High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRFA/3619/2015disposed of

Hsiidc v. Ashok Kumar And ORS

2017-04-07Mr. Justice Arun Palli9 pages

!"#"$%&' & () $ * $+,#("

- . -/0 $ (/( "$ 1$2 () $

* $+,#("

- $+$ ( #(,!,( . -/0 $(/( "$3"0" +4 // -- $ 5 (#,# #678,0 ( $+6 (# #/$+ $#

$+6 (!$$ ! +0 (#%

!"#"

!""$ #!$

%!% % %$!

#$! # ""! # $! "%

""!&

$ # #'

% "

&( %%%$!$"! #$! $! $!"

!"#! $! % ! !

#%% #%! #% ! #%#! # # %! " !

! #" "

! $ $"!

! "

! $ ! %%! "! %!

##! #"

! "! "! "

! " %! " ! "

! "# "#"! """! $ " $ ! $

$ ! $#! $"! $" $$ !

$ ! %

! % %! % ! % !

# !

! #! $!

! %"! %$!

! $"

! "

! "!

$# ! $##! $#"! $""!# !#%!# # !

# !#

&# " *+

!% ! #!$#$$! !%% !%

%!% !%

!%# !

%""

! %""! %$ %$#! %$"% %$" ! %$"#!

$ ! #!

! $! $!

% !%$$!

"!" !# #!##& #"

&)&

9%:39*33 , &- .

, &/0&!12)0 .

34 0 )!12* .

34.&20&!12* .

, 1& &/00 0&!12* ' 033&56( 3&&56( .

&7.!12* .

&81!12* .

9,9&/ !12* .

&/081!12* .

:/ !12* .

&!12* .

0&81!12*& .

&7;00!12 ' 0&)& .

0&09&!<! & 33;1( -4 ;0 &7 / &!02 20'

33!')020"#3301 &' 05 &'2 '02= &6&0

3301 &3

0 2 &>&)& !0 '0 2= &!

&0= &0 =

&&&0332

0 &/3' 2

& )1 ! 2&& 0 '2 &/2 '

%$'

% 5 & & 13 & 3 & 5&) & & & &'

13 & 3 &? 6;04:

& 0 6 ;&'2&

! & 2&'

0?&2= &2!%"$!5' 0 @02@6!&

&/"% $ 4& ! &$'' &1/ 20)!&3

, 0 !9)! 0&! 0&!: &)!0 0 &)!

0& 2) !) /0 2= ' A&&'

& < )0& !)&2 & & 2& '0 2)3

0&%

0?&2= &2 !1 3 ) !' 20'0 1& !0 41 '

0 2= & %

(> 3 2 &/ // 1 0 &&02 3&&) 02 !02 & ' 72& & 2&%"'02 &!03 )

&!&2& &'0 !0

!1 /&)

% 5' 1& ')6!%$

% 5' 1/&3

% 5' 1/, 0 & 9)6! %

% 5' 1/ 0&6!

% 5' 1/ : &)6!

% 5' 1/0 0 6&%

% 5' 1/ )6! &0&2 0 2 3&& ) 0 2 & %

(>3 2 00)! 003 &33 ' 0

B'2

!3 00) 56 & &2

!&02 &4'

0 &0&2 & .

, &/0 &! & 2 & ' 0 33&

0 0 &2

! ' 0 &0&2 & ) 02 &0& 0 /0!0 !0 &2

0&1)'0'2!2

&2&02&'

02= &!02 &) &'

0 &0&2 &!

&0&/&)

7 '02&2 &

0 !0

0 033&0

/0& 0CA D(D( !D(%!D( &D( D(!

' &&2) 2

' !&

'2&

'02!02 &2 & / &2 3&&0&)0 )) 02

033 &0 & /&

& , 2& ! & 2 & ' 0 2 &>&)&

& &&01&0 /00

!& & 03 2'2!2

&2!02&'02= & 0&2&0&2 &!

0'2 &0&

1&2 ) 02 &0)00& & 2= &00 / 3& ' &/ ' &(2

2(& 3

3 0 !0/ 1&2'02 &0

33 & '33 201&2& !&0 !02 3&& ) ' &=

0 ! 01&'

000)

/0& 02 & ) ' !

' 0) 2& 3 & &&2 &) A 2 2!02 &1 /& B ! !2

4&&22 &)0&33 3 2 0 !

/00 2 & &'

0 &0&2 & B& &0 /0'

2& &'0 & ! '02& 1)00 /&) )0 & & !

&0 ! ' 0 &0 &/ 0 &>&>' &2!0?&2= &2 00

41 '02= &%

(>3 2 !&0 &2

&0&202 3&&%

(>3 2 !03 2

/ 1&2 ' 0 5 &'2 ' 0 2= &6 0 0 &0&2 &)

0& !&0'&&/

&0 / 3 1 !) 33 0 2&2 &

-> <6 / ""$ (# 6 . !- "0 + 6 6 !0/ $# "$

(+ +=)- ($ +3 $+!>,"#""$-- !("#. ()"$ + >, /(. 6 "( !

# ; = #"+ # ( - ."+ $! $ *"$?6 1@ 4; $?

+,( 1@ 4 $+ *,( #6 8,0 ( 1@4; 6 / ""$ (# 6 .

/(+,! +$ "- !/) # - + +#A@'BA@'B "# =# (. +6 # - + +#A@'BA@'B/ ( "$6 ) (

$+6 # 0 / ( "$#0 --!6,$7 - $+"## - +- 26

#0 --!6,$7 - $+!

$$= ( -" +,/$ (+ (0"$ "$ 6 (7 .

