Balbir Singh Alias Billa v. State Of Punjab
9(8 . )#-
9(8 . )#-
9(8 . )#-
9(8 . )#- 8') (!
2 8') (!
2 8') (!
2 8') (!
2
" #$%
&
B=(' ' )#(!
>(!.+.
+#,
B=(.7)#9(#'
- - - -
!(.(#'- !(.(#'- !(.(#'- !(.(#'- 5/ = " " 5/ = " " 5/ = " " 5/ = " " / / / /
!= !,)'
" #$% (9 2 9>)8 != ' #9(!
" #$%2 9>)8
!=
, #9(!
" #$% "!
99 ' )#
+#,
@@@@@ @@@@@ @@@@@ @@@@@
/ / / /2 = 3/6 = 3/6 = 3/6 = 3/6
" " " " !(.(#'
.(8)#9 C
% ' 0
! 1 "+!
1.%
"
#% '
3*)!
.%)!'
4""56
! # )=C
= := 2
!($ .'(!(9 )**(#8(.
7+# .%
"(8' )#.
2
!8)' 8 !+$ $.
.08%)'!)7 8 "+ .'
#8(.
3*)!
.%)!'
4"
8'56
#9 (#
)9(2
:
3*)!
.%)!'
4562
) 8(
;
),2 .'! 8'
<! '.
3+!
6=
=
> <(#
($
88+.(9
7(!'
# #$ 8'
> #$
)?(.
#')? 8
('.
8)#'
# #$
.'! 7.
3')'
C
('.2 =(=2 !
9)
)#$ 2
D
9!+$ <)#(0
($(9 #')? 8
!(8)>(!(9 *!) )<
=
/( !#(9 8)+#.(
'(!
8+.')90 . #8(
= := = /( !#(9 8)+#.(
*+!'%(!
.+ < ''(9
')!0 7!)> . )#.
8'
.8!+7+ )+.
8)<7
A '%2
'%+.2 7!).(8+' )# .+**(!.
*!)< #%(!(#'
9(*(8'.= /( !#(9
8)+#.(
'(!
0(9
'0 '%(!()*
.'(#(9 /( !#(9 8)+#.(
'(!
.)<(A%
. <
8(9 8) 88+.(92 <( , . %
**)!9(9
8)#8(.. )#
8))!9 # (#8% > 9( ,+9$<(#'
= ..(9 CC CC CC CC = /( !#(9 8)+#.(
*+!'%(!
'(!
.+**(!(9 <)!(
0( !.=
%+.2
7!
0(9 *)!=
C=
/( !#(9 8)+#.(
)77).(9
!$+ #$
($ .(9
.(! )+.
'+!(
#92 '%+.2
9(.(!>( 8)#8(.. )#
/( !#(9 8)+#.(
*+!'%(!
.+ < ''(9
!!(9 ! $)!.
'%+.2 <( 9 .< ..(9= /( !#(9
8)+#.(
.((1.
8( !(8)!9 8+.')90 8(!' * 8 E=
= )+!'2
1(# !(8)!9=
!9 8)+#.(
! >
!' (.
$)#( '%!)+$%
>
!(8)!9.
.(=
:=
!!(.'(9
= := A%(!( #
#>(.' $ !! (9 )+'
7!(.(#'(9
= = )'
7!).(8+' )# A '#(..(.
8 '(92 )+'
A% 8%2
(?
< #(9
'(= #9+ '
8)#8 +. )#
1(
)#$ ' <(= '
9 .7+'( . <
8(9 8) 88+.(92 <( , . %
#'(9 8)#8(.. )#
> 9( ,+9$<(#'
= = ! >
8)#'(#' )#.
.(9
$ >( ! .(
..+(.2
.%
' )8 # 9+! #$ 8)+!.(
% .
9((<
77!)7!
9((7 #') '%(.( ! >
8)#'(#' )#.2
$(2
(.'
7!(,+9 8(
)'% #$ #$ !)+$%'
*)!A !9
#9 8
1( %))9
.8)#9 #$ *!)< 7!)8(..
,+.' 8(
#'(!*(! #$ 7!).(8+' )# (> 9(#8(=
:=
#9+ '
.(8)#9
''(<7'
.(8+!(
7!(*(!!(9
9 .< ..(9
A '%9!
A#
= = )A(>(!2 1((7 #$ > (A
(?'(#9(9 8+.')90 <)!(
0( !.
'%(!( #)
.+ .'
7!)$!(..
#(9
** !< ' >( 8)#. 9(!
7!)* '
!(*(!(#8(2 !($ !92
,+9$<(#'
..(9 "
' '
* G ;%
* G ;%
* G ;%
* G ;%
>(!.+.
