National Insurance Company Ltd v. Gian Kaur And ORS
!"# $%&%!'( ))
( +,
-) -
. ,
!
"# $ %&'())*'+)*, $ +%&'-.*('+)*. !
!
"# $ *-%&'())*'+)*, $ %&'-.*('+)*. !
! "# $ (%&'())*'+)*, $ *%&'-.*('+)*. ////
. , /) , 0 $1# $
2
$
2 *3)-+)*,
1 !
0 " 4 $
$
50 56 %&'())*'+)*, 1 $
1
2 %&'-.*('+)*. 1$1
$ 2 0 $ 1
0
7 " +,
" 2!
2 # # 1 8*)'9 ',:*+ ; ! 8187" 2# $ $ < 2
" 7 $ 0 # $# "07 " ! $ $ 07 $ " !
# 2 1 8)+':),: 4 $
$
5$$ 56 1 # 1 # 0 $$
# 2
$
2
1 8! =# $2$$ $ # "
2$$ 7$ $ 2 1 1 70 7$ 2 >$$ " 1 $ 2 $ 0
$ # $ # $$
#
1 ! $ 81 $ $ 1
?2# "
2
1 7 $
2 1$ 2 "$$ 2
% ).@+)*3 -)(' +:. 2 $
8 & 1 $ # "
2 $2 '
-0) !) # 1!2'
* ! :"3))@'
+ %
4()A6 -")()@'
- $
*)"3()@'
( B
2
#
> 4*@- 6 -"C(:@'
C B :").-@'
3 $
$5*:5 :").->*:>*+D *("(3".:+@'
: % >
*C")))@'
,
$9 *C")))@'
.
()")))@'
*)
+C")))@'
0 *C"(*".:+@'
2
## $$$
2
$$ # 1 $ >
$
1
1 0
#
$2 2
;'+
1 "
#
;'-
1 2
1 ;'+
1 " $ $$
# #$ 2
1"$ 2
$# 2 2 $
$$$ 2 *:) $ 2 )C3$1#
#" # 1
1 $ #
7 2
$$
$ 7
$
$ $ $"
$#
#$
$
11
2 $ 1 1$$ 1
$ 7 " " 1 2 # $ 1"2# " 2
$
1
$ 2 11;'CB # "2
$
$ $% < "< 2
1;': "B " "B 0 0 ;', 2 "2 $ # '
'2 $$ ?
1;':
"B " "B 0 0 "
$##$
## 1
1 1 ;': "B " "B 0 0 ;',
2 $% 2 1
<
1 0
#
< $ 4?E6" "
"2 $ $ ##$ " # 2 $$$
#
3
"2# "
#
1
1 $
1
$ ! "22
$
2 FF 2 2
1$$ "1! =#
$2$$ 0$$
2 7 21 $ # 1 $ 2 $ >$$ 1
1 1;': "B ;',
2 $ # 2 $$$ 1 "2# " 2 #
1 4?E6"
"
?
1
#$$ 1
8)+':),:4 2$BF 62 = !
$
$
?
1 1 2 $$ 1
$ $# " $# 2 #1 ?
1
49>;'+@+ ;'+@+(6$$$ #1
2 $$$ 11 $
1
1 $
1 2 $ 1$
4
$$ # 2 ##
< " #$
$ 1
1 $
" $1
21
#" 2 " 2 $
$#
2#
2 2 $
1 # 12
$
$ 1 1$$
2
< 1
$ 2
2 $221?51
National Insurance Co. Vs. Pranay Sethi : 2017 SCC 270 Magma General Insurance Co. Ltd. Vs. Nanu Ram alias Chuhru Ram and others, 2018(4) RCR (Civil) 333
1
"2$
$
$
$$"
#"2
1
10 # $
# 0
$$
1
1 $
< $ ## $ $$ # 0 0 1 #1 2 $$ 1
$ $# $ "
5
2 #1# 1 "2# "
2 #1>1 9>;'+@+9>;'+@+(
#$$ 2 $
# 1 1 0 2 2 $ >$$ $
"1$ 2 2 $
# "# $ 11 ##$ $$
0
2
1
1
$ *-"2
$ #" # 1 < #
$$"
#0?51
$
$ "
$ >
2 1
*)A $ #
0 $ " 2 1 *)A 1#' # 2Pranay Sethi's case (supra). ? "
$ #
$ *3"C))@' $
$ $ > 8 " "2 "22
$ " ((")))@' "$
$$"
# 0
1 2 1 $2 '
-0) !) # 1!2'
* ! :"3))@'
+ :"3))@'>*+D .*"+))@'
- %
4()A6 .*"+))@'>()AD -3"(,)@'
( 0 .*"+))@' G -3"(,)@' D *"+:"3,)@'
C B
2
> 4*@- 6 *"+:"3,)@'4@6-D (+"C3)@'
3
$ $
*"+:"3,)@' 4'6 (+"C3)@' D ,C"*+)@'
: !
*:
,
$$
,C"*+)@'>*:D *("(:")()@'
.
((")))@'>-D *"-+")))@'
*) % >
*3"C))@'
**
$ *3"C))@ 0 *3"*+")()@'
0 " $ "
$ *3"*+")()@' 2 H,A "
> $ "$ $$ F2 1
1 0
"$1
%&'())*'+)*,
$1 %&'-.*('+)*. $1# ))
. ,6 ; 7 @ I @ ; 1 I @