High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCOCP/3579/2025dismissed

Payal Chaudhary v. Kap Sinha Ias And Others

2025-07-24Mrs. Justice Sudeepti Sharma13 pages

!"#$#%!

% &% $

'() #*() #%

+ ,

% -./# ) .#0#1(2 %#,," , % % ( / #)#%/1(" ( 3 $ 45 7#,% /,, $ %(%"

* %8#) 1

# /,$%( "%"". .8""$" 5 4$./ ,

5!9 :5" )$,%/$%* ;% < =

" >+45 '"& ?

* #% 1

@% $

"%#, % #

8% $,,"! ,""!8# %%5!$%% 2" $%%% 1 " /,$%#%. 7#9 :5")$,%/ $%" .8###%9.#$% # "8# 2"2 .#

8% "%! $,," 1/,# A .# $#

5 2" $ / " %.# /! 5

% /,$$ 9$%#% #8%

,%$"%"!8# $ / "%.# "B# %.#"2"# 5 %$

$ *#2#%"% $

"%#, % ,%$ #

8#""#,% %# ," %% /, "."

(

C$%

+"2 ,%:

# %,%$ $ %

!"# $ %! &!'( # ## ) * # + (!

#+,( - - - # # #

# #

#' ## ! (

( - (!

' $ %!

# #.!( ! !/# !(' !

(

#! !

# -! !#!

- ! ##

-! #

# # -

! ( ###) 0

! ! # !

- #! # (

- + ' (

#+ !

!(' 111111 2

!# -

( - (

- - 3!

245 # ! - !

# . # # #3!

# # - ! # !

(

- #

# ! # # #

(!-

!#(!

#6 , 4 % -

! -#

# ! - # (, 4

(

7"8 *7!

" ! 8

, # #

- - -

, /#9!( : #( ( ;1 - !

#, < %(!#

-1 -

# ! , /

# # /#9! ( -

, = # & &< # ( %!

# - # -, 9! !#! !

# # !

! , ( %!

, 4

#% -!# ', !

# -#

# %, 4!#

# & &<

, 4! &* - & , # - - ##

, / ! #

#' , ?

- #& &< , 4 % -

! -#

# ! - # (, 4

(

7"8 *7!

" ! 8

, # #

- - -

, /#9!( : #( ( ;1 - !

#, < %(!#

-1 -

# ! , /

# # /#9! ( -

= #& &< #( %!

# - # -,9! !#! !

# # !

! , ( %!

#% -!# ', !

# -#

# %,4!#

#& &<

- ,4! &* - & , # - - ##

, / ! #

#' ,?

- #& &< ,"

&8 &# .@0

# #

," 0!

$ %! !# # # 9,@

A ?

# !#6 40 /4 -;7! #& ;@A ?

!"#$ %!8 0

*&(,

!(' 60

0 -

" #

;0#

245 # # #

- ! ## #

8 - 0 # - ! #

# - < # - %#

4 4

&% -

# #. % @

# 8! % % - -!

- - (

C! -

# 4 % -

7 7& 7"8#< @7

< .

-4 < DEF8( %9!

# 7"8

! < E-!

!# #

! # # 7"8 ! (

/## ##

#< @!

#(# #

;

! !# #.

-4 #

! #! 2 : F3 3

? F?1 & 8!-!

#1 ! -!#; % - ! ( ( # : ! -!#( #

- - - !

# ( !4 ! #

/## !

# (: ( %

#:# # -( %4!0= ( # G# C!% #

9!#-(

D #:

5 3!# 4

( # !

3!# ! (

#7# (!#

(

# 9!

- G .

#4 !

# # #(

( %

7 #

# %@ # '! # # ! 7# ( %!

C!% #

9!# % #

##!

( %F ) 0& *3& &<F&3 %4!0, 4?

0@ #( ( %

#( #(

( %F

/## !

#F&4 ( %!

& &< ;- D & &< 4 8! - ! # !

!#!-#! 4!

!& &< C! - !

! ( G AH;A:7 /## !9!# -!

# -

# ( & &< / ## ! 9!# ! /

/1##

!# & #/ ( E @ &3 %4!

>23 %48! 1 #

- !- & &< #! - ! F # >2 9!

B&3 %4!

% #

9!#-&3 %4!

!# - >2 44

&( %4! & -!#;&%#

0# 4 -!#

/ -!## #( #*0 -,!#

!7 @ -!#

- - ! / ## - # ! # A ? ###

# -4 %

H9!

( @ / " FH 4

4 - #! # A ? # H 4 3! #4 !

C!9!# F "!# 0 /

-6 0 # #

-I"2G;4 "5G;4A ? ! -! #( & &< !

(

C! 9!#!#

- # ! &47

&4! #!4 ##C!% #

9!#!

# &! #

;<; !

% !

( # %;'(;# # @ #

(

- 0

0 -

-4

-4 *< ,4";4 8F844"G;4

>2;3 %4"G;4 ###- 9! ! % - # - # # # # - 4(!# !

( # !# 7# # !

# ##

-0

0 -#

<% -## #

! 3-#

" #

!"#$ %! 84J!

E5 8!

