← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRFA/1895/2016dismissed

Rattan Lal And ORS v. State Of Haryana And ORS

2022-09-21Mr. Justice Anil Kshetarpal34 pages



!

"#

 $# %& '

(

" '

! )&% 

*+

, - .

.

' / **- .

.



00 '

  1 ..2233 45

 ( '

   ..2 "-  6&0 .

%#1

"

$0  

  

   

   

    

 





   



         

      

    

 

      

!     " !    

     #$ 

     

 

     %

     

    &  "

 

     

     

    &    



 !   '



 

  (

'#"



'

&"7!# '

( ( )  * 

&

!!  + !!  +*  ,   &



  & & 

-

* & *

  





  & '





!

  &



  !

 *



  "&  ,  & & 

. ".- ) &  

 / &   2  (34/ ,  & & 

5 (34/ 6-

 

  !

 *

  2  ,  & & 

. 1.-  

 &&

  !

 *

 "  

$  & 

2  

*

 )    !  !



  

   * 

&

!!   

* ! & *



 ( 8 )   !

  &   * 

&

!! 







    "  %  (

&  

 / &  (34/    !! 

2   & ! &  

 89 '  :( ;: 8;;3 %   

 ;: ;8 8;;4 :

#

 

 3  1 &&  !



$ 

    & " 0;;;;;;<+ !

 &    &   % +' +  !

 "  !  !

&

        && " 9;;;;;;<+ !

 &         )

2   &       &   ' 





8= ;( 8;(( / >   3/ & ! & *

    "

 

$ 

    & " 48:389:<+ !

 ,(4;3 =:

! 2 

- 83 ;( 8;(0 ) " *

!

 





  *

& & !

 

$    " 48:389:<+ !

 ;/ ;( 8;(4

8 ( :

>  ?!   ! 

& 

2     

   

 

2       

  ' 

+(;

,  & & 

.

'+(;.-



   !

  & '  

@    

 & 

* !

 

'

  ' 

 !      

2   ) "



 

  

   

 (43=  

      & 

2   7 

&  

2   

  *

  



   %     



   

 

 " 

  

 (

 / ! *

 '



A* %!  

 

 (449+40

  



  

2   ) !  

   & *



 ?  

2  

( / B   

 

  & '



  !     

  1

 & 

 !! !   

 

  ( 9 B

!!  &  !   &    +  

 

 



       

          !

      

  " "    # 

 $  %&''

( )* '

"

$'#" '

&(

$

8 ( @       ?

  & +

9 '

+ ),' '

+- .# '

+

.# '

+/

  '

+/

  '

+0 ' '

+1 2,#3 '

+ 4  5 6.  '

+!

7)6 

'

+8

36759 '

+ ' 5 69 '

+( : 5 6; '

+-

, 6'

 '

+

< < 8 8 @  

   

 !  &  

  !! &    + =$ ' 9 # /-   ( 8( (88    >+:  55   5038/4  ! -   #6      ) !"+     # =$ '( 4    9  )     #  7           

   4?+))

 (/6> :

# '

/ 

  <  6  .&6  7 

.  6  >  7    

          7#+  

  =$ '-

'   #  '

 4   5 . @9A6> =$ '

9 # !

1 !+ +(881B- 3 45

   3      (80!    #    ) /// -  # !++(881 ;

 #'



' 5 696 + )5 6>

 =$ '/  ! " .

C=+::6  5  / 8 /    #  #>C.#'

!

 7 (/+8(+(88( ;      #    )  (6--6!!6888"+     5      )  (/"+ # =$ '0  - "  9D C=+::6  5  /!1 (    #  #>C.#'

!

 7 /+8-+(88( ;      #      ) (668!6888"   5      ) -(0 (/ # =$ '1    "  9D C=+::6  5  101 /    #  #>C.#'

!

 7  +/+(88( ;   #      ) 68861(6/0"+    5 ) -(- 8 # =$ '

   "  9D C=+::6  5  /-( 8    #  #>C.#'

!

 7      (0+80+(88(  ;   # ) !

6006888"+   5 ) 11 8 88 #  =$ '!

   "  9D C=+::6  5  -!! -    #  #>C.#'

!

 7      ( +81+(88(  ;     #      ) 1-6( 6888"+   5 )  -/( 8 # =$ '8  ( " 

C=+::6  5  0- -0    #  #>C.#'

!

 7 1+ +(88  ;   #      ) 016/86888"+    5 ) 6806/- "+ # =$ '8   " 

C=+::6  5  0- -0    #  #>C.#'

!

 7 1+ +(88  ;      #    ) 06(6888"+     5      ) !06080"+ # =$ '8   " 

C=+::6  5  08

   #  #>C.#'

!

 7 1+ +(88 ;   # ) 6886888"+  5  ) 60/6 /-"+ # =$ '  - " 

C=+::6  5  --( 88    #  #>C.#'

!

 7  +(+(88  ;      #    ) (6!86 86888"+     5      ) 16/!8"+ # =$ '    " 

C=+::6  5  (0 1(    #  #>C.#'

!

