← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/6025/2019dismissed

Suman @ Suman Punia v. Chameli Devi

2026-02-18Mr. Justice Vikram Aggarwal7 pages



   

  !"# $%&%!'()**  



      



 (  +,

* -./   0,       

 "#$  

 %&   

 111 ./   0,2* ,

   

    (()



!*    

+,-.(-,/0 1 2,3

  45  !    $

 0$  3  6     " 

 

 

45

 8 ** ,,

 !  



,/-90!



: ;3!



! 

"    ( 0 1 2(3" 

45 7  !!

0     3      

 03  !

  54     45 "5 !   !   !

 !  

   

(,,-(-,,

=

   /)=50!5   4  



  

 # '

   6 

 +  

 8 ** ,, 



 45

> 

 ! 2! 1

!  !

 

* "

      !

  

 4

 !! 1    !   

"



(,,-(-,,

 !



-9-?(-,( ! 

+--@(-,/"4 45 





 @   

"  6 "



!

"!! 1        

 

" 1 =

!"! 



  

45 

  



4

   .   !



"

  ?   !

  5

   5        

!



  %   

 4 

 "

5

(,,-(-,,6 

.

  4            !    7  !!

 !



9-?(-,(6

! 4      "  54 45  

45>    5  !

 



A   4     

  

   * ! 



        45  

   4 '# 4/56 4 '7%  8*  49%'# 4

:-%'7;2)- ':%' -3<=&   ""%$ 42 '!> 8*- > '/

'#!; 4& ))2# $%# #!'?*<*?

=

 6 ;4        4' 

54;@ 8* 

85:

-!6 &5'# 6 4&*2 -?* )     !

4

   

 5      

 "5  1 =

!"! %   

) 9B,(

   4   "   

    

 

4 45 

C

" 

  

< 

  

 6  4 "  4 ! !5 !

   

 ! !  * ! 

          45 6 ;4   !*    */56 A545B ' 8*  * @ ' 4&*2- ':%' -<=/5:

'#;5

6# 4&;

-;

 8*  6  &  &  4%8   ,%6% #  '#  '4*2 C%8%:  DD :

!*?3  !"  2  # $%# #  !'  **2  , (<)33E= -4% !@ ' D ::@-4%9 @ 4#;

' 8* .*%45D ##@ 4&* C-,  <32  # $%# #  !'  **2  ())E=  & ; B 

6# & -;%4!:  4&*8* !;%' 4D4%& & 4&* %8%:

=

&;%B ''4*8*/4%&;'

'

'5D4 & #4%8 #%23 - 3<* 9 *   4   45   !





?

/ *  "



!

 !    

 

!  

5          

  "



  *   "





   !   ' 

 

"

(,,-(-,,'    

  1 2?D   

  ! 

4

! 1 !



E  5

 .  2 F* ;

  ; 4 " 4  ;  D:

%'%""  DD4!

$; #  ;

# " '# ' '#4 G5 & #; 4"!4;  H $5%!' '# 4 7%&4 %!'!"; & : # #%'; 4"

8!544 7 4#%'7 ;  B!8 & %#D:!!') '#; D:

%'%"" :&!

D54$;

& #  ;  ' $ && 4@  & 6D&  "!4  &*323I"!4 &$4%B%'7  ;  & :  # #  !'  ;%&  '#  # D!&% #  ;

' $ && 4@ HD '& &%'; -   'A!"'#% 2 *-* 4 '$;2%& 4*!D@!"#4 "& : # #%&

$; # & '' H54  *!> 8 42; # " '# ' " 47 %'7 &$4%B #  ;  & :  # #2  &;  :&!  D5  ; 4 &%7'

54 I;56B6 4A #!' $;D 7 !"; & %#& :

# #B5>; '%> &B %'7 A '%'; !""%$ !";

-5B 7%&4 4%& 4"!4%&4 7%&4 %!'2; # " '# 4 &%: #"4!67 %'74 7%& 4 #; & : # #%'"

8!54 !"; D:

%'%""*J ,-

4

      

 !



-9-?(-,( 5 "!     (-,/6 "

)

   2

F<* ;

  " :%'7  774% 8 #  B@  ' 7 %8  %5# ' "

4%!5& $!"; # " '# '2; D:

%'%"""%: #

$!6D:

%'  !'  0%'#!>  8%#  !*

III??  #  #  )  $!D@

$; # &'' H54  3 '#; # " '# 'B %'7

'%'":5 '% :D 4&!'7!$!6D4!6%& #; %&&5 %';

D!:%$ & %!' *-*- # 42%& 4!'3$!D@

$; # &'' H54  ?

%'>;%$;; # " '# D4!$54 #; &  6 '!"; D:

%'%"";

; 6 ;

&  B '  $!6D4!6%& #  B@  ;  # " '# '  '#  ;

# " '# '>%::7 ; & : # #4 7%& 4 #'"

8!54 !"  ;  D:

%'%""2  B5  ;  # " '# '  ;

&  '!  7!

4 7%& 4 #; & : # #%'G5 &%!'%'"

8!54!";

D:

%'%""&!"

4 '#; # " '# ';

&B '4@%'7!

4 &%: IB $A #  !5  "4!6  ;  $!6D4!6%&  44%8 # 

B "!4 ; D!:%$ !';  B!8 & %# DD:%$ %!'!";

D:

%'%""*J ,, D ,(  2 F* ;

; # " '# '> & &A #6 '@%6 &!

#6%; 4%7;&!"; D:

%'%"" '#!7 ; & : # # H $5 # '#4 7%& 4 #%'; 4"

8!54%' $$!4# '$ >%;;  46& '#$!'#%%!'&!";  74 6 '&!& ::

#  #    '#  :&!  '!  !  #%&D!&& &&  ;

D:

%'%"""4!6; &5%:

'#B5&; ;

&4 "5& #!#!&!

@ & 4# @ '#; '$ ; D4 & '&5%*J ,(        5 "

  

  !

 54

 

5    !  ! !  !



  <



     7  !!

     5

 ,+ 4 "   

  1 =

!" ! 

   

 ! 



  '   < "   4



 ! 

!6 "

   "

! "    4 45  

*   ! * *

A&;%8*4$;B%&;!D!" '7 :!4 2C%8%:DD :!*!"2 # $%# #!'**-33 6 ;4  1  

 

  1 =

!"!  4    !            

!     !    

 8 ** ,,!



!   ,@    "" > 45 6 ;4  1

 ! & ; B

6# &-;%4!:  4&*8* !;%' 4D4%& & 4&*  %8%:

 ,.

   "" > 45 6 ;4  1  

  ! /5:

'#;5

6# 4&;-;

 8*  6&  & 4%8

,%6% #  '#  '4* C%8%:  DD :  !*?3  !"  2  # $%# #  !'

**2, (<)33E*   

"  "       

!



!      

" 1 =

!"! 6   



      < 

 ,?  ! 

         

!  

"!   < >

  4   "  5 4    

>

 

,) *

  <   454

   

4

   

"! ' <     45         !

   

 "

  

 

 ,9 '

    !



!

    5    ,/    

03  !5    ! ./   0,

  

B45 4@)2 <  %

 >  7   %

 4