##)

##G #

# ! A ##)( -

! ( -

& -3# 0

?10<7#

8 *3# , 5

(D5#! 3!

#B--

- #

#9! !

! '

!# !-( # !#

# 4 - -9!

! !#### # ! # - !

# - ! # ( - -

!# - 7 # <?8

" - D

<"@

@ 79! ! # #

; #

!# 1

4G %.# ! 9!

(

# !

# (

# % -

4 - ! % 7"8

# - !

! 1 # # ! ! - !

- # #-

&-#

(

# ! G

EG3!

# ( -###

- # # !

# B !

!# !

- (!

#(!

- 0

# (%

- !- (!

# !

# -(

#'! !

-K )1111111 D1111111 E

.B( !

! "# *8", -

(#!#

#!H

- - 1 # !

# ( # !- - ( # ! -

# - !

! #! # 4

#B - (

(

- !

# !# 2G3 - #

# #&!(

!# 2)*, 3 - #

## - !

##! (5( %

# #

'!#- .!( ! !/#

- - #(

# ! - (

# # ' ( ! '! # -! ( # #

(

& 0

# .@ $ %!

!(9!

#3!

### # (!3!

#!#

!#- # # # # #

# !

# - !# #! -# # !

! 3!

# #

" # !# !(

-3!

# ! # -

- - # 3!

( ! !

9! # 3!

# - # - (! # % -

# - - - #

!# - ( ! - !

# -!# L ?, %$"C/ # #, # "." %%%#% 1 ,,% ##.%2 % 5!#

, % / %/ ,%2 2" ,$ 58 #/ ,%2 % , < D 7#, %# ," !. /%"

%% 5" # 2

8""$" 5 % 2" #4$./ #9 :5")$,%/$% 7# $% ## $54/%#,% /, , %"!2" $% ""

$ #,$%28 /, 4$% 1

E$ "!1 # ,% /, , 8$" 5 / 5" = 7#, %1 ,5 . ,""!%5!# $% 2",,%,%2"%/ % 8#"81# ,%

.# /,, 8#$ ! 5"5

* 2 ##, %# .. 8# "!5 %5 %2"$ 2C$ ". ,%1 / ."!%2 5! / ,"

.%2 )$# $

$ .%

5$ # 4$",%

%5$ .

"!#5$%. ., ! 5%# $% 7# !". / $ #4$"%$/ 5! .. . %$/ #,, .1" .%,2 /%"

1 , ."%! $ %/ #2%!$ $%"." !

/ ".

#/ % 4$

7#9 :5")$,%/$%1

1# $ .

# /%. .

.%!$

%$,$"$ ". 8#12% ,%%$#1% % "

# $ #",% #%,$% $%" 7#)$,%/ $%/,#""!#"# $#". 18# B,""$# %/ 4$ %8#%$##$ 4$ 8#$ " # 1%

" !%"1 %/% " +"2 C% # /

%,%$ $ % / 5 #

- # !( - ##

# #!

- - !

!(!

(!#

(

! '!

!! '!

## #

L 7#, %:

$ .%2"$ ". #

% $" .%

/ $ #4$",%

1#%5! E$ % .# 2"$5"/ % $% # $% * /,%21 # % 4$ 1 # 5 /"! "/ % 4$ C,$ "!1 8#$5 ./,5!2C$ $

%$,$"$ ". (#

4$ $%1%% /!5/#,% 5 %2

#9 :5" )$,%/$%

" # $1 8#% #$%"/ #,%2 2/" %2"$ ".

" .#* 4$" !

/ 7#9 :5"(,C$%5 %2

$ % /# '!#

- H # #(

- !

( # #

@ # % #

- ! # ( #

.! - #1 ! # !#

- # - ! !

7#9 :5")$,%/$%#

"!/,# A#

%%2"$ ,,"

5!/, .C/,"%!

#". .,% * ;% 2"%!<

" % & '!

('")*

1# 9 :5"(,C$%#" ""8

- !

- ! (

#'!#

# ( - '!#

! !

!- !'!#

!( '!#

# -

# # . % -

# # # # # # 9! # ₹;4(# # ! !7# 4 4" #H !#(!

37< ( L 7# $% #

%28##,% ,

%BC/," $#5$ * #$ /,%2%# $%$,#"#

!#4$",%

,%2 ,""$ 5!$

%$,$"$

". 7#/ % $% #$%% /$ 5,% %2

%. $ .%2 %2 .4$" %2

* #".##%. .1 8##542 .

% .%% /

.1# $% ,,%,%/, C/,"%!

$, #, % (% ."!1# /,, /

8# ₹

F +$, G!7#$ "! 7# /$ #""5, 5! # , %8# ,% 8 / # %/# #

4$./ 8# # % $% $ 45 9%! 9.# $% 0% (

18## #""5$"A%

%$ F% 2 ;/

0%+/1$ 45 9%! 9.#$%1# .%#1 D * # 2 $" /," 1 # /$ #"" 5 %2%%/#, % %%% " %2 $5!#/, $#%!

C- !"#$"#%&'#()*+,-%#(&.+#/0 #&-.

!"#$"#%%#'.%$(12#0 #&-.