Dalbir Singh v. Vikas Kalia
!"#" $% &'
('
) * % $+,-
)'
.# "!
'/'/0
! """
'/'/0
'
# $ ! %&'!
() * + ,-,'&,#.
/ 0 1#,2+ 3! 3 !4 1 13 4 / 2 3 * 5
#6,7&,&%/ 0 1#&2+ 3! 4 3
* + !+ 8 -7,3 3* #.%3 3/ 0 1#2* & 9 ! +
* * !( )-7 '1( 3 $ ! ,7,#&,#&:
! #,,.&,#, * * 0 * ! ! 8 $ * ;, ,, ,,,81 ! *
#, ,, ,,,81* + #% ,, ,,,81* $ !! + *!0#,,-&,##$
#,,-&,## ! ! * !1 3 ! *+ * !7% ,, ,,,81 #,,-&,## !! !1
!! #,,-&,## * * + + 1 3 $ !!+ ! ! !
#,,.&,#, * * ! ! 5
,7,#&,#6+ 3!3 4
/ 23 +!
* ! + 9!
9 5* ! +! 9!
< = *!+ ! 3 ! 4 3 5
,&,-&,#.
* - )* -7,* #.% 3 3*!+ ! 3!3 4 / 2 3 + 5
,7,#&,#6 + ! ! !! #,,-&,## ,-,#&,#& #-,-&,#->0
! $3 !
+ * * $3<** + + ! + !7% ,, ,,,81 7 ? + 5
,-,'&,#.
/ 0 1#,2 3 ! 3 4 / 2 3
-7,!3 3* #.%3 3 $ ! ! 3! 4
5
#6,7&,&% / 0
1#&2 * % 9 ! + 5
,7,#&,#6+! !!! !
+ +*
* $3*@ * +
+ !7% ,, ,,,81>
,.,-&,## * * ++ 90 ( * + + + * * +0 >0 1'
! ! $ 3! 0 A 9 (
90 ( #;1( 3 3B1# * + >031#* + 90 ( * + + + *
5 $ $ 3B1&
!! * * +
! ! !! 9 ! $ 3 + !!
)%!,7,#&,#&
*
>031#
! +@* 3
!! + 3 3 ! * + + 3! >031#
* ! 5
,7,#&,#6 *+ * ! ! * * A 9 ( ! 90 ( * + * + + ! + + * 5 $ $ 3
=+ -7,3 3 * + * + 6 < ! !+ ; #.%3 3 ! ! !*! +! !!! 5 !! * -7,3 3
* #.%3 3 ' C ! +!! #.%3 3* -7,3 3 *1 #.%3 3 1
! "
#
$
%
&' (( ) "
* (+,
-
.
) "
* (+,
/ + ',,', ' ''(
"
*+/
*&
*&
*&+ "
"
%
%
-
"
"
"
' 0
%
"
.
"
# 1
"
/ )
%
2"
2 "3
""
"
4 5
5 "
* 6
%
"
"
"
" "
"
""
% "
5 "
"
"
. " 3
"
"
" 3
"
7
3
/ !
" $
)'' 1 /*,
% 0
"
-
8
%
"
"
"
8 #
%
. # .
9
.
#
9
% "
#
9 .
9 ' :
"
%
"
%
#
-
"
"
%
*
/ 5
% "
# ; "
"
"
.
"
"
"
* )
2"
2
. $ @ D 3 !
!
"# $ # !$ "
%
=+ -7,3 3 + + 0 ! $ @ D 3 1 ( 4$ & '
( ) *
! + " $$,-- "
*
1
(
*:
4
#
3 " <
)
0
"
=
- #
3
)": " 4
! /(>':
5
? =
)
:
" 4
#
5
#
6
#
#
?
)
4
)"
8
"
:
"
&
0
#
" 5 ;
:
#
5
&:
#
#
; "
-
4
*('""7 .2( 5
*! *
4
4 @# < ', 4""+( A+ : "
(:
8 >
-
:
:
9
-
8
7 #, ! @ D 3 !
.
*/0
) /
/ 1
2! "# $ # !$ "
1 & :
4
',, ) "
* (+,
)"7 .
B
-
8
4
/*, ""
-
4
@:949
5 C ) ' ' 3"3 " /(1 '
/4""&( :
8
()
-
8
)
8
)
4
/*, ""
8 B
4
4 9 < ',,' 3"3 " '1 ',,' 4""'/ ))31 ) 4
( ) ) 4
5!
"#$#!$ " 2+6!
5"*4""/&, " D "
4
/*, "" %'/
1 '/)
4
/*,""
#
4
-
7:
D
8
-
8
4
: -
)
#
)
-
# 7 ## ! @ D 3 !
:$ &
)
*
+ 7#!& $
" %+ !*1 *:
4
4
#
0
3 " <
)
0
"
=
% -
#
3
4
)" : " 4
! /(>' :
5
? =
)
:
" 4
#
#
6
#
#
?
)
4
)"
8
"
:
"
0
#
" 5 ;
:
#
5
&:
#
#
; "
-
4
*('"" #& < + *!+ +
! ! * ! ! 0 * 9$ * + ! ! ,7,#&,#6 + 3 4 / 2 3 > *!+ ! 3 5
,&,-&,#.
3 !+ 5
+ 3 3* 3
0 )E3$ !! !1 #,,-&,## !0 ! * !! * ! ! @
#7#,&,## * *
! ! @* 3 3
3 !! * * + *! ! +! * ! +!>0 1' ! *+ ! 3 * *! ! + + ! ! ! + * +! +!>031# > !
! > * * * ! * *!
! > +!5
,7,#&,#6 * ! ! 3*
> 5
,7,#&,#6 * * *
+ ! 3 ! + ! !! ! >03B1&8- >03B1&87 >03B1&8% *! ! !! !+
@* * * !! * ! + #- < *! <! !*
,-,'&,#./ 0 1#,2+ 3!
3 ! 4 1 13 4 / 2
* 5
#6,7&,&%/ 0 1#&2 + 3! 4 3
! #7 E +
5'/'/678 &'
('
8 F8) F8)