!0
>(!.+.
!0
>(!.+.
!0
>(!.+.
!0
#)'%(!
#)'%(!
#)'%(!
#)'%(!H (> A%(!()* 9.
+#9(!-
I
.
(7 )$+(
)>( 9 .8+.. )#2 *)
)A #$
7! #8 7 (.
(<(!$(-
"(8)#9D.+88(.. >(
7(' ' )#3.6
J %(#8( .+8% !(,(8'(9
.) $!)+#9
'0 '%(!()*=
=
"+8%
.(8)#9D.+88(.. >(
7(' ' )#3.6
A%('%(!
(!
9 .< ..(9
A '%9!
A#D9 .< ..(9
7!(..(9D9 .< ..(9 #)#7!).(8+' )#
(!
9 .< ..(9 <(! '.=
)!
.(8)#9D.+88(.. >(
7(' ' )#3.6
.+88((92 7(' ' )#(!D .%
(..(#'
0D7(!' #(#'
!(G+ !(9 .%)A .+ .'
#$( 8 !8+<.'
#8(.
.%)A #$
<(!( .+7(!* 8
).'(#.
#$( A)+ .+** 8(=
<('
7%)! 8 (?7!(.. )# .((1 #$ .(8)#9D.+88(.. >(
3.6
.'!
8'(9 #')
'(!
'(!
7(' ' )#3.6 A '%)+'
.+ .'
(**(8' >(
8)#.(G+(#'
#$( 8 !8+<.'
#8(.=
K
) (?% +.' >( $+ 9( #(.
7)..
9)A#
A% A)+ 8)#.' '+'( .+ .'
#$( 8 !8+<.'
#8(.
(>(!0
'.
)A# +# G+( 8'.D8 !8+<.'
#8(= 1 #$ .+8%
''(<7'
#)'% #$ +'
+')7 (#9( >)+!=
!$)2 ..+(
(.'
(*'
,+9 8
A .9)<
9 .8!(' )#
#$
.+8% .(8)#9D.+88(.. >(
7(' ' )#3.6=
K
#
8%)).(.
.(8)#9D.+88(.. >(
7(' ' )#3.62 8)$(#'
+8 9 .)#.
7(!' #(#'
!(G+ !(9
!(8)!9(9 #' #$ .+8%
9(.7 '( .+8%
.(8)#9D.+88(.. >( 7(' ' )#3.6= # )'%(!
A)!9.2 +.(
> #$
.+88(..*+
8)+#'(# #8(9D(#'(!'
#(9
.+8%
.(8)#9D
.+88(.. >( 7(' ' )#3.6
9(8 7%(!
*!)< )!9(!
..(9=L
:==
#9((9 7!)8!
.' # ' #$
*)
'%(!()*
.
7(!
8+.')90 8(!' * 8 E=
=
!#(9 8)+#.(
.+**(!(9
7(! )9 <)!(
0( !.2
<)#'%.
0.= # > (A
''(!2 ! $)!
8'
#9.
+'(9
$%'
!' 8
)#.' '+' )# #9
:==
% .
,+9$<(#'
' '
;+ A #9(!
>(!.+.
;+ A #9(!
>(!.+.
;+ A #9(!
>(!.+.
;+ A #9(!
>(!.+.
+#,
+#,
+#,
+#,
..(9 :C EC :C EC :C EC :C EC C C C C 3 --
: 6H
0 #$
' ) 9(8 9(#9 ,+9$<(#'.
)#5 "+7!(<(
+..
;% '))# >.= )<( "(80=2 %
" 9+
(%< #'+
>.
="= 6
" H +
"% 1%
>.= .%'!
#)'%(!2 C36 3! < #
CCH )%9
+.
& +..
>.= 3 ( % 6 !(7)!'(9
"
! < #
77(
)=C D
E= =
' '
I% ''
.A
"+ % >.= M(.'
(#$
LH I ' .% 9% 1 !0 & >.=
M(.'
(#$
L2 "7(8
/( 77(
3!
=6 )=
= = ' '
I)% << "
# * "% 1% >.=
+, 'LH ! < #
77(
)=
:
= ' '
)7
;! .%#
& )7
!+.<
>.= # )# #9
#1+!
% +9% !0 >.=
9%0
!
9(.%2 C3C6 3! < #
EH '%+.-
IE==
! $%'
.7((90
(?7(9 ' )+.
> '
*($+ !9 7!(>(#'
+#9+(
)77!(.. >( ' )#H < ' $
#? ('0
8)#8(!#
88)<7 #0 #$
88+.
A(
8+!'
#0
<7 !<(#'
'0
88+.(9 9(*(#9 % <.( *2 +'
'%(!(
)>(!