 7  +(+(88  ;      #    ) 6(686888"+     5      ) 86 0( 1"+ # =$ '(  - " 

& C=+::6  5  --8 88    #  #>C.#'

!

7 0+8(+(88 ;      #    ) -6(16 -6888"+     5      ) !6- ("

8 # =$ '( &5. '  /6 >  (/#4EE #'

+(

: 5 6; .;96>1+(+(8/ =$ '-    + 6-+/,

 (/     #'

+(

: 5 6; .;96>1+((8/ =$ '     -/7#+    >5

#   8            

      

   (/6  )  )     

   (/#'

+(

 : 5 ;.;96>1+(+(8/ =$ '/ '  + 6-+/6+ ) )       (/        >  5 

        

 (/> )

)

 

56  +

5

          -  F  /  

5## 

:  

6 9> 1+(+(8/ =$ '0    9@>A+;

+(88-"( /  !+8/+(88-   !"





    01  

   5>> 7   06;  .  > #

  ?    ))  #'

+-

, '

6 9> =$ '1     9@>A+(88-"(18   +8/(88   0

 

 0

           #  '

+- 

, '

6 9>   ) )  =$ ' 9 #  - (+ 8/+(8805

5 // /-))  6>

#

)

>9 6  9 # '

+-

, '

6 > =$ '! 9 #,5  !+8-+ (8/#

>G', >#  >5  9 6  9 5

 5 

     H ) 88 ! #))              !+8/+(88-@=$ '0A" 



=$ '(8 9   #      )?   - -     (+8/+(880    # '

-

 , 5 '

6

    9 6  >  55 )  )     >   



   =$ '( 9 #   !+ 8+!!/   ((1

     #

  ) 3  3,6      9 6  >  55     + > =$ '(( 9   #         @>A+;

  (88("(-0     -++(88(    

  5

      ?                   !

##$6>55-0 /-  =$ '(- 9   #          @>A+;

  (88-"(/     8++(88-   0

  5      ?                 

 -+/6>55-01 8 =$ '( 9 #  ! 8 + +(88/   5        ?                      -+/6  > 55      # 

    9 6  >  5 --- -0    )  

6  >9 6    9 6> =$ '(/ 9   #    %&   '   () #*(  ' & +#  #,   ((+8 +(8  5

 

) 8-! 01 # 5

  !

#$!     (- . !

 >#  =$ '(0 9   #    ,5    # >G  >5  9   

 

    ',>#69 5   !+8-+(8/ 5

 

) 88 ! # 5 

))  >

3  

  >#   =$ '(1 9 #,5  -8+8-+ (8    # 

  I  5    .   <56  >  5

    )  018  # 5 

 

5 C=+::62# 56

 -+/  +   > 5   

 >#   =$ '( 9 #,5  -+8/+ (8#

> . #6>G    .   <56  >  5

  ) 18"+  # 5 

) )             ,#  #  

 >#  =$ '(! 9 #,5  8!+8 +

 (88    # 

  I  5  6 >G .  <56>  5

  ) 018"+  # 5 

   -+/6> )   

 >#  =$ '-8 9   #    ,5    # >G  >5  9   

 

    ',>#69 5 6  (0+8-+(8  5

 

) 1( 1/ # 5 

  -+/ >  

 >#  24 .



)D /0(0(88  8 :

@

     !

&   * 

&

!!    

 !  & +  9 #

 0 8! (809 '+ !1 +(88!6 29 >75

 #

 2 

 >#

J@=$ >9+(A (  9#       (0 8- (8!  F  (( 8 (8!   9&9'+-(!1+(816   5 2 I  

*J6@=$ >9+->9+ - 9#2 1- / 8  (8!

@=$ >9+/A 8 / B   

     

  & '



?



 "

   

">+( 8 9 @  

  &   ! *



  & '



+ =$ ) 0-+0 9   #          (1 8 (8          5 (1- (1    # 

  ,  5 6  >

 9 6>55



 5 >5

# 8  







  ) 08 88  ) (-! 00 # ) /8 88   ) 8-- 8/ ## ) 

)'

6 > =$ )( 0!-+0!!

    9@>A+(88 +;

"

0  -+8-+(88 " 

 55

  -8- 10         #     (/> =$ )- 18+181          0   

  

5   9@>A+(88 "

0     -+(+ (88!   5   

    5 ( 8

 

#) 

)6'

6 96> =$ )

18!

9#  =$ )/ 1+1

9 # 81  (/ 8 (88! 5 )  6806/88"+  384>  49 =$ )0 1/+1 9 # ! /  ( ( (88  5 ) (/6886888"+ 8 3> =$ )1 1!+1(( 9 # 1 8!  81  (88  5 ) (-6(6/88"+ 8138 4> =$ ) 1(-+1(0 9 # /((   - 8- (880 5 ) (6006888"+ ( 3/4> =$ )!