-, 6 - $+ 6 # - + +# A@B; A@B'

A@B2 ( A !, +"$6 ) ( ' $+# - + +#A@B ;

A@B $+A@B A@B2 ( A !, +"$6 0$6#

$, (); 9 (!6; /("-; 9 ) $+ ,$ ; 3 ($ + 3 $+ !>,"#""$-- !(6 # (+ +!0/ $# "$C#

- !#/ (

!( ( -- 7"$+# - $+ 2 . (; # / ( * !"$ 3 $+ !>,"#""$!; ';6 0,$ !0/ $# "$ (+ +=)6 !,(#6 --$= - ##6 $6 0,$ (+ +=)6 -- !(,$+ ( * !"$

+0" +-);6 !>,"( +- $+2 # ?("!,-,( -"$$ ,( 8 /"$?"$." 26

!# $+!"(!,0# $! # 6 !

# ;-!

"$ $+ $ ,( 6 - $+ !>,"( +;/,(/# !>,"("$?6 0 (7 .

6 !>,"( +- $+"# ## ## + 6 ( # ;;B1#*"A $ - !#4 / ( !( ( -- 7"$+# - $+ (0 6 + "##,"$? 6

"$,$+ (* !"$' 6 ! -$?2"6 --# ,()= $ "# ,$+ ( * !"$ 1 4; 1 4 $+ D 6 ! 6"# "##, "#;

!!(+"$?-);+ !"+ +"$

.,( 6 / ""$ (#E !0'

'0&0&2 &) 0

*0&0)4''2&2

&2'0 2!02&&&

'02= &02 3&&) 02 &) = &0&2%

(>3 2 !

)03 2) ( 0'2&2

&2!0)A20 2= &)2!)0)

&)0!&0&/&

! & 33 &!02&2 &

1 0

&3 2 &3 2'&&33 2& '0 &1&2&

0 !1&0 CAD(%CAD(0)

/0& 0 &'2 '02= &6!) 2

!' &

'2& '02!0 2 &2 & ) 2 3&&0&)0)/ & 02 E&

0 2&&1 &=

)003 3&') !!

)033 01 &1 402& &3 0 0

'2 &1& 20&&23 10 &' &2&&!0' 3

32 &0 1 '02= &0 !0'2 &00 &2

0&1&

&/0))0 2& &0) A2 ?4)!1&0&)& 01 / 1&2!' 0

& 0)

/0& 02 &!0!CA,D( CA,D() '2& &!' !03

3 '& A &// 00& & )&!! ')0&)0&&/&0&/0 &&2' 20 &4'&2&&1 4&&22 &

& 0 4 1 ' 0 2= & 0 ! 2& 3 & &&2!1&0 /0' !'/

& 02= &2&) 4&2/&F&2'. !)0 2&(2 0 &!&/1&2!)

& 7 0!

&0&/&

&2)0 )0 0)&107 '0 A2 &'

01 &3 2/&'2&!0

&202 '0&)& &3 / 30 '0 /&) - 002= &)2& >"&#%>!)

&&/& 0 * )&)) 2 !&)3 ' &3/&13 &,& &3 ! 0 2 & 3 1 0 3& 5CA,%6 32 0 2&'02= &!&0&2 1&2& 33 '

0 2 !0 )(&&/ 33 2& &'0 1&2 0&)& &0 / && 0!02)0 003 // 1

0'&&/

/ 0 41 ' 0 2= & < 1&2 ' 0 5 &'2 ' 0 2= &602&2 &

3 3 1 !' &0&/&32'2

& 0

D 2= & %

(>3 2 D0 !0/ 1&2'0 2 &00

')/0!&&33 2 0 &01&2 0 !&0 !0 &0&2 & ) &0 '21'01 '02= & 2)00 &! &2 &' 03 01

202&& 00 /&) !&0

' >2&&&

3 &2!&0

'0&

! &0 & !

&0&33 0&1 3& &!0 /&) &!0 ' >2& !&)0

0 >

&03 ! A3& 10 003 0 / &)33 & 20!&000 32'

/ !&'

0 1&2' !&01&'

' &'

0 33 &0 / &&2 & 3& 00

)0 &/033&9 #!

% 0 03 &! & G'0&0&22 3&&

&/ 02

'0 &/)&'

0 &2 &' 03 0&'20& ) &0&2 &3)00 A2 &/

20!&2 & )0 0

0& 03 &'0 /&) !02 &011& &

0& &0&2 & D0 &0 !&)020 3 &'&0&22 3&& & G)!&0'0 &) 02 &0 &/! 2 0 033&0& 21 0 &00 &

02 &!0 >2)1 !0

030&2 &33 3 &0 / !&0 &) )

&)0 & &/'&7 / &, 0 /0 0 3212 &033 ' 0 29 /!) &

%# 00 02 &'0 2 /0 20 0 ' /&&0

2 3&7

2&)1 !&0'2&2

&2'02!

0020 = 20 !

31!)0&3 ') &0'

%# 00 0&2& &A3 &'3&&&0

'02'0 3 &!0

020

& !& 2&22 &2)0) &2&32 '0 1!033 22 &/!

3'&0 1

0/ 2& 240?0 &2

' 0)0

%# 1334

D00 34&/( & 8( D00 3 - 8(