Ashok Kumar v. Punjab State Information Commission And Others
! "# # $ %
&'()*+,-.
%%%%%/0101(2/.
3/.&+& +24-560-0/27(.,-01(2(,,1&&1(2-28(0'/.&%%%%/&9(28/20& %
&'()*+,-.
%%%%%/0101(2/.
3/.&+& +24-560-0/27(.,-01(2(,,1&&1(2-28(0'/.&%%%%/&9(28/20& %
&'()*+,-.
%%%%%/0101(2/.
3/.&+& +24-560-0/27(.,-01(2(,,1&&1(2-28(0'/.&%%%%/&9(28/20& -0/(78/:1&1(2 % % ; < =;% 63* 6
=
>>>> 3* 6
=? %! =$ !
" " #$ %&&&& %&%' () * + ,* #**(-#$ %&&%. %&%'() *+
,*#**(-#$ %&&/' %&%'
() *+ ,*#** ( #" 01 23
,*#** 4 ,*%&&.0(45,(3 %
6
45,
1 1 !"" $* "
,*7
"
$*"
8 /9!2 %&%%0 *#$ %&&&& %&%'3-
8 /9!/ %&%%0 *#$ %&&%. %&%'3
8 /9!. %&%%0 *#$ %&&/' %&%'3"
5" &2 &'
%&%'" ,* #**
8 /9!2 %&%%
8 /9!. %&%%" " * 5 &2 &'
%&%'
01 /3
8 /9!2 %&%% "
!" !
!# $%$$ &
$ %$$%$
'
!$" !(" !)" ! $%$$ *
+*
, -
, $% * &, &
.*/" &
, %
'
,
$% 0!1 +* , .*/
"
"
2 ,
.*/
!%% $%$*
3
4 ,& "
, (
&
5/+6 .*/
-
-
*
+* "$%%("
.*/"5 .*/"5 . "2 7 " ""
8 /9!2%&%%
8 /9!.%&%% *" * : ,* #** ,7 * "'&* " %&0!345," ,7 "
#** " /. * *" ,
8 /9!/%&%%" *#$ %&&%.%&%' "
#**"
!&* * ";
* , "
*
*
* * "*) ,7"
* 5 ,* #** *
**) * <2(-:01(2 ./@+1./8= *
" 11 2 " ""
* * ,*#** " <
= '
> *
,*#** "
#** " " *) * *
,*#**" " *
**
"" ) , *
8 /9!2%&%%"
8 /9!.%&%% "* "
*
*
&2 &'
%&%' " *
,*#**
%&45,%&&. * ,"
8 /9!/%&%% " *
#** *
!'
&'
%&%'
01 .3"#$ %&&%. %&%' * * " *"
" "**"" , *
" "" # <
! !"# $%& " !'()&*&( < + ,-
)* $
>
*
,*#**
?
,*#** " "
)
/
> * ,* #** " ) ) *# . + . 1
.
5# )
5# . !$* & & "
-&
,
, ,&
,
",
, 22, , " ,
,
,
"
& & ,
5 $" ,"
.*6 ,
, +8
24
*
0 1" &
,&
&" &
: &
&
&
" "
$%%(" ;
,
, , " ,& , ;
"
, 2
" " "
,&
"
,
; < * ,
&
" ,
- &
&
, & 8 &
$%%(
, , & &
&
*
"
"
,
&
6&
,
5 $
&
, + &
,
8
24
&
5 ;8 ,, ; 8
!= 01 $%%(
, ; "
&
8
,
&
"
" " &
3
! *
, ; 8
& , 8 8
&
8 &,
&
> 8 & *
&
7
8
>
?-
.& @
A
B? A/ 7
$%!% 01
0 &1#($" ,
<<<<<<
(! C
& "
* *
8
,
" &
& "
8 ;38
*
& , 8 8
,
&
< 8
;38 &
& , <
&
<
&&
&
8 8 ";38
&
&
8 &,
+
8
,
& &
&
+&
8
8
8 D & ;38
8
, &
& ,
&
& 8 & +
E 8 & 8 * ;
8
*D
;38
-
, ,
"
F 3 E
; , &
*
;
8 , +
8
8 02&
2 D
0!=# 1!%%4 ,
@, &, !3 1
;
" ;
,&
,
D 0!== 1!=64((" ()$ $=
&9 & /<
"$%%!6G & %(",
) 6
&
4 , ; "H ;
& 8 H * ,8 8
&
+ " &
," ;
&
&
H2.