!8% #$ .)8 ('
#'(!(.'
> #$
.7((90
% .
! $%'
!(7(
8'+ !(8(#'
' ) 9(8 9(#9
)>(!(*(!!(9 "+7!(<( )+!'5.
,+9$<(#'.
9)A#
.(! (.
9(8 . )#.
)7(# #$ +7 #(A > .'
*+#9 <(#'
! $%'.=
8)#8(7'
.7((90
#') !' 8
(..(#'
!'
*+#9 <(#'
! $%'
*(
(!'02 $+ #'((9
7!(.(!>(9 )+!
)#.' '+' )#=
! $%'
.7((90
($ #.
8'+
!(.'!
' <(
!!(.'
88+.(9
8)#.(G+(#'
8)#' #+(.
$(.2 <( $(
#>(.' $ ' )#2 #G+ !02
77(
!(> . )# .)
#0 7)..
7!(,+9 8( !(.+ 9+( <7(!< ..
>) 9
. #8(
' <( 8)<< .. )# )**(#8(
8! < #
7!)8((9 #$.
8)#.+<< #')
* #
'02 8)+
>(!'(9=
.7((90
! #$
G+ 81 9 .7).
. #( G+
#)# 8! < #
,+! .7!+9(#8(=
)>(!8!)A9(9 )+!'9)81('.2 >0 >) +<( A)!1
!(.+
7!(..+!( 7!).(8+' )#
) 8(2 #9+ '
1((7.
(#' !(
8! < #
,+! .7!+9(#'
<(8% # .< .'!(..
.'!
#=
)A(>(!2
(?8+.( 1((7 #$ .A)!9 <)8 (.
#$ #$
88+.(9
#9(* # '( 7(! )9 ' <(=
'
.(!>(
#0 8!(9 '
8! < #
,+.' 8( .0.'(<2 '%(!
1(.
** !.=
$+ #'((
.7((90
#'(#9(9
>) 9 )77!(.. )#
7!(>(#'
<7). #$
7!).(8+' )#
)
7!)8((9
.)#
9 .7 '8%=
$+ #'(( .(!>(.
'%!((*) 7+!7).(= !.'
7!)'(8'.
88+.(9
)77!(.. >( 7!(
<7! .)#<(#'H .(8)#9 (>(.
88+.(9
#? ('0
7+ .+.7 8 )# 9+( +#!(.) 8! < #
!$(.
7!)'(8'.
! .1 (> 9(#8(
).'
<(<)! (.
9 <<(9
..
$( ' <(2 '%+.2 <7 ! #$
'0
88+.(9 9(*(#9
% <.( *= '
$)(.
A '%)+'
0 #$ 8)#.(G+(#8(.
7!('!
9('(#' )#
>(= 88+.(92 7!(.+<(9 ##)8(#'2
7!)>(# )'%(!A .(2
.+ ,(8'(9 7.08%) )$ 8
7%0. 8
9(7! > ,
*(2 +.+
)#(!)+.
8)#9 ' )#.= G+
<7)!'
#'2 +!9(# 9('(#' )#
.+8%
88+.(9 *!(G+(#'
> ##)8(#'
<(< (!.
% .
0=
%(!( 0('
#)'%(!
.7(8'
''(!
9(.(!>(.
8)#. 9(!
$(=
($
88+.(9
' #$ 8)<<(!8
G+ #' '0
8)#'!
=
M% 8)#. 9(! #$
> #$ 8)<<(!8
G+ #' '02 1((7 < #9
! $)+!.
(#+<(!
'(.
)+!'.
88+.(9
! #$ 7+
7!).(8+')!
> #$ ' .* (9 '.( 'A # 8)#9 ' )#.
.)#
$!)+#9.
(> #$
88+.(9 $+ '0
)**(#8( !$(9D
($(9
'2
1( 8)<< '
#0 )**(#8(
A%
.'! #$(#'
! $)+!.
<+.'
<(' 8+ )+.
.8!+' # N(9
819!)7
88+.(95.
*+#9 <(#'
! $%'
.7((90
! $%'
*(
7(!.)#
(!'0
!(#9(!(9 #+$ ')!0 +#A !!
#'(9
0.
,+9 8
7!)8(..2
!' 8+
A%(!( .+8%
03.6 #( '%(!
''! +'
88+.(9 #)!
,+.' * (9
(#9 7!).(8+' )# 8)$(#'
.)#.= # #9 > 9+
1(7'
(% #9
!.
#)!9 # 7(! )9 ' <( 1 #$
!(*+$( ! $)+!.
9)A#
=
($ .
'+!( '.
A .9)<2 )!9(!
