(O&M) State Of Haryana & ORS. v. Devi Lal







 
 

 




!

"
#$
%%&

#$#'$( "
#$
%%




  

        



  )
 *+,
%
 ,
 ,,
+
****   

    ! 

 " 

#   $ 



 -$"

.
#'"/012
%

%&'   (   

   "  "  

 " )* $ $" )"+*), "  $ -*)      &&./0.&&  1 ) "   " 3  (   " 4   ) " +*),   " 5 -*) %-*   '     6&&0.&&    " 5 * 789950..:; 

 " < ) $  , 

+* $ , )"* 1"  "+*), "5*  1-03
0$
'04 %0'  ($*4 "$* 5-*)%-*  ' % " = 5* ' $  , 

+* $ ) " 

   $* ) $ 

! 

 >*$  ,   

 "$ " 1 $*    "$4 "+ *$" 0?/&?:? 1 

 " 

- 2 - ,&96&?/.6&:&?/.@ ,&:6&?/&0/&?/&  ,&96&?/0  6&/&?/0   $$*   *,,  $  $ "*)" 1   "

*)" 

 *4$  $ 5,,  " +   *$"  6&/&?/0  "1 ""$  ** $"$ $*  $ 0?/&?:?  A 1  

 " * )  $  "      *4"" #,4+  $*      " , " *  * )  "  2  1"$" 1 $   &0B&?/?4 "" *4-*)A5   "%5 7&/&25  &?/?3&??.   8:&?/?'  4  "  )  "  +*),  1 ,   " +*),   " $*   *4 -*) A 5 1 *"   +*),   0::&??9    )*  $ 7&&..&??04 "; 

  <1,4 "5* A* " ""

* 

" 4    *  *,,  $    4      " 4  "1 "*1,4 "" 5-*)%-*  '  +*),  $ 0::&??9) 1"$"  1  1"$" 1 1 4  "  $ -*)      +*),   00&0&??/  4  ) *  " 4    "   $ -*)      " $ " "  1* 4 ," " $ 1""  %6' 1  " 

  $ -*) " " " "  , "1"""" 4 1"$"" 1   $ 1" 0&&??0 * " "" ) 1 " 4    " "     $ -*)   

- 3 - %" ' "  )"   )  ",4 "5* A14 " "C$*  $ ) 4   &:/0..& " 

" C "       7B&92  41 , " , $* 5",

4" ,"- $* "

$ ","4*4+$ *$, 4 " ,  %8' A""  $, 1" 7&80800..&1, 6?0..&4 "* ,5*  "*" C )" &:/0..&"$"  "1    0990..9 "  2 ) C " "  , 7&/08B/  $  1  &&0..8 " ,"   1"$"1  $ 7&/041" , " , 4" ,- 1$4" , + " $* > )" 41" ,#   )" $* !) "

" , 0990..9 1"* "  7&/0"4 =  D " &&0..8$

*&&" 

>*$ %5)5 '!

*  $* 111 4 "C5*  %B' A  )  "    0990..9 " " $* ) C"  7&/0 1"$"" 4 4  )1" "$ E* 4   $* )  ,  "   4  $   C      "



- 4 - %9' F"   5*    " 4   )  4" "   , " 1 ) *   ,  " $    *2 " 4

 "* & G""  )" , 2 C   7&/0    8B/2   "     &&0..8    )  "  $ 4   $* ) "   ,   $4    H  0 G""       $   $  "$"" 0990..94  2   )  )  1   $  1"* +* $    *"   4  4    ) * ,   " H 6 G"" "  $*  $    "  *H 8 G"" *" 4  2+ )

$

 H B G""  " *  "     *H 9 G"" "55* " +* $ 

   "  *H :  %:'    , ) " 4 *    " ) $*    4" " C, )"  $*$4"" $ $,  "   $*  , " *  "   

- 5 - +*), 6&.&0.&& 4 4  )"""$ $14

)*  $"4$*  "*     $" 1 5G7/9:60..6%>C0' 1"  ""4 "  $*  )"$ $1   " &:./0..&1"$" 2 ,  " 1E*"4 "5* 1"$"" $      $" )1 ) * $  +* $  $* * "$ 4 "")" 5* A1"*" "" 0B.80..8 5G7/9:60..64  ) $" $ "$,*)" "*14

" $
 

 %/' F" ) "+*),  6&.&0.&&     7, " )  " "     $ -*)   " +*), &&./0.&&"1"4 4  )*

2

     
   



    
  

   !  " 

 #$  
 
  #  %
  &
$ ' " (
  & '  
      #$ &)# &( "
 # &
$  " *
  +,-. /..0 11/.

. 
!

2
3
!

&
$ 4
5  
  11/.

.#$&)#6  3

2  
  #$&)#!
 "
 
7 ( %
 
   
  8 9

 
$  " (
 4
5   0 . 11: 
 
        
#$     
(   


 
 

 #$
     



- 6 -   #  




 
 $ 9

 
    

 



 ;  #   9
    

 
     
 $    
     

  
  (  
  (  

 ;  #     
        
   $ 
  # 




($ 

 
# # <  $  (  =  # (  
 
> %?' )) 4 "+*), "I 5*  "   

 "  "    )*  $   4  " 5*  %&.' 

