High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/22009/2024disposed of

Union Of India v. No 723397f Ex Sgt Gurvinder Singh

2024-11-06Mr. Justice Sureshwar Thakur,Mrs. Justice Sudeepti Sharma11 pages

!"!

#$%&&

!! "#$%$ " $& '(

'$ ()'

* +

()'

* ** * ' )(*+, - ./ 0 1.2(34. 5 0'

- .3(')02(34..( - 7.+0 .2(34. 5 '( *

* +

%0 )0 0 . 9 '2 0 ' :

;6 0 5(.2'

.+ 5 0 ).

(50 ( (.( !:< ;2.

(*+0=.

( 1( 4

% *.=44 (290 04=.15 '( 5 ) .5( .*=+' 9.

.==9(

-. /01 -#2 '( 7((. 4 ! .5 .50.=0 )04

50 34204

(0 ( .*= 5

!"# "

"$ %

& '

" "( $ ) ) "

* +,+ !

$ .(9.

( 40.

)(5 1 34 >! >: ; ?)'=.4(=91(4.=4.) +209.

* )0*5 0(=+ 4 (=.

(-(4.=?.

( >! >9040.

( .*= 04

('@A.40.(41' .

1 9.

1.(@A5 =5 ! %0( .*=+=14=.150 '(9.

74( *+ 0 1' 0 +2 0 0 ) ( 0. 0 .

( .*= 9 0 . *.*= *) .)) .3.( *+

(51=.

34 '( '

.''.= &93 20 .(.''.=*)1*.

(9.

.(*+0 .0 44 ( B =).)) 3(2 '( 5=(2*5 0 =.

( 1( 4 % *.= 44 (2 90 0 4.

40.==)0.5 .( 74 ( %0 .(2*4.1 .==9(3( ( (.( !%0' .3'.

50 .( ( < .4(0 .5

"#$$ % &'( )*&+& , -&.

////// ////// ////// ////// ////// ////// ////// ////// ////// ////// ////// ////// '$

1 "

( 2

( (

'3 ( 5(

, 6&.

-&.

5 '7&$-&'(

1 "

- +'.

/""0 1 #

'&*'-*-&'3

(

89:

( , #.

;

< > =).)) 3(5 10.5 .( ( .

(' 0:

.;2*+0=.

( 1( 4 % *.=44 (20 ' 5(.0.

5=(0 .). 0 .9 ' *5 0 # # " 3!" -1 ?5 '

4()1./.5543.(7(4.' 0'

9 '2 . 5=.

.45 ( 1)900

0*5.==15.+( 3 C3 .+11* 50(54 '

=2*' 0 *) ==(0.

1+2( '.0.=

.)2'0 *41)= (2.

.11* 5041*.. (54 .*= 012 0 .1 1.)(4(2+0 .'' '20 ' = 104*)4 .*=* 0 4).= *)4 .*=*41.)) .3.( *) . *.*=1=.

3420 .4D (25 120'

4'= 5 007()1 ( (*+0&E*='< 24.

=( .

$- #/""01 2 ' (

'3 '4 %0 =3. '.

.) .'0 5 0 .( 3 (4 .

< .4( 0 .5

-+ =

5 (

5( >

5 5

5 5 *

-&.

5 5

A !

= ( '+#-B

= *::

! '7$

: 5

5 C!

8 !

'3 D

(

* =

5 5 5 (

5 C!

5 E

5 (

5 E

5 5 C'3 D

5 ( F

C'3 DH

: F

*::

F F

( -&&- J BA ?

B( 7(#

$& %(

( 5 5

< F 4 3 .():

;50.*3< .4('

4'= 0)0'(=+(4=.

20.90.( .*=+*41 .=(' .+11* 5041*..(54 .*= 012.(9040 0 < 5 A 3 2 0 '2 0)0 .+ 40 ( .*=( 11* (* 3.=(( 5 10 1+2*+ 0

(*.

)(0*55( .*=+'

20.

)15( .*=+' .+ 11* 5041*..(54 .*= 01290*41 .=( 90 . ( .*=+ . D.1 5 A 1 2 * 1' .3=+

. (4=.

. 5 1 0 -(4.= ?.