1(1+1-1 9 # 0 0   (0  (88!   5    ) 616886888"+ ( 38 4> =$ )8 1-!+1 ( 9 # / /  (( 8 (88  5 ) (/6886888"+ (13 4> =$ ) -+1 9 # 10  ( 8 (88   5   ) 06!6888"+   8-38-4 49 > =$ )( +1

9 # --(-  8/ 8- (88   5   ) 60!6888"+   8(384 49

 > =$ )- /+1

9 # 00  (1 8( (88! 5 ) /6886888"+ 8 3> =$ )

!+1/( 9 # -- (  81 (88   5   ) /60(6/88"+   8-35  3 =$ )/ 1/-+1/0 9 # !-  8/ 8/ (88  5 ) !60 61/8"+ /3/45

 3 =$ )0 1/1+108 9 # ( -/  8 81 (88! 5 ) 6886888"+  /8 38( 4    3 =$ )1 10+10

9 # -/-  -8 8- (881 5 ) (16886888"+ 8138045

 3 =$ ) 10/+10!

9 # !

/  (!  (881   5    ) 6(86886888"+ -3845

 3 =$ ) 11+11

9 # /0  8! 8! (88!  5   ) !6886888"+   8 3045

 3 =$ )!

11/+11 9 # 0-0  8( 80 (88! 5 ) ( 6!(6/88"+ (835  3 =$ )(8 9 #,  (/ # 

  )  '

    9  &6 >0 ( (8/ 8 0 @ !  

   ! *

   

  & '



!



 ! C? '+( :

) " 

3/ & !  

    83 ;( 8;(= @ 

 

 

2      

&

 (+/ :+9

 

*

'+(;

)         

$ 

    & (8D !



 *

  &

 

2 &    &

 (  / "

! " 

 

   

   

$ 

    & " (4;3 =:<+ ! 2 



 

   

*&

/ )  7

     !  !



 

 

 

*

  ! 

 !

 *

 "



  &  "  

 2 B  

     !   

  

     :/ $ 

 /



* !

 *



  & '



    & " 8004//=:<+ !

   

 =:39   ;/ (( 8;(4 ,C? '+9- &

    & " (;=/=0340<+ )  !

 &     

!

 &  &  

 / &  (34/    :( ;: 8;;3 *

      

 

)

 

  &   

!    &

2 &

 89 '  &  

!



!

 &   &  &  

    & " 8=49<+ ! 2 

 @  * 

 

!! 

     



&  !

 !

 &    ! 

 89 '  @ 

      !     

 &       !

   & &  

 / &  (34/   



  !   * ! 

 

   & 



    *

 "  

!!! 

       !  !     

 &    

 !   

 

  !

 *

 1  2  * !

 !

 

   

8 ! &  !  &    C? "+9 "+0

 "+(( 

     * 

    &

 " 89;;;;;<+ !

     1

 && " 0;;;;;;<+ !

 

!   * &   

*

'+(;    

$  &         &    *   !

&



*



    & " 9;;;;;;<+ !

 = '

1"#11 

&(

"#

= ( @   

 " !     

 & 

$  &

&& !

 &  

2 & ! &

 (

 / "

! "  *

!

  &  

 / &  (34/    (4 ;: 8;;: *



'

     & #  /  #,)#   % 0  #$12#,34  ! #1434$ ) "

 

    C? "+9  "+4 , ! *



 -

   

  !          !



 & ' 

 

 (988/   :( ;: 8;;0      

   ?  

 8;;0     

 0/03   80 (( 8;;4  !  8/ $ 

 /

   * *2     & &  

 / &  (34/  "         

   !

 !

 &     !

 



2   = 8 7& ! &   

!!!  

      *

 " 

 

  "   

!

       





  !

(3   )     

! 

$ 

 *

 '



 (4 ;9 8;;:

@ 



  

&  $

9      !

&  

&

   * (4 ;9 8;;:

 :( ;: 8;;3

 

   

 *       

    & (8D !





 

$ 

    & " (4;3 =:<+ ! 2 

 )  

 &

  

 ,C? +80- !

     &*! 5 '6

 

  

 

$  &      *  & 



 *



!   ,#  /  #, )#    34+2$"

@ 

        $

 &   ! 



  ! *  &  

 /     &   & %



   &* ! 5 '6

 

    &

! & (;



        

$  & 

2  

    & " ((;; (4<+ ! 2 

 = :

)    * 

     &*! 5 '6 

$  

   *  &  <! < ! @   &     

 

$       

!

 *  !

 

  !

 *  

 * ! *

 !

 )    & (8D  (;D     &

! &  

((

      &    ) ?!  

  

     !   $

 * 

    @ ! !  &     !

    !  &     @&      &      !!

    !  

   !

 $

    !

> 

 

$  & 

2     

 2  $ & 

!!!   ?!  *

 



 * 

= / ) 



*  * 

 

% 0

''   #27"  #,  343       8 )          ,  !

 - . #'&  +#'# #& / 9  % #   :

 ! #"4343     !

  &  ? 

+ ! 