H <<<<<<7
5# * +
. <=+
8
$!% $%$ G.3!((%%3$%$ : : B
*
7",
,
3
*
!=01 , $% $%%(" &
(&
$#%$$%$0
< .!!1
, 3 +
3, , &
* &, "
.*/ &
&
,
+
7 ) &3
, ,
" * ,
3, &
" .*/
&
&
,
4 ,& " ,
" *
, 8
, , != +* , ,
3 "
&
* *
"
3 0#1"
* & & ,
, ;
&
!= +* "
, 3 !=I0!1 , "
&
, 3 0!1 01 3
01 "
&
. * / .* / " ",
<
,
.* / . * / " .
& <
, &
0$1G
.* / .*
/ " "
!!
"
,
01
3 0!1 , ,
& , & " ,
* *
.
&
* * " " <
, &
0 1*
.* / .* / " " ,
"
* * "
" &
0(1*
" & ; ,8
.*
/ .* / " ",
; 0)1
3 0!1 3 0$1
,
,
<
<
3&
"
,
0 1+
* * " "
0#1* "
* * " " , I 01 ; , & "
I 01 &
" ; "
J 01
.* / .* / " J
01
J 0&1
"
J 0&1
&
J 0&1 &
,
, 01 3 0!1 J 01 ;
J 01 &
J0
8 0=1+
* *
" " &
"
"
0!%1+
* *
" "
, # $% +* & "
*
"
.* / ", "
,
0!1
; " " ,
,
$% +*
3 $% . I0!1 G
*
* " "
.* / .*
/ " "" , "
&
,
3 0!1
; ,
&
"
,, 8 ;
" !)
,
& " ,& "
< ,
3&
.
&
.* / .* / " " &
.
&
&
.*
/ .* / " 0$1G
* * " "
. * / .* / " "",
"
&
,
3 0!1
; ,
&
"
,, 8 ;
"
.* /
.* / " "
& 7 = 8
&
& , ,
&
" "
"
;
8 * " *
" $% +* " ; *
"
& ,
5 01
01
.*/
& " &
5 $ , ,
, 8
" <
"
&
7 + * " . 8" , 8
!=01 $%%(,
;8
," " ; 8
"
, ;
8
+
& 3<
&
& +
3
!%
&, &
"
&G .
,
%)%$%$0
< .3=1
* " . 8
5 ($ $%$ &
+ *
". 8"
,
+
*
". 8" $ %#$%$ !! * " ,& "
&
, * " . 8"
, , !$+
"
K0, 8
!=0!1L
K0, 8
!=01L
"&
3
& 8
>
& 4
&
$%%(* " "
& ,
$%%(
,
8
1 +
,
-
$%%( 1+
3, , 1
,
"
, &1* "
,
& $%%( " "
,
-"
, -
&1 & ,
!+ . 8A4
&
"
8
!'()&*&(
+ 7
/
) & !'()$&&( 7,
/
) & !'()00( # !
#1 /!// 7"
, 7 @
, "
" ,*#**"&2 &'
%&%'
01 /3
8 /9!2 %&%%0 *#$ %&&&& %&%'3
8 /9!/ %&%% 0 * #$ %&&%. %&%'3 5
8 /9!2 %&%' " " ,7
*"
* * " * !& &/ %&%'
> "
#**" /. * * " ;
* 5 "
8 /9!2%&%%
8 /9!.%&%%A011 .3" " #$ %&&&& %&%'#$ %&&/'
%&%'B* ,7* * ;
),7 " * * 5
,*#**
" " **)*<2( -:01(2 A-& ./@+1./8= 5 * ) " ,
8 /9!/ %&%' " &2 &'
%&%' "
#** " !& * * 5
!'
&'
%&%'A01 .3"#$ %&&%. %&%'B* *
C
"
5 "*
,*#**
"
) " " *
01 23" ,*#** *
?
01 .3"
) $ ,* #** " ) " " # . + . "" !% * + .
!&
5
,*#** %% &D %&%'
5 ,* #** " *1
" **
,*#**
!3* 6
=$ 6/90/,5/. ? ) $? )E F $ E F