ %/,/,

',=2($, (0 '( + 00$- 0 ($60$' ( 2 ' 2' ( 6 ( 2 , -(') 2($, $ /22 0$ $'( 2/,+ ,6'(

8,3-(' ,

,8%, ''($'3,

-() $ '

:9$2 2/3'

,$ '( 8$2 2 $-,

''2 00E )( ($ '0$ & '( ($ ) '( $// 00$ '", ' /0 '($'

-() $ ':($2 , -(')'

, 2'9 '(0$ $ '($'( 9$2 ' 2/3'

9( $2 '( '( ,($ )$6 ''

0%)'( 00$ '", '($ '

6$ $ %$//0

9($'2 ,''( $3'(,

2, ,,

, 9(

(3/'&/22 3,

-()

$ ' :) ($2 /,6

'0% 8

2(9 236/'

',3'( $6 ''

0%$''$ ( ''(

, $6$8$

23 0 22'(

83''

'( )'( /0$ ", '($2 '8

$80 ', 83''(

2$ /, 236/'

',3'( 8% 0 - - ' $ +

-$, -/22 + 2/3'

, ; +

9'( $8+ )

-2,

, ,2'

$// 00$'

3,' '23 ,,6$ % ,,,0$9,$ ' $'( ,)'(

232'$ $80 $ $, $ ,6 00'( 2382'$ '

$0@3 20$9$,

$ 29 $-$ /0$ "$// 00$ '$ $+3,'( $ '"

' 2 '0%)'( -30$,2

$// $0 /0$ ) $// 00$ '(

)($+ - 6

'8 /, /$,

J$-3''K A(

/,'

,20 $0/$/ ,26$%8 $009 '2

73-6 'B A( ,'8 ,, ''(

/,'

,2, 'B < A( 73-6 '2(308 /,'

2'B 2