;

5+ 5 ) #6 9# & !.  #,)#   53476++12

 9  



5

 6

9   

 

 5        5   

      55  ;

 # 

 

  9 

  5  

5

 

   5



,5 6

 9 



   

  

 5 5



 ;

9 

 

    ;

  

 $  B+  :6

>5 9

          5

   

  5    K

  5   

    >#6  (8(  99  &   'F>  !8

L  6

  5 

              

      ;

      

   

       :    6 

  

,5 "           6

5

# 6    5

 

  

6

  

  

    > 6   

     6  

 



     

  5   K

 5  

   >#6(8( & 'F>!8

L   , 

#

>5 9       5   

               



6 

 







 

  

    ,    

   

 $5

  5    

  

  

  

 

 6?               

,5 " 5

    :

          5             



5

    

 5 3          



>5 9  5

5 ;

     

 

 

  6#

 

   55

   #            

 #  

   6 :

   5



     ;

           #  #   5 

    ",5 :

 # 6 #

 ;

 

#

, 

      

    

        

         ;

  # 5             ",5

 5  / 8 # 

 5    ;

 ,5 

 

  5    

5  ) #6  



  

## 

 

  #    ;

 5 #  #

 

         5   ,         55  

  

    56 6     6

 

 

:  #

    

5 5

##  5       5 " ;

     ",5   

  #             

     ;

 #

#,5 "   #

  $  :       ",5       $6 

          6     ",5    

  5     

  5

#,  : 

         5   6  

  J

5 # 5 #          

 ",5 

# * ! / :

 

 9 6

  

 



 $

  

 5

      

5

6

9     

;

9 $  ,   



 :   65   

 ;

#



  5

 

 

9 

   # # & 

  5

 6   # , 

 

55



 

  



 #

  #



 # 

 

5   C

 

6  

6 #5 #6

 ##

 5

  :

5 

 6

  9  6 

     #6   

 

#5    ! 0 D

6 

  5 

  





 !

 6

9

      # 

           ;

6

9 

  



 :

 

 

 6

  

  



    :  6

#              

     5

  >6

,"  #  

  

  # 



 $

          :       #6

   







$ C #6   (;

9  :6

 #

>M 9 5

 6 6  

 

#     6# 5

 

    #

  

5 

 5

 

  #5 6



  # 

 #        

 5

    

  6

5   6

>M 9    # 

  5

   ##

>M 9 4,3M@A6  #  

 > 6

 6

#

6

'5 <5# 

#  #



#



  ;

  >G    9      &.;##,#  51146"++34<6

$5

 G) .G 

B+ 34 :

 6

  



    5       ;

        

#56#6

5 

55



  

    

  

 

 5

 

    ;

            ##

 

 

55

,  5+$ 5 

     #    ,5+6        5

  

    :  6

 

 #

  

 # # :

  >#@

 62 (06/1-A ;

           5 



     

 

   6           

,5  

  ,  

   

  6 



 

 





    G # 

 #        #   6         # 5  

   5,5  



#5

 

 :    

      5  #  

 ,5 6  5

  * = 9 ) &   & 

*  

$ 

 *

   

* & <*  $ !

 *    *   ! 

!      &  '  ".

   !    *     @    

    2  $ & *   *  

 @    &     ?!  & 

2     

 *  





 *

  

!  

 &

&&

2 ! = 0

      

$  !   :( ;: 8;;3      & &  

 / &  (34/    

!!!   ! 

&   ! &    ! *

 !

 

 *  &+ 10 ' '

$'#" '

&(

0 ';

1 1.

.

<*=*

.

13 '

.

'

3  >5

* . >5 $ 

* . >5 * 2 1?.

(

* . ( +( 9:3( (8 ;8 8;;3 +9 /3(=:(89<+ 8:=(0;;;<+ /4;;<+ +/ 43/= ;4 ;( 8;;= 8;04(

 ((/((33=/<+ 8004//=:<+ 99(9<+

10 ' '

$'#" '

&(

0 ';

1 :

+9 (9(3/ :( ;: 8;;0 89;

 8;;;;;<+ :3=8;;;<+ 3;;<+ / '+9 =:39 ;/ (( 8;(4 8:+(= (;=/=0340<+ :0;9;49;<+ =//3 9/<+ 10 ' '

$'#" '

&(

( "+9 /;=( 89 ;3 8;;4 /+(; (/;09;;<+ 89;;///<+ 9(0 08<+ "+0 (8 (8 8;;3 (  89;;;;;<+ 89;;;;;<+ 9(0 9:<+ :

"+= =3;4 ;= (( 8;;3 =+3 8:(89;;<+ 89;;;;;<+ 9(0 9:<+ / "+3 (988/ :( ;: 8;;0 :

+(9 8(00;;;<+ =;;(8(<+ (// 09<+ "+4 0/03 80 (( 8;;4 :

+/ ((=;;;;;<+ :30==04<+ =44<+ "+(;

((9/9 88 ;( 8;;3 :

+:+(/ 9(4:=9;<+ (9;;;;;<+ :(;<+ = "+(( ((=0( 83 ;( 8;;3 :+0 0(4;;;<+ (9;;0;0<+ :(;<+ "+(8 (::8:

;9 ;: 8;;3 8+(; /04;;;<+ (9;;3;;<+ :(;<+ "+(:

((00( 8= ;8 8;;4 / (9;;;;;<+ :;;;;;;<+ 0(4<+ (;

