High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/7310/2017allowed

Iffco Tokio General Insurance Co Ltd v. Birmati And ORS

2019-07-08Mr. Justice Harminder Singh Madaan9 pages

!"# $"%&'()

''## *"$ +& ,"&-"

.' /"

0"12-34

.4"""34 "-''##

-"&'#34"

*4 2-"34 ""'0

+& ,"&78$5("9:3 2" 37 8$ ("9$7-" " 378$("9&"

+- /:2$&"3$"$4&"- 8"$7-#&'$"+;;- "*-#3 7"' *""9 "4"$&:" !"# $"%&'() 9 $"" $ . -:

8"7 "7" 0 <.;%5 -"" """ - 74-# 3#&7&'-$. =#

'"--'">#&3 5 =3 +- /:2$&"#7:-+>+- .&'-#<$ &%-3+1(

.1":77+&'#"&%--"8(-74-# "48("'0 ?-/:2$&":7"7- "4"9*""3:-".&'-#3+1(.1":"7 -8 -74-#?-"'9*"": "47-74-#4"(-7-'"-#(7#7#(? -/:2$&"-"'7"- "'0 9 *"""4'"'"&"8$3"$##(- 74-#$"$"#"7-/:2$&"& $"- - 7 4-# - '3 - :( "'0 -$-8(-"-7#7"47 -74-#3"$#7-/:2$&"?-"&# .0 5 5 ="-$"+ 5 /%:7""8(.&'-#<$ &%-3" 4##7 %--"3 " @-11"? - '&"& A& : '""&-8(/:2$&"

77-#&'38--"' -''"-#&'

-:"&#8-#"'0 3 ---(- '# 5 =8$ 5 & +$-"'3-:4"&--:"- 74-#

-:"&#8-#"'0 9 $"&'(3# $'4"$#7#817 -"&-$"'#(-84#?- $"-#&8"7-#&'?-

"'0 :-474#4"47# -&-4-#B$:##(4#48( -#&##$:--'#?--#&- ''"--%$":-#- &"3-$"&'( - - 7 4-# : $" :- - &"#&3-:"7"':#8#'(( &'

-38--"''"("&#- #&' - '#7 - '"3 ##:7 $ :" "& C--"- '#$"-7#7"47 4-# 8"7 "7" 0 <.;%53 "4 8( "'0 3##78(-#&D//

$ '"44$"#&3:--"-#& "#7&'7"' 3:-&$"&:--3'"("D//

C--""' :-474#4# -&D/.

C--""' -4#-"&

$"/#(3.$/"& D/.

= .#

,--'"#4$''"-""'4 #&

$''" -" 3 - #& 0 - 7 -"

5 & "" /C 8 A&7 +- .&'-# /C 3 +- *""/C+- *4 @/C5 -'"-# "&$&

- -" -3 - "' - A& +& 0"&#4.C3+- +$&2".C 3+- *"" .C3+- *4 @.C58"7&$&

"-"7"7$&3-"8$#$0 4$"#&7-"'3$0 4$" -#&7-"'3$0 54$" "'0 7"'0

.$##(:-###:7 - ' 4 :" = ;3 - "8$# 7" &'. 3 3>#7:-"E =F'"$& "&-#7-'##"#G3'(8#8(8-- "'1#(4"##( -&":---&' 8''"#74-:"

+$-:"#- $"%&'(77"4- -"-%$"'"(7--''#8'3- :"$"-##78

0 - ''# : $ - "'

.'0 ='$''"-"$7-$#

-4-"#"$#"-'"877 -"$7--"" -$7--:"&3-$"&'(- $''#-"&-$"'#(:" 4#3-""3 -$"&'( -$#8 8#4

= #8#(&(-$":-"'#8#('(- &'&$ -8-'#7"7- 4$8(-'"3-"8$#-"$"7- -4-#B$8#77"'0 :$#($" :- "' 0 4 $" '#(3 -:4"3 - $" &'(-#(4-:-"'0 - 4#("&-$"'#(

