Katar Singh And ORS v. State Of Haryana And ORS
!" !#"$%& '
&
& (()*
* +,(- ..// 0 , 1 . !2)
!3%4 2$", 2 , 5, 24+
!"#
!" $ " $$
$!$ $! !%&" !%&$ $'$% ''
! '
!
!"
!
"%# #%
#%$& %&'"
% (
%'$ %&'#
) *
"
# # #$ " % ! $ $$ $ && "!
%&'" +
"$$
"$
'' $
$ ! ! # %&'" ) ,-
# %&'" .
,/
/
,/
#%## #%# %&'" %#"$ %#"
%&'# - *+0 1+
!&& %&'" $ $!& %&'#
20
#''
#'"
( !
%&'" *
%
%&'# .
3
''# %&'"
2.
4 5
## #! %%% %&'#
+ , .+ 2. +
$ $$ &&'
%&'"
* 6
!!&"
%&'"
# ' % '
%'"
%&'# 20 )+
- / 25
,- 6 /
7
- 8+09 :;< =
% , 9 :;< =
7 8+0 + 9 :;< = >>>>> 2 , 5, 24+6$ , - 5+
+ - +
?+
5
00
!
+
!
!"
! "%# # " % #%
#%## #%$& # # #$ ! $ $$ $ && "!
%&'"
% %%% %#"$
%#"
%&'# -
+
?+
'$ & %&& + ?+ '$ "
@ @ 0 / #"
+
!"#
!" $ "$$
"$ " $$ #%# ''#
'' $!$ $! !%&" !%&$ !!&" $'$% $
$ ! $ $$ &&' ''
#''
#'" ! !&& ! ' ! # %&'" ## #! # ' $ $!& ' % ' %
%'"
%'$ %&'# -
+
?+
&$ & %&& + 1
+
- + /
?+
0 + / - - AB6 B
'$ & %&& + 0 - % &# %&& +
-5/ 0
+
+
!
"
#
?+ )
+
2
'
'$ '& %&'&
% '$ '& %&'&
# '& '' %&'&
1 - - ,
1 / )
0+ 0
+0
' &&&&&<B
/ . C - 58 + '$
?+
0+
&' &% %&'"
"% 0
%&&&&&&<B
+
&D .
+
+
0 / &$ & %&& +
?+ 0 -
& '& %&& +
0 +
+ -
+
$
%
&
" ' !
( )
% #
* ' $ "
+
!
!
"
%
?+ )
+
-
2
%# '$ &# %&'&
% &! %&'&
%!
'$ &$ %&'& .
+ -
+0
' &&&&&<B
C - 58 + '$
?+
''
0
00
' &' %&'"
0 0 5+ /
&D .
+
+ -
5
0+
)+ -
-
-
5
?+
0 + 3- - +
/
5 + + 0
!
%&'"
*
2 /
+
?+ -
7 + + '$ & %&& 0 /
+
?+ &$ & %&& -+
%&'"
8
2 /
4 +
0
/
- /
0 +
-
?+ .
+
+
?+ - + + '$ & %&& - -
+
?+
- E
5 - -
5 +
'!
'$ 0+
&' &% %&'"
4 + 5 / 0
- / C 0 +50 / + 5 5 + - 0 3 + +50 +/ 8+ / 0 /
.
+
+
B - -+ + 0 + -
?+ -
5 + - - ,/ -+ + +50 / 0 /
+/ +
.
+
- - 5+ / + / - /
* 0 / F .
+ 4 +
B - + +50
+ - - 5 /
+
5 + - - 0+
0+
+
+
5
+ +
++
5
0+
+ ,
- /
- + 5/ 0
- 0 0+
&' &% %&'"
-+ - +
/ + + - E
0+
0 + #&D + ?+ 0 .
+ + - 0 #&D +
+ 0 #&D + / 0 +
0+ -+ 0
%'$'%$!<B
3- -+
+
5+ 0-
8+0 / ;F '
0 /
.
+
+
5 + -/ 0
0+
+
-
'!
'$ 0+
5
+ - + . 5 E
5
5
5
+ F0 + 5 .
.
+
,
-
- 0
+5 8+ 5-
-
.
+
+ . 5/
+
+ ;F 7'%<1
;F 7'%<) + -
;F
-
;F % + -+ 0
%#"#" " !# - +
%#"#" #<B
E 5 3@5 +0 28/ +89( : ;-<6 (= 0 , #:9> 6
;7<, -
5
+
+
- .
+ 0 8+0 3@5 +0 "&0, 16
; < , 7
5
3@5 +0
'!
( '$ 8+0 "&@ + - +/ -
+ , " "
' "
- ""
" ." "
"
"/ " "
' "
"
0 .
"
"
+"/1
2' "
'"
"
' " '
"
"
" "
'"
"
? .
* 1 -
"-
"
/"
"
'
"
- "
" "
" "
"
'"
" .