"+(/ ::38 ;/ ;= 8;;3 : 9089;;<+ (9;;;;;<+ :(;<+ (( "+(9 ((4:

;9 ;9 8;;3 (9+(9 (403=9;<+ (;;;;;;<+ 8;0<+ (8 "+(0 83:9 (; ;= 8;;4 +8+8 3(;;;;;<+ (84:/(:<+ 80=<+ (:

"+(= (:9(:

:; ;: 8;;= =+0 8=;;;;;<+ 84934;/<+ 0((<+ (/ "+(3 4/9( 84 (( 8;;= :

+=+( (8;;;;;;<+ :;4(=3=<+ 0:3 3<+ (9 "+(3 /9(0 ;4 ;4 8;;4 /+(0 4;;;;;<+ (9;;;;;<+ :;4 48<+ (0 "+(4 (0:0 ;8 ;0 8;;4 +/ :=9;;;;<+ (9;;;;;<+ :;4 48<+ # =     !  ! '!    ( !#&' () +

  ,#  > #,( . )&#,  (  '# ! (#.  = = @&   &

$

  

 ! C? '+(

 

 

 ! C? +:    

 *



2      

!



 

     ?    &   @ &  

 & 

& C? +:    

  



  '  )  ! 



 

 '  "



  = 3 )  

 9:3(  

! 

&& 

  '



   

!!!   

!   

* &   !  !

    E+ +E 

2   @

&  *  

  

 8;(4 

  & '



!

    &







  ! )     ) "    ! 

 ) !



  2 "

* 

 "  8;(:

,  & & 

. 8;(:

.-

   &  ;( ;( 8;(/ )

2 &      8;(:

  

  

*   

*& 

   



 * *  

    !

 

 (34/  )

    2  ?

 

&      ? &  &  &    &  &  

 /

 &  (34/  

  & '



  ! 

2  !

 &   * 





 &









) #$ !  ' 7



1 & >+4=(3+8;;4 



2    &  

   * 





 &







   

   &  

 / &  (34/      

 

  )  ! 

  (0 ;4 8;(0 ) '

   2    ?    &



   

  

 

   

! & ?

 ' 

  & '



  ! 

   

  *

 % 7

&  '

 A  





&

! &   & ! !

  

  & '



%  !  *   !  ! )

  & '



 

 

     &

! &

2 &    %  !

&  ! 

&& 

  !

    &





    & " 8=49<+ ! 2 

  



! *





  ? &   

 =:39   ;/ (( 8;(4 )

&  !

 &  

* !

 *



  & '





&&  &   F &

 

&     ?

&  "    ! 

 ) !



  2 "

* 

 "  8;(:

   &

      



&  &  

 / &  (34/    )   

&  !

 &  

 

* !

      & !   ! &   (4=( ' 

    *    * *

 

  !

 

!  

$  & 

2   '   

 =:39 ! 

  

C? '+9   *  ! &  !! &

 

$  & 

2   !

 

     & !

 * !

 &     !  !

 * ! *



  & '



= 4 )  



  !  

 43/= ,C? +/-   ;4 ;( 8;;= &

  !

 !

    & " 8004//=:<+ B

 & !  & 

 ! ! *



  & '



    

 

&  !

 &     



&&   & 

2    

&&  &  

)      ! 

 

&  !

 &     

 

 43/= ,C? +/-  !

 * 



2   @ &  

&            

 * ! *



* !

 )      

 

&  !

 &   ! *

 

 43/= ,C? +/-     

     

2   *

&    :( ;: 8;;3   *  &   !! = (;

) "

        ! *



  & '



   

  

   !

  B

 & !  &  

 ! C? '(    

 

&  !

 &  

      

& 

 8

2   

 

 

2         &         ?! 

  

*  !

  @  !



   !

 $

 *

 

     *

  *  

:

 &  2  !

 &       

  !

     

    & !

 &    % +' +

 !

 ) !

 &          $



 &

 

  !

 

 !

 &    



  & 

   )

&  !

 &      

(9

 & 

2  

= (( !

 &      



  !  

  !

 *

   

 

$  &       '  )  

 

   

& 

 !

 *

  & !

 (

 / & '   &    (4 ;9 8;;:

C? +(3 

 

  !

 *

 "  (8 ;9 8;;0 

! 

2 &    *

&    (4 ;9 8;;: 

! 

 (

 / ) 

 

$  &   69 

 ;;

   

    & " (;;;;;;<+ !

    5,   



    & " (9;;;;;<+ !



     

 

  !

 *

 "  :( ;9 8;(:  

 



2  &    (4 ;9 8;;:   

$  & 

2  

*



    & " =(;<+ ! 2 

 )    99 :9

 

2 &

 (

 / '  C? +(4<80 

 !

 *

 '



 

$  & 

 9

2  

 (4 ;/ 8;;:

    & " ((;; (4<+ ! 2 

 &

 ( :

 / ' 

   C? +8/ 

  !

 *

 1  

2    &

 :

 9 '  @     &  

 / &  (34/     (: (( 8;;8

  1

&&

&

$  &  69  6 5 ,6     &

" 0;;;;;<+ !

