High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRFA/7185/2013allowed

Subhash Kumar v. State Of Haryana & ORS

2019-10-23Mr. Justice Gurmeet Singh Sandhawalia9 pages

!"#$%&' (""&($&#!))&!*+ ('++,-.&($/"+

&+&'0&#"123 3

'"4"(&#"1 3

))&!*+/*&#-5*!"#6"&'+ ))&!*+/*&#-5$%&7$!$& !

"#"#"

#"#!# $ "

"%""# %"$%$" !

""!"

" " $" %% %!"##%"

# "#%"#%%"$#%"$ $!"

#"#!"!"!$$"!$"#"

# "!%%"! #

" $ " #$%" $" $!"

## " "

%% " $ % $ # % # %" %$#%#

#$$"#!"#%"# %"# $"

#"#%$"###"##$"#!"#$ "

#$ "#$"##"#$#"#!"#"

# "# #"# "#!!"# "#%"

# !"#!

"# $"# $%"#%!"# $"

#% "# "# %"# $"#!%"#!"

#% "#"#%"# "#!# % &'( )*+,-$ -./-# %( -#% -# % )*+,-$%-./-# %( -#%!-# % )*+,-%-./-# ( -# $-# % 1 89 777:9 1 ( , (" 34 '( (5 "34 " (& "34 "

( + "34 "

(, ("34 "

06 3"34 "

"34 " .( & "34 " ((5

"34 ( . "34 " 57 &("34 " ( (("34 ( , ("34 "

5 8( "34 " 9(3

"34 "

6 3"34 ' 2 9 ":" ( 7('

(":"

,, 77!"#%!6!*/!

; 7 9& ( 3

$ 4

-94( ( 4( ; 4<( ((4" != >4>?'(4% $

-94( 3( ' 3 ( 7'

# $

": & ( 4<( (3( &8 5 ((&((4 ( $ # (

4( 47 ( '

' <'

%## "

# #

53 (@ # 7 '(4((&

#4 " 4 '(4'

9!+&3<87=$!'&"#&'>!4'7!%!"/?+ 7$!$& !'5!"! !"# $%&'+8 4

5 3 #"

" "A- &'( ( 7 4 4( '

# $

( 9!+&3<<8!%&"#&'7/"@%?+7$!$&!'5!"!!"# !"$%&'8=B@0)? ((4 ( # #"' '

4<( '( ( (5(& 8'

7' (8( ( (&' 3( & 5(8 : & " C4 (3(4 " ""A- 4'

&(3

53 $ 7 ((4 ( 4( ( < ( '

, ,

$ # "' (& !! 4 (&(3( & 8 5'

4<( 3 ((D (

4 4 !!

" : & 7; 4<( (( .4 3('

# $ $# 3( & 8 5 '

% 5 '

'& '

' 3 ( # # 3 ( '( ' (

53 4'

&(& ' #"""A- $"""A- 7 4 . "

'3 " ( '

(2 (&> 4 = ? ( # # #

# & ' @4 # (

4 4(((4 ( . ' 3 4 ( 4 9& ( .

( ,

, ,,/"A!"#

,, 8%!'!=-/'!"#!"$%&'?+7$!$&!'5!"!!"#!"$%&'8 44 3(' (4 ( (& - - -./-# (A - $-# $"- -#-./-# (A -$$-# - - $!-./-# (A -# -# "'(4' 4( ## /( ( 44 ( 3( &8 5'( (&'(

4<( ((# #"( . 4 4 (#" ""A-/( " " &

5 3 (@ ( (4 (3(4 E

#C ( 3(& (# & (

,<, " ""A- & % . ( 4 ( 4 4( ( 4 4( 4

4 ( 4( &( (4 " (( 4 3 4 ( 4 49& @.

(8 /*!"#!$4'!*!+')'!$/"9/=/$&#?+

!=&+%-%!//0!"-%!/ !$&*!"#!"$%&'B < 7<

( 4( 4

4 3 ' 4

4"'(4 ' 3 ( 7

53 (& 7 "< (& (& #C 4 (3(4 /( & 4 ' @ 4 4 "< ( 45 '

# $ =B@0)? 3

7( . '(4((& (%!'!=-/'8+(!+&

+4)'! (B@0 0%"'(4 #

'(4' "' E$4 (&(3(' (

B@0'(4( # #%"

53 4#" ""A- ( (&

C4 @. (/0/*))&!*<, 2<87$!$&!'5!"!?+ !=%!"#&'!"#!"$%&'8 4( !# "('(4((& ( ( (D< 3( & 4<( (( # #

,, 7&"3( &8 5 94 4 ( (

4<( ((". ( +4'( 4((&

<<8 !=%!"#&'!"#!"$%&'?+7$!$& !'5!"! !"# $%&'+8 44 4 4( # # %

4 3( & 8 5 '

; 4<( ((.4 7 '

3( &4 5(2 9 8 5( 4

( 5 4 8 5 4 4( " '(4 3(' (4 ( ( 3( &8 5 '

53 (@ ## 74 ( 3( &8 5'(

5 3 ( ((& ( 3 (9&

(4 %!'!=-/' +4)'! 1F/ 4 " ( & '(4' ( 4( ((4 (7 3 1

B@ (5

8 ; 7 4 ( ( 4 3

B@0

$ # #% $""A- "%"#"A- 8 5 # B@0

# !

# $" "# "A- $"""A- 8 5 $ B@0%

$ #

# # "$" "A- $"""A- 8 5 B@0 #$ # # $ - -

" ""A- $"""A- 8 5 B@0 #$!