(2 4.((=+ 4)0.0 .(..(( .*=+*). *.*=

*41).)) .3.(*+1=.

34%0 .((4=.

.*41

7(*+0A !

= ( '+#-B

= *::

! '7$

1 20)00 .'

1' .

)( 5*K*50 ('0+ 4.=.(1.=0.=05.+11* 50 (54 .*= 0144 (2 '4.==+90.0 .)50

*41) ==(20 4 (.*0 *41)* 90.+( - 3 20)00 .= .5

1'2 0. 90 .+ ( . 0 2 0 44

* D=+2 0 0 .( 0.'') 5 ( .:

;

) 5.+( 2 *'

1(*. D=50

( ) 34 .

. 11* 5 0 (54 .*= 01 1' .3=+20 5 '

3)0(91 D.*5

.;5*K*5044 (2* (01'=+ 2.( 4.

20 .( 1. ( 40.

)(20 '204=.1. *41 =( 43( .*=+' - 3 2.==05.4

.( 4 41 .4 .(. 0 ( 5 34 *+ 0 44 (2.

*4= =+ G(20 5 (4=.

)900 5.+( 3 C3 044 (2 . D=D. (

5 1=.

34 .(6 0 .1 *) .)) .3.( *+ *) . *.*=1=.

?0..

1.+20 *41 .= 5 0.5

4'=:

;0.+0 4.*(.=5( .*=+' 0 44 (2*=+', .;015.44'.45044 (1=.

342 1) *41) 4 ((*+0-(4.= ?.

( 3 .3 0 *) * 90 . ( 9040 093 2*41 44=((*+ ( )01 5*41= ( *; + 5 ( . 0 5 2 1.+ .=

* D=+*4144=((*+0-(4.=?.

(2 .

5 1 ( 5 1=.

+ 34 *) . *.*=1=.

342 0 .1*).

4).=(

2501(4.='0=( 0.0( 4=( 0.3*(4(1(4.=<.1.5044 (*) 1.(20 '

0 *41)= ( 3420 ' 20

.19==*(1(0.3.

( ) 342+0

.;20-(4.=?.

( ( .0 5

44=()

! - 3 2 .= (4=.

( .20. 1.(. 5 0-(4.=?.

(5==90)(= =.((90.' 50H$(-(4.=:-=.

+ ;2IH"=1, $ .= 4'= H

%0 5 20.

*9( 1(900 5 0.*3'

4'= 2900 .015= 150'

'(0 1+20 .5 .'

=1.

+1(4.=<.1. *)1.( 5**5 0.=020 .*4.1 4 ((.*

1( * )01.(6 900 1*4.1.''(( 0.0 .(( 9.

.( 1. .)- 3 2 .=

(*( 1(25 105.4 .0.(2900 .

.=< 0 '50( 2.(6 0 )

5 20 '

20 ' 0 ==150'

'( ./) '=.42 5**5 0 .43 ( *+ 01 5 1=.

34290 20 1.+44=(0.0 5 0( * 9.

. D=50 ( ) 340 1+ .(.

409.

. *.*= *4.1.)) .3.(*+0 ( ) 1=.

B .((2 .= (*).0 (5 10

4 ( 2900 0-(4.=?.

(2((.==+'

4(1./.

(.=(4 3.4(.=404/2'.

4=.

=+.'' .)0 .(350( 20 )01'=+1 5.5 1(4.= 40D 2 0 3=) 0 *=4/ 40. )4 442 90 5 1 2 0( *4.1 4(- 3 250 .(

1'=+15.= =.=+20 1.+*4144=((D.

' 520 * D0.'' = 1./) '=.42 9.

4).=*9( ) (5 1=.

34* ( *). *.*= *41).)) .3.( *+' 5 1.451=.

34 .

=+250 .1'=+( 40D .0 .)5.'' = 1./)'=.420 *+0 -(4.=?.

(44 (2=.( .44= 20.0 .

( 1.4(4 5.+( 2*+0 .(( 1.( 0*)0= 15.+'

=0.

1+2.3+ .

5 4 =.=+0 * D.43(46 '0 5 ( )04

5 (51=.

342*9=(. .==+ =.(.9==44= *+0-(4.=?.