     !

 &   

 

*



    & " 9;;;;;<+ !

 @  

2  " 

    (4 ;3 8;(;

 

$ 

    & " 0=;<+ ! 2 



*2   '

     " =89 =9<+ ! 2 

  

 &    *



!  

   88 ;3 8;(/ ,C? +89- )  

 

  C? +8= !

 *

 "  :; ;9 8;((  

 

$  &   

2  &  

 / &  (34/   (; ;( 8;;8 &  !! &   ?  & '   

A* C +@@ # 

  ' 

 :





 (

 /  "

! "  ' 

*2   '



 

$  &   

2  

&  & 

    & " 409<+ ! 2 

 

 

  

 !

 *

 

 

$  &   

2  

!

  &  & && !!  

  !   

!

   *   !

 *   & !  !

 * !    

  *

   &  

$  ! 

    & &    !   @  

 

* &      

* & 

!

 *   

     

         !

 @  !    "

         

&  ! 

$      & &       

!

   ' "



3 ( 2  

 !

 *

 "  

    

  !

 *

 1 

  3 8   !  

!!  &





 ! &  12>=@

$0 # %#'!

5" BN"

  BN" Sr. No.

Case No.

Party name 1.

RFA-1895-2016 RATTAN LAL AND ORS V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND ORS 2.

RFA-1091-2022 STATE OF HARYANA AND ANOTHER V/S RAJINDER KUMAR AND ANOTHER 3.

RFA-1092-2022 STATE OF HARYANA AND ANOTHER V/S SMT. AVINASH KAUR THR. HER P.O.A.AND ANOTHER 4.

RFA-1089-2022 STATE OF HARYANA V/S NIRANJAN LAL AND ANOTHER 5.

RFA-1090-2022 STATE OF HARYANA AND ANOTHER V/S HANUMAN SINGH AND OTHERS 6.

RFA-1093-2022 STATE OF HARYANA AND ANOTHER V/S SMT NIRMALA RANI AND ANOTHER 7.

RFA-2948-2016 KIRORI MAL V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND ORS.

8.

RFA-2846-2016 KULDEEP SINGH V/S

STATE OF HARYANA AND ORS 9.

RFA-2702-2016 SAJJAN KUMAR AND OTHERS V/S STATE OF HARYANA & OTHERS 10.

RFA-2614-2016 BUDH RAM & ORS V/S STATE OF HARYANA & ORS 11.

RFA-3758-2016 SANT SINGH V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 12.

RFA-2696-2016 SUBE SINGH AND OTHERS V/S STATE OF HARYANA & OTHERS 13.

RFA-4387-2016 DILAWAR SINGH AND ANR V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND ORS 14.

RFA-1898-2016 NARESH KUMAR AND ORS V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND ORS 15.

RFA-1899-2016 RAMESH KUMAR AND ORS V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND ORS 16.

RFA-1897-2016 VIJAY KUMAR AND ORS V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND ORS 17.

RFA-1896-2016 RAMESH KUMAR AND ORS V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND ORS 18.

RFA-1893-2016 SMT. LAXMI DEVI AND ORS V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND ORS 19.

RFA-1894-2016 SURESH KUMAR AND ORS V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND ORS 20.

RFA-263-2018 SHRI BALRAJ SAPRA & ANR V/S STATE OF HARYANA & ORS 21.

RFA-4904-2017 DATA RAM (DECEASED) THR. LR V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 22.

RFA-2829-2016 LAXMI DEVI AND ORS V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND ORS 23.

RFA-2120-2016 BHAGWANA AND ANOTHER V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 24.

RFA-2692-2016 SMT. VIDYA WATI AND ANOTHER V/S STATE OF HARYANA & OTHERS 25.

RFA-2606-2016 DR. TARUN SAPRA AND ANOTHER V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 26.

RFA-2705-2016 RAGHUBIR AND ANOTHER V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND ANOTHER

 : 27.

RFA-2947-2016 MAHENDER KUMAR V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND ORS.

28.

RFA-2843-2016 MIKI SHAH THR. HIS BROTHER G.P.A.

V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND ORS 29.

RFA-2845-2016 RAM KUMAR AND ORS V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND ORS 30.

RFA-2830-2016 OM PARKASH (DECEASED) THR. LRS AND ORS V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND ORS 31.

RFA-2119-2016 M/S SUPER SEEDS PVT LIMITED THR. ITS DIRECTOR V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 32.

RFA-2117-2016 RAM KUMAR V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 33.

RFA-2701-2016 KRISHAN AND OTHERS V/S STATE OF HARYANA & OTHERS 34.

RFA-2825-2016 NAND RAM AND ORS V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND ORS 35.

RFA-2840-2016 SOHAN LAL V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND ORS 36.

RFA-3040-2016 DIN DAYAL AND ORS. V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND ORS.

37.

RFA-2946-2016 RAM BILAS V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND ORS.

38.

RFA-2703-2016 RAM NIWAS AND OTHERS V/S STATE OF HARYANA & OTHERS 39.

