High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/7104/2017allowed

Akbari & Others v. Hari Charan @ Hari Kumar And ORS

2019-05-10Mr. Justice Avneesh Jhingan4 pages

!! " # $ !# %& '

!"! #$%$&'

#($')&*)+#,-./)'$ #

#%(0%(1+'),-./)'$ #'($)++$22)&'%

#"03)%!0&4(,-./)'$ #

#5(06)&71!0&4(,-./)'$ ##$%+&-$&'% )&-

#)(12)'()&0),-./)'$

#*)+#,-./)'$ #'($&%1#)&/$6+)&7 ())#*#+,-*. !/ ($ )8)#- -)'$-

9 +)%%$- 57 '($ '# //0-$&'

2)06%#051&)2, $8)':

#%(#','($#051&)2;()%5$$&)%%)02$-57'($ +)#$&'% )&- %0%'$# )<06 :-$/$)%$-; %$$30&4 $&()&/$6$&'

/6+$&%)'0&)8)#-$-1&-$#!$/'0& == '($ '#"$(0/2$%/', >??

#%(#','($/'; ($#$%+&-$&'%0&'($)++$)2)#$'($-#0.$# '#1/35$)#0&4 #$40%'#)'0&@AAB@ >= :($#$0&) '$##$ $##$-')%'($

$&-0&4 .$(0/2$;,8&$#)&-'($0&%1#$#:0$($$8&-0)%%1#)&/$6+)&7 060'$-; '($

$&-0&4.$(0/2$ ($0%%1$%)#0%0&40& '($+#$%$&')++$)2)#$'()'& 1'1#$ +#%+$/'% ().$ 5$$& )8)#-$- )&- '($ )61&'% )8)#-$- 1&-$# '($

/&.$&'0&)2($)-%5$6)-$)%+$#'($-$/0%0& '($!1+#$6$1#'0& !+& $ 01"2 0 -+'

$ ($ )/'16 )//0-$&'0%&'-0%+1'$-57'($+)#'0$%6'# .$(0/12)#)//0-$&''3+2)/$& =A =($)//0-$&'+#.$- )')2 )<06 ($ )//0-$&' 8)% #$%12' #)%( )&- &$4204$&' -#0.0&4 '($

$&-0&4.$(0/2$($0&%1#$# '($

$&-0&4.$(0/2$8)%($2-20)52$' +)7'($/6+$&%)'0& &'($/2)06+$'0'0&,0'8)%+2$)-$-'()''($-$/$)%$-8)%) 60236)&)&-8)%$)#&0&4 ,

C@+$#6&'(($/2)06)&'% )02$-' +#.$'($//1+)'0&)&-$)#&0&4 '($-$/$)%$-($#051&)2)%%$%%$-(0% 6&'(27$)#&0&4)%?,

C@,D-$-1/'0& #%$2 @$E+$&%$%8)%6)-$)%($ 8)%)5)/($2#)&-612'0+20$# ?8)%)++20$-/&%0-$#0&4'($)4$ '($ -$/$)%$-)% ?7$)#%%16 ,?>,

C@8)%)8)#-$-)2&480'( 0&'$#$%'FAG+$#)&&160 '($)61&'0%+)0-80'(0&9 -)7%)&-0& -$ )12'F>G+$#)&&16($)61&')8)#-$-0&/21-$- A,

C@'8)#-%

1&$#)2$E+$&%$%)&- ,

C@$)/( #2%% $%')'$,2%% 2.$)&- )

$/'0&)&-2%% $E+$/')'0& 20 $ '($-$/$)%$- $)#-2$)#&$-/1&%$2 #'($+)#'0$%)&-+$#1%$-'($#$2$.)&'

-/16$&'%+#-1/$-57'($6 $)#&$- /1&%$2 #'($ )++$22)&'% /&'$&-% '()' & 1'1#$ +#%+$/'%().$5$$&)8)#-$-'($#0%%1$()%5$$&#)0%$- $)#&$-/1&%$2 #'($0&%1#$# /&'$&-%'()''($)61&'% 1&-$#'($/&.$&'0&)2($)-%5$)8)#-$-)%+$#-$/0%0& '($!1+#$6$ 1#'0&2 03.& /)&-&)61&'5$)8)#-$- #2%%

2.$)&-)

$/'0&)&-'8)#-%2%% $E+$/')'0& 20 $

9 ).0&4-1$#$4)#-''($-$/0%0&% '($!1+#$6$1#'0& 0 3 .& / )&- # '4 " ! +& $ 01- 5.

