High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/22709/2024dismissed

Union Of India And Others v. No 775149 G Sgt Rajesh Jaswal (Retd) And Another

2024-12-13Mr. Justice Sureshwar Thakur,Mrs. Justice Sudeepti Sharma11 pages

!"#$$

!"!%"& !"$'$

() *+( ,,

, -

*+( , ,, , ( ! "#$ % &'

()(& (&'&* +,& -( . % &&+ (&'&* +,& *- .

////

, -

/ .

(!(( &0 *( ( 1 - &* &# - ( ! & - ( & 23 ..

5 1.

* & & "# ( 6 & '

, "&6 ,, *0( "#( ,6&'- .-( !&- &"6# 0&&660

0&1%020&34 !%"

.7 &, .3 .339 &-& -( &6(& 0& ,(&!

-' 0( -- ,-'

42.9 !( , -( *( , ( &"6 -:

% ;;

<23 2 82=

;

% <23 2 .1>= ?

( '

- ,(&!

*( &"6#0&& &@82= ,'

"#'

,&6"& -6-

( &"6# '

,6&'-( 0& ,

"#( )'

(#*(( ! (&( & &"6# 0& ( &"&"6 "

!&!!&+& "# -'6&#

6!&!! + ,-( ,6&'-( &"6# '

- ( &"6# "# ( &( * ( &6,&-6 .94.-424."

- ( 6 & '

, "&6 0(,( 0& - "# ( "&6 + &

( & *"

&660 *( &+ &-( & 5&, ( &-

" # $% & !# ! ' (

)* + ,

-* .

# (' !

/ /

!"#$

%&'

( >

6!&!! + -'( &- & && *"#( 6 & '

, "&6,, *(

1- &(&-6 ( &!&( &0 - () "5

!5167 !% 1

- ,

!'&C & -- ,+ & 7 ,& 0 *& -6&&, - '!0( ( -&66'

-&# +1D1+&#'

-( - 6* "("

! 66 ( &'#* &( &6&!

* ( "

,'! 6 * & & '

- ( ,'"&& -

&"6('

*&( ( &'

'&! , *# ( &

* ( 6'

( "

! ,&"6 "

( ,!

&6 "

! ,&"6 "

&!!&+& "

&"&"6 '6&# *(&,E *-'*( ,6 -(( 7 !'

F"6 5)*,& 6

&0 !

#'!

& -/ + , * 1 &

( +&&&!&(-( & + ,& 5&, ( &-

)*+

, ,

- . / 01

)' ,

3 4

5 6 +

*&)7+ 82##/

9:0 / 0+

# 4

; < ! =/0> / 0" /

/ *0 / ,0#

; =/ 0> /,0#

;=/0> /, 0#

;=/0>B

/, 0# @

2## 7C

/@ 0 ))D75 .C

6 7

& *

, :

4 , ,

,+ & !

- ( &"+ 5&, ,6 * (!( 6# ,6& *(&0( & &"6#"

&6 &#'

-( ,'"&& - &"6('

*& 0(,((

5 -42=+ *( *(!(&#,( &"6 '

+&6 -'( '#*"# ( &! ( -- &"6# *( &!'

- &"6# &# '

-( ,'"&& - &"6('

*0("

0(& &"6#&E&'-42=' *"'

&+ 6#

& ,6&&-'( % ,&6B& *&( ,& 6#,!(& & && &"6#"

!&"&"6 "

,'!&!!&+&

"# '6&#

( & ,6&& "

7 "# ( 5 6 +

*&)7+ ##/

9:0 ( ' *(!(( & '&! +1 D1+( (#,&6& '

&6( &6(-&#'

-( -

&"6('

,, * ,&66#0( &( &!

-("

,'!

66 *( , &"("

,'!"

0(&#

% + *(!(( ( &6&-( '* (&0( &# &( *(,," 6#*( "# & (& !- & !-&# *&( "

& 6-( ! &&'

- - &"6('

&+ 6#*( -+!(

E&"

- +1D1+( ,, *" '6# * & ,& * ( & '& 1 ,(&!

* *( ,6&'&"

6 + &"6#

% + *&66( -&,& ,,'&, & &( - ,, *& ,6 6#,I *(- ,6&!

0( ( -&# +1D1+( ,, *& 6E& -'6&# & J( &'

!&!!&+& "# !&"&"6 '6&#

.2 (&&'&#*( "

&6 -(&-( ,6

(&# ( ,&"

&6- &"6# ( ,, *"6#$

& ( '

-&,, &, -( ,, '6&# *'

,'! , % ,&6 B& +1&1+ ( "

! "

0( & 0(,( (0 + *"

,,6 # !('

#-( &( -*'&#&6" 6# ,,6 % ,&6B& *& -'

-'6&# "

!&"&"6 '6&# *&( ( &'

!&,!

( *-( '

,&6(6 (&( ,6 (&+

, '

,&6 5&'&-( ,, !

'& *(("

,'! 6 *( *( &'

066"

(&+ & ! *# ( &

* ( % ,&6 B& & ( & - ,,6 !

% + *&6 ,6& &*(&'& &#- % ,&6B& -660( ! 6 6& 0)(& 1-( K % ,&6 %6&#

*4224LK6 '

$ &6

,6 K

.8 ( - *(&"

0 ' 0( '- &"+ ,6 *0( &( '

- 6'

-( ( '#*(&- & 6'&#'

,&6 5&'& !'& +1&1+(( &6(*(& , &"'

!('& J0( '

& (& & 0&& '&&!

