High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRFA/3267/2015disposed of

Ram Kanwar v. State Of Haryana & ORS

2015-11-27Mr. Justice Ramendra Jain4 pages

!" # !"#$ %%&''"( )* +((& $,""-(.&$* &*%"-&"(* /0 1 2/++ 2 $34&-5,0 +6+.$78"&&(+7"3.9 7'*4%(9 +"-&&%!('"-."-&$.* -89-8:(&*

$(.&'"-#"&$* /$5.7"*.7"9**7*("(-8:(&&"&$'9$," ;&*. 7"-' .7*$-&$#7''-7*%*& *

( 9 ( <9 ( 9< 9<=(< 9<<>>9< 9< =9< = 9>9 >9 <( <9>(> "(.&%%&'* 7'&-5,(.&'"-#"&$*9(.&,$&*&&?7"3 4$(.&$ &".":& &"( : %&"*(7" $(.&:@47$&-'"-

$7& ',9(.& :(* (.&:*&$&(.(87-&"(7 7:(7"-(&-

97**4&-4"-&$+&:(7"< (.&2"-:@47*7(7":(9>=<A $ *.$(91(.&:(1B9(.&+((& $,"9*43.((:@47$&== :$&*

'"-9*7(4(&-7"87''3&.;;$9

9&.*7'C 7*($7:(9.;;$ $ -&8&'% &"("-4(7'7*(7"(.&$& *$&*7-&"(7'"-: &$:7'+&:($ .;;$ .&* &#* ''#&-5,"(7 7:(7"-(&->

9 7**4&- 4"-&$+&:(7" (.&:(.&2"-:@47*7(7"''&:($A $*.$(91(.&

''&:($1B987-&#$--(&-

9**&**&-(.& $?&(8'4&

(.&:@47$&-'"-D 9

6E%&$:$& 7**(7* 7&-#7(.(.&#$-

(.&''&:($9(.&'"-#"&$* 7'&-5;&:(7"*9#.7:.#&$&$& &$$&-((.& '&$"&-$& &$&":&:4$(.&'&$"&-$& &$&":&:4$(-&(&$ 7"&-(.& $?&( 8'4& (.&:@47$&-'"- D 9 >9 <6E %&$:$& (7*(.7*#$- #.7:.7*7 %43"&-5,(.&'"-#"&$*5& $&(.7*:4$( 2&$"&-:4"*&' $(.&'"-#"&$**45 7((&-(.(:"*7-&$7"3 (.&':(7""-%(&"(7'7(, (.&'"-9(.&'&$"&-:4$(5&'#.* 7'&- (**&** 7$8'4&(.&$& .&*'&-&&-AF B9#.7:.#*%$( (.& :@47$&-'"-9.*5&&"(('',73"$&-)7-& $&*7-*'&-&&-9?"'* '"-#**'-("8&$3&%$7:& <9 9>

6E%&$:$&.& $&*7- *'&-&&-#*$&37*(&$&- $&(.""&,&$%$7$((.&:@47*7(7"9.&":&9 &8&"7":$&*& $(.&(7 &3%7*$&@47$&-(5&3$"(&-.&:7(,#* &F%"-7"3"(.7**7-&2( :"*($4:(7":(787(7&*.-*($(&-"7(7'',9 == :$&*#*"(7 7&-4"-&$+&:(7"< (.&:(9.#&8&$9 7"'', >

:$&* '"-#*:@47$&-&*( (.&'"-#*$&'&*&-"::4"( :"*($4:(7" '$&-, &F7*(7"3 #&8&$9 '&$"&- :4"*&' $ (.& '"-#"&$* 7$',*45 7((&-(.(':(7" (.&*'&-&&-AF B.*"( 5&&"%7"(&-4("",*7(&%'""(.&$&:$-& 4$(.&$*45 7((&-(.( (.&'&$"&-:4$(5&'#.* 7'&-(3$"(*((4($,5&"& 7(4"-&$+&:(7"

AEB (.&:("#$"3%$& 7*&(.(**&** &"( : %&"*(7"7*

$ (.&-(& #$-5,(.&''&:($ &$&',5&:4*&(.&%'7:, (.& +((&.- 7F&-(.($(& $(.&%4$%*& **&** &"( : %&"*(7""

*4%%$( .7*%'&9$&'7":&#*%':&-4%"7*.7'+7"3."-(.&$*8 /&&$4( &8&'% &"(4(.$7(,"-"(.&$9A

B+ GF&:4(78& "37"&&$9!$"(?4*7"3 $-82"-:@47*7(7"

