Sri Guru Hargobind Educational Society v. Union Of India And Others
! "
## ! ! $!%%
&
'!% ## !%(
% !"#$%
&'()*% )%&*!%
(*!+ *!(
!%!
)# *+ ++
',- . !& '!(! !+ *+
! '- . !&!%(
% +/ 0+ )%&*!%
(*!+ *!( &
,-
! !#% ! " & !
'! , (! %!!2 *
3%& '!!%(
# 4 2 !&!!5!
,
% +!+!
+67809:;;:;;;;;/<8
.
+6709;;;:;;;:<9:63 " '!% ' & '!(! !# % ! "+ ((!
"- !%(
+6 * 4 ' % !
% %% '! & '!% ! " %3!3! '3
% '% %% (!
!&! '! 3(! !
+ 33 !
=+7+9;:8((!
!>! #:< , !.! ' '! 2'%&5!
'!
% "& '!
!% ' %33 %%%!
" '! -@ ' '.!!!
!
!.!
" '! 2+ '! 3!(&(! 3 "'! !&!
'% 9=+8+9;:8
,' ! %% ! & 3 '!
!%(
2 '!%3%% & %! ' !!
' % '
! %' !!
%%!
" '! , '! &!!5 & '!
%
%% '- '! & '! 2,% "
! +
%! ' %( & ' '! && "! & " '!% ! " ! ! % '! %% " % , %!3( "!!%& '!
% ' +
'!%%!?!
!&'! +!+/+:;+9;:8((!
,%( !' && '! 2
3!,%%' & !!( "+ '! %!&!%3!
'! - '%!!
((%!
' & !%!. !& '! 2 '! - '! 2'% ,
'%!
& ! (( %!!2 % &3 '! '!
(!
% & !
"!%(
+6A* 4 'B,'! '! &!!5!
!&!!5! '!%.
% % !
+ % '(( - '!& , !'%!!
(%%!
" '!
9<+:;+9;:8)#
!"#$%"$& '
()""!*(+,-. )$/0$1, $ (*(+,
"+& 223*1 !*((4", 3##%"#"(% (! #$ %"#$""5*(+##$""5*(+# 110(!. $"."(!& , +%"6*(+,%60(."3#$23 *(!*## ,""2 7 7,*) %63#$%"#"(% (!. 8
,/*$*.,%%61 !"0(."3#$%"#"(% (! 0(."3#$%"#"(% (!
,*.$%"$#9*("., 33%*.2."# ( 223*1 !*(96"% 4:%"#"(% (! 0() 4 !*( 3 (7$ (1, 7,; 3 % 0%,* ( .""7*(+%*$"1!*(.#$"*!,"$!#$""5"$%"<#$""5"!," 6*(+ (7110(!=>?
'
= (%0$$"(!110(!
=>?
' ,"3% ;*!, *! *( !," ( 9" # $* /0$0 $+4*(%%01 !*( 31*"!:," $%!,"%0(."3.#$!," 2 $!*". (% , 6" 1 $"#033: +(" !,$0+, !," #*3" ," 223*1 (!"#"(% (! *(!," 223*1 !*(, .1(!"(%"%!, !!,"
2$"."(!.0*!, .4""(#*3"%4:23 *(!*##. + *(.!%"#"(% (!. 9(+.! ;,9!," 223*1 (!4 (7, .4""( $$ :"% .%"#"(% (! 4:
!,"9 (%!, !4".*%".!,*..0*! ;$*!2"!*!*(4" $*(+@< =?=
!*!3"% .A$* $+4*(%%01 !*( 31*"!:-. (*(#(%* "!1B , . 3.4""(#*3"%*(!,"(B43"0() 48 $: ( *+,0$! , (%*+ $, $"+ $%*(+ !," .04)"1! 9 !!"$ *( ;,*1, (B43" $ 0.!*1" )*(%"$*(+,,*(%. , % %)0$("%!,". *%@$*!"!*!*( 6*%"$%"$% !"%
!=
#$1(.*%"$ !*( (% !,"$"#$"%*$"1!*(.4"+*6"(!!," 223*1 (!%"#"(% (! #$ #$""5*(+$%"#$""5*(+!,"4 (7 110(!#!,". *%1*"!:
2((!*1"23 *(!*##.#*3"%$"23:.! !*(+!,"$"*(!, !!," %"#"(% (!. !', 6"( 0!,$*!:!2"$ !"!,"4 (7 110(!. "C130.*6"3: !!,"*$;(," 110(!47.;"$"4"*(+2"$ !"%4: 23 *(!*## (%%"#"(% (! )*(!3:40!(;!,"." 110(!. $"
*33"+ 33:4"*(+2"$ !"%4:%"#"(% (! ;,, .($*+,!#$!,"
. 9" 4: "C130%*(+ !," 23 *(!*## #$9 2"$ !*(+ !,"." 4 (7 110(!.(!,*.; :!,"%"#"(% (! 3(+;*!,%"#"(% (!.
