High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO-CARB/36/2022dismissed

Chandigarh Housing Board v. Jai Bhushan Malik, Contractor And ANR.

2022-10-11Mr. Justice Augustine George Masih,Mr. Justice Alok Jain12 pages

"# ! $$%%&& '!# (

# &)* !! ! $$ % ++++ ,! !- %. /#*.!. #&0 %&,#!*1! %%&& ++++

,!2! %%&!&2 2& %%& ! ! 3 %%&* 3 &&0&2 2& %%&

,!2! %%& ! 43% !3 & !%24#! (# 355 ! !3 %%&*3&&0 43% !%!2!

! "# %!%%& 7%!!!3%# 0!

-2-

8%72 !7!! !!55* !72* &! & ! (# *

* 3 % #! . 9 !7!

&* :: !!!!! ;<#% & 0!&2=%!3 ! 0! 7 #% &&2 !3! 3 7! * #&! %%&&

#73*! %%&&&!!%!1 /! .#%%&2 >* .0! >* .!3 /! ! .23* . "!1 .!##!!5995.3&&& *

6 !%0 ##&7!0&& !

!1&# *:*99*8:

? ! 74#0 3 0 9

6 %#& ! 3%& 0!) 0

7# 3&2 ::@ 0!)03%&0 &2A3 ! 0!)03%&

=#73 &7&&72 !% 0 !& 5 A.#7B# !* !%! %##73 &3#! &&0

# !! C! 2A3 #637! .

#! !.!3/! .0! 6!

#!> &.#!2% ,23& && 9 # ! C4/!

-3-

A # =&& & 1!2 !3 % & # 1!2#! " 1!2 8 # 37#!3 > 3 .#! # %!& ! %! 0 #!!#1!#7! %!3# 1&7&2 &! D &2 #%%&2 ! * !B#!#%%&3!2 !3 5 #=&& & 1! : #> #

# ! E 5@ %! #3 ,! !!* ##!

# !7! &!!7!!!!! %! 0&2!&1 3!*0#&%& ! 7&2 #3* %! !!* ! 1!2 &3 & &&0 3!

&3F &&0 #3 :* * 8A: #!! ! 72A3

&3F F&* # 637! .

#! !!3*0!0!

&3F &&0 @!%!#3! &2 %!

9 3

B#&23#5*88*85

-4-

&&0

&3F9 F&*# ! 40! !

&3FA &&0 #3 A*

*5 # && & !1!2 !3 3&&#%3&

&3F &&0 #3 *8* # !1!2 #! 3&&#!1!2

&3F8 &&0#3& *5:*8 *AA # !37#!3 & 3 #!#%!& !%!0 #!!# 1!# 7! %!3 # 1&7&2&!D&2 #%%&2 ! * !B# ! #%%&3!2 !3

&3F5 &&0 #3 A*9* : #&& &!1!

&3F: F&*#&7#

&3F &&0 @!%!#3

&3F

F&* # !7! "01!* !% & &&2 7# %2 -.6 1&&2 % 3* 3# &&

-5-

7!37#!72 !% %%&&%!!! %#!. 9 7! &!&!(# *

72& 7G % %# !! 72 !7!! &!&!(# *

*%%! 1!27G!72 %%&&&0 &&0

! ! " # " $ %

&& " ' # ( '" )

" $ *+,-&&.-/01 *23 " * ,/3 4 " ( " " " " ,* ,& +,**

"""

( " /, ** +,** ( "4 " ",5 ,- +,*+ ( " " 6, --37 " /, ,2 +,*/

-6-

( 8 " " """ "

( " ,& ,

+,*5 ( " " " 9 " $ *-*2..5 -, : 5, " #; " $ -//2/,01 # " ;" $ *5** *,01 " < # <; " $ *.+* /01 $ = % < $ " $ + -./,5501 "" "

"; " $ 5,&2/-01 ; 9 ">* 3 " " ?(" 9 " " $ *+,-&&.-/ ,, (

-7-

" >*53 $ * *&*.*

-5 9

" $ /&,*+,-/ ,,+ 3 * .3 " 4 >*53

( /, " @

" " 9 " " " ) 1 1 A

B ! & 0 7G* &! & ! (# *

&# %%&& & 3!21&! !#1&7&#!. 9

-8-

!7! & >!#&! %%&& 1 3&2! # 0! % 72 !7!! !! % 72 &! & ! (# ;,#7& ,&2< = 72 % ! ! 3% H &30!72 !7!!%&&2#! &38072 %#!10 !>!#&! %%&& !& #% G# 3 % 72 372 " #! &

*#73 &3 !72 !7!! # !37#!3 & 3 #! # %!& ! %! # 1!# 7! 72 %!3* !7!! %%& "# !3#&0 # !7 2%1&72 &3 ! #3 %%&&##! ! &! !7!! 0! !! ! 7! !0! %%&& 1!### 1&7&2&!D&2#%%&2 !0 D&2%! #%%&3!2 !3!1!* !017!# !!3!!#! #3!2%! &2& 1 #!!#2 %! !%3&2*1 &7&&0 0 #73 2!

0 &! 2! A 6 !7!! !&&2!! 0 %%&&!%!7! 7! !#&2 4#0!)

-9-

!! & !0!1!

&*# %!& 2 !! 3 !#& & %! 0&& ! &2*0 &%%&2 "#!3#&* !7!! ! !& &! #& ! %%&& 1 3&2 ! # 0! %#7&%&2=7##& % # 0 0! 0 #! %!%& 67

" 9 !; 67 9; 67 4 " ; 67 * & 0 ! !3#& 37 %#7&%&2= !! #3!72 #&! %%&& 2 ! !%! 0 %&#7& %7& %!2 !#&1&7& &72 "<7&.#%!3 #!= !

"##$$%&'( )# * +" (*, ,#!

@*.

9" " 9 + -,

# * . $/ "##$" 8 /&

C @+& (/& "

-10-

A " " " " /&

)"4 ( " /& " 4 " 9 "" " @ I% 10 &2 3!* & %%&& &7! %!%%&0 #! !! 7 %% ;%#7& %&2< = #%& 0 %0! #! . 8 ! 4!3&2 !#3!7 6 %%&& & 3! 2 1& ! !# 1&7& #! . 8 0 ! #! !!!00. 8 0 !#!

01 2

3 & 6*7 DE " F "

-11-

6 "7 " " C D67 ; 67 " -; 67 /& F 6+7

" 67 1 6+716/7 *2; 67 " "*.

6/7 E "

" B =&72 G# 3%72"<7& .#%!3 #!= !

"## $$% & '( )# * + " (*, ,*0 ! &#!

*5 4 /& " /.

-12-

4 8" "" GGGGGGG

B %!#& 71%!1 &0&0 72 "<7& .#%!3 #! =* 3 &!&2 3! 0!7 && &2 !#371 %G#&!10!7!&0!1!2!!0= %!* !4!72 %%&&&2%!! &2%23 !!1 &7&&0 0 #7372 !%

* 30!&! 02!03 72 %%&&5 A*0 & 0 # %%&& "01!* & 71 & %!% &0 #%&0 %%&&&&0 #!. 8 * %!%%&7 12 3!!173 !!! &2 ! # ! # $%&'()

.% / !%) ?! J?F / ! %!7& J?F