(#.+!( .7((90
' <( 9 .7).
.(.
7!)> 9(9 8)#.' '+' )# .7(8
)+!'.
:
: 8'=
)A(>(!2 '+!# ( .)#5.
(0( 7!)'!
8'(9
0.
.0.'(< ' 8 #(** 8 (#80 *!+.'!
($ .
' >( 7+!7).(=
9+'0 )+#9 (#.+!(
(8)<( 8)<7 8 '
> )
#9 > 9+
5.
*+#9 <(#'
! $%'.2
#)'A '%.'
#9 #$
#0'% #$ 8)#'
#(9
'+'(=
M%
#$
$)>(!#(9 ! $)+!.
2 <+.'
.'! 1(
,+9 8 )+.
#8( ('A((#
($ .
' >(
#'(#'
8+!
<(# 8( 9!+$.
8!).
#8'
! $%'
88+.(9
(?7(9 ' )+.
!) )#$(9 ' )#2 A '%)+'
,+.' *
+.(2 ! .1.
#.*)!< #$ 7!('!
9('(#' )# #') 7+# ' >( <7! .)#<(#'2
)+'8)<(
#' '%(' 8
7! #8 7 ,+.' 8(
(G+ '0=
!$)2 +#(G+ >)8
#*(!(#8( A%(!(
8)#8 +9( A '% #
.)#
' <(2 !(.+ ' #$ 7!) )#$(9
' )#2 '(.
7!(8 )+.
*+#9 <(#'
! $%'.
*(
(!'0 #'(9
#92
.+8%2 8)#9 ' )#
(!'0
)>(!! 9 #$ '+')!0 (< !$) 8!(
8)#. 9(!(9
7(!
8'.
$ >(# .(=
# )'%(!
A)!9.2
7(!'
# #$ 8)<<(!8
G+ #' '02
$!)+#9 +#9+(
*(''(!(9
=L
"+** 8( *+!'%(!
9('(#' )#
+#9(!'!
!!
#'(9 8'.
8 !8+<.'
#8(.
.(=
E=
# > (A
)>(2
)A(9= (' ' )#(!
)!9(!(9 .(9
% .
*+!# .% #$
D.+!('0 )#9.
' .* 8' )# /9= 8)#8(!#(9
)+!'D+'0 $ .'!
'(= )A(>(!2
99 ' )# 8)#9 ' )#.
8)#8(!#(9
)+!'D+'0
$ .'!
'(2 .%
!(< )+#9 *)
)A #$ 8)#9 ' )#.-
3 6
.%
< .+.(
(!'0 #'(9=
3 6
.%
<7(!
#0 (> 9(#8(2
9)8+<(#'
!02 9+! #$
3 6
.%
.(#'
% <.(
#0 (*)!(
3 >6
.%
8)<< '
#0 )**(#8( A%
3>6
.%
9(7). '
% .
..7)!'2
#02
)+!'=
3> 6
.%
$ >( % .
8(
7%)#( #+< (!
#>(.' $ ' #$ ** 8(!D" 8)#8(!#(9 ) 8(
.%
#$( % .
8(
7%)#( #+< (!
A '%)+'
7! )!
7(!< .. )#
)+!'D
$ .'!
'(=
3> 6 .%
#0 ##(!
'!0
3> 6 .%
.+ < '2 * !.'
A)!1 #$
(>(!0 <)#'%2
** 9 > '2 (*)!( 8)#8(!#(9
)+!'2
(**(8'
8)<< .. )#
#0 )**(#8(
.(9
#
*)+#9
#0 )**(#8(
% .
(#
!$(9
2
. .
% .
** 9 > '
)'%(!A .(2 <)>(2
*)!'%A '%2 #8(
% .
+'
8)+!.(2 .%
' )8 # <(! '.
'%(!()*=
=
#
#0
*)!(.
8)#9 ' )#.
'%).(
8)#8(!#(9
)+!'D+'0 $ .'!
9 !(8'(9
%(!( # )>( .%)A #$
#0 )'%(!
.+** 8 (#'
+.(2 '(D8)<7
.%
(!'0 <)>( #8(
=
!9(!(9
88)!9 #$ 0=
)'% #$ %(!( # )>( .%
8)#.'!+(9
(?7!(.. )#
)7 # )# <(! '.
.(=
" #8( 9(8 9(92 7(#9 #$ < .8(
#()+.
' )#2
#02 .%
.) #9.
9 .7).(9 )**=
3" / " / " / " /6
8') (!
2 8') (!
2 8') (!
2 8') (!
2
> !
M%('%(!
.7( 1 #$D!( .)#(9-
(.D)
M%('%(!
!(7)!'
(-
(.D)