← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/24882/2021disposed of

Ajit Nagar v. Pt. B.D. Sharma University Of Health Sciences, Rohtak And Others

2025-05-15The Chief Justice,Mr. Justice Sumeet Goel13 pages





 

  

  



 



  !

$%& '( )&*+,+'-

.# .#

.

    23    

 

  

  )  

 " #   

 " #   

 

  



 

  45    +  

) 4  +  +  -# 2"

 ) !6

. 4)

   ) 789   ,       ) :  

 



! ;   *) )#((93((:

:  " #  $

        %#     

 &'!!('( (!) *) (- <# >!7.*)    ) +#  ) ) *    ) )+*         , # -          .

.

+  %#/  0*1-  

  )   #  ==; , ('(!  ( >      #  <    #*  # 

-.

 ;)

$#4    



- ) (>.(&'

'6('!!#* )  4 0 0 -. ;    =<   -  

 . # 3 *# # ==;> ,>('(!#  

('(! -. ; ) #    %#

   ) > )  (++    #  (('&('

'(!

#*    )#            )  +#   ) + +#*)   -. ; )

 *  )   *  )#   +    

    " @  -"@ @ > (&?6&>('

(!.*"#+  *)*+  +

(?!!('(!                    !       ! "        # #            $%&$$&'('$ )* + ,2 2$(  ! "       3      !     -   . ,/ '('$&

     

   &$   '  !      $%&$$&'('$) )* +,2$(           +  "   "            !!  

 

  !!"& 0 1 ! !

! "       

&$ '     & 0  !

!  !   

     "      1       

/        &$   '            -"  !!

"

"&4 -. $ )    *    ) ( )  )

 &'!!('(!  !

   +   #   0  !

     5  5     '6&$$&'('$ 7, &'8698 '('$   #  

             $%&$$&'

('$ 1  "     "          !

 " !

!

  3    :&*3 ;

     . ,/2'('$   1     ,/ 1   !    " !           &4 -. ;  ) )) ) "#*+  

   ++  + ) (&!(('(!       

   );2$6@(827,2'('$

 '<&($&'(''&

    

 A     (<&$(&'($<)* +,2'( >  ,& &:& -! = 1"

"   5 -  >#  !!     

      &  -  

  ! !          2 &.!     "  &  5        1       

&$ '

     ! ! 

  1 "

        '?&$'&'

'('$&4 -. $ # *  ) )       #)    

 "#

+0$1 23

 34+,,+'-,

& A #)   # !

     * )  )     #)      "  

# ('

!9+  )) * )



 *      4  =# #  )   

         



 #  -    .A # #  )    * +   +  ) (    #*  )   4  0   (&'6('

'!!    )  )*      #-. +#  # *## )>+ <))   ) )##    &A # #  #  ))   )##

 # * # 

) *#          )   *  ) >* + )  !

   A  #   #  )   )##      )  *  "#   (&!(('(!

  )  )          +# *  ##  )   +  +   )   *         )##

)   (:'6('(6 0      #* *              6    +  #  +  )  < ) )  :>    ))   # # )



 #

.    ) :> >    *      )  :  )    -.

         "#)      ':'7('(7  #  6! +) * * ) !

! 6;   

)  #  $& .  # !!!

!6!   1 3  

    &.    17,  

&'

'8698 '('$    !

 *"

"&& B       1"  1   ''&(8&'('$  

  !   !  

  .,/2'('$  

      1         ,/    1      !    "!

!            

&.    -   ;

; 5>#

    & . -   ; 5>#     &./1 !

!     1" 1   $6&$'

'&'($9   

 #  A  A    - 0    ;  5 5 ># !"      A 

AC " ! A     1"& '& . 5;-    

           

  !

" -0  ; 5>#      , && :& -! =5- > #   5;-   

     :     5  ! 5" &.      7, &'?'?@ '($% !*,       5;- :   !                 "&4 

 #*   +)  #   )  (  6          $#  4     >  # +  ))    )## #    # *    +  # 

   %#    $    * 

#     ) -. + +



7

+)# 

      

+#*   6( ) *# * ) 7

 9A  # ))  )  7 9 #   )    )  ) ) !  6  !

      * )  *      $#  4    > ) (-. 0 #*          #  7 @   #  ))  

 ) )# 5+4& ,, ,2&

9 ;)#           +)# ) )!

  



+  ) #*    ) *    )+* 

 %# *%#  -$16,+, :

 )     #)     )

)  

 ## $ #*+  #   )  )            (&!(('

'(! )  *   "#   %#

 +  #   )  +        )

 ) )    # 

++

8

#*(:!( ('(!

*#+ #               # ## )     (:'6('( (6 :!   ##   +# * ))      #  ) *"#

   !"  #

     

            

  $%&  +

#  8& 7   !       #       "!!  

1      "!

   &&;-&.    3    !    1 )    "!