% + *&6

' *-'( -&,&(& *0( ( &,&&6 5 1 ( -( *& J( !( -*(

*(( 66'

-( &C!6&, * +1&1+( &,+ "#('-'6&# *0( "#*( )'&#,,6 (&( -( "&( 0&& -( ! ( '#& &,(0&&"&"6 &!!&+& "#( !'6&#

.A & * &6 "

!&( -' ( , *0( ( % ,&6B& * &66#,

'&C &

&6 ,+ &

&6 ,( ,C* &,6&6# & &! ( & + -( *(!( '6#'

- & -'

,&6 ,(E * ( + 6! ( "6,C ,(& !

, , ,* 0( -'*&( ( ,

% + *-( &

'6#'

-&6 6&6#*( "#'&#"

,,6 E&

( -*(" ( & 6'

&C!6&, * &( 0&,!

&6"0 ! -'6&# "

! &"&"6 "

,'! &!!&+& "#

-'&, - '6&#

)&6#* - ( & '6#

,(E &( &!

-& 6'

&C!6&, *("#( % ,&6B& ,, *6 & &,,6*(&( & &( '&, -&# *"# ( & '& ("!( 6'

-&# 6( &'#*&+#&-,

6&6#( " &,+ ,J ( -* !( , - -'6&# *"06 &&66#6 & &0 ,,6"#( % ,&6B& *(&&,+ ""

) , -' & -- ,+ ,&&6 !

, , , 0( "# ( 06 "

&6- &"6# .>

0 + *0( & &+*()

5&,!( , -( *&"

, '

,&6"& ( & !& *( & ,

% ,&6B& & 5&, ( &-

&"6# "&"6 !!&+&

"# , ,

&J)& J

,-,& , &

'&# #

*<23 ;

&, & + &, & &- # & - , ,

0( + && A8 - )(& - % %6

422H

#6 & '& ;

&"6# !

, ( &, & &C - ,( && -&#&,

, ,

*<23 .9

& !-( , + &6(&&( '

-( & 6'

&C!6&, &( '& '- ,6 ,6& F"6 5),& 6 & 0 !

#'!

& -/ + ,

1 !

2"#( % ,&6B& *(& '

0(,((0 + * -" ( * 6 ( '#* '&C 6'&# ! -* ,6&& - 6&0 7 !'

(& ( "# ( & ' (& ( ,! - ( & 0& & 6 - - * -&+&"6# 0 +1&1+( (!(( & ' "&"6 "(

& + " ( & ' "

,& (

0 + *( & ,& + & ,! ,(&!! +1&1+ ( * &( - ,!

6# "! ( & '*"&&66#&6 ,&& #&6( % ,&6B& * !&!

6-( &+- &(!*(!(

'6#'

-( & -"6,C,(&!

,,&&6, , ,(E

*0( "#'&#"

&+ (&( !-( ( &'# 6* "

, -' &

&6 !

,-&'6#(# % + *( "#0&&6 & ( '

,&6*(&( "-&0 66-'

&&( 0&&,!

&6 & "

( &!!&+& "# "

&"&"6 '6&#

0 + *& & !- * ,6 (&(&

, & # -'& &(&+

( 5

& 6#* , + " ( ' (&"

6 *( "#*() ,& !+ 0 !(&!

( -( '

,&6"& *&

5&,

),6#*( "#,

,&"

&! &66-'

&*"

( "#( !-( ,&"

& "

& 6-&

&6!

,-&'6#(#

)&6#* ,6& & -' -'6&#

& * ,6& &"&"6 ,'!&!!&+& "# -'6&# "# (

.H % + *(!(& ( (&(

,, 0(6 -'

- 6&( & &, & &*", ( 5 '& & ( +& !6&*0(,('&C ( !-(

& &, & &* "

&-( 6(&&,(*F ! & -'

-'6&# "

&!!&+& "# - '6&#

, *( 6&,C-( & 5 '& & ( !6&* ,&(),,6 *(& + -( ! - ( &

( ( ,, & &, & &*( "#*( & !& ,6& &!!&+& "# "

! &"&"6 - '6&#

.3 ( *, '-( 7 !'

)*,& 6 &4+ ,

-/ .

# (' !?

& 5

3 60( *& ,6&&'& ( 5 *(&( -- !--*&( (&"

0 ( ,,

6&6#&6( & - &"6 !("

+ ( -(

C!E&( & !--"

'& (-&+ + ( 0 , ( ,6&&-6&0'& + ,

'&C ( & ,6&&"

& 56&-6&0 '* "#*( 56&-6&0 '*&'& + , &6 '&C ( ( ,- -+1&1+( - ,, **

*&6 6 ( ,, *(&&#'

C( !&!-( 0'

&'& ( *& (&*

-66 ,'6 '

*& 6( *"

,+ -( "&*-&#*- 6&#& 6&,( 4.

( - * ( !&! - ( "

- - ( & !--* '-( + , "&6 ,, *&6 -- -'&#66 !&6#& (

7"02

!5167 !% 1

&- '&(*()- '

( 0 & 0(" +&&"+ *( &'

( '! * & & "# ( 6 & "&6 ,, *'&& & &--'

-&6!0(&66 !&6,& *-&#

, -

8, , (9 $'$ '&('& 6

037"4.

)

10;2

)