RFA-2881-2016 BALWANT AND OTHERS V/S STATE OF HARYANA & OTHERS 40.

RFA-2121-2016 NARESH V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 41.

RFA-2870-2016 BHAGMAL DECEASED TH LRS V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND ORS 42.

RFA-2844-2016 NUNI RAM (DECEASED) THR. LRS AND ANR V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND ORS 43.

RFA-2122-2016 NAND RAM V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS

  44.

RFA-2124-2016 ARUN JAIN AND OTHERS V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 45.

RFA-2693-2016 BASANTI DEVI AND ANOTHER V/S STATE OF HARYANA & OTHERS 46.

RFA-2615-2016 BISHMBER DAYAL V/S STATE OF HARYANA & ORS 47.

RFA-2616-2016 SURESH KUMAR & ORS V/S STATE OF HARYANA & ORS 48.

RFA-2651-2016 SMT. KANTA AND OTHERS V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 49.

RFA-2695-2016 TARA CHAND AND OTHERS V/S STATE OF HARYANA & OTHERS 50.

RFA-2125-2016 MOHAN LAL V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 51.

RFA-3525-2016 VIRENDER TANEJA V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND ORS 52.

RFA-2841-2016 MANJU V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND ORS 53.

RFA-2847-2016 INDER SINGH V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND ORS 54.

RFA-2849-2016 HAWA SINGH V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND ORS 55.

RFA-2880-2016 SMT. CHANDRO AND OTHERS V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 56.

RFA-2824-2016 RANDHIR SINGH V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND ORS 57.

RFA-2827-2016 OM PARKASH (DECEASED) THR. LRS AND ORS V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND ORS 58.

RFA-2003-2016 SINGHA RAM V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND ORS 59.

RFA-2689-2016 NIHAL SINGH AND OTHERS V/S STATE OF HARYANA & OTHERS 60.

RFA-3757-2016 SATISH KUMAR AND OTHERS V/S STATE OF HARYANA & OTHERS 61.

RFA-3756-2016 TARANJEET SINGH V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 62.

RFA-2123-2016 BANWARI V/S

  STATE OF HARYANA & OTHERS 63.

RFA-2607-2016 DR. VIKAS SAPRA V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND ORS 64.

RFA-2698-2016 RAM CHANDER AND OTHERS V/S STATE OF HARYANA & ANR 65.

RFA-2826-2016 MUNSHI RAM AND ORS V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND ORS 66.

RFA-2694-2016 SADHU RAM (DECEASED) THR. LR AND OTHERS V/S STATE OF HARYANA & OTHERS 67.

RFA-2697-2016 RANBIR SINGH AND OTHERS V/S STATE OF HARYANA & OTHERS 68.

RFA-3293-2016 CHOTI DEVI V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND ORS 69.

RFA-2842-2016 SMT. KRISHANA DEVI AND ORS V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND ORS 70.

RFA-2828-2016 PARVEEN KUMAR AND ORS V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND ORS 71.

RFA-2118-2016 BHALE RAM V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 72.

RFA-2318-2016 LALIT KUMAR & ORS V/S STATE OF HARYANA & ORS 73.

RFA-2181-2016 ANUP KUMAR & ANR V/S STATE OF HARYANA & ORS 74.

RFA-3755-2016 SANT SINGH V/S STATE OF HARYANA & OTHERS 75.

RFA-2690-2016 SUBE SINGH AND OTHERS V/S STATE OF HARYANA & OTHERS 76.

RFA-2691-2016 RAJINDER PARSHAD AND OTHERS V/S STATE OF HARYANA & OTHERS 77.

RFA-2848-2016 BHARAT SINGH AND ORS V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND ORS 78.

RFA-2699-2016 GANGA DEVI AND OTHERS V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTEHRS 79.

RFA-2700-2016 HARI CHAND DECEASED THROUGH LRS V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 80.

RFA-2704-2016 LILU RAM AND OTHERS V/S

8 STATE OF HARYANA & OTHERS 81.

RFA-3039-2016 SAJJAN KUMAR V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND ORS.

82.

RFA-1132-2021 SNEH LATA V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 83.

XOBJR-107-2022 SNEH LATA V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND ORS 84.

XOBJR-106-2022 NIHAL SINGH AND OTHERS V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 85.

XOBJR-91-2022 TARANJEET SINGH V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 86.

XOBJR-142-2022 DR. TARUN SAPRA AND ANOTHER V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 87.

XOBJR-123-2022 NARESH V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 88.

XOBJR-141-2022 MOHAL LAL V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 89.

XOBJR-140-2022 BHARAT SINGH AND OTHERS V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 90.

XOBJR-89-2022 SMT. VIDYA WATI AND ANR. V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 91.

XOBJR-119-2022 BANWARI V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 92.

XOBJR-118-2022 SADHU RAM (DECEASED THR. LR AND ORS. V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 93.

XOBJR-135-2022 DATA RAM (DECEASED THR. LR V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 94.

XOBJR-136-2022 CHOTI DEVI V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 95.

XOBJR-157-2022 RANBIR SINGH AND OTHERS V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 96.