5*  " 2*4,""1 5* ")  

 1 )""  1"$ "5*  5G7/9:6 0..6    1"$" "    1  

    78  *$" "  $

 )  $, 

C "   J "$   C    " 4 ,   1     I* "  " 5*  "   " $ 4 

5G""   $

 4  $

 4 $*     , ) "   %&&' A* " $  ""+*), "1  5* *  ,  , " ) $""C5*  $;


 

   

    

  !" """     $ ,   )* J " $1 4$* 1 

- 7 -   $"4 $ 4-4
#5
- 6-$-
7%
- 6-$-
0$- 6
-$"
 
#(0-40#$
8 0$/
0!01
..

-1
#%9&9
#5
::;

.# 4 "
-

+
9 1"  "* ,5* "" "  ,    ( " #*,    "  ,   $$ $ 1" " *

*   " * +4  $ 5,, +*) "  *4  " )*   $ "  " #*, ,*4$*  ,""+ "* * "  , 0?.&&?/0 "  $ ",   4$

4"4 )*  $  $ 4))  "    $   

) " 4  *  " ! 5 $*   0 -*  &?/?1"$ $

$ $* &9" &??.A )* " " $ $*   " ,+  +*),   " )" 5*   "   1" 

 * $

4*  %&0'  " " "   

 $*  

3, $  ""+*), "1 5* +*   4$*","4  C, )" $   "  $  $     +*  $ ,

  $$ $1""$    ", *$" " $

  " $ %  7&/0' 4  "     ,* *  " , $

 4 "  ,   7&/0 8B/ " 4)) 4"  *,4  1 $  1""

$  %&6' * " 

"*&&"*#1

,*$" " 1"  1   .&.&0..8*$" 2 $

 C "    "    09.90..9 

- 8 -  C "       .&.&0..8  4  "      *&&A* " $  ""1 5* " ,    1  " +*),   " 5*    #$  %&
  '$$ ()  '$ *+$,- .

$ .?.?0.&.  ) *  " +*),   * , 5*    *    

/  +$!-,  0,. #$1   2  %   

 $ 3    )   

 $ &:&.&??B  ,  $" +*),  * +$ 0  ,   4) 

 

$ ()  

$ &/&00../  11"$" "$  $ "4 $* 1  *$" " $

4

   ,4)* "+*), 4 "

1 5*  $$  ) "  )* $ 44, %&8'  4"" $ *1"" 4  $ $-160 %&B' F", *  "  1"" "2 "$  $  4 3   4  4 $*  " )*  $ "" "$+*),  * " $ %&9'  **&&" 

>*$ %5)5 ' !

*  $)"1"  "*  %&' F"  2",,4 " $"4 , " )"$  ** $

 " $@ " $  ,,4    4   $ $ *,  "    , 

- 9 -  ,  4  " $,,    " $ * ) *"  "  4 * 4 C )"  1 " 2 "  

)  "  , "5,,  "

$ * ) *"   *$"  "  2  "  )"  $" )" , ) 1"*

+*4  1"$""

4 $ "1  , 4 " 2  %&:'   "   5  78B6B2520.0.  )    

  " $ $$  )  1"$"   .0.?&??0  ($* 

*,, $   $ ,  4  1"$"1, 0::&??9  1 1"$"11 00&0&??/ +*),  $ " $* 1     1 "    " 

$ ,    "  4     :B&???    >C$* $ 1"  4+$ 1 4 "1"$"1  , &?.?0... >C$* $ 11 5 ) " , )"4+$  1 )" >C$*  $  1"$" 1 , 4  " 5*    &..&0..& 1 79&0..&4 " 1"  &..&0..&1,4 "5*  &9B0..&7&8080 0..&1 

") " &9B0..&1"$"1 ,4 "* ,5*  .6.?0..&  1 "  " &:/0..&C ) "    "  4$,    1"  ,  " 1$ 7B&92 .&.?&??: *$"   3  (  "  )"  )  * 4 "   

- 10 - &:/0..& 1"$"1"*4+$, * )" ,"  $* ** ,5* F"   "*4E*   

 $ E* $  $ "     &:/0..&     *"4 "C5* $ .6.?0..& %&/'     " E*   $*  )  2"$    *  $ $

 "5* "$   " "  4   ) )*  $   )  " +*),   $ 00&0&??/4 "1 5* " 4 " ) "  "

$ ,  4   ") * )"$" )" )* $  " ,4* 4 "  "   ", ) " 4 "1 5*  "$ F"   "$

41)" "1  5*    "     $ )  $ "      $ )41 ", "4$,  4  ) "       

   "   2  "  4$* 1" "  $,*" " 1 5*  $$  )1"$"" "4 " 

$ ,  $ E* 4 $ %&?' F"1 5* " * "+*), " 5*  4* $", 1"$"5G7/9.80..:1" $ 1" 4  " 5*  1" 1 ) "

  +*),    #$1   2  % 5 6 %* ' " 1 " 1      $" $* "    $

- 11 -  1 " " 1 "  "$ E* 4  %0.' , 1"4  4  $""5*   7

  8+$,,-  4 () 5$$  %&
 56$$ &6&.0.&&4 , )"       *" )"  "

 ) -*)  $ ) "  (   

  $*  "  "$  $

"1  ( 1 "  $ $*  !

, 5)  

F" $" "1) , 1""  )"

 )-*) *4 $4  )""*  $*  

 $) 1"$"$,, * 1" $ &8 &9%&'  " 5 *  " $ E* $    1* *,$ 1 ,"   $ "5*  

)   , ",*) +*), "$*  #$(1'0#$ %0&' 1"4$*  "5*   ,          

     ) +*), 3$   " 1   5*   &&./0.&&  1"$"  $$  ) *" %00' , &B.&0.0B " -$"

.
#'"/01

'"/

1. Whether speaking/reasoned?

Yes/No

2. Whether reportable?

Yes/No