# # $!

- A# $"!"$" A- #"""A- 8 5 % B@0!

#$ # # !

- A# $""$" A- #"""A- 8 5

B@ (5

8 ; 7 4 ( ( 4 3

#% " "A- ""A8 5

,2, # B@# #$$

# % $" !" A- ##"

#"$A8 5 $ B@$

! # % " %"# A- !"!" #A8 5 34 '& ' B@0-(

4 (3

@ 5

& 4 ( (( "%"#"A-7( . ( & 45 '(4( (

B@0- 0- "(' & 45 &4

4(4

53 B@0-0-! ( (& ' @4# #9 ( 4(((4 ((< (/"

( . 5 (4 ( (B@0- G0-%"(( #

#" ' @4

'& '

@42 (9 ( 03; 2A

2 5(&03;" 3(& ( (4 #%A#": 8 & B@"; @ ( & "

'8( 3 ( (

(D+ 8( 4 73 ( 4

" "2A & 403;"'

( $!-"0 4 0 5" '8(7 " 4 "

3( ' "'

4 (& &45 '(4' #!5

= @( $% 4 ?"

'(4 4 (

45 "

4" "4( ( ( "

4" 44

@ 7 "

& . 4 44

(D "( ( 94 ( '& ' 4

53 ' $4 "'(4'4 B3( 44B@0-" 4( 44

53 '4 ' $"

""A- (

&' 3( B@ 0-G0-! 4 ( "(( (4 3 &$ '' 5

53 ' 3

/ 44( 4

4 "( . ( (( ( @ ' '

&(& 4 5 &((

5 3 7

,, (4 ( &+ ((

( 4(+( 4 (3(4 8 5( (&(34 !!G # '(4 9((& (- '& '

2 @ 4 '(4( 4 (&

8((: &

"( (

(3( &4 "( & 5(2 9 8 5 3(& #"(4 (- "( ( ( ' (&' " " 8 5( ( ( (

( (& 5 7@. & C3 4

( !=%!"#&'8+(!+& +4)'! 3 9& / ((" 4( C '

3 ' 3 (4("'(4& 3 (( 4 "(4( 4 4 "

4 ( (& ( ( ( < ( 3 '(4 5 4 7( 4( 4 7 "' (

( ( (&. 3@ ;4( 44 (& "( . ( (( (

(4((

( 4 "

53 '' #" ""A- &'( ( " & (& C4 443 4" (" &45 " ''

& "'(4( . (( ((& (< 9((& 3( & 7 '" 44 (&H ! 7 @((( 4 (

B@ (5

G 0 ( ((4 (

$ # ; 7 4 ( ( 4 !G

# # #

$ 2

" "" #"""

,, 0 #$ # #

! 2 $""$" #""" $ # #$!

# #

$! 2

$"!"$" #"""

$ 0I#A) # #! # %

2 #"%#" " #""" 0%

$ #

# #

! #2 $" "# " $"""

$ #

# #

# 2 "$" " $""" %

$ # % $ #

2 $"" "%"#"A-

#$ #

$2 #"$" #""" % !$ #%

$2# # "

"$% $"%""%$A- !

$ %

# #2

"%" $"%#"%%"

!$ #

2# %"

!" $$ $"%"$ "

! #%

$2 %"" $"#"$!

34 ' & '

53 4'

3 (& '#"""A- $"""A- ' 3 "#, "#

( (( B@0 '(4( # #% 5

" " (& 3 4 ( 4 "%"#"A- 4 ( (

@( ((( '( ( 43 $ 7 "

( (4 ( @4 #% #

=B@0 %?' (& $5 #

E$"%""%$A- ( ( "# #

=B@0 ?

,3, 3 "(4 ( ( @ $"%"$ " A- 7 % #

=B@0 ? '

(& (4 E$"%#"%%"

A- "('

"(( ( ( 4

. ( '9 (( ( 4 ( 3(& (( 4 4( 4

4 453(4 & (&(4 ( (4

'( ' C 4 4 (3

# 44 (&" C 4 (3 (4 ( & #" ""A- ( 3(& (# "'

5 3 '' 5E$"" "A- &'( (

$ " 4

-94( ' ' (

(&4(3( 4 (4 ( ('(4

" ( " 44 (&

77:9 ;3 I 5(&A 1 6 I 1 6