2 - /"
"
"-
"
" # "
/"
''
"
) 4"
"
'
4"
''
-"
"
" "
4 "
" "
" "
60 - "
2" 1 1
-'
" "
0
" / "
/ .
/
"
.
"
"
" 7
"
' "
2 -'
"/ / "
%
"
%
- 3 %%%%%89
4"
.1 " "
$ 1 %% "
-'
" " 3 (
1 / "
"
.
"
:4:
/ "1 3 (%
1 / "
.""
"
-
" 3 %(%%%89 3 !%%%89 '
"0 1 / "
" '
" /
09 90 "
4 ";
) 4"
<"
''
.1 " + "
" '"
-.
%%!
"
-'
" / "
" "
" 3 ( % '
"0 1 - 7
"
3 ( %%89 3 !! %%89 = " " "
-'
" "
" 0
.
.1 "
4 " "
"-
"
-
" "
/ "
/"
"-
"
"
+ "
"
) 4"
" ''
> "
/ !
/- "
"
"/ " "
/- "
"
"
"
4 " "
"
' "
-"
0
.
" 7 /- "
4 1 "
"
'0 / "
' 1- "
"
"- "
"
" -"
."
"
' "
-- 7
" "
"
' 1- " "
'
" "
"-
' - 1 ' " = -"
" 1 " = "
'
"
/1 -'
"
/ "
" "
"
' 1- "
"
-'
" . "
?
-
4" 0
/"
/ " .
"
-'
" - ""
1 +"
" "
0
.
+ "
.
" 7 "
/ "
" "
"
"
% (?
."
/"
'" %%?
/ "
'"
" .
. * -- * "
' "
" "
"
- 1
-"
-
" "
"
"" " "
-'
" /2 .1 "
) 4"
"
"
"
"
4 " " -"
.
-
0 .
" "
" "
"
"
0
.
'.
/ " " ." "
" -
" '
.
/ "
-'
" "
"
' 1- "
-'
" .
' 0 -"
" = " 0 "
- ""
"
' " "
"" " 1 " "
/ "
-'
" '
" 0
-"
% "
' "
"
'"
" "
/- - -"
.
+
'
0 "
'- "
"
' 0 "
% /
"
0
-" "
.
-"
" "
/"
" /
" "
"
-" "
''
"
/1
"" " 1 " "
"
'"
" "
"
.
/1 * .1 "
) 4"
.1 "
4"
-"
"
-' *
" "
" . ''
.
'' .
"
' "
.
" 7 ' "
" '
"
"
" "
1 ' "
60 - "
. "1
" /" "
'
"
/ "
" "
4" "
;
' / "
'. "
2"
/ "
2" 1
- " "
-'
" .
20 1
"
"
' 1 " 0
'
'0 4 "; "
1 - 1 "
"
- 1 "
"
.- 1 "
/ "
"
"
0 5
"
.
-'1
" 0 "
'
-
" ''
"1 /"
"
. / -'
"@A , F ?+ -
+ 0
.
+
E 0
+ +
5+ +
5
5 -
B8 . 0+
-
5 / + E ?+ / + - +
+0 E
- + + 5 0
+ ?+
5 / 0 -
- +
. 0 / +
*
-
-
++ + 0
.
+
,
- 5 . +
+ 0 C 1 8+0
>,(-0,
#:9>:-4@:((( //6#(/6
*;< ; (A(/<*6 - + - 3@5 +0
,
5
C 1 '% (
8+0
>,(-3 + -
/
/
+ ,
" "
''" .
.1 "
);.
4"
B' C " "
"
"
' .1 "
- " -' - '"
"
"
" .
''
0 "
" "
) 0 "
/ ''" "
.
"" "
" "
' "
.
" .1 "
4"
.1 "
$
"
" "
"
" "
" "
-' -" 6 3 " "
"
"
"
"
.19 ' "
" " "
6 3 " "
" ' 7' "9'-' "
= " 0 "
- ""
" . 0 " -
.1 "
);.
4"
!
"##$ %"& '''
$()* "##$
+", - 1 .
" D ,
''" " "
"
'.
"
'
"
-
"
'"
"
."
''" "
0 -" "
.
-.
" " 7
" "
"
'
" .1 "
- '" =/ "
" "
.
0 "
'" ' .
.
/ "
''
/ "
- '"
" "
'
" ""
"
/" '- " "
''
" "
0
/ ''
-' "
"
5"
" "
"
"
'" 00 "
" "
.
"/ "1 "
0
" "
"
/ " " " + "
"
'
1 -" "
'.
" "
"
"
"
"
= '
"
"
/ "
"
-
0 "
0 .
"
"
1 /"
'- "
" / "
0 " "
"
) 4"
''1
"
''
"
"
/ - 7 0
/- 3%89 1 " 3(% 1 = ' " +"/ "
/ " -" "
A <
"
/ "- .1 "
);.
'
4"
=
E0
) 4"
% - . & / !
"##0
+#, /D ,= 0 "
. 0 " -
.1 "
'
4"
1 '' .