              1 &*D   5 - !       '

'  (   )' ! * #   "  *  +,-./0-1#12 20-*3.F G 9& +++++++++++++&E  3    "1& 1& ! !    -  !! !    &0   3     ! 3+    

 &"

    !

!   ! 3  &0      !    ! !

 

  !    !      "    

      #   1  "    !"&"

"3           1    "11 !

!   322 3         )3! &   !

 "!    #        &0     + +   !      3&>        1      

         !"& 7 

!        !#     !

!" ! " "3 !   "  "

" 

      ! "!

! #   C    1    1 !             1 1      " "&++++++++ EE1D ++++++4   5 - !       4 #

 ! #    +,-  0-1 1#1 20-* .    !  !        

  G 8$& >    &$3  ! "$6%<2 2%@& *! $< " 1  " & 7      " !

 !"    &0 1 1    !   "H    *!  & 5!      !

  ! &

  -.    1 3  !   "! 1      &$&0  "  #       &$!"  1 1   " !  ! "

""    &+++++++++++ +++4 9& *   1         "!

;- -     !  

  "&.    "    !    1     #  " 

 &  .     &'  !   

        1    !       "  7,2$%$%?2'($@I     " 1  )    &'  !

  2 2   "&  *  3    " )  "        A!      ""&0   1"       !      

    1  !

  ; - F1 -"   1 1)              2   !    1  C&0       !

  "   !  F  1"

         #         &0     1 1 

   

&'F             &  0       

9  1 -"  "!         & 4 :( B#    #     8

 9' !   4 '56   

7.

./ "#  # 0  !F"

"    !

"   1 2  &     "      3&E* "     1   1"&.!J"J 

!  >!  ! J J        "  !     & .   3     5         * ''@A''

?         0        3  +   !   "       3          

 !& .    +   + " 3    !"   !           3   1 !   3 1          ! !" 

 1  

 &.  " 1!

"

  !  3  1     1        !& "     !#    !  1     !     

       &.     !      

! "    3&7 "   "   

   "       1       1" 

 " !

!     1      3     "         &E!    ! 

   !        3 1   3    & .    3 !     !   " 1 1   

  !    &. !        #    !!!        +       " !    

    1  31    "

   &D 1                    

!

      !          &.!+!  ! !1 )     3  

  !

1    "         !

" !     13&*

        !            3& .       "        3  1    1 1 !

      !      3 1 " !#&   +  3  !    )       1 !        "     !      !             & .   !   ! #   "

2  1   1   1 3& 0    

      "        1 !           3      !& .  3  !

!        !     3       + +  3"   "   !&4 :& "    )##      

 (&!(('( (! ) *"#C +)   )  ) )    #         *# +         ## # )    C"#  +#*   ##

%# * #   #     

 $ )   #    "# )    #) 

# ) *"#  

9' ! 4 '56 

7/7$%&:  + # > 0 

3           

  !

      1   3  "&  7  ! " 

 3          #      KK   

! 1      "!   KK !"      !

!"3 

 &0     "            !!

  3   "   !  "    &0    !+! !" '

 '   

   6  ! !   !

 &.1           "

 

 " &7  3   1    "             " "  

"

    3"       1    

 1 & . 

 "     !   "   1   KK   ! "    3     !

"  3"!        !   KK

     3 &  0

    "! " 

  !   !

1      !    !        1            !& . !  1 !   3             

"       "    !&  .     !" 1  1       & 0 "2     1    "           !     &.  " "1 1 !  3     !   !        

   3      

      !

&0  "         " 



" " "   "      3           ! &  .       !  "

"    !  K KK  1 !

! 3 KK        "  ! " "    3"&.     "5 - !    ; 

)     !   

 3  &. " !

1   !  !    !    "

"     # 

 ! !  !2  1 !    & D  )#    !

    #* *      )  ( *) )  #          *# +   )#            ) +#    ) *    )+*   4#+

 +!

  ) &'!!('(!

 #* 

 # )-. 

) )  )     )        & 

>

  +  +

)) 1*#) "# #  *    " !       !  !    

1  3& "       

 3    !

  3  &   1 11 

 !" 

  !  1    3 & 7 1   

       &4  " )#  #   <      +  ))) %# !

  8)  ()

 )

     + + 

  

# #*%# # ) -. &*+,+'- ? $+)           ) +   -. ; )  )     *   )## 

(&!(('(! ) 

 "#

/      *  #  EC  !

  

 &'!!('( (!) *) ( > 8) ( (  )  )

    + + + 67

   )3)#    )   # 



 %# ))#        )  * 

   

#  # 

#  # #*     #  )-.+ 

) ) )## &'!!('(!

+ !

 + )   -. ;                 *  )   *) #   )# 

 #   # # -.   

 !7 *3"

 !





 !

  

('(7 @)

 3  F @) *  F