High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRFA/3728/2015dismissed

Ramesh v. State Of Haryana & ORS

2015-09-04Mr. Justice Ramendra Jain5 pages

! ""## $

% &'( !'

!"#$ %&'()! *+,-.) "/)+0 -%1"( )' *'% ")'+ !!!',$, '!""## - .

"/)+0 -%1"( /! ''0## "

! ' 1 21 /!"' ""# !$3 #4

!0'

,0!'3(!#'

1'3#0

!36

# 3(!# 0 '

1 #( 7' #(,! '!# 1 '$ 1

$##48'!7!',/!

# '!+,0 14!321' 3(!% &'( ' 41" !9 1 '#*#/0

!", $

1 1 ' % ! 21 , - ' !',:!;. 1 5

!0 #

1 (/! 21 ##'

' !',:!##';.$0'

! '+ $#1 !21'# 44'$4

!0' !##',! # 0 '

#36

,0!!0'' ''!#'

'<14,0!+" 4 $0! '#"# ''3(! "' ,

!36

#3(!# 0 '

3 4 3'' $0' 5

9 ! 0'0!! "14 "' ""#

# '!""## 13 !!!'

# 0 '

,0! # 0 21'$ ,!$3

0' !4!' "

, 0!' #( ! ""## !$ 3

' /!(! # ""# 1 ' % ! 4

' + 4' !#'

1' 3#0 '

' "

/!#'

1'3#0$ 0' 5

! 3 4 3'' 9 0

13 !! ''3(!#'

1'3#0!! ' #3(!# 0 '

0 3'','##('' 1 &

13 ! '

!"'$

!,!

1#3 #0! 0' !# 0 '

'"' ! "' !0'9

!' ,01#30! 50+ ' ! ##'1 !'0! ' ! 0',0!!$'"'="' /! 13

! !"' ,!# 0 21'$ 1 '

/!0'0

3(! ##'

/!36

0'0! #

1 '1 ! !"' #

"'$ '!' ! 3 '"' !! ! 3

#0! + 0#4 !0'/!

#3(!""## !1#3

'0! # &'#'

# '!""## "'1 !""'> 3+ /! , 0!! ' $ ' ! '' ' !

1 ! 0

/! ##'

! 0'

9 3( ! ""## !!(! '$! "

!21'# '!!(0' !+ 0#4 !0'3(!##' !' ,0!! "1, !!36

0' #3(! ""##

! 1# '=, !

1 0!! ' '

' 3(! 1' , 0!!'!36

#3(!

""## '3'0! 3(

' 4!# ' !!""## # !!(!$'$ ! 1

' ' ! !( #( ! ! + 0#4

!0'/! !""## !!(

# ! 36

!( ! ! + 0#4 !

!0'3(!##'

! ='3#0

? ))!)%.),*!,2-. ("'

' 0!!

" ! 0' (, 3( 0' ""# ! ##','21'!! '3' ''3(!##'

'!' !1',0!!'! 36 3 ! 1' !# ,! 1 "

,! "'

0! "(3#,'!""' "

4!"'

' ./!""# !## !4'1 0!!36

!0' +

)'$!$'( 1!""# !##3 ,> -. !"'

+ 40 "' ''"' 3 ##'! 0! ! ! 0',0! = 0+ 0'@ -3. !' ,0!

' !##'1 , .,'

0! 0', 0!!$'"' !## ="'A /! "'$ ! ( "'

' "!0',! (3(0' ""# ! ##''21'!! '3' ''!1'/!36

3'4' 4 1' !# ,! 1 "

,! "'

0! "(3# ' ! ""' "

!"'

' /!""# !1# !4'1

0!!!0' 36)'$

!"'$ '!"' 0!!!36

1#3 # #1 -.!' "'$ ! "'

"' ''"'

3 ' ! ##' !

! 0', !

3 #0!

0'#1 -3."'$ ! !' ,!36

3 # 0! ' !##'1

!'0! ##';

0', 0!!$'"'="' B

' %"#1(- 21 . !'$ %! * ## ! 1## !'

, -5. % , & ;3# ! %1"' 1'

1 0!!'# "'$ '

! ' # 436

3= 0

0' 4$)'4'"!

!' '=' 3#0

? 9 3' 3'!! 21

- .-5 .0 "' '3 4! # =' !"0'1

,5 =#1! 1"1 (4' 3(! 1' /+ 4 4 C ! # "' '3

"'$ ,!"'$

0' ="'

#(= /!14!%

! $#3#, !#

"'$ (3'3

"##0, !3 1! ""# 3( 21 - . -5 ., !

" ##(

30 !##' !1' !##'DB"'

#( 1'(1

'!, #1 4 0!# + 4' 1 '

'1!!##'DB 0!# + 4' 1 , 1'(1!'(

## 1' ' ! "1'" % ! /!14!!' (3, $0 " # "'$1 '"'$ % !, 0' !

'$0!

3 ""# ! "'$ - .

/!##'DB,!' ', 1'0!

! 1'(1!'(1 -./!' ', !

3""# '=

!"' # "' '31 '"'$

/!&4!1',!' ',0 '4! 4!!##' 1'1 ! A- "! 1""#. /! $0 0 ##0 % E'

+ $ =1 ,-

. % 3(! 1' F

!"# $ " ,

$0 ! #0,!#( # 36

!0' !##'

3 9 ! ,!""## 0'0##0' !21 "' ( ="'

/! 1 "

0 '$ 3(! '!

!0'

0' #( #

,0!!0'#'#(3( !"'"' '31 '!

' 4! 1# '=,9 ! ( ##4#(! 3 3(!#'

!36

#3(!""## 3''' 4#(,! ""# '

21 #(,! " ( 4""#

-6 !7 #.

<14