" "
-""
1 "
" 1
'
" "
0 "
'" "
" .
/ .
'' ="
'0
0
" "
"
" "
"
""1 -- "
"
/
"
0 " "
"
. "
$
"
+"/ "
%?
/- "
- 7 0 " /
" "
' "
"
"
. "
$
/2
"
- 7 0
3 (89 %?
9.+ " " / "
"
. "
$
-/ " "
2"
"A E -+ /
/ - -
- -+
+ + 0+0 +
5
- / C 0 + B5
1 + - -+
5 + - -
/
0 5/ 0 + )
-
0
- -+ 8+
F
#&D
. -
+ =
/
8+0 & &" %&&$ ;,:9(,(- 4 (>,(-0 , #:9>:- 4@:((( //< E ,:9(,(-@ + 5 #&D .
+ -
+
-
:4 ) ,
5
,:9(,(-@ +
+ ,= '
"
/ "
''
"8 - " .-""
" "
"
''
"
"" " "
(%?
"
- 7 0
= "
' "
1 2 . ' 3 4 $555 %"& 6
!
+05!
83 /
.
/
"#99 8 :,#5!
; 4 .
83 /
"#95 8 '!,)+!
83 / !
.
%$55$<$& 8 '9,+
83 / !
. ' 4 "#9# 6
7
!
00)!
.
83 / "#9) 6
,#"
- .
83 / "##) %$& 8 : ,"0 F "
"
&461 '"1
0 "
&+ . ''
.
/ "
' " ''
"
" "
''
" "
"
E""
$
"
-'
" /- "
""
" 7
" " "
"
.
" 7
.1 "
4 " ="
.
.-""
" "
"
-'
" "
: .
83 /!
%'= ;
""("
"##"& %%%% .1 " 4"
"
.
-
"
. / "
- "
-'
" "
-
" "
// "
0
"
4"
.
'
:2 &9 "
" "
-
0
'
"
# #( 1
-" ' " "
"
"/ " "
"
" = '
"
"
.
" "
%?
"
- 7 0
"
"
/ 1 "
/ = 0
/ "
' " 0
"
" " " ="
'"
" "
"
''
" 0
' :2 &9
"
" 7 - " "
0
' / 3 #%%%89 - " 3 #%%%%89
-'
"
* $ "
; 4
/ "
" "
''
" "
0
" " "
"
" "
0
' - " " "
"
" "
0
""
"
0
" " "
'"
" "1 "
0
""
- " " "
0
'
2 '"
/
" "
"
&59 " "
"
0
""
7 ' + "
/ -1 0 " "
.
/ " / "
'' - " -'
" / "
'
1 0 "
/ "
" "
"
1
0
.1 "
''
" " - 0 "
"
:2&9 0
'
"
// "
# #( 1 ."
-" ' " "
" "
.
"
'
0
/ "
''
"
- 7 0
"
"
- "
.1 / "
- "8 ''
" / "
"
-'
" '
"
"
.1 + "
/
"
"
"
- "
/ "
- "8 ''
" "
"
+ " 99 .0
" 4"
1 (%?
"
- 7 0
/
= -1 0 "
''
"
"" " (%?
"
- 7 0
/
0 "
3 + - ; 4
B' C 6. ; 4
B' C -" ; 4
B' C 6' ; 4
B' C
3 ; 4 B' C
; 4
B' C E ; 4
B' C
, +
- / C 0
+0 8+0 , 102(:,(-6;
< 7?#4*7* 8 ,
+0 +
- / C 0 5 + -
, +
5+ 5
2(:,(-@ + - + 8+0 5 +
- / C 0 5 + 5 E +
F 0
5
/
8+0 00
+0 . -
3@5 +0 #::0, (/: 6
;<, 7 )0
+
?+ - + + &$ & %&&
+
/ 5 + + 3- + 5 / 0 +50 F / 0 0
.
+
-
+
?+ '$ & %&& = +
B - +50
+
?+ -+ + 0 0
.
+ - 5
? -
?+ '$ & %&&
++ +
- .
- /
+0
+
?+ -
0
0+ 0
+
0+
+ - 5
-
?+ E 5 + -
'$ & %&&
&$ & %&&
++/
8 -
+ +
?+
-
?+
0/
0
E
- + 8+ -
?+ / +
0
+ 0
/ 5 -
?+ /
5 + 5 /
0 5- -
?+ ;
?+ '$ & %&& -
?+ &$ & %&& +
+5 0 G ++ + / + - 5
?+ 0 0 / - 5
?+
0
0
%""#" #<B
0 +
/ 8+ -
+0 5 ) +
+0
+ -
0
-
- /
0
5/
- F
, -
+
?+ '$ & %&&
-
-
+
?+ &$ & %&&
0
+0
%""#" #<B
0 + ,/
#&D
.
+
+ 1 - 5
?+
+/ 5
5 0 +
+ / - 5
0 - -
2 , 5, 24+C ' &% %&'
$"&
0