(%' (%!,"$%"#"(% (!. $"1 0.*(+."$*0.2$")0%*1"!!," $*+,!.#!,"23 *(!*## (%, 6" 3.1 0."."$*0.3..!!,".1*"!: (%!,".1,3($%"$!2$!"1!9(":#$94"*(+; .!"% !!," , (%.#%"#"(% (!. !'*!*.%".*$ 43"!#$""5"!," 110(!.
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
"$0. 3#!,"#*3".,;.!,":, 6"4""( 22" $*(+*(!,"10$!( " $3*"$ % !" #!"$ 96*(+ # !," 223*1 !*( #$ 2$"2("9"(! ;"6"$!,":%*%(!#*3" (:$"23: (!,"!,"$, (%%"#"(% (! 4 (7$"D0".!"%!%*.2."##!," 223*1 !*(D0 4 (7 110(!. 9"(!*("%*(!," 223*1 !*(%0(."3#$!," 223*1 (!%"#"(% (! 4 (7.! "%!, !9 !!"$4"!;""(!,"2 $!*".*. 3.2"(%*(+*( !,"(B43" *+, 0$! (% !," 4 (7 *. .022."% ! #*3" $"23: $"+ $%*(+ 110(!.*(D0".!*(4"#$"!,"(B43"*+,0$!," 23 *(!*## .;"33 .%"#"(%(! 3.$"D0".!"%#$%*.2.*(+##!
223*1 !*(!% :*!."3#*(6*";#!,"0$+"(1:*(636"%(6*";#!," 46"# 1!. (%1*$109.! (1". (%7""2*(+*(6*";!,"# 1!!, ! 2043*19(":*.*(636"%!,*.10$!%""9.*!#*!!%*$"1!!,"4!,!," 2 $!*".!, !!," 110(!.*(D0".!*(9 :(!4"2"$ !"%;*!,0! 2$*$2"$9*..*(#!,"10$!!*33%*.2. 3#!," 223*1 !*(0' $03" (% 2"(%*(+*(!,"2$"."(!1 ." .*(!"$*9$"3*"#D0 . *% 110(!., . 3.4""(.0+,!*(!,". *% 223*1 !*( (%!," 9 !!"$ D0 2"$ !*( # !," 110(!. *( D0".!*( *. 3. ! 4" 1(.*%"$"% ;,*3" %"1*%*(+ . *% 223*1 !*( % : $"23: ! 223*1 !*(0
$03" , . 3.4""(#*3"%;!,"1 ."*.
%)0$("%!'
#$1(.*%"$ !*(( 223*1 !*(0
03" .;"33 .#$#*3*(+;$*!!"(.! !"9"(!(4", 3##
%"#"(% (!.,39 %*.%*$"1!"%!."(% 12:#!,*.$%"$!!," 1(1"$("%4 (7 %< 3)*(%"$ 0$ *6*30%+"E$*6*.*(F 0%,* ( '
!"#$%"$& ' G
3& !- '% %& '!.!, ' '!& & '!
(( '!'
%& '!!%(
2,% & ! ''
"& ! '!"' !!
%!.!
& '!( !!
% '! , (! + & !%% '! 2 ' '.! %'
%C & %! %&!!5 & '!
%( '. ! " !%+ (( ,%3.!
" 99+:;+9;:8-,'!!% '!
%' ! "!!
&5!
( ( & 3!+!+ =+7+9;:8+ ! ' % 3"- '! @ ' % ,%!5!
& '!%%!+ '%!!
&3!
' (( '% %!!
& !
" !&!
% +:
9 '!%
,''((!
! '!'3
!% & '! (! !% ! " %!!2 (!3%% & '! &
!&!!5
&(! '!
% + .!,& '!(!
& %
3%
!%& '! %!- '!
% %(%!
&, ' '! @ ' ! '!(( 3.!
!' && '! !% & '!
(! !% ! "!>(!
% "
" %!, ' (! &%>,!!2% &3 "+
! % %(%!
&+
)%&*!%
(*!+ *!(
&'+%
2"
D'! '!%(!2 C!% ) !%C D'! '! !( !) !%C