/21' )%'($-$/$)%$-8)%5$28

7$)#%)&-

$220&'($/)'$4#7 %$2 $6+27$-#+$#%&().0&4 0E$-8)4$%,

1'1#$ +#%+$/'% )#$ )8)#-$- % '($#$ 0% & /()22$&4$ ' '($ 2%%

-$+$&-$&/70$ ?,= ,

C@/)2/12)'$-57'($#051&)2,

G '($%)0- )61&'0$9, A,=

C@0%)8)#-$-'8)#-% 1'1#$+#%+$/'% % '($ H1)&'16 /6+$&%)'0& 0% 5$0&4 #$@.0%0'$-, '($ )61&'%)8)#-$-1&-$#'($/&.$&'0&)2($)-%)#$6)-$0&/&%&)&/$ 80'('($-$/0%0& '($!1+#$6$1#'0&2 03.& / ($/2)06)&'%)#$)8)#-$- A,

C@$)/( # 1&$#)2$E+$&%$%)&- #2%% $%')'$ )61&' 0% )8)#-$- # 2%% 2.$ )&- )

$/'0& )&- $E+$/')'0& 20 $ ($&$'#$%12'0%'()''($)61&')8)#-$-57'($#051&)20% $&()&/$-57A ,=

C@ ($ #051&)2 $##$- 0& )8)#-0&4 /&-0'0&)2 0&'$#$%' ($ !1+#$6$1#'0&!+& $1(%"6& .

/ $$7 ,($2-)%1&-$# @ I(14(!$/'0& '($/':/##$%+&-0&4' !$/'0& '($$8/';/& $#%)-0%/#$'0&&'($ #051&)2 ' )8)#- 0&'$#$%', '($ %)6$ 0% 6$)&' ' 5$ $E$#/0%$-0&/)%$%8($#$'($/2)06)&'/)&/2)06'($%)6$ )%)6)''$# #04('&'($)5.$5)/34#1&-,0'0%'5$ J1-4$-8($'($#)%'0+12)'0& #(04($##)'$ 0&'$#$%'0& /)%$ -$ )12'/)&5$06+%$-57'($#051&)2&/$'($ -0%/#$'0&()%5$$&$E$#/0%$-57'($#051&)2')8)#-

%06+2$0&'$#$%'&'($)61&' /6+$&%)'0&'5$ )8)#-$-)')+)#'0/12)##)'$)&- #6)+)#'0/12)#-)'$, '($#$ 0% & %/+$ # #$'#%+$/'0.$ $&()&/$6$&' -$ )12' 0& +)76$&' /6+$&%)'0& $E+#$%% # 06+20$-+8$#0&'(0%#$4)#- /)& 5$/122$- 1' #6 !$/'0& '($/'#!$/'0& '($&$8/' !1/( ) -0#$/'0& 0& '($ )8)#- # #$'#%+$/'0.$ $&()&/$6$&' 0&'$#$%' #-$ )12'0&+)76$&' '($ /6+$&%)'0& '4$'($# 80'( 0&'$#$%' +)7)52$ '($#$& .0#'1)227)61&'%'06+%0'0& +$&)2'78(0/(0%&'

%')'1'#027 $&.0%)4$- )&- +#$%/#05$- ' 0%, '($#$ #$ -0#$/'$-'()''($#)'$ 0&'$#$%')%)8)#-$-57'($04( 1#'%()22)2&$5$)++20/)52$'022+)76$&',80'(1''($ %'0+12)'0& #(04($##)'$ 0&'$#$%'5$0&4$& #/$-,0& '($6)&&$#-0#$/'$-57'($#051&)2K ($/2)06)&'%%()225$$&'0'2$-''($$&()&/$-)61&')2&4 80'(0&'$#$%'FAG+$#)&&16&'($$&'0#$)61&' #6'($-)'$ 020&4 '($/2)06+$'0'0&'0220'%#$)20%)'0& ($)++$)20%)228$-0&'($) #$%)0-'$#6% .())#*#+,/ *8,)

A > B($'($#%+$)30&4C#$)%&$-

$%C B($'($##$+#')52$

$%C