7:&$9 "-(.&$*9A B + < "- /;&"!%7'/&.$"-(.&$*8 "7" "-7"-"(.&$9A B + "(.&(.&$."-9'&$"&-:4"*&' $(.&+((&*45 7((&-(.( (.&'"--&'(#7(.7"*'&-&&-AF B#*%4$:.*&-5,/6* .$( &($'&4 $%$(7" 2(- $: &$:7'%4$%*&.&'"-(.&$&7"7* ':(&-"&$ 4*+("-" :(9" 7$**&** &"( : %&"*(7"5,(.& '&$"&-& &$&":&4$(9(.&+((&&8&"-7-"(:.''&"3&(.&#$- "

:(9(.&$34 &"($7*&-5,'&$"&-:4"*&' $(.&'"-#"&$*(.((.&$& #*'( -&8&'% &"(:(787(7&*$:"*($4:(7"7"(.&$&.*"'&3*( *("--(.&$&5&&"*4:.*7(4(7"9(.&$&#4'-.8&5&&""4 5&$

*'&($"*:(7"**.#7"38'4& (.&'"-.&&"(7$&:@47$&-'"-((.& (7 & :@47*7(7"#*':(&-4(*7-&(.& 4"7:7%''7 7(*9.&":&97(7*"( :*& $&".":& &"( : %&"*(7" &$-'&$"&-:4"*&' $(.&%$(7&*"-%&$4*&-(.&$&'&8"( $& &$$&-$&:$- * $*(.&:@47$&-'"-7*:":&$"&-97(7*"(7"-7*%4(&(.( (.& * & 7* ':(&- 4(*7-& (.& 4"7:7%' '7 7(* ( #* :@47$&- $ -&8&'% &"(*+&:($ 9.;;$.43.$&'7":&#**43.((5&%':&- 5,(.&'"-#"&$*"*'&-&&-AF B954(7(*$&:7('*.#*7(#* %4$:.*&- 5,/6* .$( &($'&4 $%$(7" 2(- $ : &$:7'

%4$%*&* .&'&$"&-& &$&":&4$( $(.&%4$%*& **&** &"(

: %&"*(7" .- %':&- $&'7":& 4%" (.& %'7:7&* 7**4&- 5, (.& 8&$" &"( $ (7 &((7 & $3$"( 7"7 4 $(& $(.&:@47$&- '"-.& 7$*(%'7:,#*7**4&-" ><

%$87-7"3 $ 7"7 4 $(& D 9

6E%&$:$&7"(.&$&7"@4&*(7"9#.&$&(.&#$-.-5&&" ""4":&-5,(.&''&:($"$ (&$

.& $&*7-%'7:,#* $&87*&-.& $&*.%'7:,#*7**4&-" <

$&87*7"3(.&$(& $ 9

6E%&$:$&(

6E%&$:$&#&

.&'&$"&- & &$&":&4$(:"*7-&$7"3(.&(7 &3%7"(#%'7:7&*"-(7 &3% $ (.&-(& #$- $(.&'"-7"@4&*(7"93$"(&-%$%$(7"(&7":$&*&( (.&'"-#"&$*"-**&**&-(.&: %&"*(7"D9 >9 <6E%&$:$& * $*(.&:'7 '"-#"&$* $*((4($,5&"& 7(4"-&$ +&:(7" AB (.&:(7*:":&$"&-97" ,%7"7"9(.&:"(&"(7"7* &$7($74*.&**&** &"( : %&"*(7"7"(&$ * (.&%$87*7"*

(.&:(7*"(.&-(& 7**4":& "(7 7:(7"4"-&$+&:(7"< (.&:( .&%'7:, (.&+((&9"-45(97"7(*#7*- 9$&'(&-(.& 4"(

: %&"*(7"((.&-(& #$-$ (.(97(:""(5&(?&"(.( : %&"*(7" **&**&- $ :@47*7(7" '"- #* 7" 87'(7" (.& %$87*7"* (.&:(%$87-7"3 $**&** &"("(.&-(& 7**4":&

< "(7 7:(7"4"-&$+&:(7"< (.&:(.&+((&.- &$&', 7F&-(.&$(&*9 .&":&97" ,%7"7"97(#4'-5&4";4*(7 7&-(-&",(.&'"-#"&$*''(.& *((4($,5&"& 7(*7":'4-7"34"-&$+&:(7" AB (.&:("(.&%$& 7*& (.(: %&"*(7".*5&&"#$-&-((.&'"-#"&$* $ (.&-(&

#$- $(.&$&*"* &"(7"&-58&9#.7'&4%.'-7"3(.& 4"( : %&"*(7"#$-&-97" ,%7"7"9(.&'"-#"&$*$&&"(7('&-( *((4($,5&"& 7(4"-&$+&:(7" AB (.&:($-&$&-::$-7"3',.& #$- (.&'&$"&-& &$&":&4$(7* -7 7&-((.(&F(&"( .&%%&'*$&-7*%*&- ::$-7"3', A;&*. 7"-'B 4-3& 8& 5&$ 9 ?