Satpal v. Suman And Others
! "#$%&$%'#(
! "')'*$%'+( ,-.
! "#$%&$%'#( ! "')'*$%'+( !"# $ %&'( %
/
0 1 )"*+ , "-.
012
)"-.
01 , "*+2
21
'%+$%'#
3 !34-30 '% %%%5
0 0
0
1 60
-
1 7 ! "#$%&$%'#
.
0
'* $' $$ 6
'*89 : ; <= !3 4 -
- 1
0 ( > 1 0>
0 ?
#8$%%9- 6
/ 30
00
3
( 31 1 ( > ( $9''$%'% . '&3 0
3 3 1
>'(/
!3 4 -
- 1
1 1 0- 1
03@
0 1
3 9% %%%5 1
3 @
0
5
.
3 3 3
0
0
>'
0
1 3A 6 1 3
0
3
>' 1 1
0 3 3 .
0 1 1 $$'$$%'% !
3$%''
1
3 B
4 -0 0 0
0 A
03$8%%5
0
3
>'. 3 1
0- 1
03@
3 $8 %%%5 1 3 6
3
3 "
4 3
/ 4 0
1
' 3 1
4
)3+41 , #1 /1
-12
00 0 1
C 3 0/ 4 0 $%'# 7
)%- 4 -
1 0
>' 0
1
- 1 0
0
'% %%%5 1
11
1
21
3 !34- '%+$%'#
1 1
21
0
4 0 0 1
00 0
>'(3
- 1
'* '(
'* $( 3 1
4
3+41 "-*1.
0 00 0
'* 3
3 3
0 1 0
3 0
C 3 .
1
4
),.+4
540 6+ ,
,+4
0740 6+ 012
4
)"- 01 , 681 9+
012
@ D
61 4
) .
61/ "0 ,
6- :2
@ D
4
)%+ , 6+ " ;02
!
.
0
'* 0
" #
&% '( ) ')% *+$%,-
)- .
) (% )+%$+%, / ,, !%(',% ', ($%, $+% &'//% &%/% $ '( $+ 0 &$0+
!%% %$'!%/
% ($%, $+% % $+ '( +%, +0!
!1 +%, ( $+%,-
)
,'
% $'$+%%2$% $$+ $0+% 0 % $'/
+%,0% ('$'(+%,') % ,
*0 ', '$+%, 3,'3%,$1 ', )+%,% 0+% + 0 ' 3,'3%,$1 '( +%, ') 0 % $' '!$
&%-
(,'/$+%%0$ $%'(+%,+0!
', +%,( $+%,',/'$+%,', !(,'/+%,0'
', *+$%, ( 1 ',+ 0',+%,%0$ $% 1 '!
* $ '
%, 0!-0%&$ '
0+
'$!%% (',&% !
% ($+%( $+%,-
) + 0 '$ $+% /% 0 $' ' 0' (,'/ 1 &'3 ,&% ,1 3,'3%,$1
+ 0 3'00%00 '
'$ '( )+ &+ $+% *+$%,-
) + 0 '$ '!$
10+ ,% 10&+'!
* $ '
0+
&% 0% '
$+% ,%/ ,, *% '( $+% *+$%,-
)4 . 4 0 3
00 0(
'* '( 3 .
1
4
>'$ 1
11 0
" $+%
0$ $& 0%$+%,% 0 '3,''('( 1 0',&%'(
&'/%', 13,''('( 1%0$ $% (,'/ )+ &+ $+% 3%$ '
%,0 & /
$+%/0%
%0 $+%,%(',% $ & !% 0 (% 1
(%,,%$+ $$+%&'
'
0 %,%&$ '
0$ 0 ( (
% 5+'*+ $+%,% 0 0' ' %
% &% '( 1 //'
% 3,'3%,$1 (' $+% ,%03'
% $+')% %,$+ 0 ',$ 0 0''($+%
%)$+ $$+%$%,/63,'3%,$170%
%&$ '
'( $+% .
'3$ '
8 #
&% &$ % '$%0 /'
% !
% 3,'3%,$1 0 )%
5+%0 ,1, ) !1$+%,%03'
% $ 0 + 0 /'
% !
% 3,'3%,$1 5+%,%(',% +% 0 !' $' /
$+% 3%$ '
%,0(,'/ $+ $ 3,'3%,$14
<
B 1
'* 4 ,.+4
5 30 6+ "-*1( 4 "- 01 "-*1
614 .
61/ "0 "-*1
C 3 1 0 00 00
3 3 0
30
3 0 3 21
3 4 0
3 1
4 3+41 "-*10
1
0 00 1 0
0 3 C 3
"$+'*+ %,$+%&$$+%, *+$$' &
//
&%!1 ) ')% *+$%,-
) *
0$$+%( $+%,-
)
0
$%$'$+%%2$% $'(&'3 ,&% ,13,'3%,$1
$+%+ 0'(( $+%,-
) '$'()+ &+) ')% *+$%,-
)+ 0 '$$ 9% 10+ ,%!$ %, $+%:
.