)"$#"-''##9$"&'(- "7$ - - $" -: : ""(7 '7" &" - '"&8#:4"#&$--:7 :--&-"3$-$"&'(8#4 #8#( <:4"3 ( &" - - "'9$"&'(--"#(4"" -'#8"-"8$#-"7"

)" $# " "' 0 5 - """ $-"(

#$%&'

(8(07'$",- ,&8(<7-%$"3:-"#7:-:-"-$" &'(:-##774#8#("-"-- - '#$4"#7'7"$" -: :8"4--" -'":4"8(-" " 8:-:"$""-4-#"& +5- "*-#4"#7$" -: $#88$&#8"-#8#(- $"&'(:#&A'#$3-''##:

; &7-A'"-"'7"-#(#& 7$"&'( -#3-"-7"" -: - ( -" '7" "4##7 - $ " -: - $"1$""-(-"#&'-8#8(( -"1$""#7#"'"4'7" )"$#""'0 5-$"-"""" 'A%$"1$7&%%

)* +

% % ,,("-# .' !/ :-" - $& $&8" '7" "4##74-#3:--:&"-'"&:-#8 $&#8"-"#--$""& 87&"-&7$-4-# )"$# -$"-""""4,-1$7&2"#<7-%$"

0%'% .

2 ' 0

#$ -3:-":8"4- 4"#7 4-# :## $ - #8#( - $" &'( -"1$7&""":

$2 4+

% /"3#'%%'%"5#- 8(-'A %$":-8$""(7 '7"7""7'"&5 '7"-##0##- ;'7"-3:-";5 -"41$"3:8"4--$"&'(: #8#&:""'5 '7"#(

H"-"$&3 --$"&'( 4#8#("-" -$7-#"$#"- ''## $" &'( - " "7$& :- "7" #7#("47#-"4"-74-#8$-

"%#&"8$##7--"$& -4$8(8--'"-"$" '7-"'0 :-47#7#4#"47 #-& ("":- -"8$#-'

C- "7" B$$& &' :"3 - "8$#4:-7"-'&"&"'"IA /- -8"4--:78$5("-& - -&-#(&8. 35>'"&- "7-4"-#&--:"7.

35>8( :" 7 C"8( !#G +"4 /"4 )&3 -#

$"#I3/-

30:#-377"$#$"# :" -#&:. 3>'"&- +-#& -#$$37474- "7"3-"8$#-"7-#( &-8 . 35>'"&- 2'74:-'"4#7:7#&8( &$#:" "4-"7-"#4&3-&$ "#(8 8-7-"

-"8$#- -&-#(&8 . 35> '" &- 4: - " $-"(

2 +

% /"3# ''"5# , $-4$#( =F-&$8 :" $$" '"' <:4"3 - "8$# - 74 ( &$:"$$"'"' %"7-$&8"'$'-

8-"3-"8$#$7--4$>"-&$ - :"7#(88"4-$&8"':A3:- &"#(-"'" ::3&"$7-"&"

--#-#&'

-"8$#-$&$#'#"3:-- '7 4:-7--8'"'"#($ <:4"3 -$7- - "8$# - ## """ 7(&$:"$$"'"'3$7>5- - &$:--$#8>":"'"#A'8$- #&-4#("''#""813 '"'"7"$-8-& H"-"$&3 ##:-'(&$ "&. ;3>3$#'(8. =3;> ;3A " ''#(7 &$#'#" 3 - &' & $ .

3 3>

-"8$#-:"$& =3>:"$"# A'3. =3>#&0 $#"$& . =3>-#& :"##4

<:4"34:-"$-"(

2 +

% $'" 3-#&"# 7&'$"4#- . =3>$ #3. 53>:"#"$&. =3> $"#A'3#. 3> -#&'&$ .

3 3J3K3= 3>

- "8$# - :"7#( :" &'

. 3 3 > -&"$. 3= 3> -#& :$#8#7"E =F'"$&"&-#7 - #& ' ## $# "#G - &$ . 3= 3 > -""&-"7#:"-## "&-& &$'A8"$8(-#& -"#

C-$-&3-''###:'"#(:-

,"1

!"#$ %&"'

!()$* "&#

'# !+,

"&#