← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/694/2012dismissed

Maan Singh And Others v. Gurbax Singh And Others

2015-11-30Mr. Justice Sudhir Mittal15 pages

 

      

  

 

    ! " #"

$%

  



 !"#

 "$ &   & '() *+*

  ,,,,  

 

        

   

   

   

     " % & & 

    "       "

    -"

$ .

 & 

  "    

  /. ""  '"

  0   1 '   "            +      .  2"$*3  4   /('$ /

 "' 0  / )

 $

 . ' -  #+ ' . .

     6 7 -''

 

. '$+*     .

     (" '     -+  -"

   



  .  ' +  ("$.   & 

 "

    

8 0 

 +  .   / 0 

     " .   8 0

"

 / " + $       * ' /*

*0

* 

*#"



2 

   /*  . $ "



& 

  '$""

 

/ * +    '  "  $" /   

 $  "

%  "  *

95: /  ;* 

8 0

'    0.  $"     0     $  .

 /       '        $   2  

     

 0 .'+$ -  *::# *4     +"6

 +   

2

 

 0  '  

+  1 ;  & 

 "

   2

   /      "

      '    2  

*  ' /   0   $.  

 8 0  

   2



" '  

7 



+             ; ;*    $/ -  *4 *         -"

    -  *  4  3   -  *  +       * '   - 

 

 -   + 

 

$" + + 

 ;    *       $ -   !   

* -   

.  "  $"    #+ '*  *   $  ' - #+ '   & 

  "

               

*$/ -  *4 .     +  -   + '

$*"  +        $          '    - #+ ' 3  * /*"  +$  +

'

""

  .       

$/

. '$/   -'' *  7 <"

 +      

      " 

 -+ -"

4  '(" 3 -+ 2" * +(" ' 



   

8 0



$"  (" '$'

 

 : ('$ /

* '

-  #+ '.  "' $   

$/-  *4  

  +$ 7 -'' *- 

  -''  '   "* 

 ' /. 0.    / + 3  $/ 7 -''  

 $ '$    $

$/   ("$" (" ' -+ -"





   ("$.  

. $   " +       "        

('$* ("

 +"-"

."  /-+ -"

  ("

 

 ('$ & "'$     +    "

;

-&- -  #+ '  ".$/     

"   :  .   '     2  

*    

  ' "  /  ;

=  .     ' " +$   "

 "

%2

'"" "  & 

8 0

  $  2

 . +

   /3 /.   ' ' . +0  '& 

8 0



0  '   /+ . +"

      '"   7  -'' *  .

  +      

      

     0          '  

   .  

'   

 *  . ".

'$/  -"

5 >?

 @  

      / A6&&

?

    

           B"     

    0



'0  

('$

/

 '  

 " + A6&& ?

 "'$ A6&

?

 

 + "     "A6&   C 1 8          +  +   "    ;  -"

"" ( /

  ' 

:+.   

 " "  * "

." ' / '+(" '   

"

" *  /+

 '$  -"

& 

   $  2" *7 <"

 @.  -"

* +(" '  

*   + "'$   

  

+"     ('$"   &"($@+"*$" $ +  * (" '9 $/  -"

. "

 

" $   +

"   '    *  "    '"   . B"  .5 >D?

 "

$ . +' '5  +"$/    A D ?

   (" '       $.   ' (""     '   (" "$B""A D ?

   +"  "

     $"  $/ 

  "

$/ + "

 "'

*.

   

 0

A +D ?

   +  "

          +" "



   0    ('$  "9       &"($  @ +"A +D?

 + "'$ 0"



 +" A +D ?

 '  . . " 0  .

 ' '

$ '  AC : +  

"'   "     !  

* $  -"

  $ +        '  .    '"   $/      "

 + "



"$  B"    .   ?

     "   .

. "* "

'

'  "$  B"    .    '  "



-&-"$ B"  . +$

'     "

 "

 

"'*  " 

   B"  $  "$ B"  .    @ "   

;

 

5 . $    

/     '  " 

$" / $0  

 $  / "

 '    *

95    : /

 ;* 

'0.$"   .