XOBJR-137-2022 SANT SINGH V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 97.

XOBJR-152-2022 OM PARKASH (DECEASED THR. LRS AND OTHERS V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 98.

XOBJR-130-2022 BALWANT AND OTHERS V/S

8 STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 99.

XOBJR-131-2022 RAM CHANDER AND OTHERS V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND ANOTHER 100.

XOBJR-149-2022 SOHAN LAL V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 101.

XOBJR-92-2022 MIKI SHAHTHR. HIS BROTHER G.P.A. V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 102.

XOBJR-102-2022 KULDEEP SINGH V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 103.

XOBJR-101-2022 RATTAN LAL AND OTHERS V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 104.

XOBJR-111-2022 SAJJAN KUMAR AND OTHERS V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 105.

XOBJR-114-2022 BHAGMAL (SINCE DECEASED) THR LRS V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 106.

XOBJR-115-2022 MAHENDER KUMAR V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 107.

XOBJR-94-2022 INDER SINGH V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 108.

XOBJR-93-2022 DIN DAYAL AND OTHERS V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 109.

XOBJR-133-2022 LILU RAM AND OTHERS V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 110.

XOBJR-116-2022 SUBE SINGH AND ORS. V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 111.

XOBJR-95-2022 BHALE RAM V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 112.

XOBJR-121-2022 SAJJAN KUMAR V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 113.

XOBJR-129-2022 MUNSHI RAM AND OTHERS V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 114.

XOBJR-134-2022 PARVEEN KUMAR AND OTHERS V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 115.

XOBJR-128-2022 BISHMBER DAYAL V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 116.

XOBJR-126-2022 RAJENDER PARSHAD AND ORS. V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS

8  117.

XOBJR-125-2022 RAGHUBIR AND ANR. V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 118.

XOBJR-139-2022 HAWA SINGH V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 119.

XOBJR-113-2022 ANUP KUMAR AND ANOTHER V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 120.

XOBJR-138-2022 SINGHA RAM V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 121.

XOBJR-103-2022 SURESH KUMAR AND OTHERS V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 122.

XOBJR-105-2022 OM PARKASH (DECEASED THR. LRS AND OTHERS V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 123.

XOBJR-104-2022 KRISHAN AND OTHERS V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 124.

XOBJR-117-2022 BASANTI DEVI AND ANR V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 125.

XOBJR-156-2022 SMT LAXMI DEVI AND OTHERS V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 126.

XOBJR-158-2022 HARI CHAND DECEASED TH LRS AND OTHERS V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 127.

XOBJR-148-2022 RAM KUMAR AND OTHERS V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 128.

XOBJR-146-2022 SMT CHANDRO AND OTHERS V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 129.

XOBJR-147-2022 M/S SUPER SEEDS PVT LTD THR. ITS DIRECTOR V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 130.

XOBJR-145-2022 RAM KUMAR V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 131.

XOBJR-108-2022 SANT SINGH V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 132.

XOBJR-151-2022 VIJAY KUMAR AND OTHERS V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 133.

XOBJR-122-2022 VIKAS SAPRA V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 134.

XOBJR-85-2022 RANDHIR SINGH V/S

88 STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 135.

XOBJR-120-2022 RAM BILAS V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 136.

XOBJR-82-2022 MANJU V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 137.

XOBJR-132-2022 LALIT KUMAR AND OTHERS V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 138.

XOBJR-84-2022 SATISH KUMAR AND ORS V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 139.

XOBJR-112-2022 NAND RAM AND OTHERS V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 140.

XOBJR-83-2022 SMT. KANTA AND ANOTHER V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 141.

XOBJR-155-2022 SHRI BALRAJ SAPRA AND ANOTHER V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 142.

XOBJR-154-2022 SUBE SINGH AND OTHERS V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 143.

XOBJR-88-2022 LAXMI DEVI AND ORS. V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 144.

XOBJR-96-2022 ARUN JAIN AND OTHERS V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 145.

XOBJR-98-2022 BHAGWANA AND ANOTHER V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 146.

XOBJR-97-2022 SMT KRISHNA DEVI AND OTHERS V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 147.

XOBJR-100-2022 TARA CHAND AND OTHERS V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 148.

XOBJR-99-2022 BUDH RAM AND OTHERS V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 149.

XOBJR-124-2022 KIRORI MAL V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 150.

XOBJR-144-2022 NARESH KUMAR AND OTHERS V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 151.

XOBJR-143-2022 DILAWAR SINGH AND ANR V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 152.

XOBJR-86-2022 NAND RAM V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS

89 153.

XOBJR-87-2022 RAM NIWAS AND ORS. V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 154.

XOBJR-127-2022 RAMESH KUMAR AND ORS. V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 155.

XOBJR-150-2022 GANGA DEVI AND ORS. V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 156.

XOBJR-109-2022 NUNI RAM (DECEASED THR. LRS AND ANOTHER V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND ORS 157.

XOBJR-110-2022 SURESH KUMAR AND OTHERS V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 158.

XOBJR-153-2022 RAMESH KUMAR AND OTHERS V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS

$0 %#'!