(20. .43 ' * *4.1 4( 5 1 . 5543 4.

.= )4 44 90 9=(*(.=5( .*=+'

> &93 290 .((.3 20 ( *< .4)0'501(4.=*.

(0 .( ).

(2 '.

.:.;50 '=+5=(*+0('.

10.5 .(2

< .4(0 .5 , 3

A*= %

E=LAE :=4 ! F

$6 %( =4 5 =4F"4*' ' F -&'

(

=3I3

:@*

M :@* = !

M 9 0

5 5 ! ?

@*'N- 5 2

'3 O -&&# '7 F '++6 5

M , -&.

:@*= !

M 9

, -&.

,3&.

@ P 0 !FG 5 @ F9"

( 0Q %= ( :=4 '7 F -&'<

.()50 4 ( 3.= 0..0150 .'' = 1./)'=.4 *4.11.(

50'

4'= :

.;(4=.

(*+0&E*='< 4.

=(.

$- #/""01 #5

*+0-(4.= ?.

(20. 1( 9040093 2((5 *(0'

'(2*41= (0 1+2((1./ '

=1.

) 5 2 0 (4=.

. 5 =.9 7()1 :

.; 0. .'

1'0.04

)50 .(( 9.

. D=5 (5 342 (*5.3 .*=+ (9(3 .3 0 '(%0)0 0 .( '

*.*=*0 =.(3(4 *0 .('

1' *4.1 4.

' 0 ' &93 2 0 .( 4.

3(4 .((4)( 40.

)) 3 .3 0 '(2 5 4)=+

*)0 .('

1'2*. .==+.= ((4.

(+.= '0-(4.=?.

(2).) =50(.3 5 .

0)2 0 )0 1'=+1 5 0 . 5 *=4/ 40. )4 4.

.= 44 40D:

;2 90 1.+ *4.1 .3=(0.0 )50( 0.

1+'

=2 *4.1 4(5 1.4(.=)45.1=+0 +- 3 9.

.= (* .(01(4.='20. 0( *5 .9==5 1( 9.

.4).=(

.(*4.10 .)) .3.(*+ *4.1. *.*=1=.

F &93 2. .()5':

.;2( 4= 0.0.

* 4 ((. +'(5 1.( 0.3* 4 (( 0 < :

.; .(=+2 4 3(4 * 0 1':

.;0.

*=(*+0' 20 20 4 .()39)0.)0'501(4.=*. (2 .

< .4( :

.; '4 =+2 0 4 (4 4. * .

)(0 .==5 1( 2* ( 0 ) 50( 4.* .(*. D=5.4(.=)4 5.1=+0 + .

=+2 (*(4=.

5 1

(51=.

34.((2 (*(4=.

( *. *.*= *41).)) .3.(*+ (51=.

34 *+0'

2 4 507()1 ( (*+0 '< 24.

=(.

6/""01 #

'+ '34' 90 2.(4=.

. 1.(0 <20.0*55 ()552 0.

*41(9( 044 ( =.=+.= 0 (

.(5.

*= )0 *4.1 3 ( 0 '

'( 5 0 /) D. 0 .'' () 55*)1.(0 5.3 "3 0 9 4 0 (4=.

. 5 =.9 1.( 3 (4:

.;1./ 0 .((4=.

.*.<' =.5=.9 120 20<' =.5=.9 12.

1.(3 (4 :

.;.= 1./ 00 (

(*5 3 .3 0 (54 '

= 44 (2 2 2 .= = 0

44 (20 ..+1 /0) .)50(91 .

1.(0 (

2.(0.205== 41'=12.

'= (

2* (

'4350*.

25.+25(=.+.(=.40 %0 5 2 0 ) .) 5 0 *5 5 0 .''

() 552 503 (4:

.; ( (*+0% *.= 44 (2.= ( 55 5 1.+==).=+.( (* '0=(

!#. 12 1 3!" -1 .5 1.020 5( 1 09 ' .(90* 3. .*320 .1 ( 1

( ! %01')( ( 2.

(*+0=.

(% *.= 44 (2 1..(.(.55 1( ' (5.=)90.=='().''=4.:

;25.+ 4*

* +

4* * '5 %&& JK 00 './)6 ( , L 00 ' .*= , L