)3,%
*!%(',%$+%% &$/% $'($+%&$$+ 0, *+$'(
&%'() ')% *+$%,-
) *
0$$+%0% ( &; ,%3,'3%,$1 '(( $+%,-
)) 0
%.'
7!
%.
*+&',$+ 0(,$+%,+% $+ $$+ 0 , *+$ 00$
%$'$+%) ')% *+$%,-
)'(3,%-%&% 0%0'
*
0$$+%0% ( &; ,%3,'3%,$1'(+%,( $+%,-
) 0$+ 0, *+$0+
'$ &% 0%$'!%
(',&%!%& 0%$+%0 /% 0 '$
&'
0$% $) $+ 13,'
'
&'
$+% 0 &$ 5+0 $+% ) ')% *+$%,-
) '( 3,%- %&% 0% 0'
0 % % $' &
/ , *+$ '( /
&% *
0$ $+% 0% ( &; ,%3,'3%,$1'(+%,( $+%,-
))+%$+%, $ 0
+ 0+ ',
$+% + '(+ 0+% ,','
%%4
B
0 7
3
1 A1 4 3+41 "-*1 0 3
0
) 0
" :
%,,
* %((%&$ '( &$- % 0 '$+%,) 0%%23,%00 13,'
%
$+ 0&$- 1$%2$, %',
$%,3,%$ $ '
'(.
)', 1&0$'/',0 *% 03 ,$'($+ $
)
(',&%
//% 1 !%(',% $+% &'//% &%/% $ '( $+ 0 &$ 0+
&% 0% $' + % %((%&$ ) $+ ,%03%&$ $' 1 / $$%, (', )+ &+3,'
'
0/ %
$+ 0&$< ! 1'$+%, )
(',&% //% 1!%(',% $+%&'//% &%/% $'($+ 0&$0+
&% 0%$' 1$'.
0
0'( , 0 $ 0
&'
0$% $ ) $+ 1'($+%3,'
'
0&'
$+ 0 &$4 .
,.+4
540 6+ "-*1 4 "/
&%'( / ,, %) (%,
*0!0 0$% &%'( / ,, *% 0'
$+%+0!
$ 0 3%,0'
'!
* $ '
5+%'!
* $ '
$'
*+$%,-
) , 0%0'
1)+% $+%+0!
+ 0 %&+ '! %&$ '
& 0'!%/%$(,'/$+%3,'3%,$ %0'()+ &+$+%+0!
0 &'- 0+ ,%, '$'$+%,) 0%=',
'9
*$+%0 3,'
'
$+%+0!
+ 0 0+ ,%
$+%3,'3%,$15+%3,'3%,$1
$+% /%'($+%/'$+%,-
)&
% $+%, !% 0! %&$ / $$%, '( $$ &+/% $ ', ,
* $+%
(% $ /% '( $+% +0!
+ 0 3%,0'
$1 $' /
+ 0 ) (% & !% ,%&$% $' !% % (',&% *
0$0&+3,'3%,$14B
1
) 4 "%&$ '
3,'
%0(', '
'!0$ $% & 0% $%,/0'($+%0 3,'
'
$0% ( 1'!
* $ '
'
$+%3 ,$'(
)0
$%,/0'( 1$%2$, %',
$%,3,%$ $ '
'(.
)', 1&0$'/ ',0 *% 03 ,$'( )!%(',%$+%&'//% &%/% $'($+%&$ ,% ' '
*%,
%) '( $+% '
'!0$ $% & 0% &'
%&$ '
$+% 3,'
'
0'($+%&$ '
% ,% 33
& !
%%&$ '
0 3,%0&, !%$+% 0$ $$',1
%0
,%* , $' /
&% '( ) (% !1 +%, +0!
'
1 '
+ 0 % $+ 3'
$+% ( $+%,-
) #'$+%,-
) $+0 &
'$ !% ( 0$% %) $+ 1 %*
$1$'/
+%, *+$%,-
)(,'/+%, ') 3,'3%,$1','$+%,) 0%4 / 4 0 0 13
4
3+41 "-*1
- 1
'* 0
00 0 3 0
0
00 1 0 3 0 C 3 0 0 0
0
'* $( /
4 0
0 3 1
1 A1 4
3+41 "-*1 0 1
1 0( .
0 1
$' $$
40
121
)'001 " ;0 >0 " /1 012
0 1
3
5 C
/ 0 0
0 1
13
0
4 0 0 '% %%%5
0
0
3 0 3
0 3 4 00
3'5&-
1 0
0 1 ! "')'*$%'+
0
0 0 1! "#$%&$%'#3 3 1 0
1
1 1 0 3 0 0 3
0 1 ! "')'*$%'+ 3 > $ E &
0
#%%%5 1 '5& ! "#$%&$%'# '% %%%51 0 1
/ 0
3 3
!
" ?+%$+%,03% 9
*@,% 0'
A B%0@C' ?+%$+%,%3',$ !
% A B%0@C'