       '        $   2  

* *   /           

    0

$  -  *4       -  * .   '  $/     -  *         

    $   $    B" 



 0  & 

 "

 '  . ' / $. 

8 0



$  2

*.

 /   "  '        $ -  *.

+   

   

$*$". -  #+ '* *.  0

$  ' -  #+ '3 -  . '$   *$" '. $"

 $/ -'' +  

 :     ''*                 " 

'(" 3 -+ -"

' "+ (" ' 



 

8 0

.  $"  /  "    $'   $.    "

  ('$ /

.    "' " +*' -  #+ ''* $ "

"   

$/ -  *4 +.  $ 7 -'' & 

. . $" /

+    " 3 

  $/     7  -''    

  .  '    $          $  "      

 &   (".  '$+ +  @ "      '  2

*          * '   "  /  ;

 3 /' " +$ $/"

 "

% ;

*2



'"5

" "  & 

.  +   /

'2

 3 /.

+   '. 0

 '   & 

 8 0  

    0   .

 /      +"

   +  . +"  

        .

  

" 7 -'' *.

+  

 



 0  '     -'' *  7 <"

 '       

 

 : +$ 7 -'' *  

     

"

  "         .     " 

 & 

     '$/ ./ .

 =

-"

& 

 /

    0.    $"      /  +   $      7  -'' *  $"     +    $ +.   "  " 0  -"

    7  -''    & 

    

+ +  * /"

 " /  .  $0  :+.   -  -'' * 7 -''  

" $

" " / '   /     $/ 

    /'

  $/ 7 -''  

*.



. $/



 ' *  .  0.    /  

  "   6         $/     7 -'' . " +$    " 

* +" /"  $  .  $0 

7  -''      /*   *   

 "  + /   " 

  -+ -"

 



 "

$'

 *$"  . $.

  2

 :  (" ' * .    2

.  " *$".+    

8 0

.  " :".  /

'

  .



  8 0

' " " 

$.2

 '*$" " . $/ 

8 0

 " .  '3 * (" ' $ "'$ +"

 

8 0

 ' "+ %0

 ' " .      ' 2

 

/ 3  ' 0

   " "$  

 / 

"   

/   " "  

$ $ * 

%'       

    '   0  

   0 $.8 0

2

 /   11  & 

  +         "

     /  +    $    8 0  

 .        "     0  

      5

%'  "'  $.8 0



2

 /  11$ '  ;5 9 0     .   $     

.  * / $" +  0    - #+ '   "'    $  $ "

      

  " .   2

8 0

 "$ "'  $. ':

.' ' / * .  8 0



+ "

 '$  +



+" "

   ' $  2

3  + "

 

+ 0.

. ' / '*  

8 0

 2

. ' .'+  

+""  

 0 :

.  / $. $   /  11* .   8 0

+  0

  *.

 . . ' 2



  /  ;;5; 3 "" /  $"   E+  ' /  /  11*2

'""

 B"  ;

=.

"     "+     ' /  /  11 ' 0

  :+.   . $

  $"$ B"  .3 ""  2

+ "

'$"  '        "  "  *   

  . +  $ " * (" '   ("  "$B"  "   3     B"     '    $ "$  B"    .    B"       . 

 E+  -+ -"

'  + ("

 

 0     ('$* '$.  +"

 

+.       / '

  7 -'' 3 7 -'' + $   *    $



+  B"  .*.

   -"

                E+      B"  

'" 

"   0 * '+ 

'"     $/ -"

$ .$ '

   $      +          "     / '  + + "

.  + / / "

F"$   



   /" -"

 7 -'' 

 7 -'' $ $%  &    " ." /   $/ 7 -'' * * $ "'  7 -''

. $0

F"  . B" E+ + "'$  

 0 

    

('$ +" * 

 .  3 +"$/

   ' /  11     / /  ;

   "'+. '0" +"

 3 + *' 0

  $/    7  -'' +    $     * '0           

    $  .

 /  ""$  *B""

$/

 

  + F"   '"   $+    $       $  "$ B"  . 1 :+.   + +

$'$/$ -"

* -"

     B" / "

  +  B"  ..  

 + +             '    / ' ' "$(  !)$

 *+ ,-%.-&/