← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRFA/7824/2013allowed

Vivek Kumar v. State Of Haryana & ORS

2019-10-23Mr. Justice Gurmeet Singh Sandhawalia7 pages



     

 !"# $%&'(""&($&#!))&!*+

&+&',&#"-. /

'"0"(&#"-  /  

            ))&!*+1*&#23*!"#4"&'+ ))&!*+1*&#23$%&5$!$&

 ! "# $%# $  !&"

"%#%#% # %"#&'&&# &' #!&$#!!% #!'&#!'!#"%%"# ""#"$!#!$# ' # '&!# %! # $ !&

! %! $#'$$#'"%"# '"&#'"!#'%!#' #' &!#' &"

%% !&'

 &'#'$$!&

!&"#"!#$%'$% #$#$&# $ % &%!&% -  67  55587 () *

 + #, - *  

#,  *

. #, # * + #, # * 

#, # *  / 0#, # * 1 #, # * + #, # *





#, # *2 0

2 #, #  - * *

#.#  *3

/- #.#   55!"#%!4!*1!

9   2 

 3

  ,' 4 ,5 ,#& $6 7 ,78 -   

33 -

::

"  

33    -   '$!&"#  !"&&!&"#  &'&!&#  !&!&#  &!'!&'  &!&' 3 ,9 #.

0 # 0 0 (

  !   ,  9  

  

,    

    &#&#%#%!:; ,-  ,0 ,  -  ! '!&"  7!+&. 6',1"#0)$!;+5$!$&!'3!"!!"#!"$%&'66<=(%8-    ,      !'&! &#&#"#'':; 

  3  

  #,

, >&?- 0 ! =

  >&#&#%#%!:; ,#  0   ,0 ,  2  =9   7&%'!4!*<%&4!=1'0+$

&># 9 !'1#?$!"#$%&'+;+5$!$&

0"=!2!"#$%&'+6 5  "   ,5          ,   -        

0&%" ,#- ,5    

@ 

, ,$$&&'# .

0 # &"&!& , , -  '    "&"!&#   4  ,5  9,

%

 ,  ,9 - ,0!', '$!&"#  , - 7!+&@6;1,&?<0A!';+5$!$& !'3!"!!"#$%&'+6

=

  >&#&#%#%!:;

,-  ,0 ,      ',1"#

:

:

0)$!6+(!+& +0)'! 9 , 3/ ,9   -  !"&&!&"#&'&!&#!&!&#&!'!&' &!&'- - '  -<=(&("  ! ! -0 0 0 0 3- =,                  

,       ,   ,  %     ',1"# 0)$!6+(!+&

+0)'! - 0 -

  ,, #  ! ! -

3=, !      ,, # =

 -  ,   0 - -  >"#&#&%# "':;

,/  # ,''?- , 

  &#&#"#'':; ,    9   A,       9   -   

,0    

.6 !A%!"#&'!"#!"$%&';+ 5$!$&!'3!"!!"#$%&'+6  ,,, , !'!&%# 0(

  # ,   &!!6<=(!:8-  0$

!

 6 

% ,8 - 

 0# 3

3>#%'#'!#""&:; ,/    - 3

3  

  -2,   2   );

B;1**!>& !4!*!<%0+'0)0'

::

 B 0 , ,,

 , , # ;

<=(!: &!!-  3 ;#-



3 

 3  0

   ,5  / 300,

  -    ; 

- 0$

 !*  B- 

= , -       0<=(!:-  ; 3 0&  & &!!#- 3 0 $

!*  -     #%'#'!#""&:;

,C  ;#- 3

, - #  ,   

   ,          

'# #$'#%'!:; ,<=(# %#$'#%'#!&:;

,<=(% '###:; ,<=(%% , 3  ;-

 , 0

#

 30 ,    0

   ,5       0-# 9 

  #   -  03          

 

    #  -

  3 ,        ;  <=(!:     &!! ,,0#- 0  3; 0 0 ,3  ,, # 0  0

 , -  ,  # -   0  , ,    ,5      #%'#'!#""&:;

,#   , , ,D  =9 1,1*))&!*:@ 65$!$&    !'3!"!  ;+  !A  %!"#&'  !"#  !"$%&'6 ,   '$!&

 ,

,  3&'?   0=  

   >"#$'#%$# &"' ,   

:.:

 2   );

E&B #  ,&'?-   - 

3 ,#-  

3

  , # ,   , , #,0    5    

  ,   / 3 

 ,         ,   /

#  -      

3 0 9  3= 4 ,3

 ,,0D $ 9         - 

  

      

, >&!? 0 "#$'#%$# &:; 

&?

, 0  - &  0

 33 ,, ,,   ,

  $'!  0"% %

 >#'#"!#$%:; ,6<=(&8   &!&&! 6<=("8 - >#'#" #:; ,#-   B &'?,    #-  ,, ,  # # 3 ,

,  ,! , 3 0  &!?3  &?# 0- - -3  =9   6 1*!"#!$0'!*!+')'!$1"71A1$&#;+

!A&+%2%!11,!"2%!1 !$&*!"#!"$%&'C  5./   2   );

E&&(

# ,  ,  ,  ;  

        #            0  #  3  

 #  

   B     ,  ,#, 

:@:

,- 3-#  0

#-    2

C  

# 3  ;

3    #  -            #  -  

           -        , ,

,   # , 

 , 

,

 # ,     B , 30 ,#    

 # , ,

 , "?'?   # 0 C  = #    -  - ,

,  

  3 #     ,   0          

0      &?!? 

/ 

0, ,, 

    3 : ;

3   , 

       /  , 

   3 : ;

3    3 &?&'?



# ,0,    -  33 

#

 3 '?'?



/  

3 0  #3  3,,  ,, , 0, ,F   ,   0  , # ,, , 0 ,

, ,#  , 3 -  

D &&

  #,

 

 3= 3 =9  ,  3# 9  -

  &!!6<=(!:8, 3

 03 

0

  #- =  ,   

3=

 ,  ,   05   , - &' -    0G- /- G    3 

::

  0    0

 G

.

0 /  ,5 , ,$$&&'# .

0 

 #, ,&% &$-  -    (

 #   G (

9 .

0 ;*  H3 9 =;!!&G 6<=(8 !!'G6<=('8/ 30,,  ,5 #  - 3  ,,   &!   0 -, 3-  0 G- ,   (   30#-  32,

  ,5  &' -  / , 0 -- 

   

                ,       G  3  &" ,,0#  0    -     3  , #  

 3 -  -          /  

        =  > # #$#!:;    ,

0-  36 # #$#:; ,8 & 0, ,  , -   

3   # ,,0

5587    9/       0: ) 1:    3) 1: