High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/27498/2019dismissed

Lallan Rai v. The Presiding Officer, Industrial Tribunal-Cum-Labour Court-1, Gurgaon And Another

2019-09-25Mr. Justice B.S. Walia7 pages

! "# $ %

& '! "(! )!*)(! !)'& +!$ #

, !" # $%!% -.!* #&/0 #, 111 # $%!%& & 2 # 3 , # ! 3 4!#$3/5!6 7 &,(2#

$ %

& '! "(! )!*)(! !)'& +!!$* 8# 9# "(! :; !# # ! 3 -*! $, #,3# !

(<3$3 = # $# $ #3 , # # , * # # 3 3<$ 3# # ,)*,2 >7

& # , %, (! # 03

2* *30 (2 #* # ,)*,2 0!

2 # ( ,$ ! ( # "(! & 3 /5! 6 &3,$#,&#30&#3, (< 3$ ?30& & 0 # , 3 $ *(2,3 3#!2

@A 7 ' , 2& # *$* < !, # , # # 3<* B 2

&#, # ,#,!

,!! ( # "(! & !

2& 5), 3 3 , $ # , , *, *$ # (0 3&,(<3$#,B!27 3<

"# & 3<* ($ * !2#33 3#!2*#,) *,2 !*( 3 ! # , 3<* 4!$#*B!2(!#,63<*B!2& # & # ,63<* # #*

( 0 (2 *$( *!2#3&#3 2

%#, $ #,&

3$!3 * (2#"(! ) ###0 3<*3

2*C '

&3# &# C% ### *( #, * C%- 7 "#"(! (2<$!

, #*& # # * 2 # , 3 3<$ 3# # ,) *,2 "# *$* # * # # 3<* # #*

( *!2 * 3&3#!,$ 3<*:( *!2D5 6 &D5 6D5 63 # 3<* # #!$# $ ,& 0 , , D5 6 & D5 6 D5 67 % # (& # "(! # # $ # 3<* B !2

@7A *! #0 ( 0 (2 #* #0$ ( # ?30& # 3<* !* !2 , ($ 0 # $"#"(! !#<!#302 *,#3#.!*8 ;&

/ (! **& 3# ,! 8D5-) -); $ # ,$ (3 # ,#* 20 ##,6*$*#

< # 3<* (< !2 (! # 3<* ! !*!2(2, $## ##3!

(,#2

2< #, #!2"#"(! # ## * # 3<* ( # !2 !# * *, 2 # # 3<*#B!23##,)*$* ( # 3<* # 2 0 # # 3 ,, (2 # , * , *$ # ! ? # ,!20,0##0#(*(2# , , 0$ # $ 4!$ # , B (< !2 # # , ( # /!# !$B!2& 20 #3# ,3##*

(0#!* ( # *, # # 0 # ( * (2 # , E * 2& ! 3 3 $ # 3<* 0! #*$* 3B >

$#!(**( #"(! & ! #,,2 $ #*,!$3 * # , 3# !

(< 3$ % 4!2&

! ,!# 2#

$$3

@ A /5!6 7 &03, &5, <$!,#, ##-$ ,6*,2*# ,!,*+!$!#*##3! 2

*,*#*3##%36-$$ # *,2 * # , ?30& # # ,!( 0( !3#2 ,(!# #&( #/**)!*) /!## ,)*$*

<(<#3<*!2(!# 3<* ,

2 ! B !2 (2 , $ # # ,#2 #*## #*$*3# ###& 02$##$0 !* #B # & # , 3!

2 *,* # * 3# # *$* $ #* , 2 #(2 !

$ 2 #

$$#3F #,5, # 2#$ 5, 0!, 2# $# #, (0&( 0( "#!&, *# # (* 0& # * # # , #

$3 7 , *#2> *#"#,#0$ B!2,#0$(! #$#

#0$( * (2 # ,6*$* ( # / **) !*) %

& < (< # , !2 # ,#0$ !B!2& ##,# B0#**!(* 0 "# &#34!*!$! *4!2 $ 2 # * , B #

@A 5(*# =#%'%#!() * !+!( !"&+ !%! %,"

-,.% & (% %+ % ) /012 345 # 641 0 5 # * ,!!) G"#(!!# $ $ # 3<* #0$ 0 # 3 ' # $& 0 #! D5#( -6 D5#( -6 #(0#*,!$33## 3 3 , **! (2 $ , #3<*

$!,#*B! 2#, ( ,(< !2"##3 $0 H, #0 *& !$#& +!$H "# 3<*&3# ,,$&#*#) 5* # !# 3 / , D5#( -63 !0$ ! ' # $# !,, 0##(!! # !##3<*#(0 3 * "# !& 5 !,02 B!& 3!

$ # 4! 4!2!

2 0"# $0(2 #(!!!

*2 *2 > "# 3!

( ,! 3# # ,, # # -$*6*, 2( <$<

# * *, 2 *

! ( * !2!#F$%3!

#0*, 23##

@>A ,, ! B!'# #,&# -$*)*,2 # ! 3 , **! #!$# $ "# 3 ,!0

! 0$ #0#( (#

#,) 3<**25, #0$(

3# $ ( * !2 *, #0$ ( * B (< !2 E !# !*& # (#

# , # 3!

( *,0!$!

*4!2##$ ( * !2 3#! * B "# ,, ! B!3!

(<*, 3# ! # *, 2 #0$

!, $ ,,!2#3<*B! 2( , (<!2I ' # $# # , (0& # , #

,0 ( * ! # ,)3<*# 20 (2#3<* #325, #0$(

3#$( *!2 *,#0$(*B(<!2'!#!*& #!(*(#

#,#$!

*4!2 3!##$ ( *!23#!* B"#,, ! B!3!

(<*, 3# ! #*, 2#0$

!,$,,!2 #3<*$05, 3

B!2'# # $ #3 # 3 (* 0

@ A $ 2 $(2#"(! B$# 3 2 "# 3 , ( * $ 2 * * ?30& # #

( 3 # $%!%5 +( /2 /017 B#<<#! ##